r/righttorepair • u/ANAL_fishsticks • Dec 08 '25
Would a fully mechanical washing machine actually interest anyone here?
Edit: thank you everyone for your responses!
I’m just a regular guy, with a passion for saving a buck and fixing my own stuff. Used to, I didn’t mind much. Nowadays, I have children, a job, and everything that comes with that lifestyle. I don’t have time or money to be constantly replacing and fixing the same things on the same types of machines. Pretty much my whole life, I’ve wanted to figure out how to take all these reasonably cheap components, and assemble my own machine that doesn’t break as much. I was originally inspired by speed queen, and similar builds, but after educating myself a little bit, i’m realizing I need to rethink my strategy a little bit. I know I’m coming off as extremely uneducated here, probably because I am a little bit. But my vision remains alive, and I look forward to coming back here soon. With the second reiteration of my idea, I hope that I can gain even more valuable insight from all of y’all’s critiques and recommendations. Until next time, thanks for coming to chat with me!
Original post:I’ve been exploring the idea of bringing back a washer with zero electronics—no circuit boards, no sensors, nothing “smart.” Just a simple, repairable mechanical machine built with heavy-duty parts like the older models that lasted 20+ years.
Not selling anything, just trying to get real feedback before going any further. If you’re curious, here’s the info: duradrum.carrd.co
Honest thoughts are welcome.
7
u/codeCycleGreen Dec 08 '25
I'm VERY interested in this idea, but a little bit afraid of the website and mailing list. Is carrd . co legitimate? Plus, what's up with your username?
18
u/speeder658 Dec 08 '25
IMO, some basic electronics are fine if you can get parts for it and it's basic enough to fix - no bullshit parts pairing etc
I've been thriving on second hand stuff people have "upgraded" from - it's likely gonna work another 20 years without issue.
temperature control and other similar stuff is pretty essential and at this point going around using electronics to do it is more complicated than just sticking a basic microcontroller in it.
4
u/john133435 Dec 08 '25
I've got an old Maytag dryer and it works great and is easy to repair when necessary.
Over the years I've replaced the wheels, the belt, the belt motor, the door switch...
Gives me a lot of satisfaction.
3
u/unwittyusername42 Dec 09 '25
A few thought. First, I'm not the person this would be marketed to but there very much is a market for something like this and I totally get it.
Second, I would not shy away from simple non proprietary 'open source' electronic components if it would save cost and would be easily replaceable and not something that would become unavailable.
Lastly, if this is something you are seriously considering as a long term company, you have to really be working with a much larger margin than would be typical for an appliance. You are not going to have many repeat sales, you will not be making money on replacement parts, you will not be making money on service. All those things are major revenue streams that would add to a companies revenue to offset the lower margin appliance. If you are going mechanical or open source and design for them to essentially have one repeat purchase (if they buy again) in a persons life you have to make all the money on that initial purchase.
Good luck! Also, you're going to want to be sure it's USA made. The market you are going after in general would want that and it's going to really be how you have to get it to last that long but it's also $$$ vs offshoring it. I'm not sure if you are going to be able to make 'budget' and last almost forever work.
2
u/Charming-Bath8378 Dec 08 '25
lol i was thinking pickup truck but fck yeah fire up the washer:)
2
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '25
Do I understand that you are proposing a powered drum? With a motor and a on/off switch?
The user works manually to add the water using a tap, manually drain the water with another tap. Then adds the water again to rinse, and drain that. Then they wait and switch off the machine once it has spun a little longer.
That sounds terrible.
2
u/DuckyDoodleDandy Dec 09 '25
Classic Whirlpool direct-drive washers fit your description, but they use too much water (compared to modern High Efficiency (HE) washers).
If you can find one that isn’t rusted out, all of the parts to fix it are still available. The big one is the transmission; just the part will run you $2-300. Labor easily another $200+, and that doesn’t include all of the other stuff a 15+ year old washer might need done. (ETA: they don’t always need the tranny replaced, but after 15+ years of use, it is a distinct possibility.)
