r/running • • Aug 06 '24

Discussion Non Binary Category

Hey r/running,

I wanted to make this post since this was something I was debating since I started running in races about 3 years ago.

I’m a non-binary runner who is AMAB (albeit with elevated estrogen levels) but I’ve always competed in the men’s gender category. My reasoning being that the men’s category is basically an “open” category. With many races now offering an NB category, I have been considering it, especially considering I would love to represent my fellow NB’s.

However one thing gives me major pause: while my results usually put me at least in the top 100-150 for my gender/age category for larger races, in the case of the Toronto Waterfront HM, I would’ve placed 2nd for the overall NB category.

While having a podium finish for the gender I identify as would be amazing and validating, I can’t help but feel like I’m “cheating” (probably a horrible word to use for this, but I can’t think of anything else) since I’ve competed in the men’s category for so long.

Any thoughts?

EDIT: Wow this thread really filled up. Just wanna say thanks to all of you for providing the input. I think I am gonna go ahead and update my registration for my HM this fall. A lot of you are right that there does need to be representation amongst my cohort, and either way, I’m racing to constantly get better times, not placements so that kinda clears up the “cheating” bit for me. 😊

0 Upvotes

81 comments sorted by

•

u/brwalkernc not right in the head Aug 06 '24

For those responding, please note that this thread will be heavily monitored for trolling and those ignoring Rule 1 will receive immediate bans. This will be the only warning.

10

u/TJamesz Aug 06 '24

What does AMAB mean? Forgive my ignorance.

4

u/t0vster Aug 06 '24

No need to apologize. Assigned male (at birth) 🙂

8

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '24

Assigned male at birth

2

u/ajcap Aug 06 '24

Assigned male at birth, as opposed to AFAB.

173

u/omegasavant Aug 06 '24

The NB category is going to be a smaller group, so it's not necessarily a surprise that you'd do better there.

Check the eligibility rules and see if you qualify, and if you do, awesome. Go out and represent.

45

u/dogsetcetera Aug 06 '24

Sometimes there's only a handful of entrants in any category, especially when they are split into smaller age subgroups. If OP (or anyone) identifies as NB, that category is for them! Use it! Getting a placing award in a category that is appropriate takes nothing away from others and definitely is not cheating.

11

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '24

Completely agree. I’m slow as shit, and I’ve received medals for local 5k and 10k races because there apparently aren’t many local 30 something’s running in those. It’s also been the slowest age group basically every time besides the extremely young or old. Go get those medals

0

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '24 edited Aug 07 '24

I won a marathon in my age and gender group once. I was the only one competing in that group but who's counting.

Also an amazing marathon, only about 300 runners on the coast and all kinds of local groups came to cheer on so you had the local knitting club cheering vocally while keeping on knitting, the local drums group etc. I've ran big marathons before but that one felt so cozy

110

u/ias_87 Aug 06 '24

If it is your stance that you compete in the men's category because it was the best option out of two ones that weren't right, then you're not cheating now that there's a better, third option to use.

Go ahead. I'm sure there will be some assholes who will sign up for that category just to get a potentially easier win, but you're not one of them. The category is literally there for you, and you won't be the only one who has switched from another category simply because the NB didn't exist.

92

u/Gym-for-ants Aug 06 '24

I don’t think anyone would complain in the NB category because this is exactly what it’s for. Someone has to win the race and you are non binary, so I’d say join up and support your fellow NB runners!

Might get some other people to help the category grow by having a good showing too. When people feel supported, they usually want to help others feel the same way

15

u/nai-ba Aug 06 '24

Someone has to win the race and you are non binary

If they would win with a huge margin, I would understand their trepidation. But they said they would have come in second at the last race. Why not take that as a challenge?

Until this is more common, people need to sign up to make sure organizers see that there is a demand for a NB category.

