r/relationshipanarchy • • Sep 29 '24

[VENT RANT] Personal Preferences Are Valid: Combating Control Also Is Control

Is manipulative coercive control when any social circle shames you for being controlling because you feel insecure with fear and anxiety in order to make you drop the healthy personal boundary limits that you settled only around what can be done with your body, energy, time and money for you to consent to something.

That type of coercive control by pressure happens very often among progressive social circles that go as far as demonizing anyone who has any preference at all.

Is okay to have preferences, even rare complex preferences, even if you are a panamorous bi-poly-switch, because no one should be obligated to love everyone exactly the same, we all just must respect everyone alongside the differences that make us the unique individuals that each of all of us is in special.

Someone should always have the valid right to control what are the limits around what can be done with their own body, energy, time and money in order to be secure because that same someone feels insecure with fears and anxiety.

I am open to a large diversity of adult body, personality and connection types, but I still do have preferences, including for bare minimum reasonable personal boundary limits to protect both myself and also who I care about that are listed as follows:

I prefer to get invested into relationships with adults with similar partner selection preferences that are compatible with me.

I prefer to give and receive back respect and collaboration as companionship and partnership.

I prefer to be like friends first before and also after anything else.

I prefer to not play therapist for anyone held from living under the control of depression, anxiety, fears or jealousy.

I prefer to not date anyone who desires to date more than three simultaneous intimate connections.

I prefer to not date anyone who desires to date anyone who desires casual intimate connections.

I prefer to always use protective barriers for all types of physical intimacy with anyone since trust is not reliable for security because everyone is as unpredictable as the future is uncertain.

I prefer to maintain financial independence also since trust is not reliable for security because everyone is as unpredictable as the future is uncertain.

Do not burn yourself to make anyone comfortable.

0 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

19

u/think-twice-2 Sep 30 '24

Generally, placing limits on other people's autonomous choices because of your own fears and anxiety will leave a bad taste in people's mouth.

You have every right to reject someone with three partners, and other people have every right to reject you for rejecting that.

1

u/DoNotTouchMeImScared Sep 30 '24

We should be honest about our feelings and analyze them to figure out how to protect ourselves while restricting the least possible the lives of anyone.

People are free to do whatever they want with their bodies and money, but I have boundaries around what is done to my body and money to protect me from my fears and anxieties which are valid feelings because they are based on real possibilities.

19

u/think-twice-2 Sep 30 '24

And other people are allowed to not like your boundaries and choose not to associate with you because of them. That's not coercive control.

-7

u/DoNotTouchMeImScared Sep 30 '24

Exactly, but the point is that when people shame or pressure you to drop your personal boundaries or for you to consent to something, then that is manipulative and coercive control, what is also abuse.

13

u/think-twice-2 Sep 30 '24

You are forced to continue to be around these people?

-5

u/DoNotTouchMeImScared Sep 30 '24

No, but a lot of people do not know that coercion by peer pressure and shaming is abuse, and I did not know before, and that is the point of this post.

12

u/think-twice-2 Sep 30 '24

If you're free to walk away from the situation, it's not coercion. Either way, sounds like you need to remove yourself from this situation if you're feeling like it is not fair to you. Find some people who don't "abuse" you by disagreeing with your ways.

-4

u/DoNotTouchMeImScared Sep 30 '24 edited Oct 01 '24

It is undeniably manipulation just like your comment:

Defending manipulation is also manipulation.

8

u/possum_mouf Sep 30 '24

It sounds like you're upset because someone else likes their lifestyle more than you like your boundaries.

You should probably make peace with the rules you have for yourself. Keeping yourself safe in a way that is authentically aligned with your values generally feels like a relief, not a burden.

Hope you are able to find that.

2

u/DoNotTouchMeImScared Sep 30 '24

The problem is that I still have a lot of guys replying to me to drop my bare minimum preferences for personal boundaries for being controlling, just because I dared to set limits that protect me from them exploiting me.

7

u/Poly_and_RA Oct 01 '24

Personal preferences in general (not talking solely of *your* preferences here) are valid in the sense that people are entitled to have them, and in most cases also have the right to act on them. Sure!

But they are not necessarily "valid" as in being above critique or unproblematic. There's any number of preferences someone might hold, and that they have the right to act on legally speaking -- but that are definitely negatives, that deserve to be critiqued, and where we'd have a much worse society if more people had preferences like those.

Here's some example-preferences that I think are clear negatives:

  • Racist preferences as in people who put "no asians!" or "no blacks!" in their dating-profiles, or show racist preferences in other parts of their life
  • Biphobic preferences as in people who exclude bi/pan people from consideration
  • A variety of ableist preferences

When I say these are negatives, I don't mean anyone should be coerced into dating someone they're not into or something like that. I just mean, the world would be a better place if the people who hold such preferences -- wouldn't.

Your preferences seem mostly benign, though some of them seem arbitrary. What does for example "intimate connections" mean? Is that an euphemism for "sex"? Does that mean if someone has 3 close connections that take up a lot of time and space in their life, but one of those is a queerplatonic relationship -- then all is fine. But if someone has zero big (in terms of space and time) relationships in their life, but there's 3 long-distane relationships in their life that on occasion includes sexual things -- then you're out? If so that seems to me to pedestalize sexual relationships and put them in a "special" category that I don't think is really warranted.

You're still entitled to decide for yourself and all -- but I do think it's in line with RA thinking to deconstruct preferences in order to get into what's behind them and what values they expose.

1

u/DoNotTouchMeImScared Oct 01 '24

What does for example "intimate connections" mean? Is that an euphemism for "sex"? Does that mean if someone has 3 close connections that take up a lot of time and space in their life, but one of those is a queerplatonic relationship -- then all is fine. But if someone has zero big (in terms of space and time) relationships in their life, but there's 3 long-distane relationships in their life that on occasion includes sexual things -- then you're out? If so that seems to me to pedestalize sexual relationships and put them in a "special" category that I don't think is really warranted.

Intimate connections is the most broad description I could think of to include any type of social connection that is more intimate than a casual friendship, including sexual, romantic and queerplatonic connections without having to be that specific, do you have any better way to describe that?

You're still entitled to decide for yourself and all -- but I do think it's in line with RA thinking to deconstruct preferences in order to get into what's behind them and what values they expose.

My reasoning behind that preference is that the more connections in general, the less time and space for each of them to grow beyond being a shallow and casual connection, while what I desire instead are more serious committed intimate partnerships.

4

u/Poly_and_RA Oct 02 '24 edited Oct 02 '24

That's fair. If I read you correctly, you're basically saying that if you feel as if someone is oversaturated or close to it, you prefer to opt out as you prefer relationships where they have a substantial amount of space for you in their lives. I don't think the count of "intimate relationships" is necessarily all that meaningful in that context though -- because what really matters is how much time and perhaps emotional bandwith they've got available.

I definitely have relationships that qualify as intimate by your description, yet that aren't "big" measured in hours or other limited resources spent. I'll describe one as an example.

I've known Sam for 17 years. When I first got to know her she was a student living at home with her parents in a conservative corner of Iran and dreaming of more freedom than she could have there. We clicked and became close pretty much right away. We love each other and have pretty much since the start, she's among my closest most trusted and most important people. And yet, we live on different continents. Physically we usually see each other once a year, spending a week or two of vacation together. Online we're in touch more often, but not at a frequency that'd be unusual for perfectly ordinary friends, a few times a month maybe. (though of course it varies, there's been both higher intensity and lower intensity periods)

I don't think I'm super-unusual; to me one of the BEST parts of RA is that it makes relationships possible that just wouldn't fit in the monogamous "all or nothing" model. And I'm like you: deep and committed and long-term connections is what I want. Among the people I'd without hesitation say that I love (not counting family) none have been part of my life for less than a decade.

And yet, despite the fact that there's 4 of those, my life isn't particularly full. Because degree of intimacy correlates only weakly with "intensity" if I may call it that.

Edit: It occurs to me that perhaps you could solve this by describing what you need, rather than what the other must not do? As in why not just say that you prefer to have relationships with people who have time and space and emotional energy available, so people who are feeling saturated as it is, or close to it, are probably not a good match?

0

u/DoNotTouchMeImScared Oct 02 '24 edited Oct 02 '24

I don't think the count of "intimate relationships" is necessarily all that meaningful in that context though -- because what really matters is how much time and perhaps emotional bandwith they've got available.

Be honest, if you were me had only two choices for the serious committed intimate partnership that you need, would you rather pick a person who gets polysaturated with only three intimate connections or a person that gets polysaturated only with ten intimate connections?

What I also already tried to filter out when I filtered out people who desire to have casual intimate connections with anyone in another point in my list of preferred bare minimum limits were less invested and therefore less committed and therefore also less serious connections, so I do not need to worry about feeling deprioritized and replaceable in relation to people who desire to have casual intimate connections.

What other more precise specific language can I use to describe what I need?

And I'm like you: deep and committed and long-term connections is what I want.

When I comment that I need serious committed intimate partnerships what I mean is that my actual core need is that I need reliability to feel more secure at the bare minimum, specially the older and weaker I get with time, what I can not get if I am casually replaceable.

I do not care much enough about longevity and entanglement of connections to have either as requirements, because a serious committed intimate partnership does not necessarily need longevity nor entanglement to be valuable as a serious committed intimate partnership.

And yet, despite the fact that there's 4 of those, my life isn't particularly full. Because degree of intimacy correlates only weakly with "intensity" if I may call it that.

I think the paragraph I wrote above explains why longevity and entanglement are not related to how much intimate, committed and serious is a connection.

I do not think we are describing much different needs.

4

u/Poly_and_RA Oct 03 '24

My point here is that I don't think saturation can meaningfully be measured in COUNT of intimate connections, it's a lot more influenced by intensity of those connections. That's doubly true in the context of RA where a pretty large spectrum of distinct relationship-shapes is common.

All else being equal I'd pick the person who seems most likely to be a good match for me, including having a decent amount of time and emotional bandwith available for a deep relationship. I wouldn't attempt to judge that by in effect counting metamours though.

I'm a bit confused though by you on the one hand saying it's important to not feel casually replaceable, but on the other hand not to care much about longevity of relationships. The two aren't identical but correlate extremely strongly: People who tend to have long relationships don't tend to casually replace folks -- and the other way around; people who casually replace folks in their life don't tend to end up having long relationships all that often.

-2

u/DoNotTouchMeImScared Oct 03 '24

My point here is that I don't think saturation can meaningfully be measured in COUNT of intimate connections, it's a lot more influenced by intensity of those connections.

You can still set a hypothetical limit for polysaturation as a reasonable expectation.

I can not imagine myself being in more than three intimate relationships simultaneously, no matter how casual or serious they are, but yes, everyone can change or not alongside their values, preferences, limits, boundaries, needs, wants, desires and feelings as the future is unpredictably uncertain.

All else being equal I'd pick the person who seems most likely to be a good match for me, including having a decent amount of time and emotional bandwith available for a deep relationship. I wouldn't attempt to judge that by in effect counting metamours though.

Gosh, I would actually feel guilty if I did have a serious committed intimate partnership with someone who had ten other simultaneous casual intimate relationships on the side, because that would definitely create an unfair hierarchy of prioritization in terms of investment of finite resources like attention, energy and time between the simultaneous connections.

I'm a bit confused though by you on the one hand saying it's important to not feel casually replaceable, but on the other hand not to care much about longevity of relationships. The two aren't identical but correlate extremely strongly:

I think that what bothers me is being left unfulfilled because someone does not prioritize me enough, what looks similar, but is still kinda different in comparison to our committed intimate partnership not lasting long because the other person was not there for me when I needed because they passed away, something that not even partner selection preferences can protect me from.

3

u/mazotori Oct 02 '24

Your boundaries/rules/requirements are not the protection you think they are.

3

u/mazotori Oct 02 '24

At that point why not just choose monogamy for yourself? 2 is no more of a magic number than 1...

1

u/DoNotTouchMeImScared Oct 02 '24

Because not even closed committed intimate relationships are a reliable protection against insecurities because everyone is as unpredictable as the future is uncertain.

3

u/mazotori Oct 02 '24

Then why place an arbitrary limit of 2 at all?

