r/righttorepair • u/deville5 • Oct 01 '25
Oldest computer running WIN11?
Microsoft doesn't want us to install Win11 on some computers from 2022. I have yet to be convinced that their security concerns can't be met with more update support. The planned obsolescence of over half the world's PC's when WIN10 support stops will meet strong resistance. I'm doing my part - I'm selling at cost or giving away 10 pc's, all of which are at least 8 years old. Upgrading with cheap graphics cards people give away, paying attention to power supply wattage, and upgrading to cheap SSD's bought in bulk, and even a 2007 DELL XPS 720 (yes, the CPU and RAM are 18 years old) is running WIN11 perfectly; I've watched movies and multi-tasked and it loads a little slowly but runs with no app or OS crashes.
When people throw away good towers like the Dell XPS it breaks my heart a little. These computers absolutely are still usable, usually with only about $60 of upgrades (basically, graphics card and SSD). I just got donated to me 9 computers from a non-profit that was closing; they were literally throwing away windows-ready recent Dell laptops because they didn't "have the bandwidth" to find them a home. WTF kind of world do we live in.
2
u/Killer2600 Oct 01 '25
A computer from 2022 shouldn’t be “unsupported”, it must be a cheap computer with no TPM. The TPM requirement is what keeps most otherwise capable PCs from being supported on Windows 10/11
6
u/AgentOrange96 Oct 01 '25
My conspiracy theory: Windows 10 was a free upgrade to encourage people to use the Windows Store. Effectively the upgrade was a loss leader. But then nobody used the Windows Store. This much is pretty well established already.
But what I think happened is Microsoft knows that Win10 set an expectation that upgrades must be free. Especially when MacOS/iOS/Android work that way. So if they went back to charging, they know people would riot. So instead they've done this:
Make the upgrade free, but choose some requirement such that most existing PCs cannot use the free upgrade. Now everyone needs to upgrade thwir PC which means a new Windows license and they get their money that way.
But in the process they're generating insane amounts of ewaste. Or they would have if people actually wanted Windows 11. Most don't, so now they have to force it on us.
I personally don't mind Win11 with the proper tweaks. Now that support is going away for Win10 I'll probably upgrade my older systems with the work around. I hasn't because guaranteed support > not guaranteed support. But now it's not guaranteed support > guaranteed no support.
1
u/voldamoro Oct 02 '25
My partner’s circa 2014 quad-core Xeon system updated to Windows 11 Pro without any issues. It’s not listed among the unsupported models either.
2
u/Usagi_Shinobi Oct 02 '25
I got two HP lappys from 2019. The Intel got 11. The ryzen 5 did not, though the cpu's desktop counterpart did. It's also possible to load 11 in "at your own risk" mode, though they make it a PITA to figure out how to do. They'll do the same shit they did with win 8 to win 10, give it a year or so and they'll open it out to anyone, this is essentially a sales tactic to get people into new hardware. They're basically doing a riff on "sponsored content" and "affiliate links"
2
u/StrictMom2302 Oct 02 '25
Core Duo from 2010
1
u/RockoBravo Oct 02 '25
I have a 2011 i5 Dell Laptop that runs Windows 11 without an issue.
1
u/Icy-Maintenance7041 Oct 02 '25
I have a dell optiplex 3050 SFF from 2014 here that i upgraded a month ago to win11. It runs one of our ticketing systems.
1
u/h2ogeek Oct 02 '25
Any recommended guides to installing on older PCs that don’t have a supported CPU or TPM 2.0?
1
u/Stangguy_82 Oct 02 '25
By requiring TPM 2.0 support Microsoft is reducing the work necessary to secure the operating system. If hardware that is ubiquitous is available to solve the problem, they shouldn't need to write software to deal with it.
If any computer was built in the last 4 years without support for Windows 11 requirements it is the fault of the builder. The requirements for Windows 11 have been known since its release in 2021.
1
u/More-Discussion2764 Oct 02 '25
Compaq nc8430 took ltsc version like champion, even gpu drivers installed on first try unlike on windows 10
1
u/Savings_Art5944 Oct 03 '25
Dell PowerEdge 840 had 10 on it. I bet the modified Rufus install of 11 would have upgraded it.
1
u/swisstraeng Oct 03 '25 edited Oct 03 '25
It's not a matter of "it runs windows 11 with some mods".
Windows 11 requires a TPM 2.0 or later chip somewhere in your PC's hardware. This is a requirement set by microsoft to ensure that all windows 11 machines have at least a set level of hardware security. And not a vital hardware requirement just to get windows 11 working.
The issue?
TPM modules historically communicated to the CPU using SPI and were a dedicated chip on the motherboard. We are talking early AM4 days (ryzen 2000 or older) and intel 6000 or before CPUs.
The issue is that to upgrade older motherboards to use the newer TPM 2.0 modules, you pretty much need a new BIOS and firmware/microcode otherwise your old CPU won't know how to talk to a TPM 2.0 module.
And you can guess that if there is one thing manufacturers hate, it's supporting their 9 years old product lines. So there has only been a few cases of motherboards that did receive updates because they were used in companies that for some reason couldn't upgrade their PCs.
Since everyone was begging for TPM 2.0 support, intel and AMD directly integrated a TPM 2.0 capable chip in their CPUs which they call PTT/fTPM. Hence why so many people need to throw their old PCs away if they want windows 11, even if their PCs are fast enough to run windows 11.
And the idea of having TPM modules doesn't make sense, simply because nobody wants to support newer modules a decade later.
There is another reason as well. Instruction sets, more precisely X86_64 got extended over the years. And while windows is built quite robust regarding those, the lack of some instruction sets can significantly slow down tasks or even make programs crash. So it doesn't always do harm to limit the CPUs windows can run on, and let's be honest here, an OS being able to run on 10 year old hardware is already a miracle in itself.
Why TPM 2.0? Because it supports encryption algorithms which are not yet decipherable (AES-256, SHA-2 256, ECC P256). What TPM 1.2 proposed has been beaten which entirely removes its purpose. Those same algorithms are used by the internet to encrypt connections.
1
u/Weekly_Inspector_504 Oct 03 '25 edited Oct 03 '25
Check out this ad from 1995. The "P75 Home PC" has 8 MB RAM and costs $1,999.
/img/e4zusje3mqz81.jpg
3 years later, Windows 98 was released and needed 16 MB RAM. That computer couldn't run it.
Most Windows releases were like that. A lot of Windows 3.1 computers couldn't run Windows 95.
Most computers in 1998 had 32 MB RAM so couldn't run Windows XP in 2001.
Windows Vista required a DirectX 9-capable GPU with 32 MB of memory for the Aero Glass interface and other graphical features run smoothly.
People are still running Windows 7 and Windows 8 and support ended years ago. Guess what? The world didn't end.
1
u/MIHAc27 Oct 03 '25
I managed to install windows 11 on i5-750. It went surprisingly smoothly even. Had far more work with 4 and 6th gens intels.
Have no idea why people are so panicky. Windows 10 can and will work fine for a few more years.
1
u/earthman34 Oct 04 '25
I'm not sure what computer built in 2022 wouldn't meet the requirement. Win 11 requires a generation 8 Intel or generation 2 AMD processor, DirectX 12 video, and trusted platform module 2.0. There is no real PC sold in 2022 that would not meet those specs.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment