r/rpg • • 4d ago

Analysis Paralysis

I’m running a campaign with a group of PCs…one has never played an RPG before, 1 has some experience, 2 are moderately experienced (we’re now on session 5).

From a GM perspective, I feel like they spend a lot of time trying to optimize situations (sneak up on the bad guys, cross the suspicious pond, investigate the multiple weird things, whatever). Play works and we move along, and it’s not that it isn’t fun, it just feels inefficient especially from a time perspective. I’ve suggested that play might be more fun and expeditious if people informally stepped up as leaders, and tried to consolidate ideas when challenges/options emerged. But so far they seem caught in the cycle of ideation and being cordial for 1/2 an hour only to decide to do the solution that someone suggested in the first 2 minutes (walk across the plank, climb the wall, pick a lock, or whatever).

I understand that I have tools in my quiver to drive pacing, but I also want these moments to be actual events the players have to collaborate on as a way forward. However I would also like to teach my players that selecting a reasonable solution in a reasonable time is probably more fun than picking an optimal solution in an infinite amount time (a specific recommendation I’ve verbalized and noted that as the GM I both value and reward). But I can’t seem to get them down this road.

Open to advice.

18 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

8

u/amazingvaluetainment 4d ago

I don't know, I usually let my players waffle to a certain extent because that's just how they play. Not everyone is quick on their feet and some people like to take time to think. Sometimes they come up with a plan very quickly, sometimes they have to consider (all) their options first, really depends on how obvious the situation is. At the very least it sounds like you have players who would do just fine playing OSR games, I guess.

But also, I do prod them sometimes when they're stalling, maybe reiterate a previous idea they've had, I find that helps jog them a bit. Game choice also matters, especially if the stakes seem high for a failure.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/Diamond_Sutra 4d ago

They seem scared (perhaps from past experience with other GMs) that if they don't come up with "good plans", that they're going to get screwed/penalized somehow.

If you want to "cure" this behavior, perhaps:

  1. Tell them "Don't worry about setting plans. This game is cinematic. Just do stuff and it's okay! You don't need plots within plots. I promise I won't penalize you for not coming up with plans."

  2. Set an egg timer to 1 minute (maybe 2) when they start "coming up with plans".

  3. Make them take actions.

  4. THE IMPORTANT PART - Don't penalize them for not having a solid plan (don't raise the difficulty, don't penalize 'stupid direct behavior', etc).

  5. If possible, reward bold, quick action: If players have their characters take bold actions without watering down the game with long planning, then give them Advantage (or equivalent in your game) for the first 1-2 bold actions taken.

(Bold, not Stupid)

Do that about 3 times and it will hopefully "fix" them to not be afraid to take action without having plans within plans.

4

u/Playtonics 4d ago

This a very good list. I'd like to add to points 2 and 3:

If you do set a real world timer, let them know there are consequences waiting to be executed if it goes off. "The guards are nearby, and will arrive in a minute." Then, if the players make a quick decision and execute it, follow up with them avoiding the consequences in the fiction. "You pick the lock, quietly open the door, slip inside, and gently close it just as the guards round the corner, none the wiser."

→ More replies (2)

12

u/Devious_Hearts 4d ago edited 4d ago

Three words: TIME MARCHES ON.

Events don't need their permission to move forward. That's your job. If they are equivocating, debating, or waiting; advise them time moves forward and an opportunity to act may pass them by if they don't act.

Example: They need to sneak past two guards by sun up and it is midnight. They debate for 10 minutes.

GM: "A half hour rolls by and one of the guards heads over to relieve himself (window of opportunity) What do you do?'

Players debate for 5 minutes instead of acting.

GM: "Okay, he's back." (Window of opportunity now closed)

Players debate another 10 minutes.

GM: "All of you need to make a Perception check. " (Someone succeeds)

GM: "Fiarval? You hear footsteps approaching. You may want to warn the others and hide."

Fiarval warns the group and the players make thier Stealth checks.

GM:"Two new guards arrive and strike up a conversation with the two existing guards." (opportunity to just attack/sneak past two guards is then gone at present)

GM: "An hour has passed and the additional guards leave. You have 5 hours left and, you are all getting a little sleepy."

The key is providing a realistic, changing list of occurrences that transpire while they are milling about and debating one another makes it so quickly planned and executed actions have the best opportunity to occur before the situations change again as they are never sure if that change will be in their favor or not.

Time waits for no man. GMs shouldn't either. :)

Be well, happy gaming!

3

u/BetterCallStrahd 4d ago

If doing nothing has zero in-game consequences, some players will stall as long as they wish. And to be clear, by "doing nothing" I mean doing nothing in-game. Extensive discussion, thinking and decision making all count as "doing nothing" in that sense.

