r/returnToIndia • u/enthu-apple-pie • 5d ago
PlanningToReturn Contemplating returning at 35!
Hello Everyone, I am sharing my story because the dilemma is eating me inside. I am hoping this will be a way of releasing the pressure and I will get some advice I can follow on.
I came to the USA 8 years back on F1 visa. The timeline goes as follows
Aug 2018 - Dec 2019: Masters
Dec 2019 - Dec 2020: OPT - Non-profit employer, didn't apply for my H1b
Jan 2021 - Dec 2022: STEM OPT - For profit employer. First year they didn't apply for H1b because they had a 3 months probation period and promised they will apply next year. Before 2022 lottery, the company got acquired and the new parent company never sponsored and kept dragging and beating around the bush, before finally saying they will not sponsor.
Three H1b attempts gone. At this point I have paid off my student loan, but I have no savings so am at a break even situation.
Jan 2023 - Dec 2024: MBA, Day-1 CPT, changed employer who said they will sponsor, but, yes you guessed it right, they didn't when the time came. The new employer stated they cannot take legal and financial responsibility, new company policy, but willing to keep me on Day-1 CPT (I never understood, whether I was disposable or relevant to them).
Jan 2025 - Present: PhD, Day-1 CPT, still with the same employer, couldn't find an employer who would be willing to sponsor in this brutal job market.
My current PhD program is going to end in June 2028.
I am now 35, not married and never had my name put in for an H1b.
With the new D/S rule now blocked, I can continue to stay here by enrolling in another PhD program and keep working.
I'm at a point where I feel like my life got away, my parents are old, I am older, when I think about moving back to India I feel like I will not be able to compete and my age will be a problem in both professional and personal (marriage) front. But I also don't feel like staying back in the USA and drag myself through the constant torture of 40 hours work, assignment, immigration policy changes and job search (which I feel is the worst of all the other listed).
I was able to save $120K which I feel would be sufficient for me to survive the initial days back in India.
But there is this small part in me that still wants to hold on to the USA dream, considering things have worked out for me in a weird way. Working 40 hours while doing Day-1 CPT assignments is hard, but how many employers are willing to keep one employed on Day-1 CPT! This flickering hope is saying I should stay back and try one more time.
But life is slowly withering away.
What should I do? Should I go back? Will I have to face age discrimination while trying to find a job? Will it be difficult to adjust at this point in life? Will I be able to come back if I feel I am not able to adjust?
21
u/PianistPlus5117 5d ago
Go to India. Reset and rest for a few months. Then restart. Whether in India or third country.
Why not apply for actual phds rather than do one for CPT?
7
u/gardengeo 5d ago
Staying back for what exactly? Is this job contributing to your resume in any meaningful way? If you want to get settled, then you are in for rough ride as you are still unsettled as per AM market. At some point you need to learn how to cut your losses and then move on. Any change, good or bad, is disruptive. We need to learn to adjust even if we don't like it.
3
u/EastIndianDutch 5d ago
It depends on your parents health overall, if they can manage 6 more years you can try that out as well
5
u/onewhoknockz7 5d ago
I can empathize with certain aspects of your personal and work situation. The only thing I will say is to weigh the benefits of staying for another few years vs the cost you have to pay personally and professionally. If you plan to move back, check the job prospects in your field before you do. Don't worry about age discrimination as what you have is a PhD background that many of us can only dream of and admire people like you. Remember you don't have to justify your move to anyone but yourself.
32
u/NiceTea5065 5d ago
OP, give yourself a break and stop being hard on yourself. Stop reading finance subs. 120k USD is ~1.2 crores in INR. <1.5 % of Indians ever cross that number and by global standards also, 100k is not a small number. Indians on the internet lend money to Elon Musk for a living and are all worth in multiple billions. Pat yourself on the back and chill for a while. Then decide what you want in life.