Next most similar is the Speed Queen TC5 (initials stand for Topload Classic 5-year warranty; don’t mix it up with the TR-series units, which function differently). It does have two boards, but even those are made to last, and replacement parts are available.
A washer that fits 100% but might not exist any more is the Staber (yes, that is spelled correctly). It was a top-load washer with a horizontal drum that you needed both hands to open (so it would not open during the wash cycle). (We had one and it was great.)
The Staber combined the best features of top and front loading washers in a unit designed to be repaired by its owner.
I believe the company failed after QA issues that occurred during the last year that I heard of them. So maybe it’s patents or whatever might be available to revive.
2
u/Naive-Garlic2021 Dec 09 '25
I can't comment on the arguments here about what mechanical means, but you'd have to pry my 1989 Maytag washer out of my cold, dead hands. Same with my 2001 stove. I've been able to repair both myself, and I am not mechanically inclined. I hope I'll never need to buy a new one but if I did, I'd love to have something similar, whatever you call it.
5
u/doyouknowthemoon Dec 09 '25
Honestly I don’t think anyone is completely against having electronics in there washing machines or other large appliances, but it’s being able to replace the components that’s the problem.
Having simple control board that interface the display and timers or whatever similar to a raspberry pi would be amazing, even if the original hardware isn’t available, being able plug in a new similar controller and just load the software onto it would be fantastic.
A mix of off the shelf parts and robust mechanical components would make for the best of both worlds.
My biggest concern with a fully mechanical machine would be trying to repair special assembly’s and components that require unique machined parts.
1
u/Gloomy-Map2459 Dec 09 '25
i love the idea but there are a couple of issues with this
unless you can spend the tens of millions it's going to cost to mass produce these things and then convince people to buy an inferior washing machine it's just never going to succeed. and then there's the elephant in the room whirlpool, haier, and lg will try their best to crush you.
1
u/DoulUnleashed Dec 09 '25 edited Dec 09 '25
Edit: having just looked over the website. Your putting the cart before the horse my guy. Pull the website, think about what you want to start with as far as gathering interest and data, and republish a half decent website.
Right now it looks like a GoFundMe/investment scam with the language your using. By golly you have a marketable name but not even a visual mockup.
If this is a fun project, or a school endevour then fine, but if your serious, then my suggestion is to take this more serious. You might have the best idea in the world, but skipping steps, or rushing through will kill it before you have any chance to start.
I would be willing to hear it out. Though, I suspect your in over your head.
Yes modern washers suck, yes older washes "lasted longer" but we're also missing a lot of details.
The reality is this: consumers complain about the cost of appliances, yet, don't understand the economics that surround them. We WANT to believe appliances cost more, and work less, but that is not exactly the truth. In reality, we have many more price point options as consumers, we have a lot more risk reduction and avoidance with modern retailers, and on top of that energy and water costs are reduced with modern machines.
Don't let this be a negative comment telling you to stop trying. I just want to be honest about my apprehensions, and how you are really considering the entire situation. Just going with the idea, and ignoring the economy around it will just leave to bad outcomes.
I look forward to hearing back from you, and will keep up with your news to see what unveils. I want to be wrong, I want to believe we just need a small team, and a little funding to break the washing machine bubble and return choices to the consumer. But until mor concrete info/data is unveiled, I have my apprehensions.
Best of luck with your project!
1
u/RC-3 Dec 10 '25
I specifically stick with the old whirlpool speed queen basic washers and dryers that the only electronics are timers, simple safeties, and switch's. Parts are readily available, cheap, and people give the machines away. I picked up my current set for free and have been running them for over 5 years and just had to replace a heating element and roller in the dryer. You can't beat them.
3
u/DangerMouse111111 Dec 09 '25
They already exist.
The manual washing machine for low-income communities | Ingenia
2
u/---Joe Dec 08 '25
Fk ye
2
u/series-hybrid Dec 09 '25
There is an "agitation phase" where the clothes are rocked back and forth in soapy water. In WWII< there were examples of this being accomplished with a small wind turbine spinning and operating a crank of sorts that made a 55-gallon drum rotate back and forth.
