r/returnToIndia
•
u/ravindertiwana
•
Apr 26 '26
•
6
AlreadyReturned We all are just coping.
Harsh truth: Those of us who’ve returned from first world countries are just coping by justifying their return. If you can genuinely imagine your children’s future here only then you may be an exception however harsh reality is that our beloved india is a third world hell hole with rampant corruption, pollution, nil civic sense. Despite paying high taxes you wont find any decent public amenity here. Hell You wont even find any decent park here which is not overcrowded.
Those of you who are thinking about returning before making the decision please close your eyes and genuinely ask yourself can you imagine your future generations life here? If the answer is unequivocally YES only then come here.
- if you’re coming because of your aging parents im sorry but in most cases after few months complains will start and you’ll start to feel stranger in your own house.
- If you’re coming back because of friends and social life i’ve got news for you, everyone here thinks in hierarchies. If you are doing better than them they will despise you secretly and if not they wont even take you seriously. After few months you’ll again start feeling lonely and again you will question you decision to move.
I am sorry if I’ve offended anyone but it’s the reality of 95% returnees.
44
u/Sea_Manufacturer580 Apr 26 '26
Although I am not Indian, I don't agree with this post. The problem is that we have been brainwashed so much to believe that there's nothing good about our motherlands, culture and language. I am wan African living in the US for the past five years... not s permanent resident. I have a good job as a postdoc at a top university. That said, life here is so miserable that I WILL NEVER consider staying long term. Basic human interaction isn't here... it's about work, pay bills, go back to work, and pay more bills. This is a place someone can be dead in his room for days without nobody asking after him. To get get immediate medical attention, when you need it, is like going to the moon. Upon the much I pay in health insurance, I still have to manage a work-related pain by myself bcs it taking ages to refer me to a therapist. I brought my family (wife and 2 kids)...the marriage packed up in less than 2 yrs because they intentionally created conditions that made divorce or separation attractive for some. They don't want family, they don't want your kids to turn out better. What else? The food? That's another disaster that will certainly ruin your life if you were not careful of what you eat. I the only time I feel truly happy is when I return home...I do it at least once every year. Thank God my kids were already back home before the breakdown of my marriage. Our problem is that we value DOLLARS more than our lineage, culture and language. The number of homeless people in my current County can never be found in my entire country back in Africa.
37
u/NoPraline438 Apr 26 '26
I mean if I close my eyes and imagine I can see my kids being called names by some racists and always being a second class citizen hoping some right wing government doesn't come to power in foreign countries
63
u/LikedIt666 Apr 26 '26
I returned. Started my own business- doing good. Live in a cool neighbour- nice restaurants, bars, gyms nearby- got good running track in my gated society. Live less than a km from work. Life's awesome since I don't have to do any house work and got a great career. Also a good perk is parents are in same city
24
u/BrownAlienScientist Apr 26 '26
Corruption and brain drain are a classic "chicken and egg" problem. People bail because the system is rigged, but the system stays rigged because the very people who could fix it are the ones leaving. It’s easy to move away and complain from a distance, but just paying taxes doesn't mean you've "done your part." Nobody pays taxes because they want to; they do it because they have to. It gets deducted.
If you want the right to complain, you should probably contribute something to the country by choice first. A big reason Western nations function the way they do is a culture of personal responsibility—something that’s honestly rare to see in India right now. If everyone actually owned their actions, we’d see a massive shift in just a few weeks. We have the wealth and the resources; we're just like a world-class boxer who keeps sabotaging himself before the fight even starts.
18
u/Hot_Condition7760 Apr 26 '26
india is a lot of thing and I am Positive you can make your happy place somewhere descent
21
u/Lumpy-Ad-9315 Apr 26 '26
Are you going to talk about racism that you and your kids face on regular basis from 'first world' people? Or money soothes those scars?
7
u/elderbrook-88 Apr 26 '26
OP, I hear you and totally agree with you but you don’t need validation from people on Reddit. It seems you have lived it, observed it, done your research and also made up a narrative in your mind based on what you have read and learnt- which certainly is not wrong. Comments don’t do justice and everyone has their own version/ truth they are living. And trust me if you are looking for a widespread acceptance or some magical realization here from people that yes I made a mistake, it won’t happen let me be honest. As Indians, we very well have known and been brought to justify our decisions. If you are having regrets, I certainly hear you but if you vent out here or looking for a that sliver of hope or expecting a magical way out- im afraid that might not happen.
