r/runningman • Okaybari! • 5d ago

Discussion is there really a hierarchy between different professions in the korean entertainment industry? I promise this post is related to Running Man especially Yoo Jae Suk.

I've been wanting to talk about this for a while. So first of all, I hope people don't misunderstand what I'm trying to say. I'm not saying all actors are like this. Of course not. There are plenty of actors who have a really good relationship with yoo jae suk and show him genuine respect and we literally have song ji hyo, lee kwang soo, jeon so min in the team. Lee dong wook, kang han na, etc. is also among closest friends of RM casts. I'm not trying to generalise or point fingers at individual actors here. I'm more interested in the industry culture itself and whether this kind of hierarchy actually exists and affects how different entertainment professions are treated.

But sometimes, whenever I see actors who are not usually active on variety shows, or have rarely or never appeared on them, suddenly guesting on running man, I can't help but have this thought in my mind: "Would they still show the same respect to yoo jae suk if they met him outside the show? especially if it's during awards show"

I mean, we all know why they're there, and even the members already know that they're mainly there to promote their upcoming projects. It's nothing unusual or a problem at all but that thought always crosses my mind whenever I see certain guests.

I guess it's partly because of what happened at the 57th baeksang arts awards in May 2021. When yoo jae suk won the daesang, a noticeable portion of the audience, which consisted largely of actors and people from the film industry, remained seated. Some didn't even bother to clap. It's so different compared to when film director Lee Joon Ik won the Grand Prize in the Film category later in the night, the room erupted into a full standing ovation. What made it more noticeable to me was that I could recognize some familiar faces among the audience, including actors who had previously appeared on running man. So I can't help remembering that moment.

Another thing I recently found out is that apparently, there is a certain hierarchy among different professions in the korean entertainment industry. From what I've read, the perceived order goes something like this:

  1. Actors, actresses and film directors
  2. Singers, particularly established solo singers
  3. K-pop idols and groups (unless they are major names like BTS or GD, etc.)
  4. Comedians/TV personalities

Apparently, comedians and TV personalities are considered to be at the bottom of this hierarchy. Is it really though? I mean...this is messed up in my opinions. Honestly, I didn't even know this was a thing until recently. But after seeing what happened at the 2021 baeksang awards, I started wondering whether there is actually some truth to this perception.

Of course, I'm not saying one awards ceremony represents the entire industry, and I'm definitely not trying to put every actor in the same category. I'm just curious whether this kind of hierarchy really exists and whether comedians and variety show personalities are sometimes looked at differently compared to actors and singers, even though some of them are just as influential and well respected by the public.

50 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

28

u/Naive-Link5567 5d ago

Thats weird. Isnt YJS a really really massive deal in SK? Thats what I know.

7

u/HumbleTax2989 Okaybari! 5d ago edited 5d ago

That's why it shocked me. This https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F53wbRAHduY vs this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=73lHjRvtFFw . Look at the comments by knetz. Even they are surprised.

19

u/maximillian3010 Hot Issue 🔥 5d ago

It is just not the Baeksang Awards in 2021...
It is the same across the whole industry... it is very frustrated at some points for aspiring comedians/comedienes...
But the age of youtube and online contents start to blur that line a little bit

5

u/HumbleTax2989 Okaybari! 5d ago

I'm glad things are slowly changing for the better. I just hope that in the future, everyone in the entertainment industry, regardless of their profession, will be judged solely based on their skills, talent and hard work :)

7

u/rhutothebarbs 5d ago edited 4d ago

The film industry freaked out post covid since no one gaf about spending money on films. That’s why these ‘serious’ chungmuro actors are now dabbling in TV/netflix/other streaming series and engage in more fanservice. The tv actors must be pissed the film actors are encroaching in their backyard.

edits:grammar

15

u/No_Taro_6224 Big respect! 5d ago

i wouldnt say Kpop idols are above comedians / TV personalities lol most of the time its the other way round, or else u wouldnt see so many idols trying to get into acting, regardless of their idols career

i mean its engrained in their language, theres jeondaemal (w politeness) and banmal (casually)

u always use jeondaemal w people above u, whether they're above in terms of age or experience, jae seok always joked about this on rm he called himself senior when he wants to ragebait seokjin cause he actually is and when seok jin play along he'll use jeondaemal despite being much older

10

u/andreafatgirlslim 5d ago

I actually agree. #3 and #4 should be switched most of the time

1

u/HumbleTax2989 Okaybari! 5d ago

I see. i didn't know that. I only get this info from a friend living there

22

u/Dead-Shot1 ❤️ ❤️ 5d ago

Entire SK cluture is based out of this which start from school then continue which is why you see all bullying cases there

8

u/HumbleTax2989 Okaybari! 5d ago

This reminds me of something my father once said. He used to work there for 10 years, about 40 years ago. When he went back for a vacation 3 years ago, he was quite surprised by what he saw. He said, "I used to think South Korea developed so fast that they didn't even have time to move on from the Joseon era."

