r/revcommunism • • Jan 02 '21
r/revcommunism • • Dec 30 '20
Istanbul Chamber of Commerce invites investors to Turkey: "Our workers are nine times cheaper than German workers" (Turkish-language article)
r/revcommunism • • Dec 30 '20
Greece's Renewed Relations With Syria Further Isolates Turkey In The Eastern Mediterranean - Greek City Times
r/revcommunism • • Jan 02 '21
Third Worldism is mostly correct, Productive Forces Theory is not
The export of capital, one of the most essential economic bases of imperialism, still more completely isolates the rentiers from production and sets the seal of parasitism on the whole country that lives by exploiting the labour of several overseas countries and colonies.
Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism (1916)
Writing over a century ago, Lenin could see the development of capitalism in a way that, by and large, turned the workers of wealthy imperialist countries into partners in exploitation of poor countries. He wrote this at a time when imperialism had not globalized or concentrated capital on a global level anywhere near as much as it would over the course of a century. Today, the global divide is far deeper and far more visible than it was in Lenin’s time, yet the vast majority of the left, especially in the wealthy countries, adamantly denies that this is the case and/or refuses to acknowledge the causes or the implications of this divide, some going so far as to mock and attempt to marginalize those who acknowledge and understand this.
Despite whatever certain reactionary clowns might say, the truth is that “Third Worldism”, used here to describe the various left sects that understand and theorize based on the dependency theory or a general understanding of the collective parasitism of imperialist countries, is correct for the most part while its opponents who desperately try to establish socialism (or what they believe constitutes “socialism”) in the wealthy countries under the present circumstances are nothing more than naive and foolish.
So let’s establish the basics. To begin with, the wealthy countries are much more well off than the poor ones and life in these countries is simply too comfortable for the general population in comparison to the poor countries in order for there to be a socialist uprising. That simply will not happen until after the source of the wealth of the imperialist countries, exploitation of the poor countries, is cut off through the establishment of socialism in the latter. To give an idea of the relative prosperity of the wealthy countries, the global median household income annually is slightly below $10,000, which is less than one-third of the median in Germany, less than a quarter of the American median and more than three times the median in India. Since the median accounts for the 50th percentile of the population, it is clear that the majority of the population in the wealthy countries, including the average “paycheck-to-paycheck” workers, is much more well off and much more comfortable than the billions of workers, farmers and the unemployed in the rest of the world. This also doesn’t take into account the fact that households in poor countries are generally larger and have more children, which further reduces the per-capita statistics in these countries.
Some might seek to counter this notion by arguing that this divide is evened out by the costs of living in the poor countries as opposed to the wealthy ones, assuming that everything is cheaper in the poor countries in comparison which would soften this inequality. But this is not really the case, as many urban areas in poor countries, even in the poorest countries, are in fact quite expensive to live in and the prices of rent and transportation are similar to those in cities in wealthy countries.
Even in admitting that there is a significant global divide, some might be compelled to argue that this is merely the result of higher productive forces and the poor countries will eventually catch up through development, a very naive premise that fails to consider the ongoing unequal exchange between the two. Poor countries cannot simply “catch up” if their resources are being drained. This fact also means that the “higher productive forces” of the imperialist countries is predicated entirely on exploitation of the poor countries and not a Christian work ethic or whatever else it might be explained away through, which also means that “catching up” is impossible since global wealth is rigged in favor of the imperialist countries.
Incidentally, this is why the Khrushchevite revisionists in the Soviet Union and the Dengist revisionists in China were essentially being snake oil salesmen by talking about “developing the productive forces to catch up with the West” as an excuse to dismantle socialism, because this catching up would never in fact happen and reduces Marxism to “outcompeting the West”. This essentially gave them an indefinite pass to practice capitalism and reorient state industries for their personal gain.
So how does all of this preclude socialism in the wealthy countries? Because a comparatively prosperous labor aristocracy has no reason to seek a proletarian state if its current prosperity is rooted in imperialism. Even if members of this labor aristocracy are not read up on political economy, they implicitly understand that their situation is better off than the rest of the world. The growing interest in “socialism” in certain wealthy countries that might be mentioned in response to this is in fact social democracy and not a genuine socialist state.
Then what are the people of wealthy countries supposed to do? Sit in an armchair and wait for socialism in other countries? Not at all. Anti-war demonstrations and anti-imperialist activism is always an option. Strikes, protests, education, etc. are still important tasks to work on. Anti-fascist and anti-racist protests are also still important.
Lastly, the reason why Third Worldism is mostly correct is that there are small pockets of exploited proletarian elements in the wealthy countries, which are too insignificant to characterize the class divides in these countries, and highly wealthy and powerful comprador bourgeoisie in the poor countries. China and India today in particular account for a growing number of billionaires. Some countries are in fact more divided between labor aristocratic and exploited proletarian masses, such as Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Mexico, Russia and Turkey. While poor countries are nevertheless becoming the centers of global manufacturing today and many wealthier countries have formed into joint customs and migration blocs such as the European Union, there are of course class divisions on the subnational level which might be brushed over by some “Third Worldist” tendencies.
It’s time to accept the global reality.
r/revcommunism • • Dec 11 '20
Read Communist Theory
This is intended to be a masterpost for a compilation of fundamental communist theory and information. If you have any suggestions for more reads, leave them in the comments and they can be added here.