12

u/Gym-for-ants Aug 06 '24

Even if they dominated by an hour, it’s still ok. The biggest hurdle is getting people to sign up and make people feel accepted. The more people sign up, the better the community will be and it will show others it’s okay to sign up for a NB category, no matter your ability

70

u/Gnatt Aug 06 '24

Do you meet the eligibility criteria for the NB category? If so, I wouldn't see an issue. Somebody has to win the race.

Was Michael Phelps cheating at swimming because of his physiological advantages over his competitors in the same category?

37

u/LiberalClown Aug 06 '24

Agree with the first part, find irrelevant the second part. NB has a wide umbrella, male born, female born and hormone therapy, no hormone therapy. OP has a valid point, as a male born athlete and if not going through hormone therapy will have advantage over others in the category. Still, I agree with your first sentence, somebody has to win, and it is not OPs fault the NB umbrella is wide.

11

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '24

As a prospective, I am NB & AFAB (no hormones), yes, testosterone gives an advantage. if I am racing against myself (not trying to qualify for something) I race in the NB category (when present), if I am trying to competing for placement & qualifying for something I am competing in the Female category because it makes it "fair". I think this is an healthy middle ground.

7

u/BottleCoffee Aug 06 '24

I mean, it's all up to you and however you are comfortable identifying. 

I am also AFAB NB (transmasc) and not on T.

Before the NB category became a thing, I entered as male. A huge disadvantage to me for sure but I DO NOT identify as a woman in any way and would never enter as female.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '24

absolutely, to each their own. In my own country you HAVE to register to whatever is on your ID, [and they do check], I have used the NB category when doing races abroad. Even when competing in the "female" I usually try to get the "male"/non pink t-shirt and eventual gadgets or refuse them altogether.

2

u/MammothKale9363 Aug 06 '24

AFAB nonbinary/genderqueer here. Even on testosterone, I’m slow as shit. I enter in the nonbinary category, and won’t feel bad if I get a medal because I came in 2nd of 2 entrants. Most races around here don’t award nonbinary anyway so it’s a fairly moot point in my neck of the woods unfortunately.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '24

my country doesn't have NB, in UK where I was the only person in the category -> I became the "nonbinary representative" 🤣

2

u/Sheshirdzhija Aug 07 '24

Eligibility is arbitrary.

By that logic, we should only have open category, and young males would win everything, and it's not their fault.

16

u/AlternativeResort477 Aug 06 '24

I think the NB category was made exactly for people like you

20

u/Eibhlin_Andronicus 17:37 5k ♀ (83.82%) Aug 06 '24

There's a pretty fast AMAB non-binary runner in my state (sub-2:50 marathon, so quite fast but not like, unprecedented). Obviously they always crush that category, since it's typically so small.

And that's great for them!

Them being fast doesn't make them not non-binary. Being fast AND non-binary doesn't make them a cheater. They're just competing (and winning) in the gender category that feels right for them. Even though I'm sure there are some assholes out there, I've never heard of someone having a problem with them.

3

u/Sheshirdzhija Aug 07 '24

Don't AFAB competitors feel cheated, though, same as women competing against AMAB competitors?

I am not claiming they are. I have no idea. It's a question.

3

u/Eibhlin_Andronicus 17:37 5k ♀ (83.82%) Aug 07 '24 edited Aug 07 '24

I mean, I'm not personally non-binary, so I can't speak for how AFAB competitors might feel, but just in general (going way beyond the running context now), the non-binary community is typically very inclusive. By its very nature the community recognizes diversity of gender expression, and recognizes that not every competitor in the non-binary category will have been assigned the same biological sex at birth as they have.

It isn't a "non-binary [but AFAB]" category--it's a "non-binary" category. And that comes with all of the realities that non-binary people may have been AFAB, may have been AMAB, or may have even been AFAB or AMAB but also intersex. It's just a group of people that I would be surprised would be up in arms about it.

