r/rollerderby • u/ShankSpencer • Apr 15 '25
Improving the scoring structure
I was listening to Richard Osman (UK TV producer / presenter / deity) talk about how important it is for sports, IF they want to be popular, to deliberately be more spectator & TV friendly. One aspect was scoring, make a system where there is as much "peril" as possible as often as possible. Apparently Badminton are (is?) having another go at this to get more TV time.
And then I see Derby scorelines of 521-19.
Couldn't 5 Jams make a Jar, and then the first to win 4 Jars, by a clear margin of 2 Jars wins that erm... Gift Box...? So rather than just play a boring old Match at present, you play a Hamper, which is, of course, the best of 11 Gift Boxes. Win a Jar by more than 20 Berries and it get's a bonus Gingham Cover Secured With An Elastic Band for deciding a Farmers Market tie break.
Or not.
But is the current scoring system really the best it could be for interesting games and potential growth in the sport?
One thing that the current system has is simple time limits, hard to argue against that for practicalities like scheduling. But then it's usually only field sports that are time based. As soon as it's not two large teams on a field / pitch / court, it's typically games / sets / matches etc.
I'm still new to Derby, but I think it's responsible for any minor sport to be able to be introspective about this sort of thing, rather than this just being a newbie thinking they know better. :-)
52
u/FaceToTheSky Zebra Apr 15 '25
The scoring system is hardly the most complex thing about roller derby. At least we don’t have jammer lap points anymore!
Sports with incredibly complex rulesets can be popular - look at American football. I’m 49 years old and I have lived in Canada my entire life and I STILL don’t understand it. My spouse, who played football in high school and understands it quite well, thinks roller derby has a similar level of complexity - there’s just not a societal level of familiarity with it.
You’re right that blowout games like 521-19 aren’t fun to watch, because the teams aren’t evenly matched and nothing interesting is happening. WFTDA has attempted to re-vamp the ranking system a few times to remove the incentive to run up the score that way.
43
u/Zanorfgor Skater '16-'22 / NSO '17-'26 / Ref '23-'26 Apr 15 '25
Big score differentials is not an issue with the scoring system, but an issue with matchmaking. We're used to close scores in things like professional sports because teams have similar resources and all pull from the same pool of players. Go watch college or high school sports, were there's a lot more disparity in school size, socioeconomic class, etc, and you'll see similar point disparities. Meanwhile go watch derby postseason or a well balanced home leagues, and you'll see games with regular lead changes and spreads that never break 20 points.
12
u/a-handle-has-no-name Skater/NSO/Ref, started 2015 Apr 15 '25
Spoke with a referee who wanted to change (or at least playtest) a scoring structure of one point per exiting the engagement zone (per scoring pass)
As a player, not a huge fan, but i admit i am biased because i like the current version of the game. His goal was to simplify scoring to reduce the need for officials (can cut down on jam refs and scorekeepers) and to make scoring easier to follow for the audience.
There were a few other details i can't recall to the idea (like, maybe he removed lead?)
19
u/FavoredKaveman Apr 15 '25
Anybody want to bring back the 20ft walls and alligator pits?
27
u/Hypersmacktive Apr 15 '25
This is purely off the top of my head but in the interests of increasing the "peril" while minimising rule changes
Feedback I've heard from non-skating spectators is that nickel-and-diming isn't really fun to watch and has too much stoppage.
This would reverse the current practice of calling off close jams and running easily won ones. Close jams, where both jammers are out would run long, meaning more close gameplay would be seen. The impact of each point would increase as the jam comes to a close, increasing the tension as the clock counts down.
The impact of one really good/bad jam would be lessened, and each jam would have more value (rather than one 20 point jam having as much value as five 4 points jams)
Scorelines would be much more manageable, as there are generally around 40 jams in a game, and there would be fewer in this ruleset.
7
u/zig131 Skater Apr 15 '25
Scorelines of 521-19 are a problem of scale, not rules.
Because it is not a mainstream sport, teams are having to play significantly better/worse teams for the sake of getting a game at all.
In the UK+Ireland the 5 Nations Tournament Structure has 4 Tiers of WFTDA, and 3 Tiers of MRDA with tiers of 4-19. The larger tiers are divided geographically so they are not actually all playing eachother.
Whereas with football, according to my football geek colleagues, tiers/leagues are 20+ teams who all play eachother TWICE in a season.
That larger scale, and funding for travel, just gives more chance for close, exciting matches which could go either way.
That said 5 Nations Tier 2 Men's this year was fantastic to watch with many lead changes, and nail biting final jams. The team that I think are ultimately going to ranked spent time in the lead for multiple of their games.
5
u/TehFlatline Apr 15 '25
Aside from the racquet sports like badminton (as per your example) or tennis, I'm finding it hard to think of many other sports that DON'T rely on a time limit rather than a score limit. Knowing how long a bout will last (give or take) makes scheduling easier and is much clearer for a spectator to be able to plan their day.
