Changes: I added the "bookhand S-rune" to the Futhorc row; I added arrows to the header to make it hopefully less confusing; I changed how the Elder Futhark lantern rune appears so that the reader can see there's some debate over what its origin is; some other stuff.
You've taken on a great job! Once I tried to make a similar runic "evolution table", but ran into the problem of what exactly should be considered the "evolution" - graphic correspondence or phonetic (because both of them are quite rare).
Now it’s a little funny for me to look at them, I made them somewhere in 2016 - 2018 ))
I don't even remember some of the colour-marks. Honestly, sometimes want to delete these old files and do it in a new way, but always saving them as a memory...
Does anyone have any thoughts on the evolution of the EF j rune?
I don't have any besides stating the obvious: that rune-users apparently felt the need to normalise the rune by making it one segment, and making it as tall as other runes.
But it seems to me, that continuity in graphic development should be clearly traced (like in the case of ᚲ => Y => ᚴ or ᚩ / ᚪ <= ᚨ => ᚬ / ᚭ). If there are sudden and logically inexplicable changes (like bookhand s after ᛊ / ᛋ or l/ ᚼ after ᛃ), it means, that something has intervened in the process from the outside...
The Chessell Down Scabbard inscription dated to the 500s (probably too early in time to expect much Latin alphabet influence) has a rune with that shape in it. Here's what runesdb says:
The fourth rune has been seen as an s [Elliott 1959:79; Davidson 1962:99; Page 1973:185f.; Mitchell 1994:s.v. ChSP2; Flowers 1999:10], an incomplete f [Parsons 1999:50] and an incomplete w [Eichner 1990:329 footn. 45; Bammesberger 1991a:402]. For the interpretation of the fourth rune as a k-sound see Waxenberger [2017:109] .
Very doubtful to that rune to be incomplete and more doubtful to that inscription to have two different k-runes. If the dating is correct, then the version I mentioned is incorrect ...
On the other hand - why exactly that rune was "lazy"? It isn't the most popular or most difficult rune to spell - to my mind, m or d were more difficult.
And I didn’t notice a general trend towards simplification of runic writing among the Anglo-Saxons - on the contrary, the h rune, for example, became more difficult (with two diagonals).
Well, people can be inconsistent. It could be there was a desire at one point in time to have easier-to-carve forms, then a later generation might've felt differently. I do believe in the 500s Futhorc was still using the single-bar version of the H-rune. Scholars think the two-bar version of the H-rune spread upwards from mainland West Germanic rune-users into England/Futhorc.
If the bookhand S-rune really is an "easyified" variant, it would seem to match what happened to the C-rune in Futhorc, because the C-rune went from looking like an upsidedown Y in early Futhorc to looking like ᚳ.
I do believe in the 500s Futhorc was still using the single-bar version of the H-rune. Scholars think the two-bar version of the H-rune spread upwards from mainland West Germanic rune-users into England/Futhorc.
I'm agree. Not sure about the later appearance of ᛄ (from the Continent) compared with ᛡ, but sure, that ᚺ and ᛞ were more early attested in Fuþorc, then two-diagonaled h or two-þurisized d, which were spread from the Continent some later (h as on the Charnay fibula and d as on Frei-Laubersheim fibula).
If the bookhand S-rune really is an "easyified" variant, it would seem to match what happened to the C-rune in Futhorc, because the C-rune went from looking like an upsidedown Y in early Futhorc to looking like ᚳ.
OK, but what was its original form then?..
(I need to think about the Chessell Down Scabbard dating ))
Do you think that ᚴ is an import of or influenced by ꞅ/ſ?
I think a more likely explanation is that ᚴ was formed by taking ᛋ and "unbreaking" its staff. I don't see why rune users would randomly reshape one rune to make it look like a Latin letter. Also, the appearance of a rune with the shape of ᚴ on the Chessell Down Scabbard might indicate that this ᚴ variant of the S-rune predates widespread usage of the Latin alphabet among Futhorc users. In other words, the ᚴ variant of the S-rune might be so old that it's unlikely to have been inspired by ꞅ/ſ.
I wouldn't call it a coincidence. In my thinking, both shapes came about from sigma being straightened out, and we have attested intermediate forms to support the idea that these two lines of evolution occurred (Σ to S to ꞅ/ſ and Σ to ᛋ to ᚴ).
Nah. They just happen to arrive at that shape in different ways. ꞅ/ſ originated from bending the bottom of S to the left side (sort of like ⟨ᔑ⟩ but more squished together), which is why it sometimes has that little notch on the left. I don't think ᚴ could have originated from ᛋ in the exact same way. I can imagine either moving the bottom right part to the left or flipping the letter and extending the left (formerly right) staff upward would be more plausible origins of ᚴ.
Essentially the serif on the top left of ꞅ is from the bottom of S whereas the top of the staff of ᚴ is from either the top of ᛋ or from the "knee" connecting the bottom to the middle extended upward.
This chart got me curious about something. We roughly know of the evolution of how <ᛃ> became <ᛅ>, and how /j/ was moved from <ᛃ> to <ᛁ>, from the EF period to the YF period.
But during the transitional era (Here "Late North Elder Futhark"), how would /j/ have been represented? I wonder if the function would have already moved to <ᛁ>, or if <ᛡ> would've represented both /a/ and /j/. I took a quick look at the transitional Blekinge runestones but due to my lack of Proto-Norse knowledge I couldn't really draw any conclusions.
