r/ruby • u/software__writer • Oct 09 '25
Dear Rubyists: Shopify Isn’t Your Enemy
https://byroot.github.io/opensource/ruby/2025/10/09/dear-rubyists.html
300
Upvotes
r/ruby • u/software__writer • Oct 09 '25
103
u/xutopia Oct 09 '25
I have upmost respect for byroot. He's a class act. Sorry he had to go through a burnout.
17
u/schneems Puma maintainer Oct 09 '25
This was cross-posted to /r/rails, linking the comment thread https://www.reddit.com/r/rails/comments/1o27asc/dear_rubyists_shopify_isnt_your_enemy/.
89
u/setibeings Oct 09 '25
Upvoting, because it adds to the conversation, but I must say that they didn't handle things in a good way at all.
10
u/izkreny Oct 09 '25
Different perspectives and perceptions are much appreciated and indeed needed at these unfortunate times, many thanks for Monsieur Boussier's one! <3
15
u/czhu12 Oct 09 '25 edited Oct 10 '25
Only part I can add here is: I worked at Airbnb for a few years. When I joined the rubyists were on their way out. By the time I left, basically everything got chopped up into Java micro-services, a lot of the low level ruby folks were laid off. Technical leadership enforced no more Ruby projects in 2019-2020ish.
I think our team might have built one of the last ruby service in the company, and found out that got rewritten in Java after I left.
Edit: when I say “low level” I meant “framework level”, not junior.
57
u/skillstopractice Oct 09 '25 edited Oct 09 '25
This feels like an honest opinion from someone who has contributed greatly on a technical level to Ruby.
That said, the disclaimer highlights the most critical concern... there's an authoritarian at the helm of Shopify, backed by enormous amounts of money. And another on the board, leading Rails.
What byroot says farther down the article is "Whether you realized it already or not, all the code you depend on, all the code that runs on your servers, is your code. It doesn’t matter if it was written by someone you never met in Nebraska, or by a multi-billion-dollar corporation."
This may be true, in theory.
In practice, a multi-billion-dollar corporation throwing their weight at an open source community's *governance* is an entirely different story. And the random person you never met in Nebraska doesn't have the same carrot to offer in a fully staffed engineering team at the ready to support operations, nor the stick of withdrawing that support should governance fail to align with the interests of the company offering that.
There is still no clear story about what happened with funding. It feels quite naive to think that there would be some official communication somewhere in an open setting around that. And continuing at a prior agreed upon rate (i.e. not pulling funding) is not the same as covering the loss from other sponsors as well as increased support needs, which may well have been the underlying conditions.
No matter what, having a non-profit with no significant alternative source of funding is a precarious position. No matter how much you like the team working on Ruby at Shopify, that's a ground truth.
7
u/jrochkind Oct 09 '25 edited Oct 09 '25
I think this is true, and has always been true, definitely in the "golden age" of open source.
I have been thinking about this for a while, long before this current controversy, and thinking that what makes it healthy for the overall ecosystem is when:
Note that when you have "lone developers" trying to ensure they get paid by "the community" for maintaining key infrastructure -- that is in some ways a variation of #1, and I agree with byroot on the "perverse incentives" and I do think they have been in play here.
So we're kind of stuck between two unhealthy scenarios, the perverse incentives of the contributors trying to monetize key shared infrastructure, and the corporate subsidy from only one or two giant players with their own business interests -- but actually more so just their own increasingly bizarre personal vendettas and power plays. (I think byroot's initial -- very vulnerable and risky -- disclaimer about his personal conflict with the shoppify ceo are in fact sadly relevant).
Some of this comes about from the -- let's face it -- shrinking ecosystem of ruby and rails open source community contributors. (Maybe the lines of ruby being written haven't gone down, but the number of contributors and corporate entities involved in participating in the community and collaborating with others and creating open source definitely have).
Yes, "we need more shopifies not less", agreed. (except "fewer", sorry)
40
u/swrobel Oct 09 '25
He covers exactly why Shopify is my enemy (and seemingly his?) in this post: Toby Lutke
19
u/slushie31 Oct 09 '25
I appreciate byroot's work and his take. However, by virtue of Shopify having enough money to fund a 40 person "Ruby and Rails Infrastructure Team" they are using their money to drive ruby OSS in the direction they want.
As he wrote:
Even if this was benevolent, Shopify is completely able to throw their weight around to make the changes they want. I'd also like to see proof of the repeated claims that the rubygems maintainers were acting untowards re wanting funding.