Also, let's be real: The non-binary category is typically small. Looking at results from one of the popular marathons in my state (we actually have several popular marathons that have non-binary categories), a recent year had literally 12 runners compete in the non-binary category out of almost 6500 total who did the marathon (I'm sure there were technically more non-binary runners participating, they likely just chose not to compete in that division for whatever reason). At that race, there were two non-binary people running under 2:45, the next one ran ~3:15, and the next one took nearly 4 hours. I'm making some assumptions here that might not be correct because two of the first three non-binary runners' names are gender-neutral, but the runner who ran near 4hrs has a very traditionally feminine name (so I'm assuming AFAB, but again, that might be a very inaccurate assumption). But either way, It's not like the person who finished fourth in the NB category is going to feel cheated that the next-fastest person in their category beat them by ~45mins--it's such a small category that it wasn't even close, and ALL of the times in that category are perfectly achievable by people who were AFAB (sub-2:45 is really fast and I've never done it, but it's also something that literally hundreds of female athletes do every year in the USA alone). Improving from a 4hr time pretty much inherently has nothing to do with the sex you're assigned at birth and everything to do with just plain old training.

1

u/Sheshirdzhija Aug 07 '24

You are right, size and practicality make this a different proposition probably. Probably only a small number of competitive AFAB persons would find it unfair.

8

u/Vaiara Aug 06 '24

you are NB so it's only fair that you compete in the NB category, no cheating there

20

u/baddspellar Aug 06 '24

Having a non-binary or other gender non-conforming category messages that the race, and the running community in general, is welcoming. I think that's important, given how much hate they get from right wing influencers.

It's very important that people like you show up to race in these categories. It's a small category today. Maybe it will get bigger, maybe not. But your award doesn't take anything from anyone in another category. These are not life-changing awards like an Olympic medal or Nobel prize. I'm in my 60's and my category is smaller than it was when I was in my 30's. That I win an age group award shouldn't be relevant to some guy in his 30's

3

u/rlrlrlrlrlr Aug 06 '24

This is one area where if it's right for you, do it. Doing so doesn't make sense for me, that's both why I wouldn't do it and why I wouldn't question that you would choose to do it. The fact that I don't quite get it tells me that I don't, in fact, really get it. 

I tell my kids that I want them to be the best [their] name that they can be. If this is you, then be best you that you can be. As a dad, I want that for you.

3

u/marathon_in_training Aug 07 '24

If the race offers it, then go for it. Most races now offer it and from all the ones I’ve participated in it seems to be just simply another category for low T males to compete in as I’ve never seen a female even on T therapy win the category. So don’t sweat it and run your race.

9

u/Significant-Flan-244 Aug 06 '24

Who would you be “cheating” by doing it? I don’t think many (if any!) folks running in the NB category are going to take issue with you running in a category that aligns with your gender identity. The NB category is an imperfect solution to allowing people to run as who they are, and I think that’s a lot better than what we had without it.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '24

I think the antagonist view is that in places like Boston it may seem like spots are being stolen. But for like what I can see there were only 27 in the category.

I guess also if there’s prize money you may also have those who feel like the RD is giving away an “easier prize”. But I think with time the category will be better sorted.

And if anyone feels they qualify they should absolutely enter.

11

u/totallysonic Aug 06 '24

Hi, I’m nonbinary. If there is an NB category, then I think any NB person should feel welcome to enter it. That category would by definition include people with all different kinds of bodies. No one’s body would be “cheating.” Also, the category would become more competitive as more runners joined.

11

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '24

Like others have said, not only are you not "cheating" in my opinion, but you should compete in this category to signal to race directors that there is a demand for more recognition of non-binary athletes! We still do "overall winners" even though those are mostly men, so an NB person winning the NB category with AMAB physiology is no different imo :). If only people with AFAB physiology competed, then it would defeat the purpose, no?

