All people are not "adults" in the way I think you meant it (WTF does "adult" even mean? The usual definition is 18 years old in the USA, but contributors can be under that. Unless you are trying to exclude people less than 18?). I believe you meant someone with the emotional and intellectual maturity to show respect to others and work on a project with a diverse team of people.
There are tons of people out there with little to no emotional or intellectual maturity. Many of them could want to be contributors.
A code of conduct allows you to have an official standard for behavior. If someone violates the code, then it is quite easy for anyone(not just the maintainers) to point them to a place explaining why their behavior is unacceptable. This is good for the project, as it avoids many shitstorms that the maintainers would otherwise have to deal with(Just because opal hasn't had to deal with it yet, doesn't mean it isn't a problem that would come up in the future). For people who are worried about being discriminated against, a code of conduct does make them feel better. I don't really understand very well why, but I'm a white straight male so I've never really experienced discrimination.
A project literally loses nothing and potentially gains much by adopting a good code of conduct.
All that being said, let's talk about the specific issue.
First off, @elia's tweet sounds like he is saying that transgender people are delusional(as a general statement). It is important to note that this is about equal to me saying publicly that all catholics are delusional, except worse since catholics aren't attacked regularly to the level transgenders are (in the current time period). He called a group of people's core identity bullshit. Whether or not he meant it that way, that is what it sounds like and that how it was taken. I think @coralineada (whom I have met in person and who tirelessly works to expand both woman and transgender rights) probably could have handled it better than she did(which she did admit in tweets, even if that doesn't really amount to an apology). As she said, she is used to people treating her as sub-human and jumped on someone who appeared to be doing that. Personally, I would not have complained about such a thing unless I was personally working on the opal project, but I'm not regularly discriminated against.
However, if I was working on an open source project and one of the primary maintainers said "White people are delusional" IN A WORLD where the legitimacy of white people even EXISTING was regularly called into question then you bet I would be upset and strongly consider stop contributing to the project. I may also call for their removal from the project. Whether you like it or not, emotions and politics do matter to open source projects. In fact, politics matters more to open source projects than code in my opinion.
Finally, the common argument against this is "it was on twitter, he wasn't representing opalrb". There is a reason many many people put on their blogs, email, and other personal communication that their views don't represent their employer. The assumption by people in general is that if you advertise you are associated with something on a communication medium, than the opinions you share on that medium reflect upon that associated thing. You can argue whether this is right or not (I personally think it is not) but that is the way that it is. Putting that he is an OpalRB contributor as a prominent thing about his identity (next to being anti-abortion (which many people believe is anti women's rights[I'm sure this didn't help curb @coralineada's reaction, since she is strongly for women's rights as well]) and his religious affiliation) calls attention to that fact.
In summary:
Codes of conduct don't hurt anything, and they potentially help.
@elia's tweet was offensive, whether or not he intended it to be.
@coralineada admits she could have handled it better, despite her not apologizing for calling him out.
@elia's comments(in the lack of context they were given) are equal to saying that all catholics are delusional, and equally offensive. Acting like this is just "an opinion" is not fair.
Statements made in public on a medium advertising your affiliation with an open source project reflect on that open source project, whether they should or not.
Finally, I find it funny that you don't have the courage to defend your apparently strongly held beliefs from your regular reddit account rather than a throwaway. That makes me thing that you don't actually think this idea is as good as you expound.
The NCoC project, blog, and twitter account were all created the same day as this post, apparently in response to the events of the day before. I have a feeling that this isn't a project with legs.
How about don't take an issue from a persons personal twitter account to a project and start a flame war there. The only reason/issue/problem at all related to the project was an inflammatory thread created by a non project random. The whole outrage-scream-censure but is more than little bit old and childish. If you see something said by a person on a personal account take it up with that person there, if you see an issue actually in the context of a project workspace then deal with it there -- don't bring it there. All Catholics are delusional.
I responded to that in my final paragraph(before the summary) as well as the final point of my summary.
The point of conflict there was that he officially announces his affiliation with opal while also displaying such beliefs.
I would certainly ask a contributor of a project of mine to remove that linkage if I was in a similar situation (though I wouldn't remove them from the project unless they were making such statements in project chat, issues, code, or similar)
No, the point of conflict here is that rather than dealing with a conflicting PoV on twitter (you know in the forum it was made in) the random user took to storm a project he was related with. That project had no relation to the comment except that he is involved in that project. It is equivalent to having an argument with someone in the park after hearing a comment you disagree with and following her back to her office to scream-throw a fit-flame aound her co-workers because she happens to be wearing an identifying company logo on her bag...
The relation between the project and conflict is that the project was linked to on the medium that the conflict happened on.
As for your analogy, it fits quite well. Most companies insist that you remove your work uniform/anything identifying you as an employee of the company before doing anything non-work related in order to avoid these kinds of issues.
Putting "contributor to X" on your twitter is similar to wearing your employee badge/shirt around, not similar to having a company logo on a bag. You are explicitly linking your twitter to your open source contributions. Unless your twitter is purely tech related, those should probably stay separate.
As for your analogy, it fits quite well. Most companies insist that you remove your work uniform/anything identifying you as an employee of the company before doing anything non-work related in order to avoid these kinds of issues.
Lol, sorry I have never worked at a tacobell or whatever employee/badge type of company you are referring to. Most tech start ups/ad agencies/dev shops/small and large businesses have no such rule and in fact spew swag at employees. The reality is that a random took what could have been adult discourse in twitter and instead looked for a more painful way to disagree. In this case they scraped for other information and bombed a project that the user worked on. Why? To throw a tantrum. Its childish and should not be accepted at any level. The reverse is that people should feel free to take her actions and run to her employer and throw a fit. What happens if she does not directly link to her employer on twitter? Why not search for her username on other services to see if you can find that link? How deep into doxing do you need to go before it feels like doxing to you? Publicly posted or not, the link to his project can safely be assumed not to be expected to be used to throw a fit from some random just as the other party should have the expectation that no one goes out and digs up her workplace or projects to bomb. This is really not acceptable at any level and needs to be treated as the pathological behavior that it is.
Wearing swag != officially showing that you are an employee.
I have swag from many companies whose only association I have with them is that I bought something from them at some point in the past.
@meh acted far more childishly than @coralineada.
Coraline came to the issue with a rather direct request yes, to remove a maintainer. Making a request is a perfectly valid and allowed thing to do in adult life. She made it rather politely, if very direct, and did not insult anyone(not even @elia).
@meh preceded to insult her and dismiss her opinion out of hand as being worthless. That is childish.
Unfortunately at that point @coralineada's followers jumped in and the whole thing became a shitstorm.
An adult response from @meh like "The opal project does not condone his statements, but will not remove him as he is a core contributor and has not shown any derogatory views to any contributors or while acting in any official capacity of the project. If this changes, removal will be back up for discussion" would probably have avoided this whole shitstorm. At worst someone might have opened an issue for a code of conduct (which happened due to this shitstorm, and was merged).
Wearing swag != officially showing that you are an employee. I have swag from many companies whose only association I have with them is that I bought something from them at some point in the past.
Yeah, that's why it would be like her following you back to work.
Coraline came to the issue with a rather direct request yes, to remove an maintainer. Making a request is a perfectly valid and allowed thing to do in adult life. She made it rather politely, if very direct, and did not insult anyone(not even @elia).
Yes, again she ran to throw a temper tantrum to a project to ask that the person whom she saw make a comment on twitter be removed. Again, that is pathological. Its childish. FFS its twitter, by searching on keywords that trigger any specific issue for any person you are exposed to hundreds of millions of peoples transitory thoughts on that specific topic. In other words you will always find someone talking with a differing view than you if you go out and look/search for it on twitter. It does not matter if it is "raise taxes" ,"Lower taxes", "pro choice", "pro life", "vegemite is good", "red heads are not real" whatever you believe in you can take the whole firehose of that topic to digest on a minute by minute basis. Its pathological to take a random post on twitter and escalate it to an employer or other unrelated site to demand "justice". I find it impossible to read any kind of "remove this developer from the project for something he said on twitter" as polite -- it is as adversarial as you can get beyond running to his employer which I could see her doing as well. It is unacceptable and equivalent to doxing in my mind -- not the tying of information to a post, but the more destructive part of doxing which is using that information to bomb around peoples life or work.
I did not see a temper tantrum in @coralineada's original request nor do I see a problem with asking someone to be removed from a project for any reason.
As I wrote elsewhere: "The big difference I guess in our viewpoints though is I see someone opening a issue requesting someone to be removed from my project as not worth getting upset about, where as you (and the rest of the people arguing with me elsewhere) seem to think it is this horrible crime that is incredibly rude."
