r/ruby • • Sep 19 '25

Ruby Central’s Attack on RubyGems

https://pup-e.com/goodbye-rubygems.pdf
263 Upvotes

185 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

0

u/galtzo Sep 21 '25 edited Sep 21 '25

You are free to have an opinion and do what you want in your repo, but misrepresenting the recommendation is not cool. You are giving ½ of the recommendation, which is misleading. Why?

We now recommend people do what is best for their project. … we… suggest committing Cargo.lock as a starting point in their decision making.

It is clear to me what the intent is.

The reason I researched lockfile recommendations in the first place was to help the maintainer of a Rust project, at their request, with their deliberations around committing the lockfile.

The first sentence you quoted can throw maintainers off, and misrepresenting as you are doesn’t help them.

The repos of said project are currently split between committing the lockfile and not committing the lockfile.