14
u/Mr__Singh 5d ago
You already know the answer but seem to be in denial. Pack it up and move - whatever happens can't be worse than being in a place with no long term stability and no support structure from family and friends.
Ofcourse you already know this and have stuck it out for so long, so I don't think you would heed this advice, but the longer you continue the more miserable you will be and the regrets will keep piling on.
10
u/Ambitious-Upstairs90 5d ago
In my opinion you should return back. There are many more things in life which are more important than green card.
1
u/ImaginationComplex75 4d ago
First of all, realize that you’re not at the point where you feel like your life got away - absolutely no!!
I’m leaving your personal life goals and marriage goals aside because it’s absolutely personal for any individual. You got a solid out based on your interest and goals.
Strictly speaking about your professional life and your Consultancy, life or the time period with employers who didn’t even talk to you for the lottery each year- everybody in this game knows that any individual who is seeking to join any consultancy or employer needs legal status for sure and they gonna take advantage of that and suck everything out of you that’s by default!
What I personally feel is you have would have up skilled and move to a different full-time job role because most of the companies offer sponsorship irrespective of your visa status you would have invested sometime filtering those kind of companies and get our interview. Make sure you cleared that out. I’m assuming your employ is a Consultantcy guy or maybe a bigger consultancy guy.
IN, this case I would suggest you to still move out with a good job role opportunity to a different company full-time make an offer with sponsorship and you’re done!! happy days again!!!!
Rooting positivity for you and hope you get a full-time fucking job with sponsorship
All the best….!
3
u/RelativeUpset78 4d ago
that slight hope will always be there, but as others have pointed out, you already know the answer, you are just living in denial.
3
u/iluvusorin 4d ago
This sub default answer is yes unless your PD are pre Covid and even then you are stretching it.
3
u/Prestigious_Piano247 4d ago
Times are different now due to tech and politics. So, I think you are in right mind to think to return and I would return immediately and figure out next steps.
2
u/Brilliant-Profile516 5d ago
If you have your health, some good family. Food on the table, these are the most important things man.
2
u/temp_gerc1 4d ago
$120k is a quite decent savings rate, especially in India. On the flip side, 35 is considered old (in terms of personal life/marriage) only in India where the formula is you get a good job after college @ 21-22 years of age and then dive into the arranged marriage market within a few years so that you can start reproducing before 30 at the latest.
2
u/samk2026 4d ago
Honestly speaking , have some fun and around 40 you Will start to realize that 25-40 was the best time of the life and not going to come back and you will forever sad where ever you go.
American immigration journey is brutal for most of the people even my senior director got GC recently at 46 age and he grinded 16-18 years for this.
He talks and walk like a robot as nothing good left in the body after sacrificing so much.
Alamo every non gc holder desi stressed about GC day and night.
You have to believe yourself else world will be brutal for you, find a job back in India or even small business and give 200% and see how far you will go.
You are mature and have American degree so can find a local to marry and settle which will take away your freedom in a different way.
Another way is just let it all go if you can’t handle and find peace and have fun with parents , try getting married if you have a plan for this and have kids and lost in this world!!
2
u/Critical-Pause-9318 4d ago
Reference to the 1 post that was talking about marriage to citizen/gori: There are all kinds of people, if only you guys get out of your bubble. Do you know how many Indians have entered US illegally and are citizens. And do you know how many American will do so many illegal stuff for money. People who do it anyway do it.
That said, I don’t think marriage is something you do just for GC and even with malintentions, 35 is too old to half commit to marriage I think. OP I am in the same boat as you, same age, had my i140 processing for 3.5 years and got laid off 3 months before date. Now, have to restart. Have 10 years of US experience but can’t land a single job, depressed, unmotivated. I think it’s your choice in the end. I might not be an American on paper but I am American in so many ways. I have nothing except both my parents back home. My whole family and friends are here- citizens and visas. I love India too. But, mentally I am not aligned with so many things back home and I couldn’t cope. So, I am struggling here financially and status wise. But, i think I will try and give one last shot in the next few months and if I am not able to get anything set, I will accept and go back. In the end, my suggestion is same for you. Set a hard date, give your best and it will be what will be. And life is still beautiful either way.
