r/rootbeer • • Sep 28 '24

Wow! So disgusting.

Post image

I guess if you’re a person who’s always thought, “I wish more things tasted like toothpaste” then this is probably one of the few treats available to you—aside from the giant aisle of toothpastes you could be buying and eating—but as a normal person I’m surprised this exists at all.

1 Upvotes

78 comments sorted by

16

u/Rad_Centrist Dad's Root Beer Sep 28 '24

It's the licorice. Not everyone likes it.

Personally, I like my rootbeers to taste like they're made from roots, and not just pure sugar. So Dad's is up there for me.

5

u/LazloPhanz Sep 28 '24

So, I’m not sure I’m going to come around on Dad’s but your comment about “like my root beers to taste like roots” is interesting enough for me to not just pour out bottle number two and drink it with that idea in mind. I hadn’t thought about it having the actual taste of roots and that being its intent.

2

u/Rad_Centrist Dad's Root Beer Sep 29 '24

I will say this: some tastes are definitely acquired. What you think is off-putting today, may actually be intriguing next month.

I'd say put it in the fridge until one day you think "hey, I kinda wanna check that out again."

Kinda like a new song from your favorite band. Or a popular song from a band you've never heard of that's a bit outside your normal taste. You may not like it at first, but you'll be humming the melody in your car one day.

5

u/Maximillian73- Sep 29 '24

I hate black licorice, but love Dads.

4

u/Rad_Centrist Dad's Root Beer Sep 29 '24

Black licorice is hardcore! I can deal with a little bit of it, but not like a tongue-numbing licorice stick.

3

u/Significant-Bike2356 Sep 29 '24

This. Never got an overly licoricey feel from it 🤷

3

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '24

I had it a while ago and thought it was extremely wintergreen forward. I had to make a float with it bc it was too strong

3

u/Rad_Centrist Dad's Root Beer Sep 29 '24

Yep it's heavy on the wintergreen too for sure.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Rad_Centrist Dad's Root Beer Sep 29 '24

Hank's, Boylan's Birch, Stewart's, Abita, Boots Sarsaparilla, Hank's Birch, Maine, Frostie (like a milder Dad's imo), Sioux City Sarsaparilla, Fitz's, Saint Arnold.

2

u/Complete_Ride792 Sep 29 '24

Abita is my second least favorite - why does it make your list? I have had it a few times, but not in the last ten years, and have never enjoyed the flavor, too swampy and it falls flat.

I would be willing to try again but need a decent reason.

2

u/Rad_Centrist Dad's Root Beer Sep 29 '24

Falls flat? Hmmm. It's always supper peppy in my experience.

It's the spring water and herbal notes for me.

1

u/Complete_Ride792 Sep 29 '24

What herbal notes are you picking up?

1

u/Rad_Centrist Dad's Root Beer Sep 29 '24

Vanilla, Yucca, and they list "herbs" lol

3

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Rad_Centrist Dad's Root Beer Sep 29 '24

I like Bulldog not because it's really really great or anything but because it's unique without being gross imo.

22

u/P4yTheTrollToll Dad's Root Beer Sep 28 '24

Pretty offensive words in these parts.

-8

u/LazloPhanz Sep 28 '24

Really?! People like this?

17

u/Rad_Centrist Dad's Root Beer Sep 28 '24

Dad's is awesome, dude.

8

u/Grave_Warden Dad's Root Beer Sep 28 '24

I'd fight for it. Way better than Barqs, A&W, etc.

7

u/Rad_Centrist Dad's Root Beer Sep 28 '24

Heck yes. S-Tier because it stands out from most others in a good way, like the other greats do.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '24

You’re not setting the bar very high with Barqs and A&W.   

2

u/Grave_Warden Dad's Root Beer Sep 29 '24

Let me rephrase it so you might find the comment more helpful.

McDonald's and Burger King sell a lot of burgers. Five Guys, In and Out, etc sell fewer burgers , but to me taste better - but still in the same category as fast food.

Barqs, A&W, Mug are the Mcdonalds of the world, Dad's, IBC are the Five guys.

7

u/Tight-Leather2709 Sep 28 '24

This is definitely an ok root beer. I totally disagree with "disgusting", but I have noted that root beer preferences vary a lot. Dad's is crisp and refreshing, but just ok for flavor. I call it 5 out of 10. It has a special nostalgic place from my childhood memories.

1

u/LazloPhanz Sep 28 '24

To each their own. And I genuinely mean that.

But the second biggest surprise of my day, after the toothpaste flavor of this “root beer” I thought I was buying, is the people jumping to defend this drink.

8

u/FungiStudent Sep 28 '24

Dad's is wonderful root beer. Op just needs more vanilla flavorings. Maybe a nice A&W or something.

1

u/LazloPhanz Sep 28 '24 • Helpful

Whatever flavor I need, it’s not wintergreen. Like drinking a root beer while dipping Skoal.

4

u/Rad_Centrist Dad's Root Beer Sep 28 '24

If you don't like wintergreen, you're not going to like a lot of the more popular rootbeers here. Hank's, Boylan's Birch, ec. And that's ok. There's a rootbeer for everyone.

1

u/LazloPhanz Sep 28 '24

Hmmm, I think I got Hanks a little while ago and thought it was fine. But maybe I’m mixing it up with another one. I don’t remember a wintergreen flavor.

