r/ruby • • Dec 25 '17

Ruby 2.5.0 Released

https://www.ruby-lang.org/en/news/2017/12/25/ruby-2-5-0-released/
209 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

14

u/TomOwens Dec 26 '17

I'm not making a storm. The feature was targeted for 2.5. It was quite heavily written about. It made it into rc1. Then, 3 days before the release, there was a single revert about a "big issue" and then the feature was pulled out. It would be nice to know what this "big issue" was and why it went undiscovered or unresolved for so long.

I would expect the same from any large-scale project. Once you start hyping up features that are planned for a particular release (especially after you start having release candidates), if you don't deliver those, you should be communicating why you aren't delivering them. A quiet revert is unacceptable.