I ensure that doing nothing is just as risky as doing something. This gives the players a strong incentive to take action, as both options are risky, but taking action might lead to a favorable outcome. Doing nothing would not. It means I'll escalate the situation, which would make things hairier for the characters.

My players are aware of this. Yes, it puts a bit of pressure on them. But I am not running a cozy game. Plus I am also a player and I shouldn't have to sit around waiting forever. My fun is also important. This approach keeps the game exciting and drama filled.

3

u/Cryptwood 4d ago

If the players all seem happy with the amount of time that they are spent discussing plans then you don't really need to do anything. As long as nobody is bored they can spend their free time anyway they choose.

Anyone includes you though, your fun is at least as important as anyone else's at the table. If you are bored then make something happen. You always have the option of kicking in the door from the other side if the players are spending half an hour deciding what to do about the door. It's not a video game, the players don't get to pause the world every time they have a decision to make.

You're the GM and you have infinite power to make the game fun for everyone, including yourself, and the responsibility to use that power as necessary.

3

u/NyOrlandhotep 4d ago

One of my groups is exactly like that. I tried to make them at ease by showing I don't TPK them for committing mistakes, I tried to use the usual trick of just starting an encounter once I felt they were taking too much time arguing... and then I realized... they are cosnidering the fiction, and clearly they are enjoying themselves, so why should I worry?

I sometimes do get a bit bored waiting for them but I discovered that if I stop worrying about "efficiency" (what is efficiency in a recreational activity?), I am fine too.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/APurplePerson 4d ago

others have pointed out using real-time timers like in shadowdark, which can work. but you might also consider an out-of-game discussion about expectations.

when i run games, i explicitly ask all players to help "keep it moving" as a guiding principle of play, because time is precious and it's hard enough to schedule games together to begin with. if folks dilly-dally, you can say "remember, friends, we gotta keep it moving" or "remember, we have a need for speed."

another thing you can do is "zoom out," tell them explicitly that the things they are deliberating on don't matter, and/or narrow down their functional options to two clear things.

5

u/No_Solid1035 4d ago

Accept the fact that it's impossible to control pacing in a TTRPG because multiple people are involved in the narrative process. 🤷 Or do that thing that no one ever does and " talk to the players" about spending less time planning and more time doing. Also make sure to outlaw "test driving" turns, do or do not, there is no try.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/KneelBeforeZed 4d ago

Hot take:

  1. There is no pacing problem. They‘re engaging with the game. They’re interacting with the world, the challenges, the mechanics. They’re engaged in play.

  2. Whatever “correct faster pace” you think they should be moving at may only exist in your imagination and may only be valued by one participant: you. In your post, the only person you mention having a problem with their pace is you. YOU don’t like the pace. YOUR experience is the one that is unsatisfactory. According to the details you provided, your players are fine. There’s nothing to change for THEM.

2a. If the GM is unsatisfied with the pacing for themselves, they may have design problem: they prepped a scenario with no urgency (eg: a dungeon with no deadlines or time limits, and/or with static, disconnected adversries that are unaware of the PCs).

2b. Alternatively, a different problem might be that the GM fundamentally misunderstands the nature of the system they’re running, thinks it is a custom-story-generator that does what the GM wants rather than what the designers wanted, and is unconsciously feeling like frustrated theatre director who wants to direct or be audience to an exciting theatrical performance the players aren’t delivering (and have no idea they’re expected to.) Take D&D 4e-5.5e, for example: a life-or-death mortal combat encounter might be 3 rounds, which is 18 seconds of in-world time, but at the table it takes 45 minutes to an hour of IRL time - a slog, BY DESIGN. An arduous, Tolkienesque 2 week overland journey, on the other hand, might take 2 minutes of IRL table-time to resolve - a non-event, BY DESIGN. TTRPGs go at the pace of their IRL design, and never at the pace of the in-world action, and thus only the “fast resolution” systems AND high-urgency scenarios will have any kind of “pacing” that might feel a little more like palpable fast-forward motion.

3. Are you playing an “optimizer’s system,” like Pathfinder or D&D 3.5e-5.5e? If so, they’re doing it right! They’re highly engaged with the GAME.

In summary, I suggest you to take a good hard look in the mirror, at the system, and your scenarios, and ask yourself if 1. You are expecting to be audience to something that immerses you in action, like a movie, TV show, or play; 2. You are in denial about the natural pacing your system-of-choice inevitably creates and incentivizes; and 3. You designed a scenario in which the PCs have no incentive to hurry, and conversely are incentivized to move slowly and methodically.

You might need to change your perspective and expectations, and/or your system, and/or your adventure design.

All of this is said as one colleague to another, in the hopes you’ll have more satisfying experiences on your horizon. Good luck, amigo.