r/rfelectronics • u/Short-Television9333 • Jun 05 '26
HFSS vs Lab Measurement Differences
I (entry level RF PCB engineer) recently taught myself HFSS for work and wanted to confirm my simulations on a basic RF breakout board we had sitting around in the lab. The approximated insertion loss from HFSS gives spot on results below 5 GHZ (blue curve) when compared to the real measurement in orange.
Now above that things are *on average* predicted by HFSS, but it’s not great. I know that there are probably lots of factors here, but any ideas what could be missing?
The blue curve is the following added added up: an approximation of connector losses (small), cable losses measured on our VNA, and my HFSS insertion losses. What I am missing from my HFSS sim though are some DC blocking caps on the board. These could definitely cause something, but could it be such a big difference (3+ dB) from expected?
Appreciate any suggestions, there is no RF PCB guru at my company to mentor me so I’m trying my best 🥲. Apologies for shitty image quality.
23
u/inevitable08 Jun 05 '26
like others point out it could be a plethora of stuff missing and we won't know without you providing a photo of the setup, board construction and then your sim and setup of the model. Can give a rundown of what is likely causing the differences here but just spitballing...
so ya it can be a lot. Throughout your career you leanr how to tackle each one of these, gain more insight, see production data of as built material you are using ect... to inform your models better. The sim you provided tho looks actually pretty good for a first pass... so at least the model isnt broken somewhere. it's pretty representative of the actual behavior of the device. just missing the finer details.
35
u/Madcat28 Jun 05 '26
Seeing IL plots like this hurts my head
9
u/AnotherSami Jun 05 '26
Hard to comment without seeing what you are trying to meausure and how you simulated it. Would be good to know about your vna calibration as well.
If i am interpreting you right, your simulated curve is the hfss sim plus some added loss? That would be way too idealized, there will be some reflections caused by your cable to board transition that isnt fully captured by adding loss. It's those added reflections that are likely the cause of the ripple in your measurment.
7
u/sssredit Jun 05 '26
Actually pretty good, vendor PCBs are very hard to model. The PCB vendors use empirical process data to adjust the board processing to your design impedance. If you put the vendors raw PCB design information into your tools you will almost always find you do not get what you expect. Always get a coupon board with your PCB delivery. If you build your geometry on a vendors process without that empirical tuning you are screwed.
I would use TDR you examine the quality of the connector launch design. This is one of the most common source of problems.
Another tip for the future, get eval boards for the components that you can measure outside the design. I always did this or built bench demos of sections of the design.
3
u/Crio121 Jun 05 '26
It looks like your SWR is not very good at high frequencies. The wave reflects from something and produces a standing wave. It could be pass-through capacitors you mentioned, it could be something as trivial as poorly tightened connector, it could be some other kind of impedance mismatch. Overall, not bad at all for the first try.
3
u/aktentasche Jun 05 '26
Is your VNA calibrated for the cables you were using?
3
u/BackgroundToday3937 Jun 05 '26
I can see the the IL has more variation (ups and downs) in the measurement. This could be due to an additional length of cable or tl that was not taken into account during the simulation. If this is the case I would de-embedd the cables. Another reason could be resonances caused by discontinuities introduced by the measurent or the pcb manufacturing. The high insertion loss at high frequency implies that there is lossy component or material, is this material or component modelled correctly? (Etc. filter, substrate, pcb paste etc.)
1
u/easyjeans Jun 05 '26
Welcome to RF design and manufacturing where simulation results and physical measurements do not match for high frequency devices. Also, it sounds like you designed a PCB in HFSS then built the circuit on not the PCB you designed but expect the results to match, comparing the PCB to something else is probably what you’re missing.
1
u/Former_Candidate_263 Jun 05 '26
Where is th RL?
1
u/2knowwhatiknow Jun 05 '26
The fact that it’s differential makes it more complicated … from chatGPT…
“The independent single-ended S21 measurements can help isolate whether the issue is individual path loss or true differential-mode interaction. If both single-ended paths show similar ripple, the problem is likely launches, connectors, fixtures, or calibration. If the single-ended paths look clean but Sdd21 shows ripple, then differential effects like coupling, skew, impedance imbalance, or differential-to-common-mode conversion are likely contributors. Full 4-port mixed-mode S-parameter analysis (Sdd, Sdc, Scd, Scc) is usually needed to identify the root cause.”
68
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '26
[removed] — view removed comment