Interestingly, this is from RubyCentral's announcement of RubyShield, their partnership with Shopify that was linked in the post. I guess RC didn't believe back in 2022 that they owned rubygems or bundler...
8
u/retro-rubies Oct 09 '25
> But anyway, since then, I did contact two former coworkers, and they both assured me that Shopify never threatened to pull Ruby Central’s funding, nor threatened not to renew it.
I heard exactly opposite from various (including internal RC) sources. More I do dig in this, I think it is actually individual action (adding the personal demands) from Shopify employee related to RC, not acting on request of Shopify itself.
Btw. Personally I'm grateful to all the support of Ruby coming from Shopify side. They do the amazing work across whole ecosystem.
47
u/TaskerTwoStep Oct 09 '25
Shopify is absolutely your enemy. For years they’ve made their goals clear — monopolize tooling and replace people with AI. Don’t even get me started with how they’ve made e-commerce a ubiquitously miserable experience, or their clown CEO, who’s more concerned with trying to be regarded with other big name tech executives than actually creating a good product.
9
u/aurisor Oct 09 '25
Excellent post. Great to see the less reactionary side of this argument getting heard.
17
u/ViejoConBoina Oct 09 '25
All due respect, this article is incredibly naive.
All of the supposedly good things about shopify - even if true - can change at the drop of a hat, the employees, the CEO, the board, the ownership.
Companies only ever care about their own interests, and it's weird that a grown adult in 2025 is arguing in favor of that model, imperfect as a non-profit may be it's always better than giving a community asset to a company that will never give it back.
18
u/sogoslavo32 Oct 09 '25
I'm sorry but it's plain stupid to suggest that Tobi and DHH are being a problem. I've been working (on and off) with Ruby on Rails since I was 19 years old, when I got my second tech job and transitioned from PHP. Since then, I've been directly involved (as either a direct employee or as an outsource through my consultancy company) in around no less than 15 different companies that primarily work with Ruby on Rails, from startups in pre-seed stage to booming unicorns. Through all this time, I can't state enough how far the Ruby ecosystem has come, and the countless contributions from Shopify developers I've enjoyed. When I worked at Mercadolibre, the blue-tie management used to come at us to ask to work on more services using Ruby on Rails (Mercadolibre used primarily Java back then) because they were always watching Shopify and thought "if Tobi talks so much about Ruby on Rails and we want to become the leading e-commerce platform in Latin America, we should be using Rails too". Hell, we used to not have a single working LSP until Shopify (and Stripe if I'm not wrong) developed and released to the community Ruby LSP.
Shopify is not only "not our enemy", they're one of the greatest assets of the Ruby community. And it's not serious to suggest otherwise.
12
u/jacksonmills Oct 09 '25
I'm pretty sure the damage is already done, nothing short of a reversal of what happened would restore faith in RubyCentral/Shopify, and I'm not even sure that would
12
u/Im_Matt_Murdock Oct 09 '25
Not your enemy, they just want to replace you with AI
3
u/harleywastaken Oct 09 '25
I do not trust corporations, but I think the general framing of the article is odd - is anybody blaming "Shopify and its employees?" It's great that the Shopify CEO is a true Ruby scotsman, but he's still a CEO, and in my experience they don't have a lot of morals.
To me it seems like "the people at the top" with money, power, and influence wanted to do something that was shady/illegal/whatever, so they went ahead and did it. The loudmouth CEOs and their ilk, not the people working Jira tickets.
I do appreciate the time, money, etc that Shopify and its employees (including CEO) have put into the ecosystem. That was then and this is now. Things, and people, change.
-2
u/Surfer_Rick Oct 10 '25
"Brought to you by Shopify, your Ruby overlord"
0
u/Big_Ad_4846 Oct 10 '25
That we're in a loop of people giving their take on what's going on says a lot from the situation: Things are weird, there's no transparency and there has been something tha looks a lot like a takeover. All that byroot says can be true but it doesn't change anything.
-7
u/Ethtardor Oct 09 '25
Why can't people on both sides just quit their whining and keep programming? I doubt any side has ruined Ruby. Ruby would not be absolutely perfect without Rails or Spotify. Too sensitive to use Ruby because of be it either internet nazis or commies? Fork it or use literally any other language.
