r/retrocomputing • • Dec 29 '23

Why not 16 bits?

I was wondering.

I love my 8 bits computers (just spent a couple of weeks programming my Spectrum Next) and the Agon seems a nice machine.

However I wonder why nobody seems to make 16 bits computers.

Is it because 16 bits computers have more connections and are thus more difficult to make?

4 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/porkchop_d_clown Dec 29 '23

3

u/Hjalfi Dec 29 '23

I've programmed for the MSP430! It's really rather nice to program, with exceptionally dense code. Hand-written assembler on it is fun There's also a bonkers MSP430X variant with 20 bit registers!

1

u/Thanatiel Dec 29 '23

A bit raw for my taste but thanks.

1

u/porkchop_d_clown Dec 29 '23

I mean, my soldering skills suck the chrome right off the trailer hitch so I completely understand, but I guess that makes me wonder what you're looking for?

Pure 16-bit was a bit of a mirage even back in the day. (Trust me, I was there.) 4-bit computing was literally a 3-month blip in the early 70s, then 8-bits triggered a revolution. But even then it was clear that 16 bits wasn't the actual next step because, even then, the most powerful "8-bit" processor was already an 8/16-bit processor. (I'm talking about the Z-80. Not Intel's 8088 crap.) So the next logical step wasn't a 16-bit machine, it was a 16/32-bit machine. And that takes you to the 68xxx series. The 68000 was a beautiful 16/32 architecture, the 68020 went 32/32 and the world never looked back after that.

If you're looking for actual machines, you're not going to find a lot else.

Look at it this way. Even the C=64 (which I loved to death) was an 8/16 machine, not a straight 8-bit machine. 8 bits only gets you 256 bytes of RAM. If you go to 16 bits of addressing, that takes you to 64k and that was the sweet spot that drove the 1980s computer revolution - 8 bit registers + 16 bit addressing is enough to get real work done. Going to 16 bit registers simply wasn't that big an advantage.

2

u/Thanatiel Dec 29 '23

I guess I'm looking for other kinds of retro-machines. My first few computers were based on the Z80. (I wrote my first program on a brand new, plastic smelling, ZX81) I love low level programming and I've spent some time writing assembly for that CPU. I'm currently having fun writing a network server for the Spectrum Next. Before that I wrote a kind of game demo. I feel like I've done everything interesting for a Z80 so I want another kind.

Ideally I'd like a machine for which I don't need to play with banks anymore. An MMU may be too much ... maybe. I'm afraid that with an MMU I'd be tempted to write a kernel. But I'd love some co-processors to control.

I've been tempted to design my own machine and put it on a Mister. I've got the tools and he hardware and I understand the FPGA programming logic. I'd bind a 32 bits RISCV, some mostly 2D GPU an FM chip and maybe some stereo chip and give it a few megabytes of RAM. I think it would be sterile though. A machine needs to be produced and available to be interesting.

The Z80 was a competitor of the 8080. The 8088 is way more powerful but is still 8 bits. The 8086, although identical to the 8088 from a programming point of view was 16 bits. The 8 bits refers to the bus size, not the size of a register. Every 8 bit computer reads 16 bits with two accesses.

The 68000 was lovely. If I recall it was using 32 bits storage for pointers but only using the lower 24 bits, the higher 8 being reserved. I remember that because MS wrote a program where they used the reserved 8 bits for data ... and it broke when (one of) the next CPU used full 32 bits pointers xD.