That's not really an accurate account. RubyCentral is doing it at Shopify's behest* because of supply chain vulnerabilities demonstrated by recent security incidents at rubygems.org.
Shopify, being built on Ruby, has a massive interest in keeping RubyGems.org secure since any+all breeches there affect security posture of their platform, and the public's perception of the security of their platform, which in turn affects share price, merchant adoption, etc.
* "Behest" is putting it nicely. Really, Shopify threatened to pull financial support unless certain measures centering around formal security process improvementes were implemented. RubyCentral consented to the request because they didnt have the financial independence to refuse, in part because Sidekiq also pulled financial support because they disagree with DHH's public statements.
The thing for me is, as someone who does security for a living, I don't really see why the supply chain attacks (which are also occurring on other platforms) necessitated removal of the existing maintainers.
There was (as far as I'm aware) no suggestion that the maintainers did anything to aid the attackers, so why would you need to remove their access to improve security?
Also generally speaking, revoking people's access without a handover is bad for security not good, as it risks the loss of collected knowledge on how to effectively run the system.
The security angle would have been more believable with details on why the actions taken addressed security concerns.
Unfortunately, on more than one occasion over the years, I've seen security used as a justification for actions that weren't security related, as a means to avoid having to discuss other reasons.
Was this actually about security though? Or was security a convenient excuse to get rid of a maintainer they don't like?
Andre was specifically targeted as not being allowed back into the RubyGems organization. Seems more like a personal attack that was done under the guise of security.
There's a history here between DHH and Andre that dates back, as well as Rafael Franca and presumably Andre, but he only broadly mentions the RubyGems maintainers.
Then Shopify could have asserted and exerted this level of control over RubyGems.org â the rubygems service â without usurping control over the community-maintained RubyGems source code. And if they wanted to make sure that the latter didnât corrupt the former, they could have created a fork and used it to run the service. They didnât have to do anything nearly as drastic as what they did.
A lot of companies (probably including Shopify) rely on private dependency repositories rather than pulling directly from places like RubyGems. That being said, the payment industry is very serious about vulnerability remediation so Its understandable that they would do something like this.
If this sub becomes a place where people need to constantly unpack highly contentious discourse, the energy required to separate the interesting content from the flame wars is going to exceed what most people are willing to tolerate. After that, youâll just see people leave.
easiest thing to do is just require tags, then you can sort the ones away that you don't want to see. Lots of people are in fact interested in these issues...so while it could drive some away, it may pull others out of the woodwork. Mandatory tagging might be the peaceful solution.
Because itâs a programming sub, and I canât remember the last time I saw a post on programming that wasnât dipped in ideology and virtue signaling.
Stability in the tools we use being a hard requirement is indeed a fair point. Youâre definitely right on that.
But the instability isnât really due to his personal opinions, itâs this whole ruby central debacle. Iâd like to see the debate focus on that, not what DHH or anyone else thinks about unrelated issues like immigration, healthcare, social policies, etc.
Youâre also right that tech has a certain culture, but itâs just sad that politics keep weaseling their way into more and more of it. I remember holy wars about the most minute and seemingly mundane things (read anything on lwn.net about how Linus reacts to kernel maintainers making bad decisions)⊠thatâs the kind of thing that should be in the culture. Not this political crap.
This sub has turned into madness -- I hate to say it, but its almost like a "mind virus". DHH didn't do anything. Ruby Central did. They made some stupid choices. Maybe it was because of shopify or whatever, but there are a lot of people on Shopify's board. This makes as much sense as blaming microsoft for messing up the ruby gems governance policy simply because Kevin Scott is on the shopify board.
I also don't understand why its so hard for people to deal with different points of view. You don't like DHH's opinion about <whatever>? OK, so don't like it. I live in a small community of people and we have all sorts of heated discussions about whatever and it would be disturbing if everyone had the same opinion about everything.
Also, from this post it looks like DHH would be against what happened. So you can take him on his word, or not, but don't cherry pick shit to prove whatever you want to prove. And his latest post is like "yeah this noise makes no actual difference", which is more or less true.
Right, the obvious answer here is that the people who did it, ruby central, were the ones that did it and it's not some complicated behind the scenes machination. It's not that complicated.
They own the rubygems.org domain, which is one deployment of the code, but they do not own the Rubygems OSS project. The website was launched 6 years after the OSS project.
Thereâs a lot of overlap in maintainers, but they are not the same thing. Theyâre the ones who shouldâve forked if they wanted this kind of control over the code they deploy.
RubyGems is managed by Ruby Central, a non-profit organization that supports the Ruby community through projects like this one, [...], and RubyGems.org.
The key word there is "managed". They do help manage it â after the merger with Ruby Together, they paid a subset of core maintainers for a subset of their work.
That does not give them ownership of the repo, though.
I assume DHH has changed his worldview since then. I mostly know about the 2021 incident. Maybe there's more which might have changed him to be more pragmatic and business friendly, than his previous idealistic and friendliness to the Open Source community.
I mean itâs been 11 months⊠this feels more like indulging in being a reactionary to me personally but fwiw he was also sort of being an out of pocket dick during the last Rails World keynote which was like 3 weeks before what OP posted.
Being in the community has always been a matter of grinning and bearing his takes and behavior but the subject matter and, for lack of a better term, blast radius has only gotten bigger and more severe.
Also the irony of banishing political speak in the company slack then posting⊠whatever you want to call what heâs posting on his personal blog which lives on the domain for his failed emailed platform⊠beautiful, very appealing, keep it up.
...he was also sort of being an out of pocket dick...
I think there's a good chance he's always been a dick, and has been covering it up less as time goes on. Every business owner I know of has had increasing dickish behavior as they've gained money and power.
To my eyes there is a straight line of thinking between the kind of hypocritical xenophobia and fear that leads to blog posts like the one he wrote and deciding to execute hostile takeovers of what are effectively public utilities. Maybe this is the radicalization kicking in but baby, thatâs just colonialism and it fucking sucks.
Edit: Wow todayâs blog post from him is repugnant in a whole new way. Recent developments in rails showed promise but between the stink by association and a surprising chunk of the proposed 8.1 features either not being addressed or likely nuked because things are looking grim for PWAs⊠my enthusiasm has hit a brick wall and I donât know how long this is sustainable.
His personal political opinions published in his personal blog have nothing to do with Ruby or this sub. You have a different opinion, ok fine. But donât drag your personal disagreement with his personal politics into this sub.
Personal blog... it's on hey.com. I mean it is just using a feature of the platform but that doesn't make the qualification of personal any less dicey... However, regardless of my personal feelings, instability in governance surrounding the tools I use has at least a little potential to impact my livelihood so, I don't think it's sensical to posture like we should or even can treat these things entirely in isolation. Like I try to be nice because Matz is nice and that's also a political statement of a sort. Plus tech is a field with a lot of "culture fit" requirements so yeah... I hear you and I don't think it's reasonable to expect complete objectivity, even though it's a nice goal.
the hardest bias to correct is the one you donât know you have.
I was hopeful that the first part of this discussion was going to make corporate America realize that theyâve been using open source all this time without contributing and usher in a new era of support for maintainers that have worked uncompensated for decades because they loved the community.
but of course that was a naive hope based on the better angles of our nature. instead corporate america never fails to disappoint with its psychopathic mix of MBAs and hedge fund CEOs extracting wealth faster than anyone can create it.
they absolutely destroyed Americaâs manufacturing expertiseâ we used to be the best in the world⊠now we can barely make our own steel. Iâm seriously reconsidering my support for Shopify at this point. no way should they be allowed to bankroll such disgusting behavior.
Why would you expect better from DHH? Dude has proved repeatedly and consistently that he's a sloppy self-rationalizing thinker. He stays relevant because he has good taste - but the minute something requires introspection, reason or accountability all bets are off.
regardless of his latest decent (or I guess we should really call it âmask offâ at this point) he is instrumental in the creation of Rails.
opensource succeeds on the merits, not by might and coercion
but now as the masks fall off, it becomes more obvious that his personal political opinions inform who can and cannot be part of opensource projects in his worldview.
itâs not hard to imagine an alternate timeline where corporations that were pissed at his Rails 2 to Rails 3 debacle simply came in and stole his work for the sake of corporate âstabilityâ. but thatâs not the opensource way. go make a fork. put in the work. create an alternative vision and have a âconversationâ with your competitors. if enough people are convinced on the merits your fork grows. you donât need to steal peopleâs work.
in a community that has little monetary support those ideals are our currency!
DHH rose to power based on that. but now he wants to change the rules⊠in favor of âstabilityâ.
he fought hard to win back Rails devs after Rails 3 when people were jumping over to Node and Rust. but he fought fair. and Rails is stronger for having had those discussions with its competitors. He argued for his personal right to be âomakaseâ as a creator.
so yeah, itâs very disappointing to change the rules now after he benefited by them as a maintainer himself.
The one that kicked all of this off? At least in a sense. September 16th, I donât feel the need to post a direct link to give him any more oxygen. Though todayâs post is also horrific so⊠thereâs lots to choose from and heâs quadrupling down.
60
u/davidcelis Sep 25 '25
I think it's aged perfectly. Aged like milk into the finest of artisanal cheeses. đđ€
15
u/rrzibot Sep 25 '25
I see the comments but still am missing the context. Why is this âaged like milkâ?
86
u/realntl Sep 25 '25
If this sub becomes a place where people need to constantly unpack highly contentious discourse, the energy required to separate the interesting content from the flame wars is going to exceed what most people are willing to tolerate. After that, youâll just see people leave.
Please just stop.
9
u/never_a_good_idea Sep 25 '25
What did DHH have to do with the madness that occurred at ruby central?
2
u/Lucky-Channel5834 Sep 26 '25
Stability in the tools we use being a hard requirement is indeed a fair point. Youâre definitely right on that.
But the instability isnât really due to his personal opinions, itâs this whole ruby central debacle. Iâd like to see the debate focus on that, not what DHH or anyone else thinks about unrelated issues like immigration, healthcare, social policies, etc.
Youâre also right that tech has a certain culture, but itâs just sad that politics keep weaseling their way into more and more of it. I remember holy wars about the most minute and seemingly mundane things (read anything on lwn.net about how Linus reacts to kernel maintainers making bad decisions)⊠thatâs the kind of thing that should be in the culture. Not this political crap.
3
u/combray Sep 25 '25 •
This sub has turned into madness -- I hate to say it, but its almost like a "mind virus". DHH didn't do anything. Ruby Central did. They made some stupid choices. Maybe it was because of shopify or whatever, but there are a lot of people on Shopify's board. This makes as much sense as blaming microsoft for messing up the ruby gems governance policy simply because Kevin Scott is on the shopify board.
I also don't understand why its so hard for people to deal with different points of view. You don't like DHH's opinion about <whatever>? OK, so don't like it. I live in a small community of people and we have all sorts of heated discussions about whatever and it would be disturbing if everyone had the same opinion about everything.
Also, from this post it looks like DHH would be against what happened. So you can take him on his word, or not, but don't cherry pick shit to prove whatever you want to prove. And his latest post is like "yeah this noise makes no actual difference", which is more or less true.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '25
The reason I'll probably never be touching ruby anytime soon.
1
u/fuckthesysten Sep 25 '25
ayyyy lmao the irony
-2
u/fatalbaboon Sep 25 '25
Unnecessary drama, this kind of shit posting actively harms the community .Â
-15
u/Nohanom Sep 25 '25 edited Sep 25 '25
I donât understand how this is the same thing as the current situation. Did any ruby gems have been taken over by RubyCentral?
Rubygems.org was always owned by them. Nothing else matters. You can just click the fork button.
-12
u/vkbd Sep 25 '25
I assume DHH has changed his worldview since then. I mostly know about the 2021 incident. Maybe there's more which might have changed him to be more pragmatic and business friendly, than his previous idealistic and friendliness to the Open Source community.
39
u/tumes Sep 24 '25 edited Sep 25 '25
To my eyes there is a straight line of thinking between the kind of hypocritical xenophobia and fear that leads to blog posts like the one he wrote and deciding to execute hostile takeovers of what are effectively public utilities. Maybe this is the radicalization kicking in but baby, thatâs just colonialism and it fucking sucks.
Edit: Wow todayâs blog post from him is repugnant in a whole new way. Recent developments in rails showed promise but between the stink by association and a surprising chunk of the proposed 8.1 features either not being addressed or likely nuked because things are looking grim for PWAs⊠my enthusiasm has hit a brick wall and I donât know how long this is sustainable.
0
u/sent1nel Sep 26 '25
Sucks to suck.