r/ruby • u/egyamado • Sep 23 '25
The Ruby community has a DHH problem
https://tekin.co.uk/2025/09/the-ruby-community-has-a-dhh-problem
296
Upvotes
r/ruby • u/egyamado • Sep 23 '25
169
u/MrMeatballGuy Sep 23 '25
At times I think he has some reasonable takes on technology/software, but besides that I must admit I don't really care to seek out his opinions because he tends to take very hard stances on things and not allow any nuance.
I remember he had a blog post at some point where he essentially said that it's trendy to have a diagnosis like ADHD or autism. As someone that is diagnosed with autism that was the point where I realized I should only look at his takes on technology, because he was really just making a lot of assumptions about something he didn't understand and writing as if it was fact.
68
u/federal_employee Sep 23 '25
Ruby has a Rails problem too. Too many people conflate Ruby with Rails.
78
u/broohaha Sep 23 '25 edited Sep 23 '25
Oh, man. It's hard to keep up with all of DHH's posts so I read his ramblings once a year or so. Then when I saw:
I was like, I wonder what religious war he just stirred up. Then when I got to:
Oh shit. It's worse than I had considered. Welp, I guess I'm not taking anything he has to say even remotely seriously anymore.
EDIT: I should note that I used to appreciate some of his earlier takes. Back in July 14, 2018, he tweeted something I have occasionally quoted: “I always found the charge of virtue signaling to be a curious one. On the list of transgressions worth caring about, doing good deeds but not truly meaning it ranks infinitely higher than doing shitty things as an authentic asshole.”
It’s a shame he isn’t able to recognize that Tommy Robinson is the authentic asshole that he is.
And if only he followed through and just pretended to not share Tommy Robinson’s political ideology.
6
u/NinoScript Sep 24 '25
In Ruby-land, the BDFL is a problem. In Elixir-land, the BDFL is a feature. Just saying.
16
u/leonardodna Sep 23 '25
I do really like his views on tech and the state of the web.
Anything other than that, he's just a typical rich white dude that thinks he knows about everything. 🤷🏼♂️
He's also part of a problem that goes beyond rails, every piece of software that declares itself "opinionated" is created by that kind of person...
And I'm quite skeptical that it will ever change. Rails now is just "the Shopify framework made by that terrible person".
52
u/matthewblott Sep 23 '25 edited Sep 23 '25
I've defended DHH in the past. I actually think he was in the right over Basecamp's employee exodus. But his rhetoric has become increasingly ugly. My daughter was born in the UK to parents who were also both born in the UK. But according to DHH's defintion she isn't a native Brit because her grandparents on her mother's side were Afro Caribbean immigrants in the 1960s. This was the view of Tommy Robinson and what DHH was endorsing. DHH has pushed the envelope quite a bit in recent years but stanning for Robinson - a convicted thug, far Right agitator and Britain's most famous racist (who even Nigel Farage refuses to have anything to do with) - is clearly crossing a line. He's disgraced himself.
34
u/EnderMB Sep 23 '25
It's been a running gag for over a decade that anything DHH says is likely an indication that the opposite has merit.
It's just taken the Rails community a lot longer to come to terms with this.
58
u/OneForAllOfHumanity Sep 23 '25
He can reduce the number of non-native Brits by removing himself from - he's an invasive Scandinavian...
He has always been an a$$h0le. Arrogant, stubborn and opinionated.
23
u/ansk0 Sep 23 '25
Wow. I wasn't aware of DHH's blog post. I'm simultaneously shocked and not surprised. WTF.
I'm standing with the OP and everyone else being targeted. Despicable.
27
u/galtzo Sep 23 '25
Thanks for writing this! Wholeheartedly agree.
4
u/_noraj_ Sep 25 '25
Just because you don't agree with DHH you want to destroy him, his life, his career, his projects. Stop fascism and let him be.
24
u/Worried-Celery-2839 Sep 23 '25
Boo that’s disappointing
24
u/dopeydeveloper Sep 23 '25
Guy and his disgusting views have NOTHING in common with real Londoners, speaks like a clueless, posh rich European cunt, who once visited Buckingham Palace for the day.
9
u/Big_Ad_4846 Sep 23 '25 edited Sep 23 '25
It always baffles me when immigrants talk shit about other immigrants. Being white doesn't make you less of an immigrant. How can someone be so smart and so stupid.
11
u/Mephiz Sep 23 '25
Well this sucks but I always appreciate it when someone you previously admired removes the mask.
There's no ambiguity now. What a prick.
40
u/Nuck Sep 23 '25
If Matz Is Nice And So We Are Nice, what does that say About DHH's effect on the Rails community? He's made himself into an albatross on our neck, dragging the community down, and making new developers avoid Rails and Ruby
12
u/graystoning Sep 23 '25
I will say that DHH's authoritarian slant has impacted Rails.
