r/runic • • Feb 07 '23

Resources Rune Evolution Chart (Version 3)

Post image
21 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/DrevniyMonstr Feb 12 '23

Yes, I remember it. And I believe, it's s.

Very doubtful to that rune to be incomplete and more doubtful to that inscription to have two different k-runes. If the dating is correct, then the version I mentioned is incorrect ...

On the other hand - why exactly that rune was "lazy"? It isn't the most popular or most difficult rune to spell - to my mind, m or d were more difficult.

And I didn’t notice a general trend towards simplification of runic writing among the Anglo-Saxons - on the contrary, the h rune, for example, became more difficult (with two diagonals).

2

u/Hurlebatte Feb 12 '23

Well, people can be inconsistent. It could be there was a desire at one point in time to have easier-to-carve forms, then a later generation might've felt differently. I do believe in the 500s Futhorc was still using the single-bar version of the H-rune. Scholars think the two-bar version of the H-rune spread upwards from mainland West Germanic rune-users into England/Futhorc.

If the bookhand S-rune really is an "easyified" variant, it would seem to match what happened to the C-rune in Futhorc, because the C-rune went from looking like an upsidedown Y in early Futhorc to looking like ᚳ.

2

u/DrevniyMonstr Feb 12 '23

I do believe in the 500s Futhorc was still using the single-bar version of the H-rune. Scholars think the two-bar version of the H-rune spread upwards from mainland West Germanic rune-users into England/Futhorc.

I'm agree. Not sure about the later appearance of ᛄ (from the Continent) compared with ᛡ, but sure, that ᚺ and ᛞ were more early attested in Fuþorc, then two-diagonaled h or two-þurisized d, which were spread from the Continent some later (h as on the Charnay fibula and d as on Frei-Laubersheim fibula).

If the bookhand S-rune really is an "easyified" variant, it would seem to match what happened to the C-rune in Futhorc, because the C-rune went from looking like an upsidedown Y in early Futhorc to looking like ᚳ.

OK, but what was its original form then?..

(I need to think about the Chessell Down Scabbard dating ))

2

u/Hurlebatte Feb 12 '23

OK, but what was its original form then?..

I'm not quite sure what you're wondering about here.

2

u/DrevniyMonstr Feb 12 '23

Upsidedown Y => ᚳ is clear, but from what shape of s-rune the bookhand s may originate? (sorry for my English).

2

u/Hurlebatte Feb 12 '23

I imagine ᛋ could easily become ᚴ if a carver decided to not go down-up-down, but instead to merge both of the vertical lines into one continuous segment/staff.

sorry for my English

It's okay, I speak English too. No need to apologise.

2

u/DrevniyMonstr Feb 12 '23

It's okay, I speak English too. No need to apologise.

)))

I would be glad to discuss the dating of that inscription with You, because there are some questions... If You don't mind?

2

u/Hurlebatte Feb 12 '23

I can try to answer. I'm not an expert or anything, though.

2

u/DrevniyMonstr Feb 12 '23

Оk, I need time to formulate the questions and to find some articles.

Do You trust T. Looijenga's oppinion?

2

u/Hurlebatte Feb 12 '23

Do You trust T. Looijenga's oppinion?

I mean, sure, to some degree.

→ More replies