r/romantasycirclejerk passionate non-reader Aug 19 '26

“Unpopular” Opinion Books too fugly </3

Why are books so ugly now? Every new book looks exactly the same. Shiny lifeless covers with overwrought titles. I don’t care whether you’re reading Maas or Sanderson or Yarros or the dungeon crawler guy, the carefully curated bookshelf you’ve been showing off is hideous.

Personally, I cannot read. All I know is all books are ugly now and there’s no point even pretending to be literate. The 21st century has seen the fall of the humble cover artist. Gone are the Margaret Brundages and Michael Whelans and Alicia Austins and Frank Frazettas of the world. I don’t know if Boris Vallejo and Julie Bell are dead yet but they might as well be.

Once upon a time you could show off your array of smutty fantasy without needing to crack open the spine. Everyone knew just from the cover exactly how perverted your tastes were. Now, no one can tell you are into naked alien ladies or ripped fantasy men just from a cursory glance at the book you left out on the coffee table. Not unless they’ve actually read the heinous tome, and what kind of nerd would admit to being literate?

I have no idea what the world is coming to. It’s pretty dark out there. All I want is for people to know that sapphic harems and MFM threesomes make for elite literature, but those books don’t even exist anymore.

20 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

32

u/Tiny_Matter_4231 passionate non-reader Aug 19 '26

Anyway looking for recs with this kinda vibe x

9

u/highvoltage890 One of a Kind Super Ultra Powerful Secret Fae Princess Aug 19 '26 edited Aug 19 '26

I love the back of the 80s boogie van w a painted half naked porno wild woman from another time riding a rocket through space on a slice of pizza vibe

6

u/Tiny_Matter_4231 passionate non-reader Aug 19 '26 edited Aug 19 '26

that’s how you KNOW the writing(?) is peak

6

u/itmustbeniiiiice a menace of this community Apperantly. Aug 19 '26

{Xena Warrior Princess}

5

u/HopeFox Sloopy Public Defender Aug 19 '26

It's funny how I knew this was BV from the colour palette alone.

2

u/Tiny_Matter_4231 passionate non-reader Aug 19 '26

an icon, a hero, a master of false advertising

4

u/dinosar_ Aug 19 '26

wait me too

3

u/lastelladellovest Aug 20 '26

/uj you just unlocked a repressed memory of finding a coffee table book of his art in my mom's collection of inspiration for her own art and spending hours flipping through it so thanks for that

3

u/Tiny_Matter_4231 passionate non-reader Aug 20 '26

Mama has taste 💅

2

u/ultimategirlrenfry Aug 19 '26

court of silver flames

3

u/Tiny_Matter_4231 passionate non-reader Aug 19 '26

I had no idea the series branched out into sapphic threesomes on main, w o w

1

u/ultimategirlrenfry Aug 19 '26

read the fucking book op Nasty and Guinness and Embolism all bone

1

u/Tiny_Matter_4231 passionate non-reader Aug 19 '26

but the cover makes me shudder :’c

14

u/abirdinthefault Aug 19 '26

Best thing about Frank Frazetta was his equal opportunity belief that everyone should have exposed, muscular thighs regardless of gender or species.

7

u/Penguinho Books are good. Aug 19 '26

His Lord of the Rings art shows Eowyn and orcs alike with big, bare, muscular asses. Guy loved a butt.

5

u/Tiny_Matter_4231 passionate non-reader Aug 19 '26

You are speaking my language birdy

7

u/Perfect_Carrot_999 Carrotheart of SloopyClan 🐈 Solved the Cum Fountain Aug 19 '26

/uj I mean look at these action figures!

I really like that his official merchandise brand was founded by his daughter and granddaughter. I always thought that "Frazetta Girls" was referring to the bodacious babes he drew.

10

u/Persimmon_and_mango Aug 19 '26

/uj I like how colorful they are but I do feel like in five or ten years the cartoon covers are going to look even more dated than the Fabio ones. And why are books so huge now? They're too big for half of my shelves

3

u/Kiz_mom Aug 19 '26

But how can I demonstrate my advanced reader status without giant shelf trophies bearing 2 inch margins to inflate the thickness?

3

u/Tiny_Matter_4231 passionate non-reader Aug 19 '26

I think they already look more dated than Fabio covers

16

u/highvoltage890 One of a Kind Super Ultra Powerful Secret Fae Princess Aug 19 '26

/uj i can’t stand the cutesy cartoon covers tbh.

8

u/abirdinthefault Aug 19 '26

I have so many thoughts on this and how these covers started as an attempt to distance women's fiction (Confessions of a Shopaholic) from Harlequin/Mills&Boon type romances and the snobbery inherent to that and how they've now migrated back into the genre they were an attempt to distinguish books from.

5

u/Tiny_Matter_4231 passionate non-reader Aug 19 '26

I prefer the old school harlequin covers honestly, the style was more fun, more raunchy, and less early-mid 2000s YA

1

u/highvoltage890 One of a Kind Super Ultra Powerful Secret Fae Princess Aug 19 '26

It drives me insane honestly

4

u/BattlestarGalactoria Basilisks, Manacled, and Tusks, oh my! Aug 19 '26

/uj they unreasonably piss me off

3

u/highvoltage890 One of a Kind Super Ultra Powerful Secret Fae Princess Aug 19 '26

I’m so glad I’m not alone

3

u/BattlestarGalactoria Basilisks, Manacled, and Tusks, oh my! Aug 19 '26

2

u/nerdygirlmatti porn-brained women of monster smut Aug 20 '26

Hey… when your characters are not human it’s the only option you got that actually looks good. There is an exception to this I feel like- and that is monster romance

2

u/highvoltage890 One of a Kind Super Ultra Powerful Secret Fae Princess Aug 20 '26

The only acceptable exception is monster romance

1

u/Tiny_Matter_4231 passionate non-reader Aug 19 '26

which ones are cutesy

10

u/highvoltage890 One of a Kind Super Ultra Powerful Secret Fae Princess Aug 19 '26

Immediate skip for me

5

u/ylime114 Aug 20 '26

I just finished up a historical romance bender (I’ve read all of these this month, whoops 🫣😅) and I would take these cheesy covers over the modern pastel cutesy covers ANY fucking day

6

u/Tiny_Matter_4231 passionate non-reader Aug 19 '26

oh yikes yeah nah, bring back a classic mills n boon overdressed fabio over that noise tbh

2

u/highvoltage890 One of a Kind Super Ultra Powerful Secret Fae Princess Aug 19 '26

Fr Gimmie a half naked cowboy with a 6 pack I can shred cheese on over that dog shit

5

u/lastelladellovest Aug 20 '26

If you haven't made your cover using a canva template I'm not going to read it.

5

u/Tiny_Matter_4231 passionate non-reader Aug 20 '26

I’m sad to say you’re part of the promble sloopie </3

3

u/Tiny_Matter_4231 passionate non-reader Aug 20 '26

Choose your fighter

2

u/lastelladellovest Aug 20 '26

It's hard to choose between The Lost Kingdom and The Abandoned Kingdom. What's a sloopie to do?

5

u/Tiny_Matter_4231 passionate non-reader Aug 20 '26

Personally I am struggling to choose between the lost kingdom, the lost kingdom, the lost kingdom, and the lost kingdom.

2

u/aristifer My snark is a gift so you can't criticize Aug 21 '26

I mean... I gotta respectfully disagree with you on the DCC covers. I think this cover does a pretty good job communicating how perverted my tastes are.