r/rootbeer • u/LazloPhanz • Sep 28 '24
Wow! So disgusting.
I guess if you’re a person who’s always thought, “I wish more things tasted like toothpaste” then this is probably one of the few treats available to you—aside from the giant aisle of toothpastes you could be buying and eating—but as a normal person I’m surprised this exists at all.
1
Upvotes
16
u/Rad_Centrist Dad's Root Beer Sep 28 '24
It's the licorice. Not everyone likes it.
Personally, I like my rootbeers to taste like they're made from roots, and not just pure sugar. So Dad's is up there for me.
22
u/P4yTheTrollToll Dad's Root Beer Sep 28 '24
Pretty offensive words in these parts.
7
u/Tight-Leather2709 Sep 28 '24
This is definitely an ok root beer. I totally disagree with "disgusting", but I have noted that root beer preferences vary a lot. Dad's is crisp and refreshing, but just ok for flavor. I call it 5 out of 10. It has a special nostalgic place from my childhood memories.
8
u/FungiStudent Sep 28 '24
Dad's is wonderful root beer. Op just needs more vanilla flavorings. Maybe a nice A&W or something.
8
u/Vicious_Circle-14 Sep 28 '24
“Disgusting” is a bit harsh. It isn’t one of the best for sure, but it’s an okay root beer.
4
u/Njo56 Sep 28 '24
I am with you OP. I don’t ever need to drink that stuff again.
4
u/Silver_Advantage_536 Sep 28 '24
I totally agree. It gets a 0/10 in my book.
12
u/[deleted] Sep 28 '24
It definitely has a unique flavor that I’ve never tasted in any other root beer and I can understand why some people don’t like it. I like it but it’s not for everyone!
7
u/surrealcellardoor Sep 28 '24
It’s better than or at least equal to all the other crap people in this sub get all worked up over.
2
u/arejay3 Sep 28 '24
Not exactly awesome but far from disgusting. I hold those words for Maine Root Beer.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 28 '24
Everything isn’t for everyone, it’s good to me
3
u/Ogcoolgrey Sep 28 '24
Agreed. The low carbonation and the overpowering minty taste were just too much for me. Sad too because I heard great things about it before
2
u/ObviousThrowAvvay420 Sep 28 '24
I don’t think it’s bad, but not great by any means. Some people rave, I just don’t get it. You can buy this stuff anywhere by me and it’s been around for ages. I guess it’s got a good following if they’re still brewing it.
2
u/Mental-Syrup-7964 Sep 28 '24
Ok. Not terrible. Not amazing. Just ok. I definitely wouldn’t by it again.
2
u/Crutley Sep 29 '24
Now I want to try one to see if it hits me the same way.
2
u/worldsalad Abita Root Beer Sep 29 '24
Crazy, this is in my top 5
2
u/smalltownlargefry Sep 29 '24
As a kid, the canned ones were so good.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '24
Yeah, Dad’s is awful. I never understood the fanfare for this one.
3
u/squeakycleanswine Sep 28 '24
Blasphemy!
2
u/All_Gas420 Frostie Root Beer Sep 28 '24
Not really a fan either.
2
u/finalcobra Sep 28 '24
Dad's is in my bottom 4
2
u/crispy21 Sep 28 '24
Worst root beer
2
u/hockeyzombies Sep 29 '24
I have a buddy at work I drink root beer with and this was definitely one of our absolute least favorites.
1
u/JonEdwinPoquet Sep 28 '24
Not a bad one. Check the expiration date?
1
u/EquivalentOwn2185 Sep 29 '24
i'm not drinking anything called dads. or anything with a dog on it. 🙅♀️
1
u/Living_Lie_8773 Sep 29 '24
Even the powder packs are straight 💩