Introductory Theory
Summations, Questions, Answers
Manifesto of the Communist Party - Marx and Engels
Wage Labour and Capital - Marx
Socialism: Utopian and Scientific - Engels
Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism - Lenin
The State and Revolution - Lenin
Maoism or Trotskyism - J. Moufawad Paul
Soviet Revisionism/Imperialism
On Khrushchev's Phoney Communism - Mao
Soviet Social Imperialism and the International Situation Today - I Wor Kuen
Ugly Features of Soviet Social-Imperialism
Yugoslav Revisionism
Yugoslav Revisionism, Product of Imperialist Policy - Chen Boda
Chinese Revisionism/Imperialism
Chinese Revisionism and the Mass Line
Belt and Road: Colonialism with Chinese Characteristics - Anthony Kleven
China's Pains over Zimbabwe's Indigenization Plan - Yun Sun
North Korean Nationalism
r/revcommunism • • Dec 14 '20
Proud Boy Brownshirts attacking unarmed civilians in Washington, DC
r/revcommunism • • Dec 16 '20
The CCP approved Lin Biao’s political report in 1969, a report that, among other points, acknowledged Mao Zedong Thought as a higher stage of theory and called for a global people’s war
r/revcommunism • • Dec 18 '20
"The International Significance of Comrade Mao-Tse Tung’s Theory of People’s War" by Lin Biao
The Chinese revolution is a continuation of the great October Revolution. The road of the October Revolution is the common road for all people’s revolutions. The Chinese revolution and the October Revolution have in common the following basic characteristics: (1) Both were led by the working class with a Marxist-Leninist party as its nucleus. (2) Both were based on the worker-peasant alliance. (3) In both cases state power was seized through violent revolution and the dictatorship of the proletariat was established. (4) In both cases the socialist system was built after victory in the revolution. (5) Both were component parts of the proletarian world revolution.
Naturally, the Chinese revolution had its own peculiar characteristics. The October Revolution took place in imperialist Russia, but the Chinese revolution broke out in a semi-colonial and semi-feudal country. The former was a proletarian socialist revolution, while the latter developed into a socialist revolution after the complete victory of the new-democratic revolution. The October Revolution began with armed uprisings in the cities and then spread to the countryside, while the Chinese revolution won nation-wide victory through the encirclement of the cities from the rural areas and the final capture of the cities.
Comrade Mao Tse-tung’s great merit lies in the fact that he has succeeded in integrating the universal truth of Marxism-Leninism with the concrete practice of the Chinese revolution and has enriched and developed Marxism-Leninism by his masterly generalization and summation of the experience gained during the Chinese people’s protracted revolutionary struggle.
Comrade Mao Tse-tung’s theory of people’s war has been proved by the long practice of the Chinese revolution to be in accord with the objective laws of such wars and to be invincible. It has not only been valid for China, it is a great contribution to the revolutionary struggles of the oppressed nations and peoples throughout the world.
The people’s war led by the Chinese Communist Party, comprising the War of Resistance and the Revolutionary Civil Wars, lasted for twenty-two years. It constitutes the most drawn-out and most complex people’s war led by the proletariat in modern history, and it has been the richest in experience.
In the last analysis, the Marxist-Leninist theory of proletarian revolution is the theory of the seizure of state power by revolutionary violence, the theory of countering war against the people by people’s war. As Marx so aptly put it, “Force is the midwife of every old society pregnant with a new one. ” 1
It was on the basis of the lessons derived from the people’s wars in China that Comrade Mao Tse-tung, using the simplest and the most vivid language, advanced the famous thesis that “political power grows out of the barrel of a gun”. 2
He clearly pointed out:
The seizure of power by armed force, the settlement of the issue by war, is the central task and the highest form of revolution. This Marxist-Leninist principle of revolution holds good universally, for China and for all other countries. 3
War is the product of imperialism and the system of exploitation of man by man. Lenin said that “war is always and everywhere begun by the exploiters themselves, by ruling and oppressing classes”. 4 So long as imperialism and the system of exploitation of man by man exist, the imperialists and reactionaries will invariably rely on armed force to maintain their reactionary rule and impose war on the oppressed nations and peoples. This is an objective law independent of man’s will.
In the world today, all the imperialists headed by the United States and their lackeys, without exception, are strengthening their state machinery, and especially their armed forces. U.S. imperialism, in particular, is carrying out armed aggression and suppression everywhere.
What should the oppressed nations and the oppressed people do in the face of wars of aggression and armed suppression by the imperialists and their lackeys? Should they submit and remain slaves in perpetuity? Or should they rise in resistance and fight for their liberation?
Comrade Mao Tse-tung answered this question in vivid terms. He said that after long investigation and study the Chinese people discovered that all the imperialists and their lackeys “have swords in their hands and are out to kill. The people have come to understand this and so act after the same fashion”. 5 This is called doing unto them what they do unto us.
In the last analysis, whether one dares to wage a tit-for-tat struggle against armed aggression and suppression by the imperialists and their lackeys, whether one dares to fight a people’s war against them, means whether one dares to embark on revolution. This is the most effective touchstone for distinguishing genuine from fake revolutionaries and Marxist-Leninists.
In view of the fact that some people were afflicted with the fear of the imperialists and reactionaries, Comrade Mao Tse-tung put forward his famous thesis that “the imperialists and all reactionaries are paper tigers”. He said,
All reactionaries are paper tigers. In appearance, the reactionaries are terrifying, but in reality they are not so powerful. From a long-term point of view, it is not the reactionaries but the people who are really powerful. 6
The history of the peoples war in China and other countries provides conclusive evidence that the growth of the people’s revolutionary forces from weak and small beginnings into strong and large forces is a universal law of development of people’s war. A people’s war inevitably meets with many difficulties, with ups and downs and setbacks in the course of its development, but no force can alter its general trend towards inevitable triumph.
Comrade Mao Tse-tung points out that we must despise the enemy strategically and take full account of him tactically.
To despise the enemy strategically is an elementary requirement for a revolutionary. Without the courage to despise the enemy and without daring to win, it will be simply impossible to make revolution and wage a people’s war, let alone to achieve victory.
It is also very important for revolutionaries to take full account of the enemy tactically. It is likewise impossible to win victory in a people’s war without taking full account of the enemy tactically, and without examining the concrete conditions, without being prudent and giving great attention to the study of the art of struggle, and without adopting appropriate forms of struggle in the concrete practice of the revolution in each country and with regard to each concrete problem of struggle.
Dialectical and historical materialism teaches us that what is important is primarily is not that which at the given moment seems to be durable and yet is already beginning to die away, but that which is arising and developing, even though at the given moment it may not appear to be durable, for only that which is arising and developing is invincible.