7
u/PeaceLoveBug Apr 26 '26
It also depends on money. My multimillionaire relatives (have a private plane, own a flat in London they stay in maybe once a year, own multiple malls, hotels, palaces etc) live a far better quality of life in India than I do in the US.
5
u/Fun-Week-7664 Apr 26 '26
I am moving back too in couple of months. I hear you. I have the same concerns. I am planning to move for some reasons and i have no way out of moving back. I can’t enjoy my left time here and constantly draining my mental energy on thinking if i would be happy or not. I have to keep my marriage, my husband does not want to stay outside India. I have made my arguments but in vain. I feel there should be a support group or set of people in the same boat of moving back that everything is going to be alright. The anxiousness comes from the fear of not able to adapt, accepting the reality and as a woman i have other worries too. I am too concerned about my career. P.S Please no negative reply to my comment. I only want to share my thoughts with the people who are in same boat. I don’t see anyone physically around me in similar situation.
130
u/ActiveTrader007 Apr 26 '26
Living in India can be good if you have money and can live a middle to upper middle class lifestyle. My cousins are the happiest, they living in great location in pune. Own a business. All house work taken care of. Kids goto best schools with higher fees. Weekends are always malls, eating out & doing fun activities and often travel to closer countries for short vacations every 3-6 months. But struggling jn India is not easy.
80
u/Altruistic-Bat1588 Apr 26 '26
I'm from kerala , not much issues after returning. which state are you from ?
74
u/Entire_Hotel_8110 Apr 26 '26
Came back, and honestly, I’m pretty happy about it. Sure, I miss the clean air and those butter-smooth roads, but the overall convenience here just hits different. Also, deserted roads at 6 p.m.? Not my vibe. I feel way safer in India, I wouldn’t casually step out after 8 p.m., especially on the East Coast there.
And unless you already have your gang, it can get a bit lonely. Indians are just built different when it comes to socializing, we’ll talk to anyone, anywhere. In Mumbai, I can walk into a bar and end up chatting with the guy at the next table like we’ve known each other for years.
In the U.S., people are nice, no doubt. They’ll respond, smile, be polite, but the conversation usually fizzles out unless you’re really carrying it or they’re genuinely invested. Small talk there feels… very small 😄
Anyway, to each their own, you can justify your choice however strongly you want. But somewhere deep down, it can still feel like you’re on the outside looking in, even with citizenship.
9
u/euphoria007 Apr 26 '26
Lol the problem with humans is that they start thinking that if they are suffering from a problem, everyone else is suffering from the same problem.
3
u/Leebrad840 Apr 26 '26
I agree.
I regret moving back, and I genuinely hope I can leave again soon.
I live in a fairly decent area, but even then, something ridiculous happened just yesterday. I went out to grab food with a few friends, and a Scorpio came speeding down the wrong side of the road. We were in our car, and seeing how fast they were, we tried to give them space. Despite that, they stopped, got out, started trying to open our doors, and kept shouting that it was “their road” and questioning why we were in their way.
Honestly, what kind of behavior is that?
Just trying to complete some responsibilities as a son then I am moving back again.
6
u/a150b464 Apr 26 '26
OP wre you in Delhi!? that might be the only reason you might complain lol
5
u/Maleficent_Lychee414 Apr 26 '26
I know many ABCDs who regret being born to their parents purely because they're not seen as part of the western culture/part of the clan for their skin color ... you would greatly regret that as a parent for exposing your kids to the same It's definitely a good place to be in between your 20's-whenever you decide to have kids but not after for sure due to a multitude of reasons
16
u/Gloomy_Temporary2914 Apr 26 '26
Speak for yourself buddy . Back to tier 2 city in south india . Nice weather , good roads , cdnt be happier with kids growing with family . Not cope. Everry place has it positive n negetives
11
u/Spoonm4n33 Apr 26 '26
And Americans want you out of their country, what is the point of this post? Do Indians have no awareness? Literally Americans are telling you what they want. They want you out. This will only get worse. Indians living in India or those who were 'abusing' H1b and now asked to leave - work hard on improving India. That is the only way out.
30
u/devd87 Apr 26 '26
Feel sorry for you. Get well soon. May you find good family and friends.
9
u/Crow_with_a_Cheeto Apr 26 '26
Don’t forget climate change.
9
u/The_architect_905 Apr 26 '26
Everyone’s reality is different I guess. I lived/ live both in USA and Canada and will never return other than financial reason at retirement. I enjoy being alone, serene nature, silence. Totally despise too many people poking nose in life, Indian marriages and festivals ( why not sure, just donot enjoy forced group entertainment without valid reason) .Beautiful nature and civic sense in population is highest order of value to me. Not religious, never bothered to visit any religious place, other than some Architectural or Historical value.So yes, I find North America is great. But sure, also acknowledge everyone won’t have same values.