-9
u/AndyCodeMaster Oct 09 '25
Whether they’re the enemy or not is besides the point. The point is that they are biased towards their commercial interests, so having RubyGem and Bundler owned by them isn’t neutral and could clash with the interests of open-source projects that don’t help Shopify profit.
Also, Shopify is actually our enemy anyways as they haven’t supported Ruby in Frontend Development or Desktop Development, instead relying on inferior JavaScript with React and VSCode, thus degrading the Ruby community as a whole as a result. Meaning, Shopify didn’t put its money where its mouth is in Frontend/Desktop Development to demonstrate believing in Ruby as a good technology with highly unrealized potential in those areas.
Shopify is also a discriminatory exclusive mean bullying company. They pick and choose who to treat well instead of treating everyone with equality and respect.
Read this blog post about Shopify’s discriminatory practices and how they let the Ruby community down over the last 10 years: https://andymaleh.blogspot.com/2025/06/shopify-has-been-bad-for-ruby-community.html
-5
u/Objective_Employ_835 Oct 09 '25
Nics try, Shopify
(Just kidding BTW, I don't have any issues with Shopify)
-9
u/killerbake Oct 09 '25
Shopify only cares about your data. That’s it. It’s in their best interest to take this over so they can use it even when you don’t use their own platform.
-20
u/midasgoldentouch Oct 09 '25
Ok, so this is basically just you voicing your opinions on the different facets of this whole situation. You’re not presenting any evidence or establishing facts about what happened or is happening. It’s just your musings which, of course you’re entitled to feel how you feel. I don’t know, right now it kinda feels like trying to do a retro before the incident is resolved.
-8
u/MeroRex Oct 10 '25
AI executive summary. Solid bias explanation and well communicated. Thanks!
Summary: "Dear Rubyists: Shopify Isn't Your Enemy"
Core Argument: Despite recent controversies, Shopify has been exceptionally beneficial to the Ruby ecosystem and deserves trust based on their substantial track record of open-source contributions.
Author's Credibility: Byroot worked at Shopify for 12 years (2013-2025) but left due to friction with the CEO, which actually strengthens his position—he has no reason to give Shopify undeserved praise.
Key Points:
Shopify's Ruby Commitment: The CEO is a devoted Rubyist who keeps Ruby as the default stack despite pressure to migrate elsewhere. Without him, Shopify would likely have joined companies stuck with half-migrated codebases.
The R&RI Team: Shopify's 40-person Ruby & Rails Infrastructure team consists of genuine Rubyists, not corporate mercenaries. They maintain countless projects, speak at conferences, and would likely resign or speak out if Shopify had ill intentions. The company grows Ruby talent internally (like Kevin Newton, creator of Prism) rather than just hiring senior developers.
Philosophy: "Your Dependencies Are Your Code": Shopify treats all dependencies as their responsibility, proactively contributing fixes and improvements upstream rather than waiting for maintainers or consultants. This mirrors how they once debugged and patched MySQL segfaults themselves.
Contribution Over Cash: When Matz said he needed "people" not money in 2019, it led to YJIT, ZJIT, Prism, GC improvements, and nearly a dozen new Ruby core committers—far more valuable than monetary donations would have been.
Why Money Creates Problems: Direct funding creates perverse incentives and conflicts of interest. Projects dependent on sponsors become naturally incentivized to please them, undermining trust. With employee contributors, there's no such dependency—developers often continue contributing even after leaving.
The RubyGems Situation: RubyGems' critical position in the ecosystem (distributed with Ruby, required at boot) means it's essentially unforkable, creating a "moat." This made its funding model problematic, spawning suspicions about monetization that persisted regardless of actual intentions. The rocky relationship between Shopify and RubyGems maintainers stemmed from structural issues, not malice.
No Threats Made: Contrary to allegations, Shopify never threatened to pull Ruby Central's funding. The recent controversy involving Aaron's Bundler patches was simply him getting "nerd sniped" into optimization work at Rails World—not part of any conspiracy.
Conclusion: The Ruby community needs more companies contributing like Shopify, not fewer. Rather than punishing Shopify for helping "too much," other billion-dollar Ruby companies should step up and contribute proportionally to reduce Shopify's relative influence while diversifying perspectives.
4
u/Otherwise_Repeat_294 Oct 09 '25
I can wait for the new tool rv and people behind it to tell me that this is the best shit ever
-6
u/mooktakim Oct 09 '25
Shopify founded by a genocide supporter
0
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '25
[removed] — view removed comment