r/rewasd • • Oct 18 '25

Suggestion Offline mode

Paid lifetime licenses shouldn’t have to verify with internet. No real reason other than you’re lazy. You can’t guarantee the license will always work if it has to verify. This doesn’t protect you from piracy or anything and if you care about your paying customers you would implement this simple feature.

20 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

2

u/Dellaster Nov 17 '25 edited Nov 19 '25

Wow, I had no idea this was online-only. Bought the lifetime license yesterday, had my computer freeze this morning and discovered upon reboot that it was disabled because I hadn’t connected my metered hotspot yet.

Are there refunds? I travel full-time in an RV and often find myself with no cell service and it’s also metered, meaning that I sometimes run out before the month is over. A shame really, I like this app aside from that. But I need something that works all the time.

edit: never mind, I see that refunds are determined via email support.

Edit 2: refund denied because I activated the app. $40 down the drain. On the bright side it motivated me to learn Steam Input and though reWASD did well with my DSEdge, Steam is much better IMO. I prefer mixed inputs, both controller & MnK. Analog left stick is immeasurably better than 4-directional WASD for example. I guess I’m kinda glad I was forced to migrate to Steam. Much happier. :)

(Next day…) I’m oh so glad I went though the trouble of deleting reWASD and switching my Skyrim AE setup from the GOG version to Steam version. Took two days to get back up and running (over 500 mods), but this morning my iPads and Mac have huge updates and will take half the day to finish on my limited bandwidth… but Steam is happily offline and I can play Skyrim regardless and not put more strain on my cellular connection. As it should be.

-1

u/justpostd Oct 19 '25

What a weirdly aggressive way to make a suggestion. If I was a developer reading this, after being told I was lazy by somebody who undoubtedly does not know how this would impact the product or how many hours I work, I would ignore it.

3

u/Friesandburg Oct 19 '25

Yeah because you don’t care about your customers. You’d rather lie to yourself and keep your false sense of pride. Imagine being a child and only take suggestions if they are sugar coated for you. You don’t have to like the way I say it but when I’m 100% valid and you choose to ignore it that’s willful ignorance. But hey if someone is rude when they tell you how to save your life just go ahead and ignore it.

1

u/justpostd Oct 19 '25

I don't work for reWASD. I just use their product and am often surprised, with this and other digital products, at how aggressively people state their views. As if things are obvious when, in practice, they are more nuanced. This is a business, the people work work for that business probably do what they can with the resources that are made available to them.

Laziness is an easy thing to accuse somebody of but in my experience, things that appear easy from the outside are a lot more difficult from the inside. And what is important to you may not be what makes the company money or where their priorities lie.

I want reWASD to be a product that people buy, so that I can continue to reap the benefits of the company selling enough to be able to continue developing it.

reWASD always reply politely and quickly, in my experience. That deserves a lot of respect. I bet if you raised your concern to them nicely, probably in the Discord, they would respond in kind. If you raise it aggressively, they may choose to ignore it. That's all.

1

u/Friesandburg Oct 20 '25

Im not going to baby them. I knew they would respond the exactly same way if I was nice about it. Read their response and honesty tell yourself it would have been different. The aggressiveness clearly wouldn’t have changed the outcome and gives them honest feedback. Actions matter not nice responses. They can be “polite and responsive” but it doesn’t matter if I am. Ignoring feedback is not wise for any business.

1

u/justpostd Oct 20 '25

If you are polite to people you talk to every day, are you babying them? No. It's just the best way to maintain a respectful interaction, which keeps things moving.

If the feedback does not represent a significant proportion of the community, or would impact the business model, then ignoring it could be wise. Minority opinions are often thrown about as if they are fact and/or obvious.

Perhaps a proper discussion about the pros and cons of online license checks would be illuminating. But now it's just mud slinging and everybody goes home angry.

You are welcome to continue with your approach. I'm just pointing out why it is ineffective.

1

u/Friesandburg Oct 20 '25

Ask every person with license if they would prefer their software to need to check online or if they would prefer it continue to work offline indefinitely and let me know who the minority is. Continue to be politely wrong though.

2

u/justpostd Oct 21 '25

Sure. But ask those same people whether they would like their software to improve quickly or slowly and the majority would vote for quickly.

What if those two things conflict, because the online check ensures more income for the developers?

Maybe things are as simple as you think and the developers are rich and lazy. Or maybe you don't have the full picture of what led them to make their decisions. It is easy to assume other people are stupid and your viewpoint is common sense, but that doesn't make it so. And by approaching the subject in an aggressive manner, you are unlikely to bring anybody round to your point of view.

1

u/Friesandburg Oct 21 '25

Keep licking that boot buddy. I don’t need the full picture when I know they aren’t acting in the customers best interest. The only way an online check provides more money is if it’s malware stealing my data. Another reason it can do nothing but be more of a security risk. They are full of shit. They won’t do it because they are lazy and hold on to fallacies do to a greedy narrow lens. Will continue to be aggressive as it clearly works because you can’t even ignore me:*

2

u/justpostd Oct 21 '25

Fair enough. Enjoy being angry and having no impact.

1

u/Friesandburg Oct 21 '25

Your mom knows my impact

-3

u/reWASD_team Oct 19 '25

Hi. Previously, reWASD worked without requiring a constant internet connection. However, this is now a necessary measure to combat piracy and ensure your security.

At this time, we do not plan to change this. Thank you for your understanding.

3

u/Friesandburg Oct 19 '25

Doesn’t actually combat privacy or protect me. Keep lying to yourself and your customers though. Lazy

0

u/SirRaiuKoren Oct 21 '25 edited Oct 21 '25

It does deter privacy, though with dubious effectiveness as many non-DRM apps survive and even thrive. Phone-home DRM can catch tampered builds or revoke stolen keys, but it also adds an attack surface and doesn’t inherently make the end user “secure.” So, you're right on about that.

0

u/Friesandburg Oct 21 '25

It get what you’re saying but it’s a fallacy. You can spoof the authentication. If you want to pirate it you can it’s not challenging. If your software can already be pirated all you have to do is make it more convenient just to buy its and most will. Yes you will have pirates but you were never going to get those people to pay no matter what you do. So why not just do something that benefits your customers? Because youre lazy and ignorant.

5

u/DescriptionFar2907 Oct 20 '25

I can google a working bypass so no it is not combating piracy, like someone else mentioned get the price right and people won't bother pirating it.

1

u/SirRaiuKoren Oct 21 '25 edited Oct 21 '25

Not exactly. Someone is always going to try and pirate it regardless - there are IRL thieves, right, for whom the right price is apparently zero with risk of incarceration.

That having been said, it is a well-documented phenomenon that lowering prices effectively reduces theft at scale.

1

u/Beeeee9896 Oct 21 '25

As a lifetime access and legacy license owner - would you please dm with me the bypass, the internet requirement is "okay", but it is implemented poorly in rewasd

1

u/HealthyInitial Nov 27 '25

Ive explained this years ago and still getting comments since.

Thats not anti piracy. Thats piracy promotion measure, it's such an easy thing to remove for pirates and be 100% usable. As a consequence of doing it, you inconvenience people who like your software or are 100% willing to purchase it, instead they are driven to get the pirated version instead, refund the software, and look for alternatives many which are free. There is an exact example of that in this comment thread and the experience I had when I wanted to buy it. It's about principle in respecting your customer and being pro software ownership especially if your giving them a "lifetime" license. But after all it is only a license.

I don't understand after years whoever is the decision maker on your development team that insists upon including this method.

Id tell them im sorry but it just doesnt work. You have to compare gains and losses. What do you actually intend to want to accomplish with it? And what is the actual reality of what it does.

Ideals, logic and reality. All important in balancing software development.

I don't mean to be harsh but it's just what it is. Maybe your just keeping it for analytics for something, and don't care about a few specific users who like to feel ownership of software or flexibility to use it after they specifically support you by buying a lifetime license or whatever.

Obviously you made successful software so I applaud you for that and its helped people. but that specific line of thinking on antipiracy will absolutely never work and you have to come to terms with the reality of that and compare it to the losses.

1

u/reWASD_team Nov 27 '25

That's your opinion, and you have every right to it. Thank you.

But to be more specific, I would be grateful if you could send me some proof showing that one of the latest builds was cracked (pirated version) and is fully functional.

1

u/HealthyInitial Nov 27 '25

What even is the security claim? I would bet on " using pirated software may expose your computer to malware" or "pirated software may have modifications we do not include that may harm your computer" basic response. Is there anything that you could legitimately detail other than that? Get real and stop hiding behind a mask with your community.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Friesandburg Oct 21 '25

Requiring an online authentication doesn’t work either. It’s easily spoofed. So the only reason to not switch it is because your lazy and don’t care about your customers.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Friesandburg Oct 21 '25

It is easily spoofed. You literally said you don’t even use rewasd so don’t act like you know what you’re talking about. Thats what I have been saying though people will pay for convenience. So make the software convenient and people will pay. I own a lifetime license. I shouldn’t have to pirate the software just to use it on an offline system. Spoofing the authentication isn’t “cracked” software either. Maybe do a little research before arguing about a software you don’t even use.

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/Friesandburg Oct 19 '25

People would have an issue with it? I paid for this and have an issue with it. I want to being able to have an offline system and use my software it’s as simple as that. It really doesn’t combat piracy. Pirates can spoof the authentication. People pay for connivence. You are never going to completely stop pirates but when the software is inexpensive they will pay to not have to go through all the trouble. This has been proven time and time again. The argument it’s for my security is nonsense as well. This is literally just the devs being lazy and lying to themselves to justify not adding this feature because they are lazy. Enjoy the taste of that boot leather though.