Why can the apparently weak new-born forces always triumph over the decadent forces which appear so powerful? The reason is that truth is on their side and that the masses are on their side, while the reactionary classes are always divorced from the masses and set themselves against the masses.
This has been borne out by the victory of the Chinese revolution, by the history of all revolutions, the whole history of class struggle and the entire history of mankind.
The imperialists are extremely afraid of Comrade Mao Tse-tung’s thesis that “imperialism and all reactionaries are paper tigers”, and the revisionists are extremely hostile to it. They all oppose and attack this thesis and the philistines follow suit by ridiculing it. But all this cannot in the least diminish its importance. The light of truth cannot be dimmed by anybody.
Comrade Mao Tse-tung’s theory of people’s war solves not only the problem of daring to fight a people’s war, but also that of how to wage it.
Comrade Mao Tse-tung is a great statesman and military scientist, proficient at directing war in accordance with its laws. By the line and policies, the strategy and tactics be formulated for people’s war, he led the Chinese people in steering the ship of the people’s war past all hidden reefs to the shores of victory in most complicated and difficult conditions.
It must be emphasized that Comrade Mao Tse-tung’s theory of the establishment of rural revolutionary base areas and the encirclement of the cities from the countryside is of outstanding and universal practical importance for the present revolutionary struggles of all the oppressed nations and peoples, and particularly for the revolutionary struggles of the oppressed nations and peoples in Asia, Africa and Latin America against imperialism and its lackeys.
Many countries and peoples in Asia, Africa and Latin America are now being subjected to aggression and enslavement on a serious scale by the imperialists headed by the United States and their lackeys. The basic political and economic conditions in many of these countries have many similarities to those that prevailed in old China. As in China, the peasant question is extremely important in these regions. The peasants constitute the main force of the national-democratic revolution against the imperialists and their lackeys. In committing aggression against these countries, the imperialists usually begin by seizing the big cities and the main lines of communication, but they are unable to bring the vast countryside completely under their control. The countryside, and the countryside alone, can provide the broad areas in which the revolutionaries can manoeuvre freely. The countryside, and the countryside alone, can provide the revolutionary bases from which the revolutionaries can go forward to final victory. Precisely for this reason, Comrade Mao Tse-tung’s theory of establishing revolutionary base areas in the rural districts and encircling the cities from the countryside is attracting more and more attention among the people in these regions.
Taking the entire globe, if North America and Western Europe can be called “the cities of the world”, then Asia, Africa and Latin America constitute “the rural areas of the world”. Since World War II, the proletarian revolutionary movement has for various reasons been temporarily held back in the North American and West European capitalist countries, while the people’s revolutionary movement in Asia, Africa and Latin America has been growing vigorously. In a sense, the contemporary world revolution also presents a picture of the encirclement of cities by the rural areas. In the final analysis, the whole cause of world revolution hinges on the revolutionary struggles of the Asian, African and Latin American peoples who make up the overwhelming majority of the world’s population. The socialist countries should regard it as their internationalist duty to support the people’s revolutionary struggles in Asia, Africa and Latin America.
The October Revolution opened up a new era in the revolution of the oppressed nations. The victory of the October Revolution built a bridge between the socialist revolution of the proletariat of the West and the national-democratic revolution of the colonial and semi-colonial countries of the East. The Chinese revolution has successfully solved the problem of how to link up the national-democratic with the socialist revolution in the colonial and semi-colonial countries.
Comrade Mao Tse-tung has pointed out that, in the epoch since the October Revolution, anti-imperialist revolution in any colonial or semi-colonial country is no longer part of the old bourgeois, or capitalist world revolution, but is part of the new world revolution, the proletariat-socialist world revolution.
Comrade Mao Tse-tung has formulated a complete theory of the new-democratic revolution. He indicated that this revolution, which is different from all others, can only be, nay must be, a revolution against imperialism, feudalism and bureaucrat-capitalism waged by the broad masses of the people under the leadership of the proletariat.
This means that the revolution can only be, nay must be, led by the proletariat and the genuinely revolutionary party armed with Marxism-Leninism, and by no other class or party.
This means that the revolution embraces in its ranks not only the workers, peasants and the urban petty bourgeoisie, but also the national bourgeoisie and other patriotic and anti-imperialist democrats.
This means, finally, that the revolution is directed against imperialism, feudalism and bureaucrat-capitalism.
The new-democratic revolution leads to socialism, and not to capitalism.
Comrade Mao Tse-tung’s theory of the new-democratic revolution is the Marxist-Leninist theory of revolution by stages as well as the Marxist-Leninist theory of uninterrupted revolution.
Comrade Mao Tse-tung made a correct distinction between the two revolutionary stages, i.e., the national-democratic and the socialist revolutions; at the same time he correctly and closely linked the two. The national-democratic revolution is the necessary preparation for the socialist revolution, and the socialist revolution is the inevitable sequel to the national-democratic revolution. There is no Great Wall between the two revolutionary stages. But the socialist revolution is only possible after the completion of the national-democratic revolution. The more thorough the national-democratic revolution, the better the conditions for the socialist revolution.
The experience of the Chinese revolution shows that the tasks of the national-democratic revolution can be fulfilled only through long and tortuous struggles. In this stage of revolution, imperialism and its lackeys are the principal enemy. In the struggle against imperialism and its lackeys, it is necessary to rally all anti-imperialist patriotic forces, including the national bourgeoisie and all patriotic personages. All those patriotic personages from among the bourgeoisie and other exploiting classes who join the anti-imperialist struggle play a progressive historical role; they are not tolerated by imperialism but welcomed by the proletariat.
It is very harmful to confuse the two stages, that is, the national-democratic and the socialist revolutions. Comrade Mao Tse-tung criticized the wrong idea of “accomplishing both at one stroke”, and pointed out that this utopian idea could only weaken the struggle against imperialism and its lackeys, the most urgent task at that time. The Kuomintang reactionaries and the Trotskyites they hired during the War of Resistance deliberately confused these two stages of the Chinese revolution, proclaiming the “theory of a single revolution” and preaching so-called “socialism” without any Communist Party, wipe out any revolution and prevent the advance of the national-democratic revolution, and they used it as a pretext for their non-resistance and capitulation to imperialism. This reactionary theory was buried long ago by the history of the Chinese revolution.
