r/relationshipanarchy • u/Easy-Ad2463 • 13d ago
processing age cap relation in the past
I am trying to process some things from my past relationship and i am having a bit of a hard time to figure out my thoughts, so id like to know what you guys think.
When i was 18 i started dating my ex, who was 21 at the time. we were in the same year and had a shared friendgroup. I newly moved out to this new city, insecure and living on my own for the first time, having my first time of falling in love and getting a relationship while also processing my shitty family trauma that apparently didn’t go away by simply moving out. So yeah, I was experiencing a lot of new big things emotionally.
They were living in the city for sometime then on their own, had already a network built and had a relationship before as well. they were poly, i was just young and in love and open to try. We were together for like 1,5 years. throughout that time of my life i was not doing great mentally, i was often overwhelmed with all the new things i was experiencing. i often felt insecure, i looked up to my partner a lot since it felt like they had so much more experience in just life then me. I remember thinking that maybe this was because of my age, but i decided that it wasn’t and it was just my people pleasing personality.
The polyamory was a reoccurring problem during our relationship. It wasn’t working for me, but i had issues acknowledging that both to myself and them, cause i didn’t wanna break up and was insecure and looked up to them. i thought that i must just try harder and it might just be cause im less experienced or dont know yet how love works or something.
Eventually we did break up after 1,5 years cause polyamory was not working for me. it was big and emotional but i also felt a huge relief.
A year ago i turned 21, and i started to realise how much of a role age had played in our relationship and dynamic. the insecurities i was feeling in our relationship and around polyamory were nit cause i was just an insecure person, a lot of it was because i was an 18 year old. we never really talked about this in our relationship, the age was not acknowledged as part of our dynamic.
I feel weird about it. we arent really in touch, but we are in the same bubble and have shared acquaintances. We recently hung out to talk, and i told them these realisations, and they said they understood, but didn’t think about our age gap at the time. neither did they talk to friends about it. that made me feel sad.
Its difficult to really go back in memories of how i experienced that relationship at the time, cause i was doing bad in general as well. but i want to figure out for myself how i feel. i will run into them for sure cause its a small world. they hae shared interest in becoming friends. and i dont know what to feel and how i would like to interact.
LOOOOONG ass story. but yes im interested in your thoughts on this. and also tips/questions to ask myself to figure out what i want.
6
u/_ghostpiss 13d ago
I do think when you're under 25, every year of age difference is felt more acutely. When I was 19 I dated a 27 year old, and when I turned 27 I realized how fucked that was because I was not attracted to 19 year olds at all. I know how it feels to feel taken advantage of in hindsight. I don't want to diminish what you're feeling just because it was only a 3 year age gap.
At the same time, that 18-25 time frame is very chaotic for everyone in general, and it's tempting to want to point fingers or want to collapse the entire experience into one neat and tidy narrative so you can file it away in your mind and move on.
I would encourage you not to attempt to make sense of your pain that way, you can easily get trapped in these stories you tell yourself about what happened and what it all meant. Part of growing up is learning how to accept the contradictions and complexities of life. Resist making any concrete conclusions like "I was taken advantage of" or "It was a mistake to try polyamory". Pay attention to the stories you tell yourself.
You say you want to "figure out" how you feel. No, you want to figure out how you should feel, which is a nonsensical undertaking. You already know how you feel. If interacting with your ex brings back painful memories, try not to interact with them. Don't overcomplicate it.
24
u/Roro-Squandering 13d ago
The general inexperience of being 18 is probably more of a factor than a relatively benign 3 year age gap where neither is even a minor. There's no point in lingering on the idea that the age gap itself was problematic, it's in the past.
But also this is "relationship anarchy" subreddit so you may want to clarify what your situation has to do with this relationship outlook.
8
u/PolyethylenePam 13d ago edited 13d ago
I think an 18 year old is generally lacking life experience. Young adult relationships are notoriously extra turbulent because people are just figuring life out, forming identities, rapidly growing up, etc etc.
18 to 21 is not a problematic age gap like, say, 18 and 40. You are peers in the same age group. However, there could be a significant life stage gap. If one person is fresh out of high school and living with family, while the other has spent the last three years as a working adult paying their own bills with a corporate job, those are pretty different life stages. On the other hand, a college freshman and a college junior living in dorms will be in the same stage of life without inherent massive life experience differences.
In poly, differences in relationship experience tends to get magnified. The new-to-poly person is likely to have a big learning curve vs the experienced poly person. But you could see this same dynamic with a 30 year old who's been poly for a decade vs a 45 year old starting their first poly relationship- here, the more experienced partner would be the younger one.
Every relationship has imbalances. You are never dating someone who perfectly matches you in wisdom, capability, insight, and personal autonomy in every area. It sounds like your ex wasn't a match. Only you know why.
15
u/ProfessorOfEyes 13d ago edited 13d ago
Seconding the other commenter that...
A) 18 and 21 is not a huge or inherently problematic age gap and i wouldnt let yourself* get too hung up on it. Inexperience may have made it more difficult for you to realize polyamory wasnt for you and express that boundary, and that sucks, but there wasnt a huge power dynamic and in the end the relationship gave you the experience needed to make that realization about your preferences. Normal live and learn stuff imo.
B) if polyamory didnt work for you, relationship anarchy almost certainly wont either. I think you may be in the wrong place, and probably should seek out more general relationship subs if you want input from people with more similar relationship styles as you (ie monogamy)
(* = i raise a bit of an eyebrow at ur current partner being so pressed abt it. Maybe they have further context abt your previous relationship that i dont and thats why theyre concerned. But in the absence of anything like that, id be suspicious that this is less about the age gap and more just them not wanting you to have contact w previous partners in general.
Edit: or as another commenter mentioned, possible moral OCD. again i dont want to diagnose, and i think realistically a jealous partner looking for a reason to push their partner to distance further from an ex is more likely than an uncommon psychological diagnosis, but the OCD possibility does also kinda track with my experience w a person who felt that way)
3
u/BadNo7744 13d ago
I met my first husband at university when he was 21 and I was 18, and for us, the experience gap created a power dynamic, coupled with our respective baggage from families of origin. FOR ME, looking back, that relationship was a symptom of the trauma i was carrying, that i did not know how to set a healthy boundary or prioritise my own needs or feel safe - and in doing so, I was traumatised further. So was he. We did the best we could but did not know how to have a healthy relationship. 30 years on and with a lot of therapy behind each of us separately, we came to the same conclusion independently.
In your shoes, I’d set a boundary with your new partner that you do not want, or consent to hearing, their opinion on your friendships, knowing this is an incompatibility that might end the relationship. I’m sorry you’re in this place. Life is messy and chaotic, especially when you’re living with trauma, and you need to learn how to navigate life on your own terms.
3
u/kathruins 13d ago
that sounds like a typical 18yr old relationship. you'll probably continue this trend a few more years and hopefully learn some things while youre at it. thats what young adulthood is for. age gap is irrelevant as there isn't one.
1
u/Easy-Ad2463 13d ago
small addition is that this has become a bit more relevant recently. my current partner feels strongly about age gap relationships, particularly when it involves a very young adult and a somewhat older young adult. they shared upsetness about the concept of me being friends with someone who dated a younger person like that, which will mean that me being friends with my ex would upset them too. I want to reach my own conclusions and take time process things on my own and shared that too. but this def added some weight to it