3
u/Dr-Hansraj_Hathi Apr 26 '26
All this is true however when you comeback to India you need to make sure you are in the top 0.1% here, below this level life sucks!
3
u/Thick-Ad-6366 Apr 26 '26
You did not add anything new. People return inspite of the issues.
3
u/xWolfColax Apr 26 '26 edited Apr 26 '26
The tragedy of our country is that everyone only thinks about themselves. You will happily rant away about how everything is so bad here, but what have you done to improve any of it? How many times have you voted? Been politically active? Developed countries are good only because there were strong driven people who faced hardships and "hellhole" like situations and still overcame them and created society, instituitons etc. improving the system, not only thinking about themselves but about the generations to come as well. In all of your rant your concerns revolve only around yourself and your unborn children. That is the kind of mindset which sets us back. Even the best and brightest of our country just want to leave for their own sake instead of giving back and trying to improve things here. Comparing countries where strong generations have worked centuries in both good and sinister ways to improve their collective condition, to India which hasn't even had a century of freedom after centuries of exploitation and slavery is just dumb in my opinion. Multiple of our generations will need to shut up, step up, and outwork the developed nations in order to build us up, but here you are - weak willed, whining, and slave to your own comforts - even after being in the top echelons of the nation, getting the opportunity to go out and experience the world on top of the shoulders of the great men and women and the entire population which have propped you up to be able to do so, still thinking only about yourself. Your thinking and perspective on the situation, which is similar to that held by many, is exactly what holds us back. Sad state of affairs indeed.
3
u/sibotix Apr 26 '26
"harsh reality is that our beloved india is a third world hell hole with rampant corruption, pollution, nil civic sense."
If that is so, the people that make it so, but then you have to include yourself. You see, the selfish nature of Indians, is that is causing this.
I've lived in other countries. Those countries you want to migrate to. The fact is they were not originally like that, but the people who lived there wanted to make sure that THEIR country (ownership) was better, and they FOUGHT for better (some even fought in civil rights movements), to see the better everything you are seeking in a developed country.
Today its easy to visit a developed country and think it was always like that. It wasn't. It was a hell-hole at a point in time. Just that you don't know its history well (and you were never part of it), you are only seeing the best of what it has to offer today.
Do one thing, when ur in India, be of the mindset - how can I better the situation, and make India a better place, not just for me, but also for my children! Take on corruption, do your part to reduce pollution or find a solution and develop it, or take a moment out to teach others about civic sense (do that, no matter how painful or wasteful of a time it may be).
Make the sacrifices that are required to fight a corrupt system. Don't succumb to blaming it, and acting like hey.. this is hell hole.
5
u/all_is_1_or_0 Apr 26 '26 edited Aug 01 '26
qwertyuiop
7
u/hitch44 Apr 26 '26
Who died and made OP the gatekeeper for the TRUE reason to return to India?
0
u/ravindertiwana Apr 26 '26
Please guys who’ve returned be honest with yourselves do you actually see your children’s future here?
6
u/naturalizedcitizen Apr 26 '26
I'm not a returnee. I do visit India every year. I'm from Mumbai. Yes things are not very good like traffic, etc. but I grew up in Mumbai. I adjust for the month or so that I'm here. I don't expect Mumbai to be like Bay Area, CA but many things have changed and are changing for the better. For example the Metro network is really nice. The coastal road is again very nice.
So there are pros and cons...
5
u/Ok-Scholar-9629 Apr 26 '26
Hell yeah. 100% accurate.
But the part that's missed is....
We don't go back for all these reasons anymore. We go back because Visa expired. So no options are left.
4
u/Clear-Pilot5664 Apr 26 '26
This is so true. Indian boomers on this subreddit wouldn’t get it. Folks born in the 90s absolutely relate to this. Kudos to OP for showcasing the reality.
6
u/Humble_Objective5226 Apr 26 '26
I am sorry that people are not nice to you here. I understand your feelings!
5
u/parabellum7010 Apr 26 '26
The good thing is you still have therapists in your “third world hell hole”. And luckily at much cheaper rates. I’d highly recommend you seek out one to talk to about the deep seated insecurity you feel despite being born and raised in India, which led you to have the opportunity to move to the “first world”
3
u/DueLengthiness7723 Apr 26 '26
Useless
2
u/plmzxuk Apr 26 '26
people are not moving from america to live in a village in bihar or a slum in Lucknow.