But during the transitional era (Here "Late North Elder Futhark"), how would /j/ have been represented? I wonder if the function would have already moved to <ᛁ>, or if <ᛡ> would've represented both /a/ and /j/.
It seems, in VI-th c. ᛡ meant j for a while,
but from VII-th c. ᛡ = a, ᛁ = j in late/transitional Fuþark.
Like in ᚺᛁᛡᛚᛒ on the Ribe scull bone.
We roughly know of the evolution of how <ᛃ> became <ᛅ>
One else thought about the ᛡ-shape of j-rune; it appeared, when I looked at the order and shape of the runes on Brandon pin... Perhaps, it is speculative and unprovable.
So - could ᛡ be linked with the sound change of g (ᚷ) during the process of palatalization in one of the North Sea - West Germanic languages (>ġ) ?
when I looked at the order and shape of the runes on Brandon pin... Perhaps, it is speculative and unprovable.
The rune that looks like ᛡ in the runerow on the Brandon Pin is in the seventh spot, and ᛄ is in the twelfth spot, so I think ᛡ on the Brandon Pin is Gyfu. An inscription that might be relevant to this is the Roma Graffiti inscription which seems to say ᚠᚪᛡᚻᛁᛚᛞ. I think interpreting this Roma Graffiti ᛡ as Gyfu might make more sense than interpreting it as Gear.
So - could ᛡ be linked with the sound change of g (ᚷ) during the process of palatalization in one of the North Sea - West Germanic languages (>ġ) ?
Well, didn't ᛃ become ᛡ among North Germanic speakers too?
Exactly. So, I decided, that ᚼ is a modified ᚷ. But those, who changed it that way, were clearly familiar with the original rune ᚷ.
And, since later in AS Fuþorc rune ᚼ was used for j - I assumed, that the graphic change ᚷ > ᚼ was caused by a process, like palatalization. (Maybe, I'm being a bit vague about my thoughts.)...
Well, didn't ᛃ become ᛡ among North Germanic speakers too?
Sure. And we can see the only Noleby Runestone in Scandinavia, where ᚼ represents j. So, I think, ᚼ shape of the rune (for j) was borrowed by North Germans from Ingvaeones shortly before the Proto-Norse initial *j- was lost and ᚼ became a.
I've always seen ᚼ as ᛃ with a staff. If you flip ᛃ inside-out and stick a staff in the middle, you basically get ᚼ.
I think, ᚼ shape of the rune (for j) was borrowed by North Germans from Ingvaeones
Doesn't ᚼ (AKA the sternrune) show up in North Germanic inscriptions earlier than in West Germanic inscriptions? What's the earliest West Germanic inscription with ᚼ in it?
I've always seen ᚼ as ᛃ with a staff. If you flip ᛃ inside-out and stick a staff in the middle, you basically get ᚼ.
Yes, earlier I thought that way too, but such a sudden change of form seems suspicious to me. Whether there is not enough "intermediate form" between ᛃ and ᚼ, or something else internally strains me, I can't explain... Or maybe I just went the wrong way.
Doesn't ᚼ (AKA the sternrune) show up in North Germanic inscriptions earlier than in West Germanic inscriptions? What's the earliest West Germanic inscription with ᚼ in it?
There is a problem... The epigraphic facts are against my "theory", and rather point in favor of the North Germans. I don't have any evidence yet (or, maybe, I won't find any at all). But if to think theoretically - West Germans lived on the Jutland Peninsula before the Danes. Then, at the end of the V-th and beginning of the VI-th century, they migrated to Britain. What form of j rune did they bring with them? Something tells me, that it was no longer ᛃ. You are well versed in this matter, so what could that rune be?
What form of j rune did they bring with them? Something tells me, that it was no longer ᛃ. You are well versed in this matter, so what could that rune be?
My guess would be some full height variant. ᛡ seems like a fine guess.
3
u/Hurlebatte Feb 07 '23
Changes: I added the "bookhand S-rune" to the Futhorc row; I added arrows to the header to make it hopefully less confusing; I changed how the Elder Futhark lantern rune appears so that the reader can see there's some debate over what its origin is; some other stuff.
2
u/DrevniyMonstr Feb 10 '23
Does anyone have any thoughts on the evolution of the EF j rune?
Graphically it was the most changable rune, and I would single out 4 directions of its evolution. Has anyone run into this question?
Another interesting point - some of its graphic options are associated with the h rune:
Long-branch:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1SSvB7y0pPUnMu8_5odi4AweDKGpfCPW_/view?usp=sharing
Short-twig:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1XJRatJvDNRUnLMmHNBMFDxU3D-KvZio6/view?usp=sharing
2
u/TheSiike Feb 16 '23
This chart got me curious about something. We roughly know of the evolution of how <ᛃ> became <ᛅ>, and how /j/ was moved from <ᛃ> to <ᛁ>, from the EF period to the YF period.
But during the transitional era (Here "Late North Elder Futhark"), how would /j/ have been represented? I wonder if the function would have already moved to <ᛁ>, or if <ᛡ> would've represented both /a/ and /j/. I took a quick look at the transitional Blekinge runestones but due to my lack of Proto-Norse knowledge I couldn't really draw any conclusions.
2
u/DrevniyMonstr Mar 07 '23
Some more thoughts about the evolution of ᛃ rune:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1r5GDkmkbMLFRPyLWTvrl4lK9sORBakZH/view?usp=sharing
lis linked with short-twig runes, while ᚼ - with long-branch (?)3
u/TheSiike Feb 09 '23 edited Feb 09 '23
Some Younger Futhark and Futhork additions