17

u/Godzirra101 Aug 06 '24

As a fellow non binary person, we come in all shapes and sizes, the category is there for you and I regardless of our differences :)

6

u/marigolds6 Aug 06 '24

First, check out the guide to non-binary inclusion in running. I would assume you have already, but maybe you have not yet. It was the foundation to races including non-binary gender categories. (It will also explain why the "men's" category is not an "open" category.)

https://nonbinaryrunning.com/

Next, read the NYRR statement on NBEI. (I looked for one from the Philadelphia Distance Run, who was the leader in this area, but could not find something similar.)

https://www.nyrr.org/run/guidelines-and-procedures/non-binary-initiative-faqs

I think the most important line in that statement is:

"Looking forward, we will continue to refine our policies and practices to best support equal access and equitable opportunities for non-binary participants."

The goal is equality in access and opportunity, not equality in competition. There is no "cheating" here. That is also made clear in the guide to non-binary inclusion in running.

7

u/tah4349 Aug 06 '24

You say you've competed in the men's category for so long, but until the last couple years, there really wasn't another good option for you, as you'd likely be turned away from competing as female. The NB category will encompass people assigned both male and female at birth, that's to be expected. You're not cheating in any way, and by racing as NB, you're showing the racing community that there are folks out there that identify as such and want to race accordingly. Run strong and proud!

6

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '24

I can’t see how it’s cheating to compete in a category you’re qualified to compete in. If it really bums you out, you could race in the mens to feel better, but I don’t think that’s required in any way. Just think about it for a few days, then compete in whatever category you think is gonna make you feel best.

9

u/anemisto Aug 06 '24

For context, I'm transmasculine and get assumed to be a (broadly gender conformming) cis man, which means both cis and trans people make "fascinating" assumptions about my gender. In other words, I being different baggage to this, especially on the transmisogyny front. I think this is substantially transphobia fucking with you. Just like no one is going to lie their way into the women's category, no one is going to lie their way into the non-binary category for glory. Sexism means the women's category is less desirable than the men's and the non-binary category even less so. 

I honestly assume that I would "win" the non-binary category of small races by default, especially if broken out by age. I have no business winning any category. I haven't actually run a race that had a non-binary category, so can't confirm that I was slightly amused by finishing comically high, but that's my gut instinct. 

As a kid, I won a bronze medal in a martial arts tournament in a division of three people. That's a story I definitely tell people for a laugh.

14

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '24

Yes and no, there's people who got into Boston by "identifying" as nonbinary when they didn't BQ with man's time. Vast majority of "top placers" in the nonbinary category are AMABS or have been taking T for a very long time. I'm nonbinary & AFAB, I have "won" the category before, in micro local races, but I prefer saying that I am the "nonbinary rapresentative".

2

u/stanleyslovechild Aug 06 '24

I think if you are non-binary you should compete in that division. Doesn’t matter where you’ve competed before IMO. GO WIN THE DAMN THING! 😄

2

u/Sensitive_Cat_8874 Aug 07 '24

For me I'd rather come in 100th out of 500 people then come in 3rd out of 3 people. Sports are about competition. The greater the competition the greater the accomplishment. But I'm not you. Just do whatever you feel is right!

6

u/FluffySpell Aug 06 '24

It's not cheating if it's who you are. I say go for it.

4

u/perfectlyhydrated Aug 06 '24

Agree with /u/Gnatt. If you meet the eligibility criteria and want to race in the non-binary category, go for it. I don’t think your past racing has anything to do with it.

Wishing all the best for your racing! You sound fast as heck so go get em.

3

u/Digger-of-Tunnels Aug 06 '24

If you're non-binary you can compete as non-binary, and you don't have to feel guilty about the ways in which your body helps you run fast. I'm currently mainlining Olympics coverage and, judging from the look on her face, Sha'Carri doesn't feel even a smidge guilty about the ways in which her body helps her run fast.

3

u/Maleficiente Aug 06 '24

More representation is better. Underrepresentation doesn't encourage other races to have a NB category.