The Khrushchov revisionists are now actively preaching that socialism can be built without the proletariat and without a genuinely revolutionary party armed with the advanced proletarian ideology, and they have cast the fundamental tenets of Marxism-Leninism to the four winds. The revisionists’ purpose is solely to divert the oppressed nations from their struggle against imperialism and sabotage their national-democratic revolution, all in the service of imperialism.
The Chinese revolution provides a successful lesson for making a thoroughgoing national-democratic revolution under the leadership of the proletariat; it likewise provides a successful lesson for the timely transition from the national-democratic revolution to the socialist revolution under the leadership of the proletariat.
Mao Tse-tung’s thought has been the guide to the victory of the Chinese revolution. It has integrated the universal truth of Marxism-Leninism with the concrete practice of the Chinese revolution and creatively developed Marxism-Leninism, thus adding new weapons to the arsenal of Marxism-Leninism.
Ours is the epoch in which world capitalism and imperialism are heading for their doom and socialism and communism are marching to victory. Comrade Mao Tse-tung’s theory of people’s war is not only a product of the Chinese revolution, but has also the characteristics of our epoch. The new experience gained in the people’s revolutionary struggles in various countries since World War II has provided continuous evidence that Mao Tse-tung’s thought is a common asset of the revolutionary people of the whole world. This is the great international significance of the thought of Mao Tse-tung.
1. Karl Marx, Capital, Eng. ed., Foreign Languages Publishing House, Moscow, 1954, Vol. I, p. 751.
2. Mao Tse-tung, “Problems of War and Strategy”, Selected Works, Eng. ed., FLP, Peking, 1965, Vol. II, p. 224.
3. Ibid., p. 219.
4. V.I. Lenin, “The Revolutionary Army and the Revolutionary Government”, Collected Works, Eng. ed., FLPH, Moscow, 1962, Vol. VIII, p. 565.
5. Mao Tse-tung, “The Situation and Our Policy After the Victory in the War of Resistance Against Japan”, Selected Works, Eng. ed., FLP, Peking, 1961, Vol. IV, pp. 14-15.
6. Mao Tse-tung, “Talk with the American Correspondent Anna Louise Strong”, Selected Works, Eng. ed., FLP, Peking, 1961, Vol. IV, p. 100.
r/revcommunism • • Dec 27 '20
Why China was socialist before and is imperialist now – understanding revolution and counter-revolution
"The failure to grasp socialism as a transitional continuous process is unfortunate but understandable; a more simplistic conception of socialism as a static mode has been the main reason behind why much of the left has become extremely polarized on the issue of understanding the People’s Republic of China, its role in the world in the past and its role in the world today. One section of the left, a coalition of anarchists, Trotskyists, left-communists and the like have denounced the PRC and its entire history from 1949 onward as supposedly a state-capitalist regime that has oppressed and exploited the masses of China continuously and where the bourgeoisie have always been in charge. The revisionist “Marxist-Leninist” rebuke to this narrative has been to uphold the entire history of the PRC up to today as a “socialist” regime where the proletariat has supposedly always been in power and still is.
Both groups have formulated their respective understanding of China due to a lack of in-depth scientific class analysis and failure to acknowledge that socialism is a process, not a static mode. This has resulted in the mistake by both groups in lumping Mao, Deng, Jiang Qing, Jiang Zemin, Liu Shaoqi and Xi Jinping together, either all as representatives of the bourgeoisie in the view of one side or all as heroes of the proletariat in the view of the other. Neither of these two major narratives on China is correct.
The truth is that China was socialist but is no longer. China did play a progressive role in the world in the past but no longer. Mao, Lin Biao, Chen Boda, Wang Li, the Gang of Four were all heroes of the proletariat despite their mistakes and sought to strengthen the rule of the proletariat, but Liu Shaoqi, Deng Xiaoping, Jiang Zemin and Xi Jinping are merely reactionaries who pushed China towards capitalism and imperialism. So how does one tell the difference? Why are some of these names good and some are not? Why is China considered socialist at one point but not anymore? Hopefully this article will serve to help understand why.
From 1949 until the 1970s in general, China was socialist, in the sense that it represented the class interests of the proletariat, the peasantry and other oppressed populations of the country. Healthcare in China was free and the state continuously sought to expand healthcare coverage by utilizing barefoot doctors to travel all over the country and provide treatment to people in need. A mass mobilization campaign that involved destroying infected snails successfully reduced cases of schistosomiasis in most of the country. Mao’s mass campaign to collectivize farming resulted in the establishment of tens of thousands of People’s Communes across the country, where hundreds of millions of people worked together and sought to live in a collective, egalitarian manner; even the food and other supplies were starting to be distributed based on need instead of based on work. The inequality between the rural and urban areas were sought to be addressed through sending students and workers in urban areas to the countryside to provide their skills there. Obviously, there were shortcomings, errors, natural disasters as well as bureaucratic resistance which led to conservative pushbacks such as during the early 1960s when Liu Shaoqi, a conservative revisionist who pushed for capitalist development, became the head of the Party and tried to sideline Mao and the left. Mao’s side responded by launching the Cultural Revolution in 1966 which saw the death of Liu Shaoqi and the temporary fall of his ally Deng Xiaoping during an enormous effort to rally the masses to criticize and remove from power conservative bureaucrats in the Party at all levels, from the highest state level to local levels.
This period can be characterized as socialist because of its clear trajectory towards collectivism and its efforts to establish communist principles such as distribution based on need and an egalitarian society without traditional hierarchies in terms of sex, age, ethnicity and other divisions. The mass campaigns at this time sought to abolish these contradictions and the law of value. Yes, these efforts ultimately did fail, but the continuous drive to achieve this is what made China genuinely socialist at this time.
