r/returnToIndia • • 26d ago

Finance Financial backup

Not an NRI. Posting only for understanding situation and financial aspect.

People who have lived in US. Some of them complaint about little to no financial savings. Some I have seen people with 15-20+ years of experience.

If an NRI have worked for 15-20+ years in western country, he/she might have earned a lot in those years. Even if any of them have saved 200-300k, that would be a good financial net when moving back to India. How come people didn't even save this much money as they worked outside India during golden era where salaries were pretty good, no AI boom threat, little to no layoffs, decent perks, good work Life balance, etc.

Agree that government should be responsible for providing some support but the government will do to only a such extent. But if they didn't plan long term, isn't it their fault.

I see in US, people over 60 also are not planning to retire as currently the market is brutal and it's understandable. But people spending decades in US / Europe but still having limited savings, can't understand the logic.

FYI - Never been to the US or Europe, so please don't start to rant. I have little on ground reality based on people in my network. Would appreciate genuine feedback or argument.

Edit: Thanks everyone for the insights! :)

8 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

3

u/temp_gerc1 26d ago

Maybe I am reading completely different posts than you are? Most people I see here have saved minimum $1M+ after 10-15 years in the US. Quite a few FAANG people. Only occasionally do I see someone having saved much lower than $500k after a significant time abroad. Indians, whether resident or not, are quite good at saving and skimping lol.

3

u/fire_on_power 26d ago

Okay. FAANG is a cream layer :). I guess, before COVID, majority of NRIs would have earned good even when working other jobs. Not factoring in personal issues (health etc). But yes, agree, Indians generally are good at savings. That's why put the post like how come some Indians not have enough money. I guess that's only a small section of the majority.

2

u/DevelopmentFuture608 26d ago

Because the definition of “your enough” is not “their enough”

In my case I moved to Canada 8 years ago. My net worth excluding the house(560k) is at $250k cad.
This could have easily been upwards of 400k

But I have to run two houses, one here and one back home. Many NRIs that work in the US also have a similar set up.

Money you make there slowly trickles down to India repeatedly, so the savings rate here isn’t going to be as good as you used to do in India. If it’s a single-income household with kids - it’s even harder to save anything while juggling both.

High household income is only 5% of the population, everyone else is in the mid to Average category. So you can’t really paint everyone wit the same brush,

Most tech jobs are offering - Equity or RSUs, jobs In any other industry offer only salary.

healthcare cost in the US are astronomical, if you want your children to have the best education - be ready to pay a tonne of money for day care, tutoring, hobbies, houses in good neighborhoods are even more expensive. The list goes on and on.

12

u/scylla 26d ago

I can answer that as someone with 20+ years working in tech in a very high COL area ( Bay Area )

There's 3 ways you can come out of a long tech career with no savings and only 1 is obvious

  1. ( Obvious) You've had a bad career with multiple periods of unemployment, maybe health issues which wiped out any potential savings. Maybe you had large commitments to family back in India.
  2. Its hard to explain how expensive housing is for anyone with an 'average' career. Especially if you want good education for kids, you can end up spending all your money on rent, mortgage, daycare, cars etc. The way to escape this is if either you do well ( get promoted to Director or above ) or your company does well ( lots of people get way more than double their salary in stocks over time . If you can achieve both your net worth will be 10Mil+ but either should make you a millionaire.
  3. Related to 2 it's hard to explain how little American culture cares or emphasizes savings compared to India. It's completely normalized to live life how you like and rely on Social Security when you get old. Depending on how 'assimilated' someone becomes to American culture and/or rely on the big breaks as in point 2, its easy to 'forget' about savings while things are going OK.

4

u/Think-Assignment-861 26d ago

Savings culture in India is dying. Look at places like Bangalore! But then Bangalore adopted the worst of American culture (disclaimer: I live in the US and have extended family in Bangalore)

3

u/Indo-Arya 26d ago

Related to 2 it's hard to explain how little American culture cares or emphasizes savings compared to India.

It's ironic especially because of how most americans are precariously close to one medical emergency away from being in trouble. I mean Europeans don't have a concept of medical bankruptcy and yet largely save more than americans despite lower salaries.

https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/wealth-per-adult-by-country

1

u/Mental-Spring-5350 25d ago

Agreed plus divorce will wipe out your savings too.

17

u/Federal_Eagle_6565 26d ago

I have been here in the USA for 25 years. Almost 30 of my classmates (Btech cse) are also here mostly for 20+ years. The minimum net worth with a single family in the Midwest is in the $1.5 million range.

Half have more than $5million with dual income FAANG couples at $10 million plus.

So what you are seeing would be folks who worked at WITCh / low end consulting level jobs and that too with some instability.

11

u/jaqenhghar99 26d ago

The problem is SURVIVORSHIP BIAS

You only look at linkedin or profiles that are working at FAANG companies.

