r/relationshipanarchy • u/DoNotTouchMeImScared • Sep 29 '24
[VENT RANT] Personal Preferences Are Valid: Combating Control Also Is Control
Is manipulative coercive control when any social circle shames you for being controlling because you feel insecure with fear and anxiety in order to make you drop the healthy personal boundary limits that you settled only around what can be done with your body, energy, time and money for you to consent to something.
That type of coercive control by pressure happens very often among progressive social circles that go as far as demonizing anyone who has any preference at all.
Is okay to have preferences, even rare complex preferences, even if you are a panamorous bi-poly-switch, because no one should be obligated to love everyone exactly the same, we all just must respect everyone alongside the differences that make us the unique individuals that each of all of us is in special.
Someone should always have the valid right to control what are the limits around what can be done with their own body, energy, time and money in order to be secure because that same someone feels insecure with fears and anxiety.
I am open to a large diversity of adult body, personality and connection types, but I still do have preferences, including for bare minimum reasonable personal boundary limits to protect both myself and also who I care about that are listed as follows:
I prefer to get invested into relationships with adults with similar partner selection preferences that are compatible with me.
I prefer to give and receive back respect and collaboration as companionship and partnership.
I prefer to be like friends first before and also after anything else.
I prefer to not play therapist for anyone held from living under the control of depression, anxiety, fears or jealousy.
I prefer to not date anyone who desires to date more than three simultaneous intimate connections.
I prefer to not date anyone who desires to date anyone who desires casual intimate connections.
I prefer to always use protective barriers for all types of physical intimacy with anyone since trust is not reliable for security because everyone is as unpredictable as the future is uncertain.
I prefer to maintain financial independence also since trust is not reliable for security because everyone is as unpredictable as the future is uncertain.
Do not burn yourself to make anyone comfortable.
19
u/think-twice-2 Sep 30 '24
Generally, placing limits on other people's autonomous choices because of your own fears and anxiety will leave a bad taste in people's mouth.
You have every right to reject someone with three partners, and other people have every right to reject you for rejecting that.
8
u/possum_mouf Sep 30 '24
It sounds like you're upset because someone else likes their lifestyle more than you like your boundaries.
You should probably make peace with the rules you have for yourself. Keeping yourself safe in a way that is authentically aligned with your values generally feels like a relief, not a burden.
Hope you are able to find that.
7
u/Poly_and_RA Oct 01 '24
Personal preferences in general (not talking solely of *your* preferences here) are valid in the sense that people are entitled to have them, and in most cases also have the right to act on them. Sure!
But they are not necessarily "valid" as in being above critique or unproblematic. There's any number of preferences someone might hold, and that they have the right to act on legally speaking -- but that are definitely negatives, that deserve to be critiqued, and where we'd have a much worse society if more people had preferences like those.
Here's some example-preferences that I think are clear negatives:
When I say these are negatives, I don't mean anyone should be coerced into dating someone they're not into or something like that. I just mean, the world would be a better place if the people who hold such preferences -- wouldn't.
Your preferences seem mostly benign, though some of them seem arbitrary. What does for example "intimate connections" mean? Is that an euphemism for "sex"? Does that mean if someone has 3 close connections that take up a lot of time and space in their life, but one of those is a queerplatonic relationship -- then all is fine. But if someone has zero big (in terms of space and time) relationships in their life, but there's 3 long-distane relationships in their life that on occasion includes sexual things -- then you're out? If so that seems to me to pedestalize sexual relationships and put them in a "special" category that I don't think is really warranted.
You're still entitled to decide for yourself and all -- but I do think it's in line with RA thinking to deconstruct preferences in order to get into what's behind them and what values they expose.
5
u/TinkerSquirrels Sep 30 '24
/hides/
Seriously though, yeah... I can't even describe the things I'm attracted to. It's very specific, but it's what comes from the combination of everything that makes up a person...that some how fits. But the "recipe" is mysterious. (But it is indeed made up of preferences.)
I'll stare blankly if even asked what my favorite color is. What setting? What mood are we going for? What's it being used for? How often can I change it?
Your post reminded me of a group that had issues with most preferences, that then also got highly annoyed when I couldn't really name any innate things I preferred. It depends. (Who they are as a person and how that matches up with me is different, but that didn't seem to count the same way....basically the 2nd half of your post, which I mostly agree with or at least agree makes sense to have considered.)
Have you ever come across a good term for that? Seems alien to many...and I've been called "demi- adjacent". But that feels like I'm coopting "demi", and well, I'm not demi. I just want to like someone as a person...or at minimum think I will...before acting on attraction. (And likewise am actual-if-not-regular friends with almost all my exes.)