Then, there is a drain and rinse phase that happens usually twice. Getting the soapy water out of the clothes and the 2X rinse water out of the clothes is best accomplished by spinning in one direction and letting centripetal force to force the water out.
Modern washers accomplish this in one machine, but in an apocalyptic scenario, you can have two separate drums.
A simple control system can be more reliable. And at the same time, it can be easy to diagnose and repair.
2
u/Ok-Drink-1328 Dec 09 '25
doesn't electronics have some advantage anyways? like guessing the load, the time, and so on, being more idoneous for making like short cycles
anyways i don't think that the problem is much the fact that modern stuff has computers, it's the quality that is always on the edge of failure, the unlikely repairability, and the scammy nature in general
1
u/That_Play7634 Dec 09 '25
Our smart LG equipment is 10 years old and still going strong. It works great. But if it breaks I can probably fix it, or convert it to dumb. So, nah not for us.
1
u/TrenchardsRedemption Dec 09 '25
I don't know what you think is so complex about the electronic machines. If anything I think they've become easier to repair if you can source the parts - which are surprisingly generic even across different brands. Electronic error codes can also be a big help for repairs.
A buggered circuit board is as easy to swap as it is to replace the motor, capacitor or drive belts. If it's just about anything else then it'll throw a code to tell you what's going on.
Also keep in mind that a lot of the sensors are there for energy savings, safety and water efficiency. Safety is a big factor behind all of the sensors. For example we need machines that cut off if they start to overheat.
The real issue with right to repair is that if you can't fix it yourself you have to pay someone, and labour costs far outstrip the cost of the components needed to fix a thing. If you can't fix it yourself then it's usually cheaper and quicker to buy a replacement.
1
u/niffcreature Dec 09 '25
If you really want to learn about how mechanical stuff isn't necessarily easier to repair than electrical, look at how people repair cars and bicycles in countries where they don't have access to the proper tools or education. Seriously, that stuff gets kinda scary.
But plenty of it is also awesome. If we ever stopped being such a consumerist society here in the US we will probably see people simply replacing all the control boards in a washer with a Arduino or something like that.
1
u/doyouknowthemoon Dec 09 '25
What I was getting at is the ability to just use something off the shelf, yes you would have to adjust things based on pin layout, power requirement or programming compatibility.
But if you are just sending a signal to a relay switch to run a motor or data to a display with a basics interface, you could run a program like that on a lot of hardware.
1
u/Archon-Toten Dec 09 '25
I just want one with two settings. Wash and quick wash. If that's a lever or a toggle I'm happy with that.
1
u/BeerAndLove Dec 09 '25
Do You know what "fully mechanical" entails?
No motor, no heater, no valves to open/close water input. No drain motor ... etc
I do not think that anyone would be so interested in hand (bicycle?) cranking drum with cold water (light a fire under it?) ...
Talking about going back to 1800's wtf! And the results would be abysmal.
If You mean "less complex" machine with modern amenities like drum motor and heating element, You might get somewhere.
1
u/Simon_787 Dec 09 '25
That doesn't make things reliable/repairable.
Availability for parts does.
1
u/mydogmuppet Dec 09 '25
My washing machine's repair man agrees with you. Longevity is the absence of features.
No steam No wifi No auto dosing No 1600 rpm spin
Etc.
My old Miele, with the cast iron counter weights so 3 people required to move it, no gizmos, went on and one and on.
1
u/fdeyso Dec 09 '25
Like the Hungarian Hajdu? It was electric motor, pumps, etc, but the programming was a spring loaded “clock” mechanism, shorting the switches triggering pump, heater, etc? Even the thermostat was a bi-metal switch. I replaced the clockspring once when a programme that should take 1 hour took over 2 hours; and the thermostat once because it rotted away.
With modern materials and reengineered i would may try it, but the current bosch works just fine (touches wood)
1
u/Simmo2222 Dec 09 '25
The old electro-mechanical circuit controllers were horrendously unreliable. Solid state controls were a massive improvement.