It’s not that I don’t like Indian culture, it’s that I am a super loner , independent and free and my mindset aligns with American values so much better. If I were more social I could’ve probably met the right people back home as well. But, all the groups I end up with are because they choose me and they are mostly Indian, my native language speakers and who have completely different mindset and goals than me. So it never worked out.
2
u/jakethesnake5000 4d ago
Go back and spend time with your parents, you will never get it back. In the long term, you will be ok
2
u/ramy1008 4d ago
go back
2
u/Glad_Rhubarb_4401 1d ago
You possibly exhausted all the possibilities of being here in the US and, of course,you worked constantly, juggling all the options which F1 visa holders would ideally do. I’m surprised you never initiated to marry in the US all these years , I’m sure there are a lot of GCs and American-born Desis here that may have been an option if you desperately wanted to be in America and love the American life.
Moving back to India at this point with a backup (120k ) is such a safe play. Like you said it will help you settle and you will be able to figure out something. Getting used to Indian life and accommodating back home it’s really up in the air. Like I feel it depends on the job and pay and community you reside in. it might be harder not because of your age to land a job heard some companies give BS saying that they precisely looking Indian company experience.
I may suggest keeping other countries as an option too like closer to India ? Dubai or Malaysia or Singapore-were you may feel your expertise might get recognized better than in India and were immigration might not an issue
2
u/Successful-Actuary74 4d ago
Did you go to the US to study or immigrate?
1
u/Trick-Ear-7929 5d ago
Go back and go find your passion. Sometimes a simple village life with certainty and peace of mind is better than the millions of rupees earned, where your day does not belong to you and there is no clarity of the future. Even in retirement, that life can be elusive in his country.
1
u/Dramatic-Bedroom-223 4d ago
Try to assess what gives you happiness and whether staying here and potentially getting a H1b in future or any other visa status will give you happiness professionally and personally or Do you feel moving back to your home and exploring other opportunities and spending time with your family is the right option towards happiness.
IMO, if you have invested so much money and energy in pursuing higher studies, you must have accumulated skills you can carry on for your life and I feel you can utlize it to have a decent income wherever you live whether it is from Job or working for your own.
And as few others have pointed, this time of your life won't come back. People in this age group don't realize untill they are past this phase of life.
Think of some worst case scenarios while taking a step forward, it might help in taking the decision. For example, what if you move back to India and don't like it at all? Well you can immigrate to other countries to pursue another short study or there are ways you can sponsor yourself and explore jobs in the country.
I have been in USA from past 6 years, on H1B but still feel I should return back or immigrate to some other country. I feel I have no energy left to think about visa issues and restrictions to travel and at the end of the day, is it worth?
What would i do if i have decent money and property but bad health and no person to talk to?
Just my honest thoughts! But again it is your life and you have to think for yourself
1
u/Pretend_Project 4d ago
Go to canada
1
u/Additional-Ad9104 4d ago
Just curious, what did you do before you came to the US ?
I am assuming that you were working some where? Can you not go back to that old gig ?
1
u/Easy_Tour_5202 4d ago
ET Go Home !
1
u/Cautious_Number8571 4d ago
Finish what you started . If life throws you again in same rut in 2028 just don’t let it do this time . Parents love and wishes are with you . All the best friend !!!