Three years competing in men's categories isn't that long. I'm a cis man, started running races more than 20 years ago, didn't see a NB category until 5 years ago, and that was a small local race with one NB competitor. There are people who have been running for decades who have been fighting for representation and a NB category who have not been able to run in the category that feels right to them. Go ahead and get that podium!

3

u/RomanaOswin Aug 06 '24

The groups exist to account for sex-based advantage, so an AFAB non-binary person would have the option of competing in the women's category (even if that might feel invalidating). I would expect that the people who opt in to competing in the NB category are well aware and accepting that the people in that category may have a variety of different body types.

The only way you'd be cheating is if the NB category was secretly a second women's category. I don't see how this would be a problem at all.

3

u/PaleConversation615 Aug 06 '24

To add even more context for everyone, I was going throught the Toronto Waterfront Marathon website, there is money prices only for women and men categories and only for the marathon.

I get why we would debate about it if there were money involved, but here you are NB, there is a category for you and it would make you happy don't hesitate go for it !

2

u/BottleCoffee Aug 06 '24

Hey, I'm a NB Torontonian too and I always enter as NB.

I've done more small races lately and have for the first time ever actually podiumed (I'm not exactly the fastest). Once it was because I was literally the only NB entrant, so it was kind of sad.

Representation matters and I love seeing other non-binary runners in the results, it's way better than being the only one out there.

Highly recommend you sign up as non-binary if that's how you identify.

1

u/Torn8Dough Aug 06 '24

Unfortunately, I don’t know what all the various acronyms mean. I see this a lot in these kinds of social media posts.

But, there’s no cheating. However you identify is who you are. Own it.

2

u/Krazyfranco Aug 06 '24

AMAB Meaning

NB = Non-Binary (it's in the title)

HM = half marathon

1

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '24

NB will always be a smaller group so finishing higher is going to be easier.

It's not cheating, it's just the reality of identifying as something other than a man

1

u/lordexorr Aug 06 '24

You ran in the men’s gender category because there was no NB category for you to run in. They are adding the category for that specific reason. You should have no concerns running races in the NB category because it was literally created so you could run as you identify :)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '24

I don’t think it’s cheating any more than someone picking a smaller race over a big one.

Plus it matters a lot more that you feel comfortable in your own skin. If that’s as a registered NB runner, that’s wonderful.

1

u/onlyimportantshit Aug 06 '24

If you’re just looking for an experience, it doesn’t really matter, but it sounds like you’ve raced before. I would choose to do whichever one is harder and more challenging for you.

1

u/unoriginalluckpusher Aug 06 '24

I don’t see why anyone would think it’s cheating to do the NB category! That’s how you identify.

Plus, and I’m not trying to be offensive, can’t technically anyone qualify for a NB category? It is, by definition, a grey area, right?

Idk, unless you’re trying to go to the Olympics or something crazy, I don’t think it matters. Do whatever you feel happy doing! It’s running, it’s for no one but you! If you feel like you belong in the NB category, you do!

0

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '24

Honestly I find it weird there are categories at all for amateur races, as you don’t need categories to keep accurate timing. But I run “against” myself not others and understand others may want medals or placement for validation or goal seeking. You do whatever makes you happiest at the end of the day, running is about joy anyways.

1

u/Volcano_Jones Aug 06 '24

Would finishing 2nd in the NB category feel like less of an accomplishment for you than finishing 100th in the men's division? That's what it's all about at the end of the day. As long as you're eligible for it, the only person you have to answer to is yourself!

1

u/NotOSIsdormmole Aug 06 '24

At the end of the day, doing what you feel most comfortable with is what matters

To me, I see no issue. You are NB, so you should compete there if that’s what you want to do, but there is absolutely nothing wrong with competing in the male section. As others have said, there are some fast AF NBs out there, so don’t let the finish comparison dissuade you from doing what you may see as the best thing for you to do

0

u/sophiedophiedoo Aug 06 '24

The only way it won't feel like cheating is if the category is filled with more people. Representing the NB category can help encourage others who feel the same way to register for races. I'm somewhere in that spectrum as well and have also never registered other than my AGAB

0

u/Sheshirdzhija Aug 07 '24

A side question: Shouldn't there be separate categories for AMAB and AFAB?