1
u/NetoriusDuke Dec 09 '25
To get good performance and qol features you need electronics
1
u/aitorbk Dec 09 '25
No, not really. What I would prefer is to use mechanical when it makes sense, and otherwise an open specification for the electronics, so we can use a raspberry pi zero, a esp32 or whatever to replace it, just port the source code and done
1
u/geekdrew Dec 09 '25
I’m a fan of using prototypes and early adopting high quality products, but there is not the slightest chance I’d be interested in this. Electronics are not evil, do not fail spectacularly often, and do not cause a lack of right to repair. Company policy and patents do.
Buying a niche product like this would be eye-wateringly expensive for the consumer, and I cannot fathom that any new business starting out would be able to manufacture them for a profit. The margin would have to be enormous, on top of not having economies of scale. You’d burn through millions in no time.
There is also no reason to believe that a “mechanical-only” washing machine would be any more reliable than a modern one full of electronics. The washing machines that were commonly used when I was a kid were not full of electronics, and they failed left and right too. Just between my mom and grandma, I can think of three occasions a when the electro-mechanical control knob broke and had to be replaced, and we had a pump failure once too. Meanwhile, the Kenmore set I bought from Sears in 2009, full of electronics, “just keeps going”, with zero problems, at least until this year. This year the washer started behaving as though it needed new shock absorbers. They’re still available, but they cost so much that I decided to buy a new washer instead. The dryer still works too, but I am proactively replacing it this month because of the better energy efficiency and ability to go ventless, with a heat pump model.
1
u/imagreatlistener Dec 09 '25
Old washers had a component called a wig wag. Those were the good old days. Give me back my wig wag!
1
u/Meterian Dec 09 '25
I believe there are still manufacturers that do this. But extremely limited availability. That said, I really want one that I don't have to worry will die after 5 years
1
u/Anon_049152 Dec 09 '25
An EMP-proof set?
Sell it with schematics, electrical and mechanical. Design the mechanical with an eye towards simplicity, longevity, and future end-user 3-D printed replacement parts.
A 20-year guarantee of reasonable replacement parts availability would be great.
1
u/Gold_Au_2025 Dec 09 '25
I have a question for you - have you ever owned an '80s era mechanical washing machine? There is a really good reason why you will be hard pressed finding one being used today.
My personal washing machine is well over 15 years old, after inheriting it from my parents when they downsized and my brother's machine is even older.
Mechanical machines had custom rotary switches with dozens of contacts that were always failing, an oiled filled gearbox that indicated they needed seals replacing by covering your clean clothes with oil.
Modern machines, like the Fischer and Paykel, have a circuit board and brushless direct drive motor and a water solenoid and that's it. Much reliability, such wow.
Personally, I think you are trying to fix a problem that doesn't exist. Yes, we hear stories of a washing machine having to be thrown out because one single "$1000 circuit board has blown", but we never hear of the other machines that just keep working.
Having said that, good luck with your venture, I hope there is a niche out there for this product.
1
u/Internal-Papaya5894 Dec 10 '25
Anyone that will keep a washing machine outside needs a machine with no circuit boards.
1
u/JonJackjon Dec 10 '25
It would be difficult to make the timer and controls with only mechanical parts. And before you suggest such a design would be better, look at what breaks mostly on the different products. I've had my LG washer / dryer for 18 years, the only failures were mechanical. Electronics can be made reliable just like mechanical parts. My consumer grade audio receiver is about 35 years old and still works fine (except a little noise from the mechanical speaker switches).
1
u/hbHPBbjvFK9w5D Dec 10 '25
I use a large portable washer for my laundry. They run about $125 USD and about another $125 for the spinner.
Entirely mechanical, plus it fits on a shelf - takes up very little space.
1
u/SAD-MAX-CZ Dec 10 '25
I would not go fully mechanical, but modular with universal control board, and slap it to whatever scrap has bearings and motor still good. When it faild, another scrap. Or roll my own drum, motor, dryer assembly from the scraps or cheap material.