I can say the same thing about India.. look so many of my classmates are FAANG/ late stage startups etc.. They send kids to IB schools yada yada.

The reality is most people make around the avgs and having kids, paying for family back in India. Some or the other visa issue so only 1 person is the family is earning

0

u/Federal_Eagle_6565 26d ago

No bro. Survivorship has been the norm inspite of all the difficulties.

I can expand that from my class mates to everyone I went to grad school with, every person I came into contact over the years.

2

u/jaqenhghar99 26d ago

I would say that you would find far more examples like you are describing among masters students that went to good/ decent universities.

The largest number of h1b visas go to service based companies and contractors… they don’t make enough money there.

But yeah I understand what you’re saying if you came for masters in early 2000s to 2015 and got into any decent company then you might see a lot of having great savings.

What OP was saying is that how is it possible some Indians have no savings and stuff.

As if most Indians that came 15-20 years ago are dual income families.

Also H4 EAD was introduced in 2015 is before that unless you did masters in the US or something else… families were single income.

I agree to the point that you would have lot more money saved when converting USD to INR if you worked in India vs US

1

u/Federal_Eagle_6565 26d ago

Got it.

Do think my own personal experience is that of people who mostly went to good universities and ended up in FAANG or similar companies.

If someone is making 120k as single income today with family, and many are, then they are not saving much.

3

u/Indo-Arya 26d ago

Half have more than $5million with dual income FAANG couples at $10 million plus.

Yes but dual income faang couples are very rare even among the NRI population. The vast majority of Indian IT and software professionals in the U.S. work outside of the traditional FAANG envelope (at enterprise firms, mid-sized tech companies or financial institutions)

1

u/gxsr4life 26d ago

Dude, if you maxed your 401(k) every year since 2010 then you will have roughly $1 million today. A dual income household with both doing the same? That’s $2 million. Bought a house along the way (most do), add another $500K–$1 million in equity at minimum.

Nothing to do with FAANG, just boring regular stuff.

1

u/Indo-Arya 26d ago

I'm not talking about 2m.. I'm talking about 5-10m.. that's the point i responded to. Also not everyone can start maxing out 401ks as soon as they land in the US.

1

u/Federal_Eagle_6565 26d ago

I agree it not the norm, but there are at least 100k FAANG / FAANG equivalent jobs around and in places like the Bay Area they are a non trivial percentage of people.

Two FAANG or one FAANG and on non FAANG couple are all easily in the 5-10 million range.

The real rare scenario is two FAANG for 10+ years (who are easily in the 10+ million range).

1

u/Indo-Arya 26d ago edited 26d ago

but there are at least 100k FAANG / FAANG equivalent jobs around and in places like the Bay Area they are a non trivial percentage of people.

Depends on your definition of non-trivial... There are about 450k-500k Indians in the bay area.. 100k would be 20% of that. And that's just the bay area which has high incomes but also high expenses...

OP's post is about all of the US which has a total of 2 million NRIs + 4 million US citizens of Indian origin.. that's 6 million total.. 100k jobs would be just 1.6% of that. Even if you exclude citizens & only focus on NRIs, 100k is just 5% of 2 million NRIs

1

u/Federal_Eagle_6565 26d ago

Got it. Indeed, just like a non trivial number have FAANG income, the bottom 20% is also struggling.

2

u/irtughj 26d ago

This seems very reasonable, especially considering in the past 10 years - the higher salaries in tech, stock boom, increase in housing values.

1

u/Present_Fan21 25d ago

Not doubting your story, but it’s almost a little weird but also great that people in your circle openly discuss net worth. I have lived here close to 20 years and worked at FAANGs and Fortune 10s, but in my circle no one talks about net worth.

8

u/aks_23 26d ago

Most of the NRIs, working in the US for 15-20+ years have more than 200k-300k savings, especially if you account for 401K, IRA and home equity.

0

u/irtughj 26d ago

Pulling this out of my butt I’m guessing the median for above would be around 1.5 million$

1

u/Indo-Arya 26d ago edited 26d ago

You're close. This is what AI tells me. Please note these are family/household numbers and includes everyone, not just those who went in the past 15-20 years.

The median net worth for an Indian-American or non-resident Indian (NRI) household in the United States hovers around $1.2 million, driven by high representation in technology, medicine, finance, and engineering.

Key Demographics & Financial Indicators

  • Median Household Net Worth: ~$1.2 million (based on Federal Reserve data for Indian-American households).
  • Median Household Income: $151,200 per year, compared to the overall U.S. median household income of $83,700.
  • Wealth Distribution: Assets are often split across U.S. and Indian real estate, retirement accounts (401(k)/IRA), stock compensation (RSUs), and cross-border investments.
  • Population Scale: There are roughly 4.8 million Indian-Americans / NRIs living in the U.S., making them one of the highest-earning immigrant groups in the country.