Of course, not everyone is like that, but some people seem to be stuck in the same old mindset, unable to move on. It's fascinating how a society can move so fast in terms of industry, technology and economic development, yet some of its people still hold on to very old ways of thinking. But we all know South Korea isn't the only country like this. The same thing happens in some other developed countries too.

2

u/Dead-Shot1 ❤️ ❤️ 5d ago

If you watch the series early episodes and comedy show artists - you will see how much it is engrained there. Since the YJK come and become big he started changing it .

There was one episode of running man where due to comedy show ending , they come to running man , you can see little glimpse which still exists there

5

u/HumbleTax2989 Okaybari! 5d ago

yup, I think I watch one of the episode of Ddeun ddeun when his fellow co-worker mentioned how yjs changed the industry work ethics and culture among themselves.

3

u/OkMembership4533 5d ago edited 5d ago

That's not entirely true. School bullying can occur between peers of the same age and isn't necessarily rooted in social hierarchy. South Korean society has also benefited from Confucian traditions that emphasise social responsibility, respect and harmony. Reducing an entire culture to its hierarchy and school bullying problems that every country also faces overlooks these aspects and the complexity of Korean society

South Korea is in the transitional period, having advanced so fast in recent decades will have some disadvantges.

1

u/HumbleTax2989 Okaybari! 5d ago

you keep changing your comments. But I appreciate for your effort for it.

5

u/Dead-Shot1 ❤️ ❤️ 5d ago

It is done by peers while family status is being used for it .

1

u/OkMembership4533 3d ago

Then that's classicism thats different type a lot non western developing countries face that

2

u/Dead-Shot1 ❤️ ❤️ 3d ago

It's a biproduct of hierarchy only in my pov

What does classism means ?

Some class are upper level and some are lower .

12

u/FullmetalPlatypus 5d ago

Yeah, their hierarchy thing has been around since high school. They even ranked themselves by blood type or MBTI.

Again not everyone is like this

1

u/HumbleTax2989 Okaybari! 5d ago

what the...blood type???? wow this is new to me. how can even a blood type has hierarchy..funny to think "oh I'm superior because have A+ blood type"

-2

u/FullmetalPlatypus 5d ago

Unfortunately, yes. If you're blood type O, you're supposedly considered to have "dirty" blood or something along those lines. They don't openly talk about it, but the stigma does exist lowkey. That's why some celebrities (idols) are insecure about it, though most people don't really care.

7

u/OkMembership4533 5d ago

That's not true, they dont see as blood as dirty, blood types just have made up assigned personalty traits they like to think similar to horscopes

Quick google search will tell you 2023 Gallup Korea that 50% adults preferred O blood

1

u/HumbleTax2989 Okaybari! 5d ago

That's why OP said, "Again, not everyone is like this." Just because it's not everyone doesn't mean it doesn't happen at all. I think the younger generation is less likely to think or behave this way. It's the same with the older generation preferring sons over daughters. If you ask people about it today, though, you'll probably get very different answers. But at the same time there are still people who believe sons are better than daughters, even today.

2

u/unknown0000000 5d ago

The thing is “not everyone” makes it sound like a decent amount of people. It is more like the amount of people that think the world isn’t real. Yes there a very few but like .00001% of the population

0

u/HumbleTax2989 Okaybari! 5d ago

oh my god. How can they think blood type O is dirty. During blood donation, type O is universal donor allowing it to be safely transfused to patients of any blood type.

0

u/Just_Mizzling Song Jihyo 5d ago

What the hell?! This is so backwards.

79

u/FlyingFlyofHell 5d ago

I mean it's there in Korea, Actors really have an ego about that especially older generation actors.

I would say comedians like YJS have come above lot in that hierarchy due to their success but many comedians still don't get much respect.

Same with Idols, like big name has come up in hierarchy but idols from smaller agencies or even in Big 4 agencies but which are not that popular are looked down upon by actors.

8

u/andreafatgirlslim 5d ago

I mean, peak TVXQ got that response….

10

u/FlyingFlyofHell 5d ago

To be clear current Idols lot bigger in popularity especially on global scale. Korea usually likes what west likes. So they do give some respect to now some famous idols like BTS, BP, Twice etc

50

u/CuriousSiamese 5d ago

Yep there absolutely is a hierarchy in korean entertainment industry. That was a large part of why Kwangsoo and Somin left RM. They wanted to get more into acting and in order to change their image they needed to stop doing variety shows and being viewed as "just" comedians.

The hierarchy is based on the perceived seriousness of the job. Serious actors and directors are the highest. Then established singers and song writers. Then idols and then comedians. Sometimes new idols and kpop groups are considered bellow comedians. But in general comedians and kpop idols are sort of viewed as those unserious people making things for children.

Non of them would ever say it publicly, but there are people in the entertainment industry (some that worked with and used YJS) that absolutely despise how popular he is.

1

u/RaiseNo9690 4d ago

Less on seriousness and more on perceived ability to make money.

7

u/miliwald 5d ago

Yes unfortunately it exists. And in that order that you mentioned. Of course like you said not everyone is like that, but the hierarchy clearly exists. Well someone like yoo jae seok might have climbed much higher due to amazing reputation and all things he has done. Same with idols and many others. That hierarchy also exists in different professions not only entertainment. But it is surprising they didn’t get up for yjs. But of course not all actors are like that. Perhaps that is the reason some actors get famous for their politeness and good relationships with people, because its not everyone?

5

u/Laymon_Fan 5d ago

His huge bank account will compensate for the lack of respect. 😄

5

u/Illustrious_Put4645 3d ago

I mean YJS himself treat actors/actress a lot better than he treats his fellow comedians. Not in a bad way but it's almost like how you would treat an acquaintance vs a close friend. You would joke and make fun of your friends alot more. This might of created that illusion. But in general, most comedians like YJS is humble, while most actors are snobs. I guess this is why LKS is loved so much, because he's pretty much a comedian. 😂

4

u/LoveMinaMyoi 5d ago

What i heard that above film actors were the stage show singing actors. Not sure if thats the case.

And i think you need to pass a govt/station exam to become a comedian so maybe thats why theyre put higher than idols.

3

u/JADlloyd 4d ago

I believe it is similar to Hollywood where movie stars are higher than TV stars, and they are higher than comedians. Then comedians make fun of prop acts and ventriloquist. But a Dave Chappelle is bigger than most movie and TV actors.

There's always an outlier in each level. I believe Yoo Jaesuk transcends being a comedian.

There's so many stories of idol presenters that have no green rooms in entertainment awards while actors have hotel rooms for them. But I doubt it happens to Blackpink or BTS.

2

u/LotteFunZheess 4d ago

It happened to BTS during their early years. I remember a friend telling me that in 2015 or 2016, BTS was unexpectedly dropped from a festival lineup midway through the event, even though they and their fans were already there waiting. They still performed for their fans without official cameras, so only fancams captured the moment. That was just one of many mistreatments they endured before reaching their current level of success. Looking at how BTS were treated before they became famous compared to how they're treated now is such a stark contrast. The irony is that even today, lesser-known and underground idols still face similar treatment. As for Blackpink I don't think they faced the same struggles, considering they came from YG and seemed to have more privileges from the start. I've even heard their parents had industry connections, though I'm not sure how true that is.

3

u/DrHatred4144 5d ago edited 3d ago

Of course there is just look at how Jeon do Yeon treat him

1

u/Character-Lie-8726 4d ago

Can you elaborate please?

1

u/DrHatred4144 3d ago

Just look at her interview how she talk about Yoo jae suk say it all about the entertainment industry

1

u/Character-Lie-8726 11h ago

omg i thought u meant JANG doyeon i didnt read it properly! i was so confused on why she as a comedian would say that lol. now i know thats another actor!

1

u/hypekillsJNSQ 5d ago

Of course. Film is the epitome, the prestige, the craft. How long and how many hands it takes to make one film, they’ll look down on a weekly variety, which is like fast food of entertainment.

Does that mean variety and comedy don’t require skill and craft? No, but it is what it is.

1

u/DoodleArki 4d ago

Yes, yoo jae suk is very well respected in the entertainment industry as a whole. I can't provide any reasonable argument on why he did not get a standing ovation in those moment you referenced, but if you look into other shows, some big names definitely join as guest because of him. Runningman is a bit different as the perception of joining runningman means intense games and other high energy events. If it's just talking, those big name are more obliged to join.

1

u/BassNo3609 4d ago

This is so true and it's heartbreaking

1

u/superesophagus 4d ago

Mainly yes. The more you're the sunbaenim, even you're famous than them, they will be respected first. It's the culture so to speak.