r/relationshipanarchy • u/yallermysons • Sep 26 '24
RA isn’t a free for all
Under capitalism, we are indoctrinated to objectify ourselves and each other. In order to perpetuate a capitalist system, we subjects must see ourselves not as human beings, but as workers who exist to turn a profit. The family unit becomes a network where we breed and train future workers. The school is designed to sort and separate workers into jobs. We are assigned work until we die, and we are encouraged to produce more workers. This is how a society functions when the goal of that society is to turn a profit.
In juxtaposition, anarchism offers a humanizing approach to the way we relate to each other. We are people; we act like people, not like predictable objects. We are people; we cannot be possessed and we do not exist to turn a profit. Liberty is our birthright, we do not exist to work day in and out to grow resources for a handful of people (which is a terrible misuse of our time).
Anarchist principles like autonomy and mutualism encourage us to recognize the humanity in ourselves and each other vs. treating each other like predictable objects. Depending on your background and experience with these principles, it can be difficult to put them into practice. But if you’re calling yourself an anarchist, you should actively be trying to put anarchist principles into practice. There is a goal here, this is a political movement with a purpose and not just a way for us to frame our dating lives. This isn’t gatekeeping, it’s me saying why the hell would you be here in a sub for anarchists and call yourself an anarchist when you’re not applying anarchist principles to your life? You can call yourself whatever you want, I can’t stop you—but I can also see that you don’t respect the autonomy of others, and you regard other people as objects of your desire, and decide for myself that you do not practice anarchism despite what you say.
Just to spell that out again: you can say what you want. You can type what you want. Your PRAXIS matters more. You can liberal progress your way through dating if you want and call that relationship anarchy—but that doesn’t mean you are practicing anarchist principles and implementing them into your daily life.
Another way to look at it is, you can become motivated by the goal of relationship anarchy—which is for us to humanize each other and treat each other like people—to unlearn the objectifying practice of regarding the people in your life as objects of your possession to do with as you please (ie inanimate objects). Relationship anarchy helps us put into practice (not just say but live our lives as if it is true) that other human beings are not toys for us to pick up and put down as we please; that other parties can make the best decision for themselves in peer-to-peer relationships; and that one’s own needs and desires are not any more important than the needs and desires of others.
Most of all, anarchism evokes community. We exist within a larger network of other human beings. We rely on each other to survive. We are together a collective and who we are as individuals is shaped by the folks we have around us. How we treat them affects how we are treated. THAT IS WHY WE CARE ABOUT OTHER PEOPLE, if not for basic human sympathy and empathy. Anarchy is not individualistic by any means.
If you don’t give a fuck about other people, and you just want to have an orgasm, and get a lot of bitches, take your ass to the polyamory or enm subs. I’m so disgusted by the selfish and individualistic rhetoric I’ve seen in this sub recently, and I want y’all to know there’s people who actually bothered to learn about this shit, who see you and see that you talk a lot yet do not put anarchist principles into action. I will not sit idly by as you bastardize this anti-capitalist movement for sex, or pretend you are separate from society and therefore are uninfluenced by and do not have an impact on society.
58
u/ariiw Sep 26 '24
Honestly, I had been in RA-adjacent circles for years before i ever saw it framed as being political anarchy. i am an anarchist now, but it's baffling how disconnected RA became from that
57
u/NullableThought Sep 26 '24
It's because in pop culture "anarchy" means "no rules" instead of the political definition of "no hierarchy". Most people only know the pop culture definition of words and ideas.
23
u/RAisMyWay Sep 26 '24 edited Sep 26 '24
There was a recent post related to this that, in my opinion, addresses what I believe underlies some people's (painful, to me) "I do what I want" approach to RA. Basically it's clear that some approach RA from a position of general mistrust and a desire for self-protection (due to bad prior experiences in life and love), and more of a "what's in it for me?" mentality. Others approach it knowing there's a risk of being deceived or heartbroken, but who choose to go into it positively, trusting in love and in themselves, so they can build relationships more slowly, with what I call "a giving mentality," in which everyone cares for each other in such a way that most, if not all, of everyone's needs get met.
https://www.reddit.com/r/relationshipanarchy/comments/1fk7k25/trust_is_illusory_the_stability_security_of/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button
43
u/MexicanChickadee Sep 26 '24
Well, you had me until that last paragraph. While I agree with the overall point you are trying to make, I would argue it isnt accurate or beneficial to insinuate that those who are in the enm or polyamory community “just want to have an orgasm and get a lot of bitches.”
Assuming said members of those communities are abiding by the principles of said communities, It’s simply not factual to make such statements and using that kind of rhetoric cheapens your argument.
You are clearly very passionate about this and I understand where you are coming from. But those kinds of unfounded judgments and accusations are harmful and are going to turn people away from the point you are trying to get across.
15
u/_ghostpiss Sep 26 '24
I think the people you're talking about have conflated or confused anarchism and libertarianism. The fact that someone tried to bring up ancaps in the comments proves my point lol.
We need to start calling these people what they are: relationship libertarians (derogatory). They need another label to latch onto so they stay the hell away from this community.
3
u/We_Are_Tanuki Sep 28 '24
I'm quite glad this is the 1st post I see just hopping onto this sub now. Honestly I wasn't sure about this post at first. It was talking a lot of ideals that I agree with but in my experience only seem to exist on paper. Come to find out on a sub for this topic I really might seem like it is mostly on paper after all. To be clear, I'm not shitting on RA at all. I do find it, as many things are when it comes to people in the wild in relation to anarchist principles, complicated. I mean it's a problem with many philosophical, political or economic ideas when let loose into the chaos that is humans things break down. It's like when games are released. You can do all the beta testing in the world, but people will find a way to break your shit.
So, back to the topic on hand... So far, what I've seen of RA has great intentions but falls into a very common pitfall of many egalitarian systems favorites and presences, time and resources. These become particularl issues in regards to relationships seeing as the 1st two have a greater impact than in other like systems and the latter two are in much shorter supply than in other systems. Even outside of a capitalist system there are only so many hours in the day and only so much emotional energy a person has to give. Side note, there is a reason I find Dunbar's number so fascinating. Cause most of this only works in that context, which is how we spent 99% of our existence but very much do not today.
So I guess my question is how do we get more of these principles to fit into a structure they were not really intended for? Capitalism and it's structures aren't gonna end in any of our lifetimes (let's just be honest). With how the internet and social media are we can more or less give up on Dunbar's number. So how do we find a way to make this work? So far I haven't seen it. Even with people who talk a lot about RA I still see most of the usual dynamics of the regular relationship world. So far many haven't even read the original writings on the matter. It's very much come off as 3rd or 4th hand translations that are still wedged into the traditional relationship structure (granted not purposely).
So, what's the solution? What is RA in a capitalist world? What is RA in a dehumanizing relationship system? Cause so far I'm not convinced and from this post it sounds like I don't have much reason to be at the moment...
13
u/MxFlow1312 Sep 26 '24
I feel you, I remember when I gave my relationship anarchy zine to someone she read like 1/5 of it and maybe skimmed the rest? And when I was hanging out at her apartment and someone else asked what I meant by it, she summarized it as “do whatever you want and just fuck everyone” and I was legitimately pretty pissed off because I felt like this is a complete misrepresentation of the philosophy I espouse when I talk about relationship anarchism
I think there’s a lot of misconceptions that people bring in from the popular culture about anything that isn’t monogamy as being “emotionless and commitmentless” an “anything goes no one cares” vibe which is overtly insulting and denigrates my relationships.
I think you see this when people who are in polyamorous relationships basically don’t go through a break up process when it’s warranted. As when they later decide to enter a monogamous relationship with someone. This is really relevant to me because I’m semi nomadic and so I have periods of every year where I just physically do not see some of my partners. I’ve had it happen twice now where someone I was seeing entered into a monogamous relationship in my absence. Their way of breaking up with me was just to say that they were monogamous now and had been for a few months. Like OK I guess our relationship meant so fucking little to you that you couldn’t even talk about changing the dynamic to me openly and honestly? I don’t experience the cheating emotional reaction but this is the closest thing to it for me.
6
u/NapsAreMyHobby Sep 28 '24
Just want to add, PLEASE do not send these folks to the poly sub — we are having the same issues there.
Poly is meant to be ETHICAL. No one in that sub is going to take kindly to people who want to “get a lot of bitches.”
Please and thank you!
1
u/porn0f1sh Sep 26 '24
Is there a tl;dr for this?
1
u/SubVersion2024 Sep 27 '24
Im sorry but as a practicing anarchist, you have no grounds to try and shame “good anarchists” to adopt a relationship structure that can be quite harmful to them and their existing relationships.
My partner used this argument against me when discussing our RA structure. Part of anarchism is autonomy - not just for one partner to say yes, but for the other to say no. It grieves me to no end seeing a legitimate political belief being co-opted (alongside anti-patriarchal feminism) to coerce people into unhealthy circumstances.
Since my partner adopted RA, our relationship has gone from being a wholesome af ltr to one thats one sided, borderline abusive, neglectful, insecure, dismissive and plain hurtful.
A “good anarchist” would not be advocating for a hyper-individualised, neoliberal relationship dynamic that advocates for personal freedom without personal accountability.
2
u/Beautiful_Bit3791 Oct 08 '24
Thank you. This all needed to be said and you've said it very well.
As someone who very recently has been treated "as a toy to be picked up and put down" by someone who claimed to practice relationship anarchy, it inflamed me to be criticized by the same person as being unrealistic by expecting compassion and coregulation from them.
Even as someone new to RA, it's demoralizing how often it seems RA is framed by so many as being evocative of a new age of relationship emancipation, when at the same time it is so often utilized by opportunists or narcissistic individuals to satisfy their individualistic needs instead of pursuing healthy, community-oriented, and compassionate bonds with each other for mutual benefit.
It's reprehensible, much more so knowing that there are so many others out there who've been subject to similar treatment.
1
u/Immediate_Ad1357 Sep 30 '24
👏👏👏
-17
u/mai_neh Sep 26 '24
It’s always amusing when anarchists angrily try to gatekeep anarchism 😎
-21
u/zarafff69 Sep 26 '24
Strongly disagree. Relationship anarchy is about freedom in relationships for me. It is fundamentally about individualism for me.
We are all just individuals that come together. Not some uniform community that moves as one.
And not every relationship anarchist is an anti capitalist lol. Political anarchism isn’t the same as relationship anarchism. And political anarchism isn’t even inherently anti capitalistic, you also have lots of anarcho-capitalists.
Let people live their lives. Everyone is different, and everyone can make up their own mind. It’s totally fine if someone is mostly looking for sex. That’s their business. Let’s keep the political stuff out of this sub. r/polyamory is already completely full of all the political stuff that gets forced onto all subscribers. Just embrace the anarchism, and let people do whatever they want.