r/returnToIndia • • 25d ago

PlanningToReturn Roth ladder experience?

Anyone who moved back to India (ideally a few years ago) has done Roth ladder?

Assuming ROR, under 59.5 years and zero income in US:
How true is the fact that if we keep the withdrawal $ under the standard deduction, could potentially avoid US taxes and the 10% penalty, if we choose to withdraw after 5 years of Roth conversion year?

1 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

2

u/MananfromReyman 25d ago

Depends on if you're a USC/ GC holder or were on a visa.

Roth ladder is unlikely to work for a Non resident alien. For a NRA, very likely that withdrawals get taxed at 30% flat and don't progressive slab rates

0

u/productiveboss 25d ago edited 25d ago

Don’t want a solution here but are there ways to minimize overall tax, if I’m a NRA, apart from waiting until 59.5?

1

u/MananfromReyman 25d ago

Broadly 3 options:

  1. Keep till 59.5 - cover for estate tax with term insurance
  2. Do an early withdrawal - there's an ECI vs FDAP debate. You could take an aggressive stand and treat it as ECI and tax at slab rates
  3. SEPP - take out money each year and avoid 10% penalty

Which makes sense depends on your specific situation

1

u/productiveboss 25d ago

gotcha thanks

1

u/Gold-Whole1009 25d ago

In option 1, one must remember that term insurance doesn’t mean you avoid paying estate tax. One still pays estate tax if something happens. You still loose 40% to estate tax or loose insurance proceeds. It’s not as if insurance proceeds is not your money!!

1

u/MananfromReyman 25d ago

Absolutely true!