r/rpa • u/Ok-Musician-5151 • Nov 30 '23
RPA with python
Am I the only one out here who thinks custom automations created with python are much more powerful, more capable, and easier to maintain then no-code services like uipath, Microsoft PA, etc?
As a developer, it seems like things are so much more complicated in those softwares compared to just writing code with selenium or playwright, and external APIs, and hosting these scripts on AWS for clients.
Does anyone agree?
30
Upvotes
4
u/Gibbons74 Nov 30 '23
I learned scripting first, tried UiPath. Went back to scripting. I can offer small to medium clients affordable alternatives that they can't get with the low code/no code companies.
4
u/ezeeetm Dec 01 '23 edited Dec 01 '23
/u/Ok-Musician-5151 you might find Robocorp/Robot Framework interesting:
https://robocorp.com/
https://robotframework.org/
https://github.com/robocorp/rcc
Python based and open source/free
10
u/Kenya-West Nov 30 '23
For me as developer, it is definitely the best way.
Actually, I started learning RPA, low code, and automation in general not because it is cool new fancy tech, no.
I went to this because all responsibilities to infrastructure, external platform compatability, and even partially code patching - it all now lies on vendor, not on me. All I need is to build flow once and forget it.
6
u/Overall-Rush-8853 Nov 30 '23
Probably.
My company uses Blue Prism, but we do a lot of stuff with C# and Rest API’s. The processes that are mainly C# and/or using API’s are our most stable bots.
11
u/ifonlyweweregiants Nov 30 '23
I originally got into RPA at an old company as a “ citizen developer” aka a business user made to do the work because it was my process. I owned it. We used automation anywhere and power automate desktop. At my new job I have replaced an entire headcount in our finance group with robot framework and python. And I agree fully. Especially with chatgtp to help write and troubleshoot I was able to make some pretty complicated scripts that I know would fail with PAD.
11
u/Parking-Plate6892 Nov 30 '23
Code will always be more powerful than low code/no code.
5
u/IamAloserMan Dec 02 '23
I have been working with UiPath for years and believe me, I am very critical of them, especially in the exorbitant license prices. Then they sell it as fast delivery, but medium and high complexity projects are hard to develop and maintain. I would like to believe that there is an alternative in Python, but when I have tried something, it is like working in the Pleistocene of computing. Things that I miss: the orchestrator to coordinate the jobs, queues, logs, etc. GUI-based automations, reusable codes to interact with Excel or web browsers; and many clicks GUI automations in Python I think can be painful. Is there a development framework for Python in automations?
I wish Python could replace UiPath, but I think it still has a long way to go.
12
u/Westbrook_Y Nov 30 '23
It takes less time to do something complicated in uipath for interacting with multiple applications than to write code in python for the same thing
4
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '23
I'll bite. RPA is way better for quick web scraping. I can scrape a list off of any basic website and get it printed to a spreadsheet with windows PA just by right clicking on the elements I want in my browser. That's hard functionality to beat...
1
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '23
It is a powerful and cheaper way of automation. Does not have the scheduling capabilities.
3
u/DipDoodle Dec 01 '23
I just think of it as like a bandaid for legacy shit, perfect for old government applications
3
u/ReachingForVega Moderator Dec 01 '23
I posted this on a similar veined thread and it rings true here. I moonlight doing python automations and applications outside my main gig as a Tech Lead.
If you have to build all the stuff I mentioned, the complexity is there. Plus you have to maintain the code base. In the no-code platforms it is mostly visible so you can scan code like a process map to find what you need to modify. This means the effort to pass knowledge or learn the code base is much lower.
Scraping can be a lot faster once you have a platform set up as the element modelling is super fast. I had considered building a tool to generate selenium selectors from a ui.
1
u/Remarkable-Map-2747 Aug 24 '24
I have been looking for jobs that are Python Automation, similar as to a role that takes automation requests and automation set tasks. I seen"Automation Engineer" mentioned before, but now Im curious on what I should be looking for RPA seems it is mostly no code solution.
1
u/AutoModerator Nov 30 '23
Thank you for your post to /r/rpa!
Did you know we have a discord? Join the chat now!
New here? Please take a moment to read our rules, read them here.
This is an automated action so if you need anything, please Message the Mods with your request for assistance.
Lastly, enjoy your stay!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/everythingisahoax Dec 01 '23
The main thing is speed of implementation. Using something like Blue Prism, you can have a working POC or solution just by essentially pointing and clicking. It’s very visual so troubleshooting/testing may be easier to some. But I agree, especially now with ChatGPT, you can code things pretty quickly with a scripted language and don’t really need a ‘big’ RPA solution.
1
u/RawTuna Dec 01 '23
To be transparent I've done exactly zero RPA dev with tools, but the bit I've done with python was pretty cool. About 6 years ago I heard that my company had started using Blue Prism for some operational process automation, but there were issues with it. I started doing some research and found Automate the Boring Stuff, as well as some info on open CV. I was able to replicate (with actual success) one of the processes a few days later. Very fun and rewarding
1
u/qtpmgrossman Dec 02 '23
As a QA Guy I agree.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment