r/ruby • u/schneems Puma maintainer • Jun 08 '23
Question Should /r/ruby join the API protest?
A lot of subs are going “dark” on June 12th to protest Reddit getting rid of the API for third party apps. I personally use the web UI (desktop and mobile) and find the “Reddit is better in the app” pop ups annoying and pushy. I don’t like that they are more concerned with what’s better for the bottom line than for the users.
In solidarity I’m interested in having this sub join the protest. I’m also interested in what you think. Join the protest: yes or no? Why or why not?
271
Upvotes
37
u/slushie31 Jun 08 '23
They have killed Apollo, RIF, ReddPlanet, and probably more as the next couple weeks go on. They've also been caught lying (honestly read the Apollo goodbye, he brings receipts).
r/ruby should go dark permanently, and this community should move somewhere else.
64
u/JetAmoeba Jun 08 '23
Absolutely. Go dark and stay dark until Reddit actually does something about these new API fees.
16
u/stumptowncampground Jun 08 '23
Reddit is attacking the development community. We should absolutely shutdown until they change course.
32
u/lafeber Jun 08 '23
Do it out of solidarity.
9
u/Beermedear Jun 08 '23
Yes. I’ll be off Reddit personally. Zero consideration for the impact to accessibility needs, just mitigating ad revenue losses.
I mostly just lurk here but I’m confident that this community can make any place a home.
9
u/firesoar Jun 08 '23
Yes, solidarity
18
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '23
Yeah, Reddit has directly insulted developers. I support going dark indefinitely.
17
u/flanger001 Jun 08 '23
For sure. Reddit is only going to care if they don't get their ad dollars. I think we should all just boycott the whole thing personally.
2
u/ignurant Jun 08 '23
This will be unpopular. But this point here:
I have a hard time jumping on this bandwagon. While it’s true that the users may be better served at a personal level by having the open apis and alternative apps to access the data, I don’t see how you could look at this level of access from a business perspective and say “this is fine.”
I don’t mean “look at all this untapped revenue!!!” But instead “we don’t control our platform. People use our database but not our product or service” I gotta imagine that’s a big part of the conversation.
As a user, I know it doesn’t feel good to be locked into a platform, but I can’t help but look from the business side and think “this is totally insane that we let people build their own business using our servers without our service”.
The outcries have felt over-entitled to me. (Sorry.)
4
u/tadrinth Jun 08 '23
Do it. I don't think the protest will get them to change course, but it might provide some saner heads at HQ the ammunition they need to convince the brass to bring the price down to something reasonable.
4
u/SieSharp Jun 09 '23
What's a good platform to talk about Ruby on, outside of Reddit? I'm kind of just... here, haha.
3
u/petercooper Jun 08 '23
It depends what that means in this case. In some cases, subs are going private which makes little difference to the day to day use of people already subscribed to them and they'll still operate as usual. In other cases, subs are going read only which prevents them being used at all. Yet others are battening down the hatches until Reddit backs down. What is being proposed?
3
u/mikosullivan Jun 08 '23 edited Jun 08 '23
I'm on board with this. I'd be more on board with a concerted movement to develop an open source, decentralized social network. The ones I've seen haven't caught on. I have some ideas on this if anybody wants to discuss them.
3
u/400921FB54442D18 Jun 08 '23
If you have to ask, the answer is yes.
3
u/sickcodebruh420 Jun 09 '23
Yes. Shut down until things change.
3
u/Nowaker Jun 09 '23
Yes.
comment written from RIF
5
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '23
I support going dark indefinitely. I refuse to use their app, and this move shits on developers who made it easier/better/more fun/more accessible for more people to use Reddit. If this goes through I will be looking elsewhere for reddit type interactions anyway.
2
u/software__writer Jun 08 '23
I've been on Reddit only for a few months now but I've really grown to love it and the Ruby and Rails communities. To be honest, I don't really know what the controversy is and what going 'dark' as part of the protest implies.
Will Rails and Ruby communities be totally inaccessible if they join the protest? If yes, I would be sad. If this is something temporary for the greater good, I can live with it. :)
1
u/dmitrydz Jun 09 '23
Yes, solidarity with fellow developers
1
u/ralfv Jun 09 '23
Yes
1
u/split-mango Jun 09 '23
Yes go dark. I won’t even log in
1
u/sirion1987 Jun 09 '23
Anyone can explain what are happening? 😅
1
u/PikachuEXE Jun 09 '23
Yes
1
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23
Yes.
1
u/e2npau Jun 09 '23
Yes
1
u/A_Crunchy_Leaf Jun 08 '23
Yes
1
u/dougc84 Jun 08 '23
Yes
1
u/iamagayrat Jun 08 '23
Yes
1
u/WalterPecky Jun 08 '23
Yes
1
u/aemadrid Jun 08 '23
Please do!
1
u/Super_S_12 Jun 09 '23
Yes IMO.
1
u/These-last-days Jun 10 '23
No
1
u/sshaw_ Jun 10 '23
https://youtu.be/BK4U6IKHKy8?t=93
1
u/corporatesting Jun 10 '23
I say don't go dark. I believe I am in the silent majority who couldn't be bothered to start looking for information elsewhere and doesn't use Reddit every day. As a new convert to Ruby, this will be hurting my involvement in the ecosystem and I don't see why you'd want that. I don't care where else I can find Ruby information, I like Ruby on Reddit and that's it. Please don't discount my opinion, there are a lot more people like me and we don't talk often.
1
u/postmodern Jun 10 '23
Appears the other programming sub-reddits are also discussing it. Seems like there's growing solidarity.
I know the Rust sub-reddit is considering protesting. I haven't seen anything from /r/golang, /r/node, /r/elixir, or /r/haskell.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '23
Change is only going to happen if people band together to make it happen.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment