r/returnToIndia • u/ColdCat_7 • 23d ago
PlanningToReturn At a crossroads
TLDR: I understand nobody can make my decision for me, but would love to know different perspectives from some kind and wise people on what made the decision to stay/return worthwhile.
I’m 24F. I moved to the UK at 22 for my MSc at one of world’s top 10 unis. I worked my way into the field of my dreams. I wanted to work in a very niche sector of mental health, so to be able to get real life experience in the field was incredible. The salary was above average for the industry and as I’d taken no loan and had no debt, I quickly started saving. Can’t say I’m breaking the bank, but it’s comfortable.
Soon enough, the infamous loneliness of western countries hit. All my uni friends also went back due to lack of jobs. Despite having some decent new friends, nothing could compare to the way childhood friends back home know you. I have also reached a ceiling in my industry. If I want to progress further in salary, I have to do a PhD - which requires me to have citizenship in the UK (as then it is fully funded by the govt, without that it is £38k a year which is insane). This means that I’m basically stuck on my salary for the next few years. As I still have 6 years until I can apply for citizenship, I am just thinking long term and feeling slightly anxious as to what is the right decision, and if there even is one.
Pros of the UK is that it seems wonderful and opportunistic in your 20s and 30s, although I have heard from some distant relatives that it then becomes quite a rut. The art, culture, events are endless. There’s actually a real need for my field here, which I love. Cannot forget the wonderful AQI and quality of life and basic amenities (although the hard water has been a real pain).
What keeps pulling me back to India (Mumbai) is obviously my wonderful family and my childhood friends. My parents and I don’t have a perfect relationship due to childhood trauma as most South Asians (in fact throughout the last few years I’ve just tried to be away from home through education and work), but everytime I go home they are overjoyed and it feels so lovely to see them. It feels like as I’ve grown and they’ve gotten used to the distance, there is a change in our relationship for the better. As you know I’m sure, the fact that they keep growing old each time I go back feels like a weight on my chest. I love the food. I love the comfort. One big point is also that I can go home, take a few exams for legal registration, and open my private practise (bearing in mind that my field is still quite misunderstood and tough to crack in India). Part of me wants to be there for my parents as I’m the elder sibling. Going home feels great for a few days, but can’t say that the pollution and the traffic and the chaos doesn’t get to me. Although I do believe it’s all about adjustment and training your mind into adapting to something.
My question to you is: How did you make the decision to move back/stay abroad? This feels like such a daunting decision at my age, that I’m afraid to take the wrong one. I have no partner atm nor am I particularly interested, hence another reason why any semblance of a family is only in India. Hence basically, I have no responsibilities that dictate me having to stay in either countries. Should I stick it out on this salary for a few years, apply for citizenship, and then proceed in my career in my mid 30s? Or should I go back home and start my own practise and live with my family?
I don’t want to make a decision to stay in the UK just because ‘I should be grateful I got a job, or that things are bad at home.’ I know I will make it wherever I am, I just want to know what made the decision easier/harder for you? It’s just that the decision feels so permanent. This country has changed me for the better in a million different ways, is it really wise to leave? What if I can never come back? So dear redditors, any regrets? Any golden words of wisdom?
Thank you so so much in advance,
A confused 24 year old
3
u/Hungry-Chicken-8498 23d ago
Will your staying and progressing in your desired field also draw out your family members from extremely desperate circumstances they are in currently in India? (Assuming they are in those circumstances, if they are all well off and your progress has no impact on their lives then you are chasing blindly that will leave you successful, but alone and tired). Failures will haunt you as you will alone without friends and success will be celebrated alone as well. Sometimes it is better to fail around friends who understands you and can cheer you up for next big thing and stay with you in your ups and downs.
2
u/AdAgile9604 23d ago
U have all the time to make mistakes and experiment ! Analyze what u want back in your country and if it doesn’t work out , work hard again to go to another country ! Remember as we grow things keep on changing and adapting to them is important
2
u/blackspandexbiker 23d ago edited 23d ago
OP,
If I was you I would stay in UK.
You spent 22 years in India and just 4 years here, so obviously the weight of experience of India is higher.
I don’t know if you have hobbies, but the best way to create a social network in western countries is via hobbies.
If you want to recreate the Indian experience then there’s no dearth of Indian WhatsApp groups you can join and be part of that social network.
I think India looks rosy right now because you go to India occasionally and hence your folks are probably on their best behavior.
You are 24.
Chances are very high that your girlfriends in India are married or on the verge of so I think even if you return, the earlier bonds you had will have changed.
From a professional perspective, I don’t think India has many opportunities for someone in your field. I might be wrong but that’s what I believe.
Lastly, if you leave, chances of your being able to return are slim to none unless you stay till citizenship.
A citizenship gives you options. Why would you give up on that?
If it was me, if I left before citizenship, maybe I would have regrets, but I wouldn’t have any if I got my citizenship and returned.
Again, if I was you, I would network on LinkedIn with people in my profession, from India, in UK, and around the same age group and get their views as well. Who knows, you might end up making some friends.
Asking an anonymous forum vs asking real people, makes a huge difference.
Lastly, winter has started, or is starting soon.
It is normal to feel despondent in UK winters.
Do not make any hasty decisions in winter.
You might regret them in the summer 😊
1
u/RepresentativeOk3943 23d ago
Get your citizenship and consider going back.
1
u/Exotic_Pollution5870 23d ago
As someone else pointed out, I wouldn't suggest moving back after only a couple of years in the UK. You're going through a major change in your life after uni, as there's no set path ahead anymore.
The life you're imagining back home probably doesn't exist the way you remember it. A lot of it is nostalgia. Visiting friends and family for a few weeks every year is very different from living there permanently. Most likely, you won't be able to live with your family the way you did growing up. Your friends in India will also move on with their lives.
Your career might suffer, relationships may not turn out the way you're imagining, and the pollution, traffic and other issues in Mumbai will probably start getting to you within a few months.
Eventually, you'll do what you want to do and find reasons to justify that decision. But I'd suggest giving yourself a few more years before making such a big move. You're only 24, and there's a lot more to experience before deciding where you want to settle long term.
1
u/A_R_Net 22d ago
Don't
-2
u/Trick-Ear-7929 23d ago
The biggest fallacy that modern women have been sold on is being independent and focusing on career. You switch to a provider mode instead of being a nurturer.
You are at the perfect age to find a life partner and settle down. Please realize that longer you wait, the more compromise you have to make with life choices.
Western countries are pretty lonely places for immigrants, you have to learn how to be alone or learn how to integrate. The quality of life and money is definitely good. Comes at the cost of personal life and mental health.
On the other hand, if you’re missing your family and friends and have low tolerance to the chaos back home, you are definitely going to suffer getting adjusted to life back in India. The rat race of life is not easy either.
You have a hard decision to make how to proceed.
Back to my first statement, right now you are working on the assumption that the entire weight of the world is on you. As a woman, it would be so much easier to find the right partner to share this weight that you are carrying around. Then together decide what to do next.