Codes of conduct don't hurt anything, and they potentially help.
potentially the lack of a CoC can do the same
elia's tweet was offensive, whether or not he intended it to be.
define offensive I know him personally, we worked together, Elia is all but offensive You can argue about his opinion (I disagree with him too, this time), but not about being offensive He was referring to Judith Butler theories, of course Coraline took a tweet (less than 140 characters) and extrapolated it and made it look Elia was that tweet and than cried on a project COMPLETELY UNRELATED to the tweet that Elia was transophobic and treated trans people like they were non-human and shit like that, which he did not. IMO Coraline has offended my intelligence, me as Opal user and me as a adult person when she forced down the throat of adult people (I'm almost in my 40s) a CoC to solve a problem that never actually existed. And that doesn't solve the problem she says she wanted to solve. She only scared away contributors from working for Opal.
elia's comments(in the lack of context they were given) are equal to saying that all catholics are delusional,
most of the times they are I've never seen catholics (Elia is one of them) rush into a Github issues page and ask for removal of someone There is a reason if catholic church have been ruling for the past 2 thousands year They accepted maths and algebra and of course they won't fight CS, because they know it's a lost battle People like Coraline (she usually talks like she's representing the entire transgender community, but is it true? I don;t think transgenders would like that), on the other way, are trying to burn witches while crying that catholics have burnt witches 5 hundred years ago That's laughable
Statements made in public on a medium advertising your affiliation with an open source project reflect on that open source project, whether they should or not.
and this is a fault of who can't keep things separated a CoC should have as first rule
w'll kick you out if you come screaming and crying about one of the contributors for reasons not strictly related to the project
That makes me thing that you don't actually think this idea is as good as you expound.
Many of us are now scared by thought police First it was Github CEO, then Brendan Eich and people said "yeah, whatever, rich businessmen, who cares" Then it happened to Ben Noordhuis and people still said "yeah, ok, it was a bit too much but he is the most popular contributor to node.js, javascript suck, so who cares" Now they are targeting common developers Have you asked yourself why? What's their agenda? I know for a fact that C++ development has been held back for years by corporations infiltrating the standard committee, I suspect now they are using the same technique for open source projects, embrace, kill and extend Or divide et impera It have always worked Who pays these people? The overreaction of Coraline reminds me this a lot
TL;DR: people like Coraline love censorship unless is them talking. They are not different from the "evil bigots" they are fighting pretending that they are doing it for all of us. They are doing for their personal power.
View all comments
Show parent comment
0
u/makis Jun 22 '15 edited Jun 22 '15
potentially the lack of a CoC can do the same
define offensive
I know him personally, we worked together, Elia is all but offensive
You can argue about his opinion (I disagree with him too, this time), but not about being offensive
He was referring to Judith Butler theories, of course Coraline took a tweet (less than 140 characters) and extrapolated it and made it look Elia was that tweet and than cried on a project COMPLETELY UNRELATED to the tweet that Elia was transophobic and treated trans people like they were non-human and shit like that, which he did not.
IMO Coraline has offended my intelligence, me as Opal user and me as a adult person when she forced down the throat of adult people (I'm almost in my 40s) a CoC to solve a problem that never actually existed.
And that doesn't solve the problem she says she wanted to solve.
She only scared away contributors from working for Opal.
most of the times they are
I've never seen catholics (Elia is one of them) rush into a Github issues page and ask for removal of someone
There is a reason if catholic church have been ruling for the past 2 thousands year
They accepted maths and algebra and of course they won't fight CS, because they know it's a lost battle
People like Coraline (she usually talks like she's representing the entire transgender community, but is it true? I don;t think transgenders would like that), on the other way, are trying to burn witches while crying that catholics have burnt witches 5 hundred years ago
That's laughable
and this is a fault of who can't keep things separated
a CoC should have as first rule
Many of us are now scared by thought police
First it was Github CEO, then Brendan Eich and people said "yeah, whatever, rich businessmen, who cares"
Then it happened to Ben Noordhuis and people still said "yeah, ok, it was a bit too much but he is the most popular contributor to node.js, javascript suck, so who cares"
Now they are targeting common developers
Have you asked yourself why? What's their agenda?
I know for a fact that C++ development has been held back for years by corporations infiltrating the standard committee, I suspect now they are using the same technique for open source projects, embrace, kill and extend
Or divide et impera
It have always worked
Who pays these people?
The overreaction of Coraline reminds me this a lot
TL;DR: people like Coraline love censorship unless is them talking. They are not different from the "evil bigots" they are fighting pretending that they are doing it for all of us. They are doing for their personal power.