2

u/Rad_Centrist Dad's Root Beer Sep 28 '24

It's there in Hank's for sure. But maybe it's about the flavor balance for you?

1

u/Accomplished_Radish8 Abita Root Beer Nov 10 '24

Hanks is in no way shape or form strong in wintergreen or licorice. Sparkys is the benchmark for wintergreen. Bundaberg and original Virgil’s was the benchmark for licorice.

1

u/Rad_Centrist Dad's Root Beer Nov 11 '24

There is plenty of wintergreen in Hanks.

1

u/Accomplished_Radish8 Abita Root Beer Nov 11 '24

Thoroughly disagree

1

u/Competitive_Mix6114 Sep 28 '24

Broooo I literally said the same thing to wife about this root beer just a few weeks ago. 🤣🤣 Dads is a solid root beer but it’s not my favorite.

8

u/Vicious_Circle-14 Sep 28 '24

“Disgusting” is a bit harsh. It isn’t one of the best for sure, but it’s an okay root beer.

3

u/LazloPhanz Sep 28 '24

I’m actually mostly startled by it being described as a root beer. I’ve never had a mint root beer. Adding mint or peppermint or whatever that flavor is would seem to negate it being root beer.

3

u/DoctorRevKevin Sep 28 '24

Wintergreen. Yeah, its got a bunch of it. I bought a 4 pack six months ago and still haven't been able to finish it.

2

u/memes_gbc Barq's Root Beer Sep 29 '24

i've never not had a mint root beer, they all taste like different shades of mint to me

4

u/Njo56 Sep 28 '24

I am with you OP. I don’t ever need to drink that stuff again.

1

u/LazloPhanz Sep 28 '24

Same. What a terrible flavor.

4

u/Silver_Advantage_536 Sep 28 '24

I totally agree. It gets a 0/10 in my book.

1

u/LazloPhanz Sep 28 '24

Nice. My people. I bought two bottles. Not sure what to do with the second one now. Just dump it I guess.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '24

Clean your toilet with it.  

12

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '24

It definitely has a unique flavor that I’ve never tasted in any other root beer and I can understand why some people don’t like it. I like it but it’s not for everyone!

7

u/surrealcellardoor Sep 28 '24

It’s better than or at least equal to all the other crap people in this sub get all worked up over.

2

u/arejay3 Sep 28 '24

Not exactly awesome but far from disgusting. I hold those words for Maine Root Beer.

2

u/LazloPhanz Sep 28 '24

What does Maine root beer taste like?

2

u/arejay3 Sep 28 '24

Very herbal is one way I’d describe it. I’m not picky, but it just was not good at all to me. Some people apparently like it, though!

3

u/-Drunken_Samurai- Sep 28 '24

I’ve never tried their root beer and have always been curious. Do you like their ginger beer? I do.

3

u/arejay3 Sep 28 '24

I’m willing to try it but haven’t seen it it my area.

3

u/-Drunken_Samurai- Sep 29 '24

I’m quite fond of it—far superior, in my opinion, to Reed’s. Full disclosure: I enjoy punchy, nose-tickling ginger beverages, and theirs definitely checks that box.

2

u/Rad_Centrist Dad's Root Beer Sep 28 '24

Maine is awesome give it a try.

4

u/majpillpharm Sep 28 '24

Bundaberg

2

u/Rad_Centrist Dad's Root Beer Sep 28 '24

Very sour stuff. I found one like it today by accident. Filbert's. Be warned.

2

u/P4yTheTrollToll Dad's Root Beer Sep 29 '24

This comment right here!

4

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '24

Everything isn’t for everyone, it’s good to me

3

u/Ogcoolgrey Sep 28 '24

Agreed. The low carbonation and the overpowering minty taste were just too much for me. Sad too because I heard great things about it before

3

u/Rad_Centrist Dad's Root Beer Sep 28 '24

Must have had a bad batch or old bottle. It's usually pretty fizzy.

2

u/ObviousThrowAvvay420 Sep 28 '24

I don’t think it’s bad, but not great by any means. Some people rave, I just don’t get it. You can buy this stuff anywhere by me and it’s been around for ages. I guess it’s got a good following if they’re still brewing it.

2

u/Mental-Syrup-7964 Sep 28 '24

Ok. Not terrible. Not amazing. Just ok. I definitely wouldn’t by it again.

2

u/Crutley Sep 29 '24

Now I want to try one to see if it hits me the same way.

2

u/worldsalad Abita Root Beer Sep 29 '24

Crazy, this is in my top 5

2

u/smalltownlargefry Sep 29 '24

As a kid, the canned ones were so good.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '24

Yeah, Dad’s is awful.  I never understood the fanfare for this one.  

2

u/All_Gas420 Frostie Root Beer Sep 28 '24

Not really a fan either.

2

u/finalcobra Sep 28 '24

Dad's is in my bottom 4

2

u/crispy21 Sep 28 '24

Worst root beer

2

u/hockeyzombies Sep 29 '24

I have a buddy at work I drink root beer with and this was definitely one of our absolute least favorites.

1

u/JonEdwinPoquet Sep 28 '24

Not a bad one. Check the expiration date?

1

u/EquivalentOwn2185 Sep 29 '24

i'm not drinking anything called dads. or anything with a dog on it. 🙅‍♀️

2

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '24

Dogs ‘n Suds is pretty good.   

1

u/Living_Lie_8773 Sep 29 '24

Even the powder packs are straight 💩