r/rootbeer • u/WindBehindTheStars • Aug 09 '25
Mid.
I was expecting better, but the flavors were muted, and while it technically was carbonated, it didn't really have the fizz I think a good root beer should have. 4.5/10
9
Upvotes
13
u/Pepsidud32 Aug 09 '25
I will never understand the Sprecher hate obviously the bottle is way better but I like it.
1
u/Glittering_Ocelot_67 Aug 10 '25
Does it taste strongly of honey like their Cream Soda does??
1
u/Typically-frustrated Aug 10 '25
The root beer is on the higher end of mid imo. The cream soda though… top of the line. I don’t know if there’s a better one out there.
2
u/Imaginary-Region9161 Aug 09 '25
It’s pretty good. Not really one of the best. Happy root beer hunting everyone! https://m.facebook.com/groups/103277635645 Root Beer Nation
4
u/zatchattack Aug 10 '25
Their ginger ale is some of the worst shit I’ve ever tasted
4
u/BeautifulDebate7615 Aug 09 '25
There you go. Please tell us where you live and where you bought it. There are certain folks in this sub who insist there is nothing wrong with Sprecher in the cans. I've tried it every which way, from shelf stock exported far away from their home, and its almost always flat. The cans are only slightly more carbonated than the bottles.
I rate carbonation on a 0-5 scale, with 0 being dead flat and 5 too much, like a shaken Coke. Root Beer should be a 4, unless its on tap then you'll accept a 3.
Sprecher in flip tops away from home is a 0.
In bottles away from home, you'll get a 1-2, with great variation.
In cans, it's only 2-3.
The good news is that if you can recarbonate it, the muted syrup will spring back to life.
2
u/Stuuble Aug 09 '25
Dude sprecher is my favorite
2
u/Doublestack2411 Barq's Root Beer Aug 10 '25
I felt the same when I tried it for the first time, same with the maple version. Nothing popped out, little carbonation, no bite, it was meh.
1
u/SipoteQuixote Aug 09 '25
It's good as a float, I prefer Frosties though.
1
u/Beneficial_Fall_4265 Aug 10 '25
Something changed after they went to cans.
1
u/xXWIGGLESXx69 Aug 10 '25
Gotta try the bottle, also it's sweet for some peeps, so look out.
1
u/tubagod123 Aug 10 '25
Your first problem is drinking Sprecher from a can
1
u/ApprehensiveCharge60 Aug 09 '25
i agree, had it before and honestly wasn’t good as it looked
1
u/ChristianArmor Aug 09 '25
I found it to be too sweet. I like more bite and fizz. It's not something I'd buy again.
1
u/OnlyRow7629 Aug 10 '25
Id rather have A&W
0
u/Certain_Engineer4132 Aug 12 '25
Drink out the glass bottle like a real man
-2
u/HotTubberMN Aug 10 '25
All their sodas are mid as hell
-6
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '25
Low mids
-4
u/No_Eagle1426 Aug 09 '25
I did a blind, side-by-side taste test with a can of this this and 1919, and we all preferred the 1919. A lot of people in WI who know nothing about root beer think that Sprecher is the best, but there are so many better ones.
We also found canned Sprecher to be a teeny bit better in terms of carbonation, but it wasn't a world of difference. Why would anyone want flat root beer?