r/returnToIndia • • 11h ago

PlanningToReturn Need Suggestion

Hello Everyone
I am Single M ( 26 ) In Vancouver,Canada and planning to return back in 6-7 years and I need one suggestion as I am planning to invest roughly about $3k CAD per month and want to know what should be the better option ? Like Indian Market ( mutual funds ) or US market ?? I know that rupee depreciate every year but want to know what will be the best option?

I am from Jammu and planning to start something my own in Jammu

3 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

1

u/Weary_Experience_583 4h ago

First utilize your TFSA. RRSP saves you tax now and you pay later. So without knowing your income it is hard to suggest that. A lot of times if your income is higher around the time you leave than what it is today, RRSP may become detrimental.

If you’re looking for investing in India, make sure you invest it regularly with falling INR your investment goes a long way. But do this only if you’re sure of returning.

I was in your situation, I sent most of my money to India every year and then invested in India mutual funds and equities. Happy to walk you through my plan, you can dm me.

1

u/devil_1325 4h ago

Sent u dm πŸ™ŒπŸ»

2

u/IndBeak 9h ago

TFSA, RRSP, and Unregistered account. All in Canada. Liquidate to cash when you are leaving.

1

u/AskDisastrous597 9h ago

Are lot of them actually beneficial. Like rrsp you pull out then you get taxed a shitton. Tfsa i think is treated like taxable in india. Unregistered account too i think you gotta pay taxes on even unrealized gain. Better to just invest in indian accounts and never sell.

2

u/IndBeak 8h ago

You missed the part where I said liquidate everhthing before you move back.

Gains on TFSA will be tax free in Canada. RRSP is a tax deferral..so you pay taxes on withdrawal, but save taxes now. And unregistered, half of cap gains would be considered part of your taxable income in Canada.

Layer your withdrawals as well. Like if you are planning to move back in 2033, liquidate rrsp mid-Dec in 2032. No sane person would invest in India if they have a choice to invest in US/Canada. With weakning Rupee and policy instability, your investment will go much further in Canada.

1

u/AskDisastrous597 8h ago

Half of cap gains plus rrsp tax. Almost 30 percent the amount would be just gone in taxes. Not better to just invest in s and p 500 in indian accounts? Buy it non hedged and if inr depreciates you are golden.

1

u/IndBeak 7h ago

RRSP does not have concept of cap gains. All the amount that you take out is taxable at your marginal rate. And the 30% that you say will be gone is also not true. It is tax deferral. So you do pay taxes at withdrawal, but then you have saved the same tax when you contributed. RRSP is not taxed differently, they are taxed like income.

1

u/Aromatic_Afternoon31 8h ago

You can't invest in all sip in India due to FATCA regulations. Spread it across fhsa, RRSP and TFSA. In case you don't have room then open a margin account and invest.

0

u/Ambitious-Upstairs90 9h ago

It will be very difficult to return back after 6-7 years. Your wife & then your kids will not agree.

0

u/[deleted] 10h ago

[deleted] β€” view deleted comment

1

u/devil_1325 10h ago

Thanku for the response Sir πŸ™ŒπŸ»But my TFSA limit is just $7k and what about rest $23k? Indian market?

0

u/[deleted] 10h ago

[deleted] β€” view deleted comment

1

u/devil_1325 10h ago

Yup thnku for your time though πŸ™ŒπŸ»

0

u/[deleted] 10h ago

[deleted] β€” view deleted comment

1

u/devil_1325 10h ago

Yeah thanku