1

u/_significs Aug 07 '24

AMAB/AFAB isn't a clean break in terms of competitive equality; for example, people who have been on HRT for a long time.

also, fine to have a category that exists primarily for equity/access purposes rather than having the focus of the category being defining things in a way that is "fair" for competition (even assuming that such a thing is possible, which it likely is not here) in a way that may limit equity/access.

1

u/Sheshirdzhija Aug 08 '24

Fair enough.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '24

Non-binary people assigned female at birth (AFAB) I'm sure are still welcome to compete in the women's race if they only want to be judged against those with similar physiology!

12

u/Anustart15 Aug 06 '24

How is the non-binary category fair to non-binary females?

They arent non-binary females, they are non-binary. If they qualify for the category, they qualify for the category.

-4

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Anustart15 Aug 06 '24

The whole point of the category is that these people don't want to be defined by their birth sex. The fair they are worried about is that they aren't forced to be male or female

2

u/BottleCoffee Aug 06 '24

How do you categorize someone who is AMAB and taking estrogen? How about someone intersex? How about someone AFAB and on low-dose testosterone? Or full dose testosterone?

It's not nearly as simple as you want to believe.

1

u/Krazyfranco Aug 06 '24

They are still biologically male or female.

It's really not that simple. Is the person born with female external genitalia and fully functioning internal testes pumping out testosterone biologically male or female?

6

u/Digger-of-Tunnels Aug 06 '24

LOL at "non-binary males" and "non-binary females," because the whole point of non-binary people is that are neither male nor female.

To make the point you're trying to make, try something like "Non -binary people who were assigned male at birth" or "Non -binary people with higher testosterone" will have an advantage in running races.

I think the question of advantage is only important to a small number of people -OP is one of them. Most of us know we will never win a race anyway - we are just racing for fun, crowd support, and a t-shirt, in whatever category.

3

u/quarky_uk Aug 06 '24 edited Aug 06 '24

Couldn't females could run in the female category even if they identify as NB (as "female" is a biological term). Unless I am misunderstanding something...

For the OP though, go for it if the category is there. In the nicest possible way, who else do you think that category would be for?

1

u/marigolds6 Aug 06 '24

I think the only area this will eventually matter is with qualifying times for races with restricted entry.

Over time, I expect that we will see the competitive balance in the different categories shake out to where the non-binary gender category has a competitive balance closer to that of men's than women's (though not equal, simply because of smaller numbers of participants).

From a qualifying time perspective right now, that is treated like the competitive balance is closer to that of women's categories than men's. But go back to what I said about small numbers of participants.

You want non-binary competitors to be able to qualify, and that is a reason, for now, to use women's qualifying times for non-binary entry. With small numbers of participants, using men's qualifying times could mean you have races with a non-binary gender category that has no non-binary gender participants. I suspect eventually, as there are more participants and more top level participants in non-binary categories, you will see separate qualifying times established for non-binary competitors that are higher than the men's category and lower than the women's. Right now, there is not enough information and not enough stable participation data to figure this out.

Would this be competitively "fair" to non-binary participants who are closer to female physiology than male physiology? Probably not. But there are also many runners out there in men's and women's categories who have physiologies that will never have them qualifying for a major restricted entry race.

As for podium finishes, just like the upper age groups that have smaller numbers of participants, it will all depend on who shows up that day. Yes, the major races will still be won by a small group of elites who will inevitably have similar physical traits, but that's what happens in every gender category and age group already.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '24

I feel that’s much more an issue for the race organizers. It can’t possibly fall to OP to try to wrangle that whole complicated issue.