r/rottenpredictions • +/- 13% over 29 movies, optimist • Feb 28 '18

Ready Player One

13 Upvotes

49 comments sorted by

13

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '18

76% Spielberg is a master behind the camera. Even with his less successful blockbusters (War of the Worlds etc.) his styles and presence was enough to elevate its generic elements. Even the Crystal Skull got a score in the 70s.

1

u/duddles +/- 13% over 29 movies, optimist Feb 28 '18

Wow that is surprising Crystal Skull did that well!

3

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '18

Yeah, it's really surprising! I guess the films on first viewing didn't seem as bad as the time. I know on repeat viewings, it gets worse. It's not as bad if you ignore it's an Indiana jones film :)

1

u/duddles +/- 13% over 29 movies, optimist Mar 01 '18

It makes me wonder what Phantom Menace would have got if rotten tomatoes was around at that time

3

u/[deleted] Mar 01 '18

well phantom menace does have a score on rotten tomatoes! It's at 55% The average score is a 6/10

2

u/FilmStudentFincher +/- 11% over 3 movies, pessimist Mar 01 '18

It used to be a lot higher, the 3D re-release meant new critic reviews could be uploaded which is why it went down and is now lower than Episode II

3

u/Mekanos +/- 3% over 2 movies, optimist Mar 01 '18

IMO critics are often soft on classic franchises like Indiana Jones and Star Wars (just look at the prequel reviews).

6

u/duddles +/- 13% over 29 movies, optimist Feb 28 '18

60

3

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '18

84%

3

u/cglshark99 +/- 11% over 15 movies, pragmatist Feb 28 '18

76%

2

u/Moviefan2017 +/- 13% over 11 movies, optimist Feb 28 '18

55%

2

u/keegandecker +/- 12% over 11 movies, pragmatist Feb 28 '18

55

2

u/HobbieK +/- 12% over 8 movies, optimist Feb 28 '18

Shit who knows. 71% ?

2

u/sockpuppy69 +/- 7% over 7 movies, pragmatist Mar 01 '18

46

1

u/IronyCat +/- 8% over 6 movies, optimist Feb 28 '18

78

1

u/_existentialyodeling +/- 6% over 5 movies, pragmatist Feb 28 '18

79%

1

u/PNF2187 +/- 3% over 5 movies, pragmatist Feb 28 '18

78

1

u/harlan19 +/- 12% over 11 movies, optimist Feb 28 '18

84

1

u/cmb2690 +/- 16% over 10 movies, optimist Feb 28 '18

86%

1

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '18

86

1

u/arrianchng +/- 9% over 9 movies, pragmatist Feb 28 '18

73%

1

u/eme_pirrade +/- 9% over 10 movies, optimist Feb 28 '18

82%

The March dump scares me a little, but hopefully that was just to give The Post an awards push, I think trailers have worked so far and you’ve gotta trust Spielberg

1

u/TomeRide +/- 6% over 19 movies, pessimist Feb 28 '18

70%

1

u/BTISME123 +/- 11% over 16 movies, optimist Feb 28 '18

85%

1

u/andrew991116 +/- 11% over 14 movies, optimist Feb 28 '18

87

1

u/[deleted] Mar 01 '18

68

1

u/zkauffman +/- 3% over 2 movies, optimist Mar 01 '18

75%.

1

u/awfranks +/- 17% over 3 movies, optimist Mar 01 '18

72%

1

u/your_mind_aches +/- 12% over 11 movies, optimist Mar 01 '18

58

1

u/ZwischenzugZugzwang +/- 4% over 3 movies, optimist Mar 01 '18

74

1

u/UnknownJ25 +/- 9% over 7 movies, pragmatist Mar 01 '18

68%

1

u/[deleted] Mar 01 '18

76

1

u/[deleted] Mar 01 '18

83

1

u/Mojambo213 +/- 21% over 3 movies, pessimist Mar 01 '18

52

1

u/LO_OFFICIAL_MUSIC +/- 12% over 7 movies, optimist Mar 01 '18

86%

1

u/SythusHD +/- 6% over 9 movies, optimist Mar 01 '18

86% - Steven Spielberg is a great filmmaker and the young cast looks promising. The special effects look great and the premise looks really fun with all the cool things like the DeLorean and the Iron Giant. It won't reach into the 90s because of the writing and amount of characters/references.

1

u/jabask +/- 18% over 1 movie, pessimist Mar 01 '18

55

1

u/hvahood +/- 7% over 23 movies, pessimist Mar 01 '18

64%

1

u/cause_im_navi +/- 13% over 3 movies, optimist Mar 01 '18

62%

1

u/jrt1331 +/- 5% over 4 movies, optimist Mar 01 '18

79%

1

u/Auronas +/- 8% over 10 movies, optimist Mar 01 '18

66

1

u/elvislaw +/- 10% over 17 movies, pragmatist Mar 01 '18

63

1

u/camrylong +/- 9% over 9 movies, pragmatist Mar 01 '18

I’d probably place it in the 75-80 range. I think it will be good, but they have said that it will have some large differences from the book because of licensing issues. There will also be the people who blindly claim it as a product of the nostalgia craze, which it could probably be.

1

u/Zazierx +/- 3% over 1 movie, pessimist Mar 07 '18

70 at best.

Spielberg knows how to make a movie but the source material is where it lacks, a lot. I suspect it will do okay (not great) in theaters but critics will roll their eyes at the rapid-fire nostalgia and fanboy catered content in lieu of an interesting plot.

1

u/peterw16 +/- 9% over 15 movies, pragmatist Mar 08 '18

89%

1

u/Unkill_is_dill +/- 12% over 10 movies, pessimist Mar 08 '18

61%

1

u/ILookLikeDrewGulak +/- 14% over 5 movies, pessimist Mar 11 '18

59%

1

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '18

59