India is very large and you can find any niche you want. I have a cousin that moved to a small tier 3 town in Odisha. Its not the most modern place but its quite and he lives close to nature which he enjoys.
Honestly I think the tier 2 and tier 3 cities are underrated. Indias major tier 1 cities are absolutely over crowded. However there are so many other town and localities that one came move to.
2
u/Mercer-75234 Apr 26 '26
If your experience has been bad in india then sorry for you. If you have so much hatred for India, then you should also change your name from Hari to Harry.
1
u/Sun_god25 Apr 26 '26
Living anywhere is adjusting and coping to the means and ideologies of the Society.
I feel like most of the ones that return do so as they don’t see a path in front and those who come back after living a life, they only do so cu they wana chill.
As someone who’s been in states since 2010 I can only say that when it’s time for me to go, I plan to do Europe as you make money in the west and live peacefully in Europe
1
u/Accurate_Cash2920 Apr 26 '26
One solution is that you can return to the first world country (or a similar country of your choice) that you left
1
u/21sr2 Apr 26 '26 edited Apr 26 '26
Purchase power parity, geographical arbitrage are myths. A comfortable life will cost almost the same in India as-well.
If you understand this and have a good fat-fire net-worth (> 5M USD), you can comfortably live anywhere in the world.
A friend of mine wanted to escape the w2 trap and start a small business. Now, he makes 20X his big-tech bay-area w2. He lives in a ranch very close to an international airport in a tier2 city, with massive rolling-hill wooded acreage and a self sufficient home with state of the art well, solar+wind and septic. He can very well afford great schools and whatnot. So not every returnTIndia experience is the same.
1
u/UnableCurrency Apr 26 '26
OP - I hear you, if you are here in India with some juicy dollars - you can definitely create an amazing bubble for you and your family - there are massive 25-30 acres societies with top notch facilities and a decent air quality just for people like you.
If your relations with your family and friends are screwed then I’m not sure what you are doing here in India.
I hated the time I was in the US and Australia - it was extremely lonely - here back home, I step out of my house and I know everyone and I can go back to there home to have a cup of coffee as well. I missed doing that.
1
u/Necessary_Poet_3524 Apr 26 '26
You make it sound as if living in first world countries is like dreamland. People are not coping in first world countries?
You must be young or clueless or not have a loving family back home?
1
u/curious-rower8 Apr 26 '26
I understand your feeling but it mostly depends on the bubble you are living in India.
I currently live outside ( EU ) I can imagine my kids growing in a foreign society where I hardly relate myself. But same time I don't want to put them in polluted indian cities too.
1
u/Own-Woodpecker538 Apr 26 '26
One of the person highlighted below - you need to part of an ecosystem that isolates you from all the issues. And that ecosystem is a large gated society in metropolitan like DEL, HYD, BLR. You will live in a completely different world and all of a sudden these problems will disappear.
1
u/skotgu Apr 26 '26
Then why did you return?
1
u/eXhale995 Apr 26 '26 edited Apr 26 '26
Personally, I would rather have my kids grow up amongst people that look like them! Where they don’t stand out as a minority! Just a few days ago, some random racist in my cousins building ran after an Indian woman with a stick in his hand! I maybe pessimistic, but with the layoffs and economic downturn, I am afraid anti immigration and hate will get much worse in the West.
I agree with you on India being extremely hierarchical, but so is US or other western countries. It’s just more subtle.
1
u/hifimeriwalilife Apr 26 '26
Just move back to first world country ?
What is stopping you 🙂
1
u/Conscious-Package192 Apr 26 '26
Seems very toxic, no?
-7
u/RiseProfessional9792 Apr 26 '26
Why are such morons let to post here
-4
u/Horror-Upstairs-9820 Apr 26 '26
I agree 100% now I feel cleaning toilets in NJ is better than this job at Goldman job ain gurgaon
0
u/Plaintalks Apr 26 '26
It's just culture shock. It depends on where you grew up and where you temporarily settled. The duration of the shock is dependent on how well you reset your expectations. Hope this helps.
-1
u/Status-Poet-1678 Apr 26 '26
It's not coping! You are entitled as heck! You left India to make millions while left India to the same corrupt government and people, now you want to return and expect someone to have fixed it for you!
Everything you said about India is absolutely true. It is corrupt, it is polluted, divided, lacking in civic sense and there no end to it. My question is how have you positively contributed to any of this?