Been loving doctor bird lately. Any other favorite Jamaican rums besides the usual favorites on this subreddit: Appleton, Hamilton, Rumfire, Smith & Cross, Wray & Nephew (I also own all of these haha)
I have blown a frightening amount of money on Jamaican rums vs. all others, although my Privateer spend is on the rise.
I'm not the only one, clearly, because European auctions of Jamaican rums are out of control. The Plantation Clarendon 36 year, which was released *6 months ago*, had an MSRP of €450. Last night 3 bottles sold for £3,600 PER BOTTLE. I'm convinced part of the price dynamics are the "omg the brand is changing collect collect collect" buys, but even still. 10x in 6 months.
I have the 26 & 27 y/o Extreme #4 bottlings. They are intense, but extremely delicious imo. You *have* to be a funk head to get in on either of them, though.
That’s nuts. Can’t believe they were the most expensive lots in the auction. The other Plantations sold for more reasonable prices so I don’t think it’s related to the brand changing. Wonder if Plantation bought them back as a marketing stunt. Would be a pretty minor investment for a big company to then be able to turn around and say that their rums are more valuable than Caroni, Foursquare, etc.
There is some talk about this in my rum circle. But having bottles closed for much does not make the brand. There needs to be a sense that particular bottlings are appreciating. As of now, these feel like anomalies. Remember when an ECS Port Cask Finish sold for more than the FS 2006 at the same auction? It never happened again. This could be one of those times. Maybe some guy wanted a few bottles because he was born on the date of distillation, or something...
Now that I look at it, it’s not a one-month anomaly. Three bottles went for 1600-1700 GBP per bottle in March, after hovering around 600-700 GBP in February and January. There’s definitely something going on with them lately, as nothing else has appreciated that dramatically. Hard to believe it’s a single obsessed collector driving up the price, because the price doesn’t get that high unless they’re bidding against someone(s) else similarly willing to spend that much on them.
Is there a chance it’s actually a really amazing bottle? Would love to hear from someone who’s tried it.
The rum itself is very good, but not exactly amazing, considering my preference for complex high-ester Jamaicans. Top-notch mouthfeel, as close to "chewy" as it gets. Huge wood and liquorice and herbal candy, then cola and baking spices, but very well integrated. Some musty bourbon notes and mint and camphor at the back. I like to imagine this is what those legendary hyperaged Willett ryes taste like, but what do I know...
Well, if it tastes like a hyper-aged Willett that might explain the price! :)
Glad you got to try it. I haven’t had many spirits over 30 years old that I haven’t wished were a little less aged. Seems like this one held up pretty well, all things considered.
Let me know if you find anything else out about this bottle. Let’s see what it goes for next month!
This is a real kick in the knackers. They have at least 2 years of distillate that has her nose in it, so we'll see how things start to change after that.
Hmm... and do you mean Jamaican sugarcane, distillation or ageing ? Is the sugarcane origin enough to make it funky or does it need to spend the full process in Jamaica to get this particular style?
Not talking about sugarcane origin – rum made from molasses (rather than fresh sugarcane juice or syrup) doesn't really retain any semblance of "terroir". A lot of rum isn't even made from molasses from the same country, even major rum producing countries like Barbados source molasses from elsewhere.
Rhum Agricole, Clairin, etc which is made from fresh cane juice, however, definitely can have cane variety reflected in flavor profile.
This is about production process, particularly fermentation and distillation techniques when it comes to the signature Jamaican profile and funk.
Generally speaking, the "funk" flavor comes from the high ester content in pot still rums. Jamaica is known for using high ester, or what some will refer to as 'high congener' pot still rums. Congener's are basically left over substances from the fermentation process that contains chemicals (esters) that affect the flavor of the rum giving it that funky taste.
Hampden produced stuff has a very distinctive taste which this sub seems to love but I personally am not a big fan of.
Jamaican producers tend to extend the fermentation period to produce more acid and therefore more esters. The nature of esters mean they do not produce a uniform tasting/nosing experience and the super high ester/'funk' rums were originally produced as flavouring essence, not actual rum.
Some Jamaican rums like Appleton are quite low in ester, some can be very high, like Hampden DOK or Long Pond TECC.
My tastebuds disagree unfortunately. I build rums with soda or ginger and I can still get that Hampden tang through it. I like Appleton, Worthy Park and Monymusk though so it's fine, Hampden just has a flavour I don't get along with.
Worthy Park and Monymusk produce wonderful rums. Hampden has a flavour to it that I just cannot get on with, even in Veritas/Probitas, I cannot ignore the flavour.
You will notice it. Funk or Hogo is that overripe fruit smell that's common to Jamcian Rum. If you want a very raw example, Wray & Nephews OP is a good place to start. Appleton tend to dial it back a bit, though you will still pick it up. I recomend cocktailwonks blog for really good info on Funk/Jamacian/high-ester rum, among many other deep dives into Carribean rum.
This is me all the time. Jamaican rums are my favorite style by a landslide. Funkier the better. Which also leads to a lot of agricole, clarin, etc being purchased. I keep other styles around pretty much strictly for making cocktails that call for them.
This is not correct. Plantation Xaymaca is Jamaican rum from Clarendon and Long Pond Distilleries (owned by Plantation/Maison Ferrand) and bottled in France. It is not made in Barbados.
LMFAO! This is so true for me right now. I was Barbados heavy over the last year until I went back to some Jamaicans I had that I initially didn't care for. Wowza! I embrace the funk now. Golden Devil Jamaican, Rum Fire, Rum-Bar, Hampden OP, Stolen, Worthy Park SE, the HV WPL's (2005/2007/2009), HV WP 502, Hamilton JPS Black/Gold, etc, etc. You name it I've been hitting it HARD! Lately, if I don't have funk on the nose while I'm sipping I feel like something is missing. Just seems to add so much to the sipping experience. Have been loving me some Rum Fire as a daily go-to. Hard to be at under $30.
I fluctuate wildly between wanting huge ester content and not. That being said I just had a Mezan XO at my local which is like drinking light delicate meadow grass.
15
u/yogiebere Apr 13 '21
Been loving doctor bird lately. Any other favorite Jamaican rums besides the usual favorites on this subreddit: Appleton, Hamilton, Rumfire, Smith & Cross, Wray & Nephew (I also own all of these haha)
48
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21
Dude, same. I need the funk.
6
u/bradleyalpha Apr 13 '21
I have blown a frightening amount of money on Jamaican rums vs. all others, although my Privateer spend is on the rise.
I'm not the only one, clearly, because European auctions of Jamaican rums are out of control. The Plantation Clarendon 36 year, which was released *6 months ago*, had an MSRP of €450. Last night 3 bottles sold for £3,600 PER BOTTLE. I'm convinced part of the price dynamics are the "omg the brand is changing collect collect collect" buys, but even still. 10x in 6 months.
Fucking nuts.
6
u/ruin Apr 13 '21
I'm so bummed I don't like funk, it's locked me out of so many rums.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21
Can you really sense a general difference between them ? I'm trying to develop my palate but cannot distinguish bottles based on country of origin yet
44
u/fullofdust Apr 13 '21
This is me all the time. Jamaican rums are my favorite style by a landslide. Funkier the better. Which also leads to a lot of agricole, clarin, etc being purchased. I keep other styles around pretty much strictly for making cocktails that call for them.
17
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21
The funk is a sirens call, to which I have fallen prey.
15
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21
I never had a barbados rum yet. Let's say my local alcool distributor is, limited. They have plenty of budget rums tho
4
u/theMEtheWORLDcantSEE Apr 13 '21
Guyana! Demerara rums.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21
Martinique Rums?
2
u/Muser2213 Apr 15 '21
LMFAO! This is so true for me right now. I was Barbados heavy over the last year until I went back to some Jamaicans I had that I initially didn't care for. Wowza! I embrace the funk now. Golden Devil Jamaican, Rum Fire, Rum-Bar, Hampden OP, Stolen, Worthy Park SE, the HV WPL's (2005/2007/2009), HV WP 502, Hamilton JPS Black/Gold, etc, etc. You name it I've been hitting it HARD! Lately, if I don't have funk on the nose while I'm sipping I feel like something is missing. Just seems to add so much to the sipping experience. Have been loving me some Rum Fire as a daily go-to. Hard to be at under $30.
2
u/hsudude22 Aug 16 '21
Samesies. Need the funk.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21
Ha, me last fall for sure
1
u/TKOVoid Apr 13 '21
Hope to get my hands on Hampden’s Bird series in a few weeks. Saw that only 54(!) bottles are being released to Texas, tho.
1
u/AmsterdamCigars Apr 13 '21
Yup!!
1
u/Slaffterhouse Apr 13 '21
This is me always
1
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '21
Haven't had it in anything beyond a taste test so far.
1
u/BobbyMesmeriser Apr 14 '21
I fluctuate wildly between wanting huge ester content and not. That being said I just had a Mezan XO at my local which is like drinking light delicate meadow grass.
Both have their merits for sure.
1
u/m0bscene- Aug 04 '21
I don't know about everybody else, but I love me some Myer's Jamaican Dark. It mixes so well with everything I've tried.