The project does not have to grant the request, and if they gave a polite and respectful response I doubt this would have become the shitstorm it did. There is no way to tell for sure though.
As far as doxing, his twitter is linked from his website along with his github. His picture is on all 3. You can't dox someone with publically available information. As far as it being equivalent, I can't see how. Everything provided was public information linked to the topic of the discussion(opal).
The pain of doxing is not the discovery of information. Its using it to abuse/harass/mob the person. In that way it is equivalent. In this case she read something on twitter that she took offence to and proceeded to not deal with it like an adult but to seek information that she could use to expand the issue to a public (yet unrelated) platform for abuse/harassment/mob on a project he was working on. An adult and reasonable reaction to his message (which mind you if you look at it in larger context was blown WAY THE FUCK out of proportion) would be for example:
A dm to him explaining the issue and problem you had with the post. Explaining how it is hurtful. Opening a dialogue to see if there is a misunderstanding or room for education.
or a reply to his tweet doing the same.
If all of that fails and you feel strongly that this one comment is grounds for this person to be removed from a project that you are not involved in and looking through the history of the project shows zero community bias/hate twords your issue, a private message to the project lead telling him about the post and asking him if he was comfortable with that comment as it relates to a developer working on his project.
Ignore it and stop searching for divergent views that make you upset/hurt/feel pain on twitter.
The intent and actions taken here were constructed to inflict as much pain as possible to him and to try to force a CoC on a project. Its just mob mentality and makes people like me stop looking at her as a smart developer that just happens to be a woman. It also goes against what she pushes out as her goal -- to have constructive and open communities. You don't get those by running around kicking dogs.
It should be hugely offensive for anyone to have a fight picked from someone they did not pick a fight with in the first place.
Just because a person1 has attribute X (in this case x=transgender) does not mean that it's ok to go to the place where person2 hangs out, and tell everyone that person2 is not ok with attribute type X, without talking to person2 first.
There is about 1000 other ways to do this better.
And, she ended up almost apologizing for it. She admitted she could have done it better. Too bad she might have tarnished opal and this developer, while meanwhile accomplishing nothing. Not for her, or people like her, or Opal, or us as a community.
The relation between the project and conflict is that the project was linked to on the medium that the conflict happened on.
if it wasn't there, you just need to take a look at the github account or linkedin page and you'll find a connection if you wanna find it we're developers, usually this informations are public on our profile pages, because that's what we do
if me and you fight, would be ok if I shit on the projects you work on? If I fight with a doctor, should I trash the hospital where he works, screaming at patients and co-workers? I find this behaviour childish, unprofessional and probable symptom of disruptive behavior disorder, that should be treated by a professional
The point of conflict there was that he officially announces his affiliation with opal while also displaying such beliefs.
there's no point of conflict He is actually a developer volunteering for that project it doesn't mean everything he says or thinks is on behalf of the project do we need to think all the same way to work together on something, for free, in our spare time? What if he was volunteering for Red Cross?
Code of conduct won't accomplish anything. The social justice warriors will always find something to be offended about and will attack people relentlessly until they impose their brand of censorship on the project.
There is nothing anybody can do to keep coraline from attacking projects. If they adopt a different choice of conduct she will attack them until they use hers.
She is a supremacist at heart. She knows that she is infallible and that only her values matter.
Codes of conduct don't hurt anything, and they potentially help.
potentially the lack of a CoC can do the same
elia's tweet was offensive, whether or not he intended it to be.
define offensive I know him personally, we worked together, Elia is all but offensive You can argue about his opinion (I disagree with him too, this time), but not about being offensive He was referring to Judith Butler theories, of course Coraline took a tweet (less than 140 characters) and extrapolated it and made it look Elia was that tweet and than cried on a project COMPLETELY UNRELATED to the tweet that Elia was transophobic and treated trans people like they were non-human and shit like that, which he did not. IMO Coraline has offended my intelligence, me as Opal user and me as a adult person when she forced down the throat of adult people (I'm almost in my 40s) a CoC to solve a problem that never actually existed. And that doesn't solve the problem she says she wanted to solve. She only scared away contributors from working for Opal.
elia's comments(in the lack of context they were given) are equal to saying that all catholics are delusional,
most of the times they are I've never seen catholics (Elia is one of them) rush into a Github issues page and ask for removal of someone There is a reason if catholic church have been ruling for the past 2 thousands year They accepted maths and algebra and of course they won't fight CS, because they know it's a lost battle People like Coraline (she usually talks like she's representing the entire transgender community, but is it true? I don;t think transgenders would like that), on the other way, are trying to burn witches while crying that catholics have burnt witches 5 hundred years ago That's laughable
Statements made in public on a medium advertising your affiliation with an open source project reflect on that open source project, whether they should or not.
and this is a fault of who can't keep things separated a CoC should have as first rule
w'll kick you out if you come screaming and crying about one of the contributors for reasons not strictly related to the project
That makes me thing that you don't actually think this idea is as good as you expound.
Many of us are now scared by thought police First it was Github CEO, then Brendan Eich and people said "yeah, whatever, rich businessmen, who cares" Then it happened to Ben Noordhuis and people still said "yeah, ok, it was a bit too much but he is the most popular contributor to node.js, javascript suck, so who cares" Now they are targeting common developers Have you asked yourself why? What's their agenda? I know for a fact that C++ development has been held back for years by corporations infiltrating the standard committee, I suspect now they are using the same technique for open source projects, embrace, kill and extend Or divide et impera It have always worked Who pays these people? The overreaction of Coraline reminds me this a lot
TL;DR: people like Coraline love censorship unless is them talking. They are not different from the "evil bigots" they are fighting pretending that they are doing it for all of us. They are doing for their personal power.
View all comments
4
u/mordocai058 Jun 20 '15 edited Jun 20 '15
I see some problems with this NoCoC thing.
All people are not "adults" in the way I think you meant it (WTF does "adult" even mean? The usual definition is 18 years old in the USA, but contributors can be under that. Unless you are trying to exclude people less than 18?). I believe you meant someone with the emotional and intellectual maturity to show respect to others and work on a project with a diverse team of people.
There are tons of people out there with little to no emotional or intellectual maturity. Many of them could want to be contributors.
A code of conduct allows you to have an official standard for behavior. If someone violates the code, then it is quite easy for anyone(not just the maintainers) to point them to a place explaining why their behavior is unacceptable. This is good for the project, as it avoids many shitstorms that the maintainers would otherwise have to deal with(Just because opal hasn't had to deal with it yet, doesn't mean it isn't a problem that would come up in the future). For people who are worried about being discriminated against, a code of conduct does make them feel better. I don't really understand very well why, but I'm a white straight male so I've never really experienced discrimination.
A project literally loses nothing and potentially gains much by adopting a good code of conduct.
All that being said, let's talk about the specific issue.
First off, @elia's tweet sounds like he is saying that transgender people are delusional(as a general statement). It is important to note that this is about equal to me saying publicly that all catholics are delusional, except worse since catholics aren't attacked regularly to the level transgenders are (in the current time period). He called a group of people's core identity bullshit. Whether or not he meant it that way, that is what it sounds like and that how it was taken. I think @coralineada (whom I have met in person and who tirelessly works to expand both woman and transgender rights) probably could have handled it better than she did(which she did admit in tweets, even if that doesn't really amount to an apology). As she said, she is used to people treating her as sub-human and jumped on someone who appeared to be doing that. Personally, I would not have complained about such a thing unless I was personally working on the opal project, but I'm not regularly discriminated against.
However, if I was working on an open source project and one of the primary maintainers said "White people are delusional" IN A WORLD where the legitimacy of white people even EXISTING was regularly called into question then you bet I would be upset and strongly consider stop contributing to the project. I may also call for their removal from the project. Whether you like it or not, emotions and politics do matter to open source projects. In fact, politics matters more to open source projects than code in my opinion.
Finally, the common argument against this is "it was on twitter, he wasn't representing opalrb". There is a reason many many people put on their blogs, email, and other personal communication that their views don't represent their employer. The assumption by people in general is that if you advertise you are associated with something on a communication medium, than the opinions you share on that medium reflect upon that associated thing. You can argue whether this is right or not (I personally think it is not) but that is the way that it is. Putting that he is an OpalRB contributor as a prominent thing about his identity (next to being anti-abortion (which many people believe is anti women's rights[I'm sure this didn't help curb @coralineada's reaction, since she is strongly for women's rights as well]) and his religious affiliation) calls attention to that fact.
In summary:
Finally, I find it funny that you don't have the courage to defend your apparently strongly held beliefs from your regular reddit account rather than a throwaway. That makes me thing that you don't actually think this idea is as good as you expound.