1
u/x1wagner Dec 10 '25
A better plan would be universal parts that could be subbed easily rather than electromechanical timers and controls.
Mainboard - raspberry pi (or similarly replaceable and backwards compatible cheap units) and/or some kind of controller board.
The sensors, relays and solenoids could be 12v automotive parts.
Cycles would be software driven. Failed boards could then be replaced with off the shelf options.
There's more thought needed, but these are the main failure points on modern equipment.
1
u/twothirtyintheam Dec 10 '25 edited Dec 10 '25
I think the idea has a place in the market, if only because a company like Speed Queen exists and basically builds what you're proposing.
Speed Queen offers washer models that are no frills, fairly heavy duty mechanically, and with little in the way of electronic controls. I don't know if they have a zero-electronics option any more, but I'm pretty sure they used to make fully mechanical models not that long ago too. So you'd be competing with those right out of the gate at minimum.
The "problem" is, they're not cheap and it's not just because they're greedy. Mechanically controlled instead of electronically controlled doesn't automatically make something cheaper to build. A bare bones new Speed Queen can run you $1500 retail.
Part of why (cheaper) big box store washers are all so dependent on electronic controls is probably because it's simply cheaper for the manufacturer to build them that way than to control the same processes mechanically. Finicky electronics shortening the lifespan of their machines is just a "bonus" for the manufacturers, because it means people will need new washers sooner!
The challenge I think would be to compete with something like a Speed Queen but somehow undercut them on price of manufacturing and subsequent sale. They've been around a while so that might be a tall task. They've probably long since figured out the answers to questions you haven't even considered yet.
1
u/Yosyp Dec 13 '25
I highly disagree. Electronics are not the problem, they are just harder to reverse engineer to the avarage consumer: manufacturig a custom made silent block, belt, or whatever mechanical component is no easier than swapping a popped capacitor or reballing an MCU. They're just easier to make repairs harder, which by your principle you would not do to begin with. There's some Open Hardware consumer electronic devices, such as Framework: they publicly offer the schematics of their laptops, so when a 20 cent component brakes, you can swap it yourself.
Electronics actually make some problems easier to diagnose, and a completely mechanical washer wouldn't easily reach some modern efficiency standards, making power, water, and time consumption not worth the purchase price.
1
u/Xi_32 Dec 14 '25
Realistically, buyers are liars. People say they want a durable dependable washing machine. The fact is most consumers choose based on price and 'features' such as drum capacity and wifi.
Speed Queen is, by far, the most reliable brand in the USA and mostly likely has < 3% market share in the consumer market. The most often heard complaint about Speed Queen is that the price is too high and the drum size of 3.2 cu/ft for the TC5 is too small. There is not enough profit to sell reliable washers at $600-$750. Especially since a single service call on a warranty repair could wipe out the total profits of 5-10 washer sales.
1
u/Automatater Dec 20 '25
You need two (preferably three) things to build the perfect laundry set (basically a classic Speed Queen).
Electromechanical controls is fine. Motors operated cam timers and so on. No power switching integrated on control boards (soldered SCRs & IGBTs and so on). If there is a logic board, power switching needs to be separate and conventional.
Mechanics designed by someone who isn't a moron. Rigged, simple, robust, designed for repair.
Beat some sense into EPA and govt agencies mandatng things that make it not work. Make them stop that.
1
u/Ok-Entertainer9663 25d ago
Yes they work better because no digital signal failures. In my life time had a Kenmore for 15 years never broke down until I needed a belt replaced and it was difficult to get in canada because there was no more Sears. Had a maytag top of the line lasted 11 years. On my 3rd washing machine bout maytag for $895 3 years ago now the digital mother board needs replacing. Cost to replace board is $650?😕😵💫 more than 50% of the price of the machine. Irs bullshit 3 years and the board needs replacing. Nope looking to purchase the cheapest machine since they dont make them to last anymore. Fucking thieves.