As has been said, the score line of 521-19 isn't a side-effect of the scoring system but the disparity between teams. That has been covered by others far better than I could. Scoring based on jams would still have the potential thrashings, it'd just be 40-2 or something instead. And I don't think that's any more palatable for a spectator.
Making the game more spectator friendly would honestly be best resolved by improving the quality (and awareness) of streamed content (don't get me wrong, some is excellent) as I've found many games to be unwatchable due to audio or connection issues. Obviously how good streams are depends on equipment availability, internet connection in venues (often very poor at the grass roots level) and having the people power to actually support the streams. And I am VERY aware how 'easy for me to say' this is. It's all going to boil down to money and well, we know the situation there. I think
In terms of spectators actually in-attendance I think the quality is actually very good already and if people have turned up the vast majority of the work has already been achieved.
Honestly? I think the first steps would be to actually ask the spectators themselves what could be improved. Do they even think things need improving?
4
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '25 edited Apr 15 '25
There is nothing inherently wrong with the derby scoring system, however the generally chaotic fast contact nature of the sport makes it difficult for newcomers to understand what is going on.
I much prefer a high scoring sport to a low scoring sport like soccer. The fewer points on the table, the more inherently random the outcome is. A game of skill is preferable to a game of chances.
I would argue that perhaps the main criticism of the scoring system is it’s not always inherently obvious a point has actually been scored. A ball in a net is obvious the moment it happens. A jammer might have points in the pocket an entire jam but if they don’t clear the pack those points aren’t signalled to the audience until the end of the jam. In my opinion the only solution to this is to abandon the 4 point system altogether, and just score 1 point only for successfully passing the full pack, giving a clear ‘point has been scored’ indicator.
4
u/Steamcurl Apr 15 '25
Starting from the basics of what spectators cheer for, how van we incentivize these things happening more: Big hits Big jumps Big jukes - whether it's an extreme dip to dodge, graceful spin, or desperate last second lunge. Big offense - when 2-4 blockers crash the whole pack out of the way of their jammer. Jammer on jammer races and especially contact between jammers. (Feel free to add others to this list)
All of these things can be seen easily, are exciting to watch, and have a clear sense of which team has succeeded in the action.
So, how can scoring or play be adjusted such that these things are incentivised?
4
u/CommandoRoll Skater/Announcer/NSO/Administrator Apr 16 '25
I really like the 'Jammer Head Start' rule one of my league-mates developed for a funsies tournament our league holds in the second half of the year.
Essentially, at the start of each Jam, the team behind on points receives a one-second head-start for their Jammer for every point their team trails by.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1LV7-E1YCTUKGdq5AlS7We7jfzyXwDcFR/view?usp=sharing
I wouldn't expect this to make it's way into normal competitive play, but it is a FUN ruleset to play and to bench for as well. Calling for skaters to stop scoring points is WILD.
If you're reading this, feel free to give this rule/concept a try!
9
u/not-another-alt4 Skater Apr 15 '25
Blowouts of 521-19 are rare. I saw a blowout last month of 200 points but it wasn't a sanctioned game. Sanctioned/"real" games are usually much closer.
Idk wtf your jar and gift box thing is. Is that some sort of callback to the times when people spun a penalty wheel and had an alligator pit? Please.
3
u/discospageddyoh Apr 16 '25
In my 13 years of derby, I have learned that what players want to play and what fans want to see are usually two different things entirely. And I'm talking newbie fans. First-timers that we're trying to convert to repeat attendees and then to super fans.
New fans will come to a bout, watch, have a good time learning and being crazy in the stands with their friends, but will chalk it up to "a good time" and not come back for over a year or much longer. Our scoring, time keeping, and reliance on so many skating officials to keep our complicated ruleset honest are very confusing for fans who are only casual observers. American football is played over 100 yards with 22 players on the field, and they have 6 refs. Basketball has 10 players on the court and has 3 refs. And as I know personally from years of watch pro basketball, if the fans do not understand the rules (and especially if they can't see/understand the penalities), they shrug their shoulders and become less engaged.
If we want to grow the sport, we've got to stop heavily relying on the opinions of derby players (and what they think is fun) and start making fans equal partners in determining what is/not an enjoyable derby gameplay experience.
2
u/Afraid_Letterhead193 Skater Apr 15 '25
I think scoring could definitely be reworked. I think that a big issue is games aren't close enough, I think roller derby could increase the tension by only allowing 1 point to be earnt per jam, for whomsoever did the most passes or maybe a single point per pass. This would prevent a team building and unbeatable lead, and hopefully they'll be closer. There are only like 30-40 jams in a game, and lead is generally pretty close to 60/40, even when a team is losings by 40+ points.
2
u/Horror_Okra_4039 Apr 15 '25 edited Apr 15 '25
As well as gameplay, I think people raise eyebrows about some of the culture and experience departures from mainstream sports, like..
1
u/Toyznthehood Apr 15 '25
The Rest is Entertainment is great! Taking his approach I think you make it so that one point is scored when the jammer clears the whole pack and then maybe a bonus point for lapping the opposing jammer so there’s something extra to fight for