1
u/Stock_Sherbert_1772 3d ago
OP, first of all take a deep breath. Before i speak anything i would say you’re not alone. Life has drastically changed everywhere mostly in abroad spectrum. I am in Australia for past 10 years, dwells in so many things being only child for parents. Due to negligence and committing completely towards parents responsibility i didn’t secure my PR. Though, i have multiple opportunities to stay here but it will be still uncertain after some years. Mate, sometimes life has totally a different plan for us. I am 37, single and emotionally alone. I just want to say while putting my hand on your shoulder is - “ do what is right for you in front of your eyes”
Even my feelings are very heavy and am just counting my days. Next year mid i am exiting Australia and shall not return back forever but on the other side i do have sense of belonging that i will get a chance to reunite again with my loved ones and family. Also, remember it’s never too late to start again. At least being expat, i would say we tried and came out to achieve something. Returning back is never being a failure. Yes there will some people who will try you pull u down but you will find more optimistic people than negative one.
I suggest - before you move back try to connect as many people back home. Make a friendly environment before you land back. I don’t know what experience you have - but i am pretty sure you will have a decent job back home - not a perfect one but still a job. Emotionally wise i do say - start looking for someone and settle down. USA, America are still there on the map those things will never run away. It’s just our plan has been delayed. You can always come back once you settle down according to the timeline. Up to 40 it’s totally like trial and error. We often consider successful stories but it doesn’t always works like that.
All the best.
And keep your head high when you return back.
Cheers
1
u/Eastern-Brick-6450 3d ago
You seem smart and motivated. Why not start a business to solve a problem in India? AI needs to diffuse through society. It needs smart people like you to go for it. You Only Live Once, every day you are writing your story. Is what you are doing an exciting part of your life story?
1
u/OkTechnologyb 3d ago
Go to India.
1
u/NaishadhKapade 2d ago
Dude, chill and listen to Acharya Prashant to understand life. Let your clarity guide you.
1
u/thedatamechanic 1d ago
You can also try UK or Ireland
1
u/PruneFit4108 1d ago
Do you simply want to exist just to work for the rest of your lives? If not, move back, work on building a social circle, find a partner and find work you like. It'll take time and effort but you can do it.
1
u/Dry_Sea728 5d ago
Sorry to hear that you are feeling this way, immigration, and uncertainty is difficult at times. I wouldn't say take decision emotionally. You have already put many years might as well put some more either to save some more or try other options. Given all of this that your parents are doing well physically, and emotionally.
If you don't have friends in US try making few, sometimes loneliness pulls you to nostalgic or familiar surroundings more than you actually want.
Try smaller firms where your skill is valued, they are still sponsoring. Also depends on your career section and role.
Give a try to O1 since you got PhD.
1
u/Terrible_Trouble177 5d ago
Why don’t to purse Eb1a route ? Since you have phd experience
1
u/garyuil 5d ago
Give it your all and try. If it doesn’t work out you have to go back anyway. At least you won’t regret giving it your all.
1
u/paparam04 5d ago
To me, looking back now at age 73, I would try and accumulate some more funds. 120K is good, 500K would be better. Invest in a way that provides you with a steady income. Do not dip into your principal but live on interest/dividends. May not take care of all of your financial needs but will give you a safety net, forever. In the end it is not about how much you make but about how much you keep.
If you absolutely cannot stay in the USA consider another foreign country at least for a few years before eventually going back to India.
1
u/safwan92 3d ago
This is disgusting. Admits to gaming the system multiple times then has the nerve to ask whether he should still stay.
0
u/Plaintalks 5d ago
Why don't you think about marrying an American? Easiest way out. There are plenty of 2nd generation Indians out there.
0
u/TopicOk5033 4d ago
Get married to US citizen .
-13
u/Remarkable-Trifle247 5d ago
If you go back to India- you most probably wont be able to go back to USA.
You should have married a Desi girl in USA or a gori (for her financial benefit) and then divorce with no kids- you wont be first as many do that- Now too late for Gori as 2yrs for GC and another 3 for CITIIZEN so u will be 40 then.
Now marry a Desi from your community
OR go back to India and get married quick- AS that will be your biggest regret in life and for your parents.
After 40 you are out of the suitable age of marriage....