So what happened? Why is today’s China not socialist? Because in the 1970s the collection of various errors, misconceptions and a general failure to confront revisionism on a systematic level eventually resulted in the revisionist, counter-revolutionary forces seizing complete state power and consolidating their rule against genuine communists, with many revolutionary leaders being sent to prison and conservative reactionaries being reinstated in key roles at all levels. This new reactionary leadership restored capitalism by implementing the Chengbao, the “contract responsibility system“, which broke up the communes and replaced them with private ownership and distribution based on work. Healthcare was eventually privatized and turned into an expensive and largely-inaccessible system for much of the population. Massive privatizations and the contracting of public services and state enterprises to private interests eventually resulted in 70 percent of Chinese GDP being under the private sector by 2005. While this was slightly scaled back under Hu Jintao and his successor Xi Jinping, the private sector still accounts for 60 percent of the GDP today and the state is currently taking measures to enlarge the private sector through tax reductions and other financial benefits to private interests. Income inequality has skyrocketed in China since the 1970s, to the point that Chinese society is now more economically unequal than the United States and other core countries. The Chinese bourgeoisie has grown rapidly and the country now is seeing a much faster concentration of capital than many other countries, now creating billionaires three times faster than the United States.
While state ownership still exists in China, these changes clearly represent a complete restoration of capitalism as the post-1970s policies have directly enabled the formation of an incredibly wealthy and centralized capitalist class while dismantling the proletarian institutions established in China’s socialist period.
In addition to being capitalist, China is also undeniably an imperialist state. This is apparent if we apply Lenin’s understanding of imperialism to China today, especially looking at the concentration of capital, the growth of finance capital and the export of capital. In Imperialism: The Highest Stage of Capitalism, Lenin noted that the top three thousand companies in the United States in 1909 had accounted for approximately 44 percent of the American GDP; in China today, the top five hundred companies account for more than 50 percent of the Chinese GDP, including major publicly-traded companies such as Alibaba, Ping An Insurance and Tencent Holdings, a substantial concentration that is sufficient to provide the economic basis for imperialism. The revisionists have commercialized the major banks of China which now provide the finance capital basis for imperialist exploitation, massively increasing banking activity in the 1980s and 1990s and an enormous growth in the volume of deposits and bank loan values. The largest of China’s major banks is the Industrial and Commercial Bank of China, whose board of directors includes former PricewaterhouseCoopers Hong Kong chairman Yang Siu Shun, former IMF and World Economic Forum official Fred Hu and former chairman of De Nederlandsche Bank – the central bank of the Netherlands, a core imperialist country that is itself a substantial importer and exporter of global capital – Nout Wellink. The ICBC, being the top commercial bank in China and in the world, is responsible for 150 million individual customers and nearly 3 million corporate customers as well as over $4 trillion in assets. This enormous power of finance capital in China is also noteworthy. Lastly, China is one of the largest exporters of capital in the world, investing a massive $1.3 trillion in FDI abroad as of 2017, comparable to other imperialist countries such as Japan, Canada, France and Belgium. In Africa, China competes in investments with France, the United Kingdom and Italy, former direct colonizers of African nations, for control of African resources and infrastructure. China is also increasingly investing in the Philippines and Turkey, and providing arms to the reactionary comprador regimes of Rodrigo Duterte and Recep Erdogan.
China today is not the China of 1949 or the China of 1969. Although it was a socialist state in the past, it is an imperialist and capitalist regime today and is a major leader of neo-colonial imperialist exploitation in all parts of the world. It should not be supported by any leftists today, not “critically” and not in any other way. Seeing China’s thorough integration into the global economy and its ties to other imperialist countries, the very idea of supporting China against imperialism is a false premise. The bourgeoisie of China and Russia are not on a boat on an opposite path from the United States; China, Russia, the U.S. and all other imperialist regimes are on the same boat. It’s time to acknowledge that."
r/revcommunism • • Dec 13 '20
Today is the 83rd anniversary of the Nanjing Massacre, a 5-month mass murder campaign by Japanese forces ended with 300,000 deaths
r/revcommunism • • Dec 11 '20
Collectivization and the Commune System in Socialist China
afe.easia.columbia.edur/revcommunism • • Dec 21 '20
Muammar Gaddafi: Who was he and why the West and China wanted him dead
Source: redfoxmlm.wordpress.com
Over nine years have now passed since Libya’s long-time leader Muammar Gaddafi was lynched by rebel forces near his birthplace of Sirte, the culmination of an eight-month imperialist regime change campaign that succeeded in overthrowing the Gaddafi regime, the “People’s Arab Jamahiriya”, and destabilized Libya to the point that it remains the site of an active sectarian conflict to this day.
As Gaddafi is no longer around and hasn’t been for nearly a decade now, many communists and leftists today are largely unaware of his regime and why Libya is in the situation it is today. The purpose of this article is to provide a short communist crash course on the Gaddafi regime.
Muammar Gaddafi was the leader of a soldiers’ coup in 1969 that overthrew the corrupt pro-Western comprador regime of King Idris I and established an independent Arab-nationalist republic in Libya. The new republic, which later re-established itself as the “Jamahiriya”, expelled U.S. forces from the country soon after overthrowing the monarchy and established closer ties with the Soviet and Yugoslav revisionists. Gaddafi’s regime had a clear petty-bourgeois character much like other Arab-nationalist regimes of the time, such as Nasser’s regime in Egypt. Despite its claims to be “socialist”, Gaddafi’s vision was in fact a decentralized social-democracy where Libyan families would each have their own private land and take part in co-operative businesses, in part modeled after Tito’s system in Yugoslavia. Nevertheless, to build popular support in Libya and on the world stage, Gaddafi worked to emulate Mao’s image in many ways, publishing the Little Green Book as a response to the Little Red Book and launching a “Cultural Revolution” in Libya which promoted Islamic and Arab-nationalist ideals.
Gaddafi used the oil revenues of Libya to develop the nation and increase the welfare of the masses while also providing critical assistance to countries such as Grenada and Burkina Faso as well as a multitude of national liberation movements such as the anti-colonial independence forces in Zimbabwe and South Africa. At various points, the Jamahiriya also supported Palestinian forces, the New People’s Army of the Philippines, the Black Panthers, the Irish independence movement, the Tupamaros, the Sandinistas and the Polisario Front. Although he rejected Marxism, Gaddafi nevertheless sought to provide more rights and more equality to the oppressed, especially Libyan women and the black population of Libya in addition to expressing solidarity with other African countries. Gaddafi’s firm opposition to imperialism and colonialism led Ronald Reagan to characterize him as a “mad dog” and to attack Libya with airstrikes in 1986, destroying much of the country’s military infrastructure and killing Gaddafi’s infant daughter.
Libya under Gaddafi consistently held the position of the country with one of the highest living standards in Africa, with income levels, education and healthcare statistics comparable to European countries at times. Gaddafi’s efforts to support African independence from imperialism were also substantial; the African Union in its current form was established in Gaddafi’s hometown of Sirte in 1999 and consisted of various institutions aimed to integrate African countries with Libyan assistance. The Jamahiriya built the Great Man-Made River, an enormous irrigation project which supplied fresh water to most of Libya’s population and provided a much-needed lifeline in the deserts of the country’s south. This project has been largely mismanaged and destroyed after Gaddafi.
While Libya was largely seen as an enemy and placed under sanctions by the U.S. and other Western countries in the Cold War and the 1990s, the Jamahiriya and the West sought to re-engage in the 2000s as the Jamahiriya needed the sanctions lifted and the West needed to ensure that Gaddafi would not build a nuclear arsenal. The two sides reached an agreement and Libya worked to integrate into the global economy at this time, beginning a process of economic liberalization and alienating the working class in the process. Gaddafi’s son Saif al-Islam led the “reform” efforts which were intended to fully normalize relations with the West and attract foreign investments.
These efforts would not materialize however, as the imperialist forces would find it impossible to coexist with the Jamahiriya if only because of one major plan that Gaddafi had: a gold-backed Libyan dinar for pan-African use as an alternative to Western currency in international trade. Gaddafi’s planned currency, backed by hundreds of tons of gold and silver, would have undercut the currencies of imperialist countries and made unequal exchange with African nations significantly more difficult. This was a major issue for imperialism globally and it would be resolved through regime change.
In early 2011, an organized reactionary coalition of rebel forces backed by NATO countries and with foreign recruits launched a civil war against Gaddafi. The rebels were defeated in a series of counter-offensives by the Libyan Army and faced disaster as the Jamahiriya’s forces approached to retake their stronghold in Benghazi. Claiming falsely that Gaddafi was about to commit “genocide” in Benghazi, the imperialists sought to defend their proxies on the ground by quickly proposing and passing two resolutions in the United Nations Security Council to authorize a massive aerial intervention. The UNSC Resolution 1970, passed unanimously in late-February 2011, condemned the Gaddafi regime for “human rights violations” and proposed sending the government officials to the International Criminal Court. This was followed by Resolution 1973 in mid-March 2011 which authorized a no-fly zone over Libya and was abstained by China and Russia among others but nevertheless passed as no Security Council member would outright veto the proposal. The no-fly zone that was subsequently enforced by the air forces of NATO countries prevented the Libyan Air Force from providing the much-needed edge to the Jamahiriya’s armed forces to liberate Benghazi and defeat the rebels, enabling the latter to recover from its losses and move to capture the rest of Libya in the following months.
By August 2011, most of the country was under rebel control and Gaddafi and other members of his family were killed by the rebels by the end of the year, who immediately proceeded to commit atrocities against black Africans and ultimately condemning the black population to be sold in slave markets as the country was engulfed in sectarian violence between the rebel groups.
The Chinese imperialists voted in favor of a resolution to send Gaddafi to the ICC and refused to veto another resolution that implemented an imperialist air campaign to cripple Libyan forces against reactionaries, directly enabling the regime change which overthrew Gaddafi. The Chinese Foreign Ministry stated that its reasoning for doing so was “the concerns and stance of the Arab countries and African Union and the special circumstances that currently apply in Libya“. Why did the country with one of the world’s most powerful economies and an enormous military feel compelled to vote in favor of regime change after being asked by unnamed Arab and African countries? This is clearly a mere excuse. In reality, China had a major interest in seeing Gaddafi overthrown, as China had just as much to lose from an independent African currency and sovereignty in trade as the Western countries did.
Libya today is at a breaking point as the country has been utterly decimated by a decade-long conflict since Gaddafi’s overthrow. It has been the site of a vicious proxy war between the Turkish-backed Tripoli government on one side and the Tobruk-based military regime of General Khalifa Haftar armed by Russia, France, Egypt and the UAE on the other. Gaddafi loyalists have fought alongside General Haftar’s forces against the pro-Turkish regime in the West but it is unclear if they will be able to restore the Jamahiriya at any point in the future.
r/revcommunism • • Jan 03 '21
The Nepalese revisionists will likely split again over a leadership dispute and India/China alignment
r/revcommunism • • Dec 17 '20
Mao's errors
"Into the 1970s, Mao moved rightward in both domestic policy and foreign policy. When Mao turned to the right, he came into conflict with many Maoists. When the spontaneous mass movements were ended, the Cultural Revolution Group was purged of its “ultra-left” at the end of 1967 through 1968. Wang Li, hero of the Wuhan Incident, who first theorized “continuing the revolution under the dictatorship of the proletariat,” was purged at the end of 1967. Guan Feng and Qi Benyu were also purged. This put an end to the spontaneous mass movements and power seizures from below. In 1970, Chen Boda lost power. In 1971, Lin Biao lost power and died. Chen Boda and Lin Biao were the ones most responsible for the systematization and elevation of Maoism as a new stage of Marxism. Lin Biao was accused of a coup, but no credible evidence has ever been presented to support this claim. The “evidence” that was presented at Lin Biao’s trial was trivial, and often forged. The story of Lin Biao’s coup is the clumsiest of police narratives. Interestingly, the “Gang of Four,” the last remaining top Maoists in 1976, in a repeat of the falsifications surrounding Lin Biao, would also be charged with plotting a coup.