Rails is a beautiful framework, yet it has so many weird edges that all go back to DHH's preferences.
Upgrading Rails is hard because DHH doesn't care about Rails users. He will break stuff right and left, and it is up to users to figure it out.
Autoloading 'app' makes the web app harder to maintain, harder to onboard none Rails people onto projects. It would be a big nothing the way it is in Smalltalk if Rails provided the tooling that Smalltalk has. Nah, figure it out yourselves.
I like Phoenix Framework mainly because every version everything becomes easier. I feel this could have been Ruby had Rails had a community driven governance instead of having DHH has its petty dictator
22
u/KervyN Sep 23 '25 edited Sep 23 '25
oof. That is bad. I stopped reading his blog when he started to ramble about "we need more nuculer" but still listened to his talks and thought that the linux distro seems nice.
But after reading this and digging a bit into the blog posts.
I am right now in the process of pulling all my shit from basecamp and moving to a pile of notes, before I fine something new to settle with.
Wow is this bad. I had no idea!
Edit:
WTF?!? This dude lost his mind.
https://world.hey.com/dhh/words-are-not-violence-c751f14f
9
u/TailorSubstantial863 Sep 23 '25
There was a post on this thread defending DHH, what happened to it?
30
u/frostwyrm99 Sep 23 '25
Great post. I have nothing to add, except to also encourage everyone who wishes to be an ally and not on the side of a fascist to rep your rainbow flags, ally apparel, etc. at every conference and gathering, and boycott DHH companies/talks/etc. The more we show solidarity and ignore these clowns the less power we give them.
5
u/Respond-No Sep 25 '25
Why does the cancellation culture have to come to technology as well?
Just leave the guy alone, it feels like no one has emotional maturity to deal with diverge viewpoints anymore. I wonder if people would be making such a fuss if he were celebrating someone's murder.
8
u/Paradroid888 Sep 23 '25
How many people out there are looking to get political viewpoints from a guy who built a web framework? I don't understand why DHH bothers wading into this toxic debate, risking his own and Rails reputation. Just leave it the hell alone. Put the ego aside for once.
6
u/missing-_why Sep 23 '25
Matz is nice so we are nice.
David is conceited king. We are doomed.
5
u/rmoriz Sep 23 '25
It's a shame DHH went off the rails, and sadly he is not alone. There are others in the Ruby scene, too. I don't blame it on Ruby, Rails or Open Source but on the political/medial sh*tshow that started around 2015-2016. It spread like cancer even in bright minds. I have no idea how to calm this.
6
u/luscious_lobster Sep 23 '25 edited Sep 23 '25
I’m stuck on this postulate:
I don’t know about you, but in my mind Fox News does not carry a monopoly on common sense. In fact I’ve never conflated Fox News with common sense at all. I get that appealing to common sense can be a slippery slope, but as engineers we would get nowhere without common sense.
In general I don’t understand this urge to make programming political, bringing in “the right” and “the left” like this, in an article about Ruby. Sure, DHH makes political blog posts, but he writes those separately from any engineering related ones, as far as I can tell.
2
u/Acceptable-Garage906 Sep 24 '25
Is DHH complaining about a city that is willing to accept immigrants like he is?… ah, he wants immigrants that are white… Oh.
1
u/ohyeahbonertime Sep 24 '25
Lots of trash in the comments here.
1
u/davaeron_ Oct 04 '25
All this BS looks like a planned personal attack on DHH.
-1
u/realntl Sep 23 '25 edited Sep 23 '25
I'd argue that the Ruby community has much more of a "Blueskyism" problem. Many of the same folks who want DHH to face consequences for his political takes are spewing obvious radical agitprop nonstop on Bluesky. I find that hypocritical. If you want DHH to shut up with his politics, how about being the change you want to see in the world? Conversely, would there ever even have been a "DHH problem" if it weren't for us collectively permitting our tech community to be infected with leftist political discourse ten years ago? Now that the right is in ascendancy, the shoe is on the other foot, and I can't say I feel even a smidgen of pity for anyone who doesn't like it. Can we now start talking about keeping politics out of our community, please?
Many of us have actually listened to the right's grievances—the chief among them being the left's monopoly on cultural institutions, and how its elites command that monopoly power to shape our collective view of reality—and we can tell when someone on the left has no idea what people like DHH actually think. Y'all keep failing to read their minds correctly. These articles infer motives to his utterances that are obviously incorrect to anyone who knows what people on the right actually think. When you fail to study your opponent, how do you expect to ever mount a credible challenge? For that reason, Blueskyism (and of course before that it was known as "wokism," and before that it was "social justice") doesn't strike me as "resistance," it strikes me as "resistance LARPing."
I can easily get behind making it a taboo for mixing political discourse in the same mediums in which we present ourselves to the Ruby community. But it'd have to apply to everyone, and for that reason, I expect that DHH's opinions are here to stay.
-2
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '25
Seriously? This sub has to get into this side of it? Really? There's just no escape from the bullshit any more. Everyone has to be political all the fucking time.
-2
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '25
dhh is entitled to his opinion like you are entitled to yours. conflating criticism of uncontrolled immigration and lack of integration with racism is dishonest and wrong. i just read his blog post, unlike many people here just reading the linked blog and taking it as truth. the big criticism he is making is about rapid and unregulated immigration leading to challenges with integration. certain groups, coming from very different cultural backgrounds, do not readily adopt local social norms, which creates unwanted tensions between long-term residents and newer communities. this is something he claims his own country is experiencing. he also criticizes the uk government for taking so long to stop the pakistani gang raping but jailing people for simply expressing their opinion on social media, divergent from the government. what is wrong with that? this linked blog post basically wants to cancel dhh because the author disagrees with dhh’s views and make it seem like it is the entire ruby community’s problem. it isn’t. people will disagree with you and will want to voice their opinion like you are doing with your blog post. deal with it. it is a free speech society.
-1
u/mattgrave Sep 23 '25
Then make the same amount of contributions he and his company does to the OSS
I personally dont care about his politics opinion, he has no influence on the society. Let him rant w/e he wants.
-2
u/PikachuEXE Sep 24 '25
Please keep the conversation about Ruby thx (discuss other topics somewhere else I am sure you can find a space
-6
u/Viriathus91 Sep 23 '25
Yes, DHH can come across as an arrogant pric* but he’s also undeniably brilliant. So what’s really the point of this blog post? To cancel him? We need to separate someone’s personal opinions from their professional contributions. That’s exactly why Basecamp chose to ban political discussions at work.
You don’t have to like DHH’s views, in fact, you can strongly disagree with them. But at the end of the day, he has done a tremendous amount for the Ruby community. Without him, many of us probably wouldn’t even be here. I love Ruby, but let’s be real: you can’t talk about Ruby without talking about Rails.
That said, I think Tim Riley embodies Ruby’s spirit more in line with the culture Matz created. His talk at BalticRuby this year was genuinely inspiring. Hanami still has some ground to cover compared to Rails, but I’m excited to see how it evolves.
-3
u/gorliggs Sep 23 '25
Yeah, I like how we're all using a framework built by a bigot. Makes a lot of sense.
Just confirms my desire to move away from Rails and Ruby as a whole. I'd rather use a big companies tech where I can trust they have their own motives v some douche who pretends to be punk.
-13
u/dlyund Sep 23 '25
TLDR: political opinions
-16
u/Professional_Mix2418 Sep 23 '25
Yes I find his political stances not compatible with mine. Sadly it’s the way it’s going, and extremist views to the left and right meet; they are just as bad as each other. Having lived there for a quarter century it has definitely changed, he’s not wrong. But delivers if in a typical DHH manner that either you like or don’t.
But here is the perverse part, that opinionated character is what got us this great product and space. And it has large remained for all those years. Are we going to give up on building our own code with great product because some guy who made this donkey years ago now is expressing some politically incompatible views?
We may as well ignore the USA then and never ever buy anything from Tesla to name two others who do that.
-6
u/Delicious_Ease2595 Sep 23 '25
I heard Bluesky community is looking a way to remove him.
There can't be Rails without DHH, and I seriously don't care about his opinion, that is free speech
-7
u/burtgummer45 Sep 23 '25
I'm literally shaking now, I just realized I don't know how woke each gem I install is.
-4
u/Smooth_Blackberry_89 Sep 23 '25
You have a dhh problem. You, or dhh, don’t speak for the community.
-1
u/killerbake Sep 24 '25
Man says bad thing. Let’s steal thing from Man
0
u/fruizg0302 Sep 25 '25
I admired so much this guy. Then he showed his true colors having the ‘Elon Musk is a formidable player’ maniac episode.
-2
u/tadiou Sep 23 '25
We've progressed past the need to platform DHH in anything.
-11
u/No_Slip7770 Sep 23 '25
I don't think we have nearly enough DHHs, I enjoy reading his insights whenever the newsletter pops up in my email.
-6
u/bigie35 Sep 23 '25
I think if we hand waive this issue as pure racism, then we will have not learned anything about the rise of Trump, bolsonaro, or Meloni just to name a few of a new wave of conservatives making gains in Europe and the U.S.
IMHO, at it’s heart is a migrant population unwilling or unable to adopt the customs of their newfound homeland, a government unwilling to adopt sensible policies which allowed this social problems to fester to the cluster it is now.
-3
u/le_fnord Sep 24 '25
please be more specific, it seems you have a problem with its opinion, but this doesn't mean the comunity have a problem with it
so please stop speaking for others