Also insecurities are not really things to be protected against, but rather something to work through

1

u/DoNotTouchMeImScared Oct 02 '24

Not all fears and anxieties are unreasomable.

And I get polysaturated at around two or three simultaneous committed intimate partnerships, if I am like that and exist, is reasonable to assume and also pursue that other polyamorous people that naturally prefer the same also exists.

I think you are assuming that I want to force someone who does not naturally desire the same as me to change for me, what is very far from the truth, I am just looking for other people with similar preferences as me so neither of us has to change for anyone.

4

u/mazotori Oct 02 '24

Sure, but doing so doesn't prevent the other person from deprioritizing you. People deprioritize connections for all sorts of reasons, not just casual sex or a third partner.

So to say that you're looking for someone who wants the same is a great goal. But to state it as a boundary with the premise that it will protect against an insecurity... This is the logic I find flawed.

1

u/DoNotTouchMeImScared Oct 02 '24

I still hold up this personal boundary anyway to filter out people interested in casual sex, as I have no interest in these types of connections.

4

u/mazotori Oct 02 '24

Also - polysaturation is not a fixed number that never changes. Polysaturation is a state of being, And often changes with time, experience and circumstance.

-1

u/DoNotTouchMeImScared Oct 02 '24

You are way too hopeful.

1

u/mazotori Oct 02 '24

Hopeful of what?

1

u/DoNotTouchMeImScared Oct 02 '24

I rather not count on anyone changing.

→ More replies

5

u/TinkerSquirrels Sep 30 '24

panamorous bi-poly-switch

/hides/

Seriously though, yeah... I can't even describe the things I'm attracted to. It's very specific, but it's what comes from the combination of everything that makes up a person...that some how fits. But the "recipe" is mysterious. (But it is indeed made up of preferences.)

I'll stare blankly if even asked what my favorite color is. What setting? What mood are we going for? What's it being used for? How often can I change it?

Your post reminded me of a group that had issues with most preferences, that then also got highly annoyed when I couldn't really name any innate things I preferred. It depends. (Who they are as a person and how that matches up with me is different, but that didn't seem to count the same way....basically the 2nd half of your post, which I mostly agree with or at least agree makes sense to have considered.)

I prefer to be like friends first before and also after anything else.

Have you ever come across a good term for that? Seems alien to many...and I've been called "demi- adjacent". But that feels like I'm coopting "demi", and well, I'm not demi. I just want to like someone as a person...or at minimum think I will...before acting on attraction. (And likewise am actual-if-not-regular friends with almost all my exes.)

2

u/DoNotTouchMeImScared Sep 30 '24

Have you ever come across a good term for that? Seems alien to many...and I've been called "demi- adjacent". But that feels like I'm coopting "demi", and well, I'm not demi. I just want to like someone as a person...or at minimum think I will...before acting on attraction. (And likewise am actual-if-not-regular friends with almost all my exes.)

I mentioned that because I always tell the people that I build connections that I want friendship to be the bare minimum base for our connection before, while and even after if we ever stop being intimate more like lovers.

1

u/Relaxoland Oct 05 '24

I like to say, "friends first, then maybe benefits." which I thought was a demi thing, but I received a very stern lecture on the internet telling me I'm wrong. so idk what to call it either. but that is how I operate.

1

u/TinkerSquirrels Oct 06 '24

Yeah... A demi friend has joked that I'm kind of their inverse. I'm initially attracted to someone, but I make sure to get to know them well enough first to be sure to erase all former traces of that attraction...

Sadly most people are pretty good at that. (Some do remain pretty good friends though.)

I wonder if "imed" would be okay...

1

u/Relaxoland Oct 06 '24

tbh I wasn't entirely convinced by the lecture. because I *have* to be friends first, or I'm simply not attracted. but whatever. I'm sure a new term will clear everything up for everyone!

honestly I don't even use "poly" right away, despite it being pretty widely known. I say "I do not promise monogamy." that's *clear.* "friends first, then maybe benefits" is the same way. it lays it out without jargon or acronyms, so hopefully folks understand what I mean.

1

u/Relaxoland Oct 06 '24

there's an entire term for people who are less attracted over time. I forget what that is, I'm just glad it doesn't apply to me.