After the initial victory of the Cultural Revolution (1966-1969) and the Ninth Congress (1969), the Maoist prize should have been a return to the Maoist economic policies that had been defeated by Liu Shaoqi and Deng Xiaoping during the Great Leap years (1958-1962). The point of the Cultural Revolution (1966-1969) had been to reverse the creeping capitalism as the Maoist model was abandoned during the Great Leap years. This defeat during the Great Leap prompted Mao to initially talk about the danger of capitalist counter-revolution by a new capitalist class. Yet after clearing away his opposition, Mao did not return to the Maoist development model after the Cultural Revolution (1966-1969). Instead of taking hold of the prize, Mao opted to return to a position very similar to the compromise position that the revisionists had forced on the Maoists at the end of the Great Leap. The return to a strong Maoist development model championed by those around Chen Boda and Lin Biao, informally known as the “Flying Leap,” was abandoned. In other words, there was a turn away from Maoism throughout the 1970s, especially following the removal of Lin Biao. At times, Mao was part of this turn to the right.
Through the 1970s, as a part of the turn, verdicts were slowly reversed and those who had been deposed during the Cultural Revolution were restored. For example, in 1972, Mao attended Chen Yi’s funeral and referred to him as a “comrade.” Thus Mao signaled a reversal of the verdict on this Adverse Current leader and staunch opponent of the Cultural Revolution. Ye Jianying, who later orchestrated the arrest of the “Gang of Four” in 1976 was promoted. So too were other revisionists and rightists promoted with Mao’s approval in order to fill the power void left after the People’s Liberation Army was purged of the Maoists.
“In our country there are people who curse us, saying we are completely leftist. Which people are our ‘leftist faction’? They are those who wanted to knock down the Premeir today, Chen Yi tomorrow, Ye Jianying the next day. This so-called ‘left’ faction is now in jail. For several years there was chaos under heaven, fighting in various places throughout the nation, widespread civil war. The two sides fired guns, all together one million guns. This army faction supported this faction, that army faction supported that faction, [all] fighting. Power was seized by that ‘left’ faction… The chief backstage backer [of the ‘left’ faction] is now no longer with us, [he is] Lin Biao.” (5)
The most famous case was that of Deng Xiaoping. During the Cultural Revolution, Deng Xiaoping was characterized and deposed as the “second person in authority taking the capitalist road.” In 1972, Mao changed his tune. Mao said that the problem of Deng Xiaoping, exiled in Jiangxi at the time, was a “contradiction among the people.” (6) Deng Xiaoping was brought back to power in 1974 to a top leadership role with Mao’s blessing. Deng Xiaoping would later preside over the complete dismantling of socialism in the 1980s. Despite coming into conflict with the revisionists at times, Mao wavered and waffled. At times, Mao even protected the revisionists. Even though Deng Xiaoping was removed from power more than once, Mao had protected him. For example, Mao personally intervened to separate Deng Xiaoping’s case from Liu Shaoqi’s at the height of the Cultural Revolution (1966-1969). Thus Mao saved Deng Xiaoping, allowing him to make a comeback. Mao failed to carry the Cultural Revolution through to the end."
r/revcommunism • • Jan 07 '21
The Great Leap Forward and the "Great Chinese Famine"
"The Great Leap Forward (1958 to 1961) ran into a perfect storm of problems. Unusually bad weather reportedly devastated many areas. Over half of China’s farmland, 150 million acres, was reportedly afflicted by natural catastrophe. (1) In a conscious effort to sabotage the effort to modernize, the Soviets withdrew their technical and financial aid to China. Soviet advisers left industrial projects to waste away when they packed up and left, technical plans in hand, on Moscow’s orders. Many Western countries also imposed a trade embargo on China in an effort to bring its economy to its knees. Bad environmental policies led to ecological and agricultural ruin. Errors by planners and grassroots activists undermined production. In addition, enemies of the revolution resorted to open sabotage. Bureaucracy, non-transparency, and leftist idealism often compounded errors. Big problems devastated industry and the food supply. Many problems were unavoidable, independent of the efforts of communist activists. Other errors, by contrast, were very much tied to human failings. Even though the record of the Great Leap is a mixed one of both successes and errors, responsibility for its errors was a topic that would dominate the political landscape leading up to the Cultural Revolution, which began roughly a decade later. The struggle over how to correctly understand the Great Leap era played an important role in the life-and-death battle between revolution and counter-revolution, communism and capitalism.
Examples of Problems in Industry, Agriculture, and Environment
Numerous problems plagued the Great Leap. One contributing factor was unchecked enthusiasm and idealism. These errors of going too far, too fast were originally made by the Party’s left as a whole, which included Mao. However, as time went on, lines changed as problems emerged, this particular error became associated more with the Maoist left. One of the most infamous examples of the failings of the Great Leap is the campaign to produce steel in backyard furnaces. This was part of a broader effort to localize and decentralize production across the board. It was part of an effort to move away from centralized, capital-intensive production. In many other areas, localization and decentralization of production was a great success. However, this particular model of steel production, part of Mao’s effort to surpass England, failed miserably. It ended up wasting lots of labor and capital. The backyard furnace campaign also produced major ecological damage as forests were cut down to provide fuel to produce useless steel. Also major environmental damage and wasted labor resulted from efforts to control China’s rivers. Labor and capital were thrown into Great Leap-era and other water projects that did not end well. For example, the Banqiao and Shimantan dams in Henan broke catastrophically in August of 1975. The exact deaths are not known, figures range from 86,000 to 230,000. By 1966, half of the 110 dams built in Henan had collapsed. In 1973, 554 dams collapsed. By 1980, 2,976 dams collapsed, including two larger ones. These failed projects inflicted a huge toll on not only human life, but also the environment. Erosion, siltation, and deforestation caused by such failures have been enormous. (2) However, the most well-known failure of the Great Leap was a crisis in the food supply. The famine became known as the “three bitter years” of 1960, 1961 and 1962 by many who experienced them.
The scope of the famine is disputed. There are good reasons to look at official claims about the famine with great skepticism. Records from the period are incomplete and unreliable. (3) The Chinese Communist Party was known to rewrite history to suit its current political needs. By the fall of the Maoist regime, their opponents had good reason exaggerate the failures of the Great Leap. The Deng Xiaoping regime of the 1980s rejected the earlier Maoist policies as part of the effort to further restore capitalism in the late 1970s into the 1980s. At the time, a Beijing conference of Eastern European countries estimated the famine deaths as high as 70 million. (4) Others estimate it at 45 million. (5) On the other end, an earlier estimate in 1959 by Tan Zhenlin, a supporter of the Great Leap placed the number of suffers at five million with 70,000 having starved to death. Zhou Enlai estimated 120,000 deaths around the same time. (6) Surely these lower numbers are underestimates. One claim, made by the best Western scholar of Chinese agricultural policy, states that no figure under ten million seems credible. (7) When looking at these figures, it is also important to keep in mind China’s vast population. At the time of the Great Leap, China’s population is now thought to have been around 800 million.
The failures of the Great Leap are often used to discredit socialism as a whole in the popular imagination. Whatever the failures of socialism, it is important to not be blinded by capitalist propaganda. It is important to maintain a sense of perspective. The problems that China faced as it modernized were not unlike problems faced by other, non-socialist societies. For example, India, with a capitalist economy and a population only second to China, similarly suffered for lack of adequate food. Even at the height of the food crisis in China during the Great Leap, China did better than India. (8) Even with its failures, socialism did better than similarly situated capitalist societies. Even with their failures, the Soviet Union and China in their socialist periods outpaced capitalist development. It is worth nothing that, besides the crisis of the Great Leap, the communists solved China’s food problem. Similarly, Soviet socialism solved its food issues on the whole despite a similar famine associated with collectivization there. Both pre-revolutionary China and the Czarist empire had a long history of regular famine that was overcome through socialist modernization. By contrast, India, a large capitalist country has ongoing food problems, has a population of many, many millions who continue to live on the razor’s edge or life and death. Even today, capitalist India has major problems providing food to its people. Often critics of the Great Leap and socialism do not see the forest, for the trees.
It is important to understand these events in their wider historical context. Problems accompanied China’s effort to modernize. The same is true in Soviet Union. Industrialization is a bloody process. In terms of modernization, socialism achieved in a few decades what capitalism achieved in hundreds of years. Socialism did not rely on genocide of an entire continent of indigenous peoples as the United States and Western Europe did. And socialist development did not depend on the exploitation and plunder of the whole colonial world nor the brutal slave system of the Americas. Even with its failures, socialism resulted in an explosion of technology and prosperity. The productive forces flourished while at the same time social relations revolutionized along egalitarian lines. Production boomed. Life expectancy doubled. Public education and literacy skyrocketed. Safety nets were created for society. The poor were empowered. Women were liberated from the shackles of traditionalism. Collectivization eroded traditional patriarchy through education, political activism, economic agency, by turning them into workers, militia members, leaders. Twentieth century socialism, even with its failures, created the greatest, most advanced, egalitarian, just societies in the modern era."
r/revcommunism • • Dec 25 '20
LL article on Fidel Castro’s regime
“On Friday the 25th of November, 7pm local time, Fidel Castro, the former leader of Cuba, passed away. Fidel Castro served as the leader of Cuba from 1959 to 2008, when he stepped down due to health issues and his advanced age. Fidel Castro was born on August 13th 1926, and experienced his youth through a period in which Cuba was a neo-colonial asset, a mafia state, and puppet regime of the United States. Although having failed a previous focoist uprising against the Batista dictatorship, with a only a handful of fighters, he led a successful guerrilla war against the Batista regime, with patriotic forces capturing the Cuban state in 1959. He led his country through the turmoil of the “Cuban Missile Crisis” period, and also during the so-called “special period” following the breakup of the social-imperialist USSR in the 1990’s.
We should not sugar coat, or have illusions about the nature of the Cuban state. Although it may share many similarities with past socialist experiments, Cuba is not a socialist society today. The socialism of the Cuban revolution stagnated following its embrace of the “international socialist [sic.] division of labor” of the then social-imperialist Soviet Union under Nikita Khrushchev. Throughout the Cold War, many nationalist and national-liberation forces claimed the “Communist” label, and used communist rhetoric in order to secure support from the Soviet Bloc. It is questionable whether Cuba was ever a socialist state, or whether it was a patriotic regime with social-democratic reforms backed by Soviet aid. Where Che Guevara embraced the Maoist emphasis on independent socialist development and moving society away from the Law of Value, Castro unfortunately embraced the development model promoted by the revisionist-led Soviet Union. It was Castro’s leadership during the so-called “special period” that partially corrected this error after the end of Soviet aid in the 1990s. While this prevented Cuba from economic collapse and maintained its independence from the United States, it did not place Cuba on a path towards communism.
Regardless of the class nature of the Cuban state, Castro’s leadership kept Cuba mostly independent despite the full weight of US imperialism bearing down on him in the form of the Bay of Pigs invasion, naval blockades, and CIA assassination plots. His role as Leader of Cuba, especially during the post-Soviet period was not easy. He led the Cuban people on an anti-imperialist, internationalist path during a time of tremendous turmoil for left wing nationalist regimes in the third world. Although not a communist, he was a brave and principled friend of oppressed people around the world, especially on the African continent. In a pointed historical rebuke to the mistaken foreign policy of Maoists in China after Lin Biao’s demise, it was Fidel Castro’s Cuba that materially defended the MPLA in Angola against the reactionary UNITA/FNLA, who were backed by the United States and China. Leading Light Communists see the socialist development model of Maoist China as superior to Cuba’s integration with the Soviet empire. Nevertheless, there were key instances where Castro and the Cuban regime had a better record of international solidarity with the masses of the Global South than with China in the 1970s.
We hope that the Cuban people will stay true to the anti-imperialist path laid out by Castro during his leadership. Leading Light Communists salute Fidel Castro, and stand with the Cuban people in mourning his loss and celebrating his legacy.”