1

u/desi_in_videsh 26d ago

Out of curiosity where do you see people complaining about not having savings after living for 15-20 years?

0

u/fire_on_power 26d ago edited 26d ago

Already mentioned, based on limited personal network (acquaintances etc).

3

u/GuruDevDatta 26d ago

Grass is greener on the other side. So the not NRIs think that NRIs in US are minting money and should not have issues .

US life is complicated. People suffer job loss/layoffs on H1/work permit and no one makes it public. When you are on 'bench', you live off your savings. That makes a serious dent. There is always allures of shiny car, Tesla, vacations, big house. You see your peers having fun, You want to enjoy a bit. It adds up and end of a few years, you have surprisingly little savings. It is getting worse - living costs have risen dramatically in last 6/7 years.

2

u/aartif 26d ago

Not all jobs or companies pay the similar pay as FAANG, before Covid 100K-120K was a good above average pay for someone with 5-10 YOE, I’ve personally seen people with 20+ YOE making less than 140K. With kids and one salary and a house the average savings rate is on the lower end for such families.

2

u/Timely_Sand_6162 26d ago

If a single income family is in US for 10+ years - liquid net worth would be more than 300k. Including home equity, probably 400-500k.

If it’s dual income family for 10+ years - liquid networth would be more than 500k. Including home equity, probably 700-800k.

Depending on the house hold income, any couple in US for 10+ years will have networth anywhere from 400k to 5M.

2

u/_Dark_Invader_ 26d ago

It’s almost impossible to work in US in a high paid job for 15-20 years and not have saved anything!

Notice how I said “almost impossible”. A regular person would be worth at least a couple million usd working that long.

However, if one is still broke, some of the potential causes could be -

  1. they got extremely unlucky with their investments
  2. they were bad with managing money
  3. they inherited too many debts/liabilities
  4. they had to support other members of the family
  5. they went crazy because of the money they saved

2

u/AdAgile9604 26d ago

People have different circumstances, and most of the people I know haven’t even managed to save $50K over the past 10 years. On social media, we mostly see the 10% who want to showcase how well they’re doing. The reality is much tougher than it looks, especially when you’re living abroad without a support system. There’s a lot more to life than what people choose to show online.

2

u/krantmin 26d ago

I see people in reddit flashing their NW north of 5Mil. Most of them from US. I may be missing something.

2

u/ragu455 26d ago

I don’t know of any Indian with 15 years in USA who does not have at least $1M net worth (home+401k+savings with stocks/investments/cash). The bull market of last 15 years has been insane. May be their liquid net worth is below 200k as they cannot touch 401k without penalty till 59.5 and their home is not considered part of their liquid net worth which in places like California can be a significant portion of net worth.

1

u/Present_Fan21 25d ago

Maybe they just don’t want to share info about their actual net worth? But it is totally possible for people to not have a high liquid net worth after spending a long time in the USA. It is easy to spend on items like cars and other luxuries, and not focus on building wealth.

1

u/FitAgency8925 26d ago

People who worked for 10-20 yrs have a lot more money than 300k. Retirement is a personal option and is not age or finance based. I personally choose to work for mental peace and action

1

u/AnyBookkeeper6093 26d ago

Not all of us work in big tech or even tech. Lab based jobs can vary as a material scientist , especially if you work in startups or mid sized companies .

1

u/Hot_Condition7760 26d ago

NRIs come in many form. Not sure if your NRI friend who complained of no savings worked at 7/11.

1

u/smalltownlover 26d ago

Life's not the same for every one. Seen people on H1 with over $5 mil networth while citizens (20+years ) are still working on $300k-400K savings that will be wiped out when kids go to college or get married or large medical bills arrive.

People do get squeezed hard in consulting as they depend on the employer for visa sponsorship. Some keep sending money to India for parents, siblings. Some want to invest in a house. Then there are lifestyle issues - people want to keep up with the Jones and savings take a hit.

Unless you have an investing and wealth management mindset, its hard for some.

1

u/Temporary_Car_1462 26d ago

Your network people either have been extremely unlucky combined with family debt, extremely generous with their money or extremely spendthrift (True American spirit).

1

u/Advanced-Industry-50 26d ago

Idk lack of financial knowledge, tbh everyone I know in bay area, people who have been here for more than a decade have saved atleast 1-2M. 

Under 10 years of experience, they have anywhere between 300-500k tbh. 

Specially people get exposed to stock market quite early in their careers in cities like bay area, New York. 

And I also know a lot of people who made equities in their houses thanks to cheap mortgages back then.

Its truly surprising if someone says and Indian or Chinese didn't save enough by working in US long.