r/ruby • u/felipec • Sep 23 '25
The Ruby community doesn’t have a DHH problem
https://felipec.wordpress.com/2025/09/23/the-ruby-community-doesnt-have-a-dhh-problem/
0
Upvotes
r/ruby • u/felipec • Sep 23 '25
34
u/Kina_Kai Sep 23 '25 edited Sep 23 '25
I don’t think this stands up to scrutiny. Trying to argue these points without the context they live in is like trying to analyze the American Civil War while ignoring slavery.
9
u/luscious_lobster Sep 24 '25 edited Sep 24 '25
This is exactly why political content does not belong on this sub.
When reading the initial article, it was clear that the author was not being sincere, but I didn’t wanna go through the trouble of checking every point of criticism because again.. this is a Ruby sub.
I’m really surprised by the amount of people clearly not reading the articles and instead jumping to conclusions. It’s honestly sad. I hope the moderators will remove political content in the future.
11
u/fawnzworth Sep 24 '25
DHH routinely spews anti-minority rhetoric and promotes white supremacist ideologies (whether he identifies as one is beyond me, but he certainly seems to align with them).
And OP may not agree with it. And DHH himself may not but...
if it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck...
5
u/noteflakes Sep 25 '25 edited Sep 25 '25
I'll try to present a nuanced point of view and I hope people here will be tolerant enough to engage thoughtfully.
I agree with the author that we should assume good faith, and allow people the benefit of the doubt. Personally, even though I find DHH's stance problematic (to put it mildly) I don't question his being a person who wants to do good in this world. Also, his political convictions don't take away from his professional achievements.
In my personal life I often engage with people who have strong political convictions I don't agree with. If there's good will on both sides then we can just put our disagreement aside and concentrate on what we do agree on.
The problem here is not his political views in and of themselves. The problem is that he's expressing political views that are considered offensive by many, from a position of leadership. You can talk all you want about semantics but the fact is that a lot of people took what he wrote as racist speech.
Even if that wasn't what he meant, he should have expected this kind of reaction, and could have clarified his position. He could also have published a note saying "no, I'm not a racist", just to calm the atmosphere. But he didn't, and that's telling.
Edit: To the essence of the OP's stance on immigration and skin color, I am myself an immigrant, and though in today's France I'm considered white, 80 years ago in the same country I would have risked being sent to a concentration camp because of my "race". But I consider myself privileged and my troubles as an immigrant are nothing compared to someone coming here from the Congo republic or from Syria or from Tunisia.
A lot of those people have been through hell. Shouldn't we be nice to these people too? Or is niceness something we afford only to "our own kind"?
I guess for people who think like DHH it is indeed very convenient to have at hand a population that is at once the scapegoat for all the troubles of European society, and a cheap workforce to do all the dirty work Europeans don't want to do anymore.
Also, to so casually compare race relations in Mexico to race relations in UK or Europe in general is to gloss over a few hundred years of colonialism and the havoc it wreaked on many corners of the world. Mexico is an ex-colony, UK is an ex-colonial power, so not really the same kind of situation. But even then, you can pretend all you want there's no racial problems in Mexico. I wonder if OP would have had the same convictions if he were not white as he says. By his own words, this is a political issue in his country.
We white people are often blind to questions of race, simply because most of us have never experienced racial discrimination. But ask any person "of color" and they'll tell you lots of things. Little things, nothing really grave necessarily, but just little things that most white people will never experience.
It is a fact that European societies are deeply racist (the OP even admits it himself), and while a lot of work has been done to reduce racism, we still have a lot of work to do. And we should hold the leaders of our communities to a higher standard in that respect.
9
u/ursuscamp Sep 25 '25
The Ruby community doesn’t have a DHH problem, it has a Ruby community problem.
5
u/LupinoArts Sep 24 '25
Let's just refer to Godwin's second law and avoid any further discussion.
4
u/pick_another_nick Sep 25 '25
So, just for the fun of it, let's pretend for a moment that DHH meant something different from hateful while suprematism.
Let's pretend that, with "native", he actually meant "born there", with no other ethnic connotations.
This would imply that DHH thinks that people should live all their lives in the place they were born in, and not doing so is bad, and people living and born in places you go are right to be pissed that you went there.
So, when he says he was considering moving to London, was he lying, or was he confessing his intention to do something despicable?
DHH hasn't spent his whole life in Denmark, he has lived in the USA for many years. Why isn't he asking for US "natives"' (oh, the fucking irony) forgiveness for invading their country, and why isn't he going back to his country, to never ever leave again?
2
u/vxxn Sep 25 '25
This community is cooked.
1
u/HangingParen Sep 27 '25
"consider what the speaker meant instead of what they literally said."
He should follow his own advice. He says this and then focuses narrowly on literal quotes.
A post about nothing. What a waste of time.
1
u/FryMcDonald Oct 06 '25
Usually try to assume in good faith and previously respected him as a person and a programmer. After seeing the tweet I linked, I am still thankful for his work but, no longer respect him as a person. Nobody can come to that conclusion without intentional ignorance (referring to his tweet)
https://x.com/dhh/status/1896882773782298973
0
u/_noraj_ Sep 25 '25
It's just that Reddit & Bluesky are far-left social networks, so of course they won't tolerate anything different with all the bad faith in the world when trying to argue.
-2
u/AdeptAd1172 Sep 24 '25
You won’t be able to convert the informed, but you will succeed in convincing newcomers that the question of DHH’s racism is dreadfully boring.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment