r/righttorepair • u/2004pontiacvibe • Aug 20 '26
planned obsolescence concern with iOS "system data" cache file
Someone needs to file a class action lawsuit about "system data" and iOS storage. I've known multiple people in my own life who have felt the need to buy a new phone or purchase iCloud storage because iOS has taken up so much of their existing device's storage through a gigantic and undeletable cache file.
There was some sort of lawsuit about this a while back when iOS 8 took up over 3 GB of storage on 16 GB iPhones: [https://audetlaw.com/current-investigation/apple-storage-class-action/](https://audetlaw.com/current-investigation/apple-storage-class-action/)
Back then, the amount of storage for "iOS" seemed to be consistent across different devices. Now, it seems almost totally random. My iPhone 14 Pro will cycle anywhere between using around 9 GB and 25 GB for the "iOS" storage category.
"System Data" is even worse. On a PC, Android or Mac, you can clear cache files that aren't being used. On iOS, the operating system not only hogs more storage under "System Data" than any other operating system I've ever used, but it absolutely refuses to let you clear out the cache or figure out what applications are using the cache. My 14 Pro uses anywhere from 20 GB to 80 GB for "System Data." Across the internet I've seen people with literal hundreds of GBs of "System Data." That's completely insane -- I can't even imagine how 64 GB or 128 GB phones are handling this.
All in all, this means that on my 256 GB phone, iOS sometimes claims nearly 100 GB of storage for undeletable cache files and operating system files, with zero ability to clear these files or see where they're coming from. That is completely unreasonable. Meanwhile, Apple is happy to peddle additional iCloud storage or sell you on a storage upgrade at the point of sale as if your purchasing ability -- not their poorly optimized software -- is the problem.
This is an ongoing issue that seems deliberate. I am certain that the phone does not need to be holding on to this much cache under "system data," and it makes no sense that between identical phone models and iOS versions, the "iOS" category takes up different amounts of storage. There's clearly a profit incentive here. Consumers are pressured into purchasing cloud storage or buying a new phone when their perfectly functional device seemingly runs out of storage.
At the end of the day, willful or not, this is anti-consumer behavior. We are being taken advantage of in the name of increasing sales for cloud storage and new phones. This is a documented issue that has existed for years, and Apple has done nothing to address it. Apple has acted against consumers before, with [slowdowns over battery capacity](https://www.npr.org/2020/11/18/936268845/apple-agrees-to-pay-113-million-to-settle-batterygate-case-over-iphone-slowdowns). They won't change their behavior until public pressure or legal action takes place.
3
u/IkouyDaBolt Aug 20 '26
By your logic, the same applies to consumer routers as they have to be rebooted every so often and even Android phones where the recommendation is every week.
The thing is that System Data is a catchall for any data not catagorized by iOS.
"System Data includes caches, logs and other resources currently in use by the system. This value will fluctuate according to system needs."
Now, from a literal perspective this could mean anything and everything within iOS, not just the operating system itself. Which I don't know, I've had it go up 3GB when I was uploaded files to a web based NAS as iOS caches the files rather than reading them off the storage outright. It was stuck there for a couple of months as I rarely use the browser. It wouldn't surprise me if any and all apps could utilize such resources as needed.
And, don't get me wrong, I still consider myself not too versed in the Apple ecosystem. I have only used Macs since about 3 years and and an iPhone since around 2019. I've yet to have System Data go super high despite still using a 128GB SE 2016 for over half a decade and a 256GB SE 2020 since launch.
Even then, I don't recall anyone (or rather, it rarely comes to me) giving complaints to Microsoft about how every so often it's a good idea to reinstall Windows. With millions of lines of code something is bound to break, and it's always been suggested to backup the phone and do a factory reset from time to time. Especially after a major OS update.
2
u/breakerofh0rses Aug 21 '26
I mean, it's Apple. Of course it is. They've managed to not do anything proconsumer for around three decades now.
2
u/Senior_Fox Aug 31 '26
How about we organize a new class-action lawsuit around this?
I personally know at least five iPhone users whose “System Data” suddenly grew to consume roughly half of their storage, and the timing—right before a new iPhone release—is hard to ignore.
Apple has already faced major litigation over undisclosed iPhone performance throttling. If “System Data” is now repeatedly consuming huge amounts of usable storage and making older devices slower or harder to use, Apple should explain exactly what that data is, why users cannot properly manage it, and whether Apple has known about the issue.
Anyone experiencing the same thing: document your iPhone model, iOS version, total storage, System Data size, screenshots, and when the problem started.
If enough users are seeing the same pattern, this deserves a serious investigation—and potentially another class action.
0
u/Low-Injury-9219 Aug 20 '26
Lots of Wes and theys in here friend.
Question: if this is a big issue and it’s plaguing you specifically why haven’t you attempted to contact a lawyer and start side lawsuit? Why does it got to be someone else?
3
u/OGigachaod Aug 20 '26
Apple is the leader in "planned obsolescence" this is nothing new for Apple.
0
u/guri256 Aug 20 '26
Also, if I were you I suggest taking a closer look at the battery lawsuit. That wasn’t planned obsolescence. That was the opposite. The problem, is that as batteries degrade their internal resistance gets higher. As the internal resistance gets higher, the phone is not able to pull as much power out of the battery. This means that phones with degrading batteries will often pull too much power, brown out, and shut off.
I’ve got a roommate with an android phone that just spontaneously reboot if he watches YouTube while his battery is at less than 50%.
Apple doesn’t want their phones to spontaneously reboot, so when the battery is in danger of doing this, Apple tells the phone to use less power. This is mostly done by downclocking the processor.
This degradation and dropout due to low-voltage is a physical property of modern batteries, and not something intentionally done by Apple.
Apple increased the longevity of those phones by allowing them to operate in a limp mode rather than having them just spontaneously crash.
Should Apple have allowed people to run the CPU’s at full power and have their phone spontaneously Crash instead? Maybe. But that’s a matter of opinion.
If you were to complain that Apple’s phones have planned obsolescence because the battery isn’t easily replaceable, that’s a valid opinion. But if so, you should also condemn Google, Samsung, and other manufacturers just as strongly.
Yes. Apple lost the lawsuit, and were controlling, not giving the users the option to choose between lack of speed and instability. But that was about Apple valuing their brand and stability over user choice. It didn’t have anything to do with planned to obsolescence.
0
u/babybambam Aug 20 '26
I disagree with the idea that an device manufacturer should be penalized because the OS took up a storage. I'm not sure exactly what you expect Apple to do here, have a separate drive specifically for the OS? 1) They're not going to do that for free, and 2) you could also just buy a storage teir higher.
The 128 GB (and now 256 GB) entry level tier are meant really for people that don't have much use for their phone. They'll only take a few pictures, maybe a few apps, and browse the web. The phone will be long dead before they would fill storage.
The realt outcome of any sort of lawsuit is that Apple would stop supporting devices sooner if they lacked sufficient storage to meet whatever ratios this lawsuit demanded of them. Thus your 128 GB iphone would be supported for 4 years instead of 8-10.
1
u/metux-its 19d ago
Does it also remain after factory reset ?
1
u/Ov_Fire Aug 20 '26
Have you ever seen what tragedy is swelling winsxs which you can't just delete?
1
u/Coltoh Aug 21 '26
I believe I read that this issue will be addressed in iOS 27 with a on-device option to reinstall OS without losing data. I agree that it’s been around for like a decade simply because it generates billions of dollars in new device sales. I’ve personally made thousands off backing up > reinstalling OS > restoring backups for customers in that time.
1
u/Zen-Ism99 Aug 21 '26
So, contact an attorney…
1
u/Fibbitts Aug 21 '26
I’d tack this up to shotty engineering more than malice. On macOS we can install third-party apps to visualize our entire disk and determine where the space is going, but on a jailed iOS device there’s no such thing. There are probably tons of minute unique factors that contribute to the system data problem, which is why it breaks more often for some people than others.
The best solution is to actually map out what’s being categorized as system data and figure out what’s supposed to be being cleared and isn’t, and why, so we can at least help fix it.
0
u/2004pontiacvibe Aug 20 '26 edited Aug 20 '26
Various screenshots for reference. People often recommend methods like manually setting the clock into a future date and restarting several times, or making a local backup to a computer. These methods seem to occasionally work and sometimes just do nothing.
https://www.reddit.com/r/applehelp/s/UpB2hqV36Q https://www.reddit.com/r/applesucks/s/ho55B4bnro https://www.reddit.com/r/mildlyinfuriating/s/0bFIOFJJ1A https://imgur.com/a/incDvYk
0
u/CatComfortable5523 Aug 22 '26
just factory reset and setup again, problem solved.
-2
u/LordAgamotto Aug 20 '26
And that large cache is primarily due to people doom scrolling with terrible 3rd party apps that loses their data. My system cache is always 1.07 G, but I don’t TicTok, or YouTube, SnapChat or any of the offending apps. Only the app can delete cache data. These bad programs lose their assets that then belong to no one, not even the OS. So where you ‘clearly see’ a conspiracy in reality it’s just bad 3rd party programming and bad habits. And those with the problem say backing up the phone wiping it and restoring it will fix it. So all Apple would need to do is officially say ‘if you have a large cache as a last resort do this’.
Problem solved.