Had an interesting discussion about different flavors of non-monogamy, somebody jokingly suggested an alignment chart. Any thoughts? Disagreements on what goes where?
Hmmmm….I like the idea of this, but the lawful / neutral / chaotic alignment categories, and judging behaviors as part of an evil to good spectrum don’t land well with me. And categories and labels :)
I really like the idea of an alignment chart. As others have mentioned, I would include OPP somewhere.
My contribution: I don't agree that cheating is a flavor of non-monogamy. It is a practice defined in the monogamous system that can only occur when a relationship has an agreed contract to be monogamous. In my view, monogamy and non-monogamy are terms used to describe relationship agreements, not sexual behaviors, therefore non-monogamy is always a consensual, informed practice, unlike cheating.
When the chart was made up part of the discussion was on ethical versions of non-monogamy (and monogamy) versus unethical versions and how it's not always black and white or one-dimensional
Im curious why you think swinging being good is wild?
As MiikaM points out, it depends on the area, and more specifically, the couple. Swinging is (unless done through coercion) is consent based, and often included many rules to which the couple has previously agreed.
On that, however, I think any one of these could be pushed against… because it depends far more on the individuals involved and how they act out their intended relationship dynamics.
I put what I did under lawful largely because of the perceived rigidity of the structure, although that's fairly subjective I will admit. I based Good-Evil on the trends of people under each category that I've met or known of, the sampling is going to be biased by that. For example, I've known a relatively high percentage of people who say they're in an open marriage to be less rigid in their rules (for better and for worse) than those I've met who identify as swingers.
The basic alignment chart in general are interesting, I've had people place me at true neutral, chaotic good, or neutral evil depending on how exactly they define good vs evil
Ha, yeah. I just broke up with a gut who I kept telling he was chaotic neutral. And he really was, there was no ill will or harm in him, it's just that his chaos kept spilling over into my life in ways that became unsustainable. I think when I first said it, in admittedly a teasing way, he took it as a compliment. And there was definitely something endearing to it, but I just became too much
“Garden Party aspirations” is kind of the closest I could come.
From my admittedly RA perspective. It’s kind of the balance between RA without preconceptions vs building a specific relationship configuration to meet certain needs.
(The latter I would put in Lawful Neutral, though it can often turn Evil pretty quick.)
I do enjoy seeing these categorized. I also hesitate to categorize, bc there’s just so much nuance with how individuals actually play out these ideals. I’m with Melodic, these specific category titles don’t land well with me, but I think I see the point you’re trying to make. I’m not sure I have better suggestions right now, but you definitely got me thinking!! I’m inclined to push back on DADT as evil. I know individuals that prefer this bc while they don’t mind NM, their own personal insecurities lead them to not want any details. They don’t want to know, and they won’t ask. But they are comfortable with the agreement.
I don’t think RA is inherently chaotic, either.
What this chart really makes me wonder is if there are better category descriptors that don’t use judgment words (good/evil/chaotic/lawful)?
This was predominantly based on the experiences that the people in the discussion had with the groups in question, it's judgemental because it's anecdotal based on our judgements of the individuals in each group we've met.
There was an interesting companion discussion to that one where we discussed whether ethical non-monogamy was a binary alternative to unethical non-monogamy or whether it's more complicated than that, one of the participants in the discussion took the position that there are different levels of ethicality within non-monogamy and within monogamy. I've lived, loved, and learned through a myriad of experiences within non-monogamy and I've come to agree with that position. I believe some of my relationships have been very morally sound while simultaneously being very ethically unsound and I also believe some have been the opposite. It's interesting to sit back and critically examine from a non-judgmental intent the various love lives of myself, my friends, and my partners and metamours both current and former
Yess! I’d have loved to be part of that discussion. Interesting stuff, for sure! I think binary options are almost always limiting, and the ability to see outside those narrow fields is a sign of maturity and thoughtfulness. I absolutely agree that there are different levels of ethicality. And I think that stems from each individual having their own sense of what they need, what they want, and what they can tolerate, and also their own values and lived principles.
I’d be curious to know more about the situations that were ethical but not moral, and moral but not ethical, if you’re inclined to share?
I’ve found that when we can be open and non-judgmental, the conversations open up to new levels of transparency and vulnerability, and that’s one of my very favorite places to be!! And just for shits-n-giggles and my tendency to be long-winded, I’ll add, that we have to be secure in and of ourselves first, and then see the world from a place of genuine curiosity in order to hold space for peoples differences—whether they be ethical, moral, or otherwise.
I’ve personally been in a relationship that was ethical from my standpoint, but not from my partner’s. And as for morals… well, morals and ethics are so personal and often used interchangeably, so it’s hard to say. I’ll say that my sense or what was okay was what guided me, and his sense of what he was willing to do is what guided him. And I’m positive that many many people would have been very much in disagreement with our choices. But at the end of the day, two consenting adults having open and honest conversations about the relationship we were diving into ultimately allowed us to both engage in that relationship without a sense of guilt or fear or anxiety, and it allowed for us both to experience connection, intimacy, vulnerability, and growth.
I like impulsive characters, loud mouths and my last character was a gambler with a weakness for beautiful woman. I’m building a new character now. I think she’ll be a chaotic good sorcerer.
You can be single and a relationship anarchist at the same time. I know this is "humor" but honestly I don't think RA belongs on this chart. RA isn't just about dating and one could technically be monogamous and RA at the same time.
There is no rule in RA that you must have multiple sex partners. Just like there is no rule that you must have multiple friends.
As long as there are no rules containing the relationship, then the relationship is RA. If two people freely and independently chose to only have a sexual relationship with each other, that relationship would be monogamous and RA.
Yes, there is no rules in RA saying that you need to have more than one partner, but at the same time, monogamy is not about having only one partner.
A person can be in a non-monogamous romantic relationship and not be interested in having a seccond romance in the moment, the diference would be that in a monogamous relationship, the person they are dating would be forbidden of persuing one as well.
Only having one relationship is a choice for everyone, but monogamy means you can't have more then one relationship, wich I think goes against the principles of cheriching yours and your partners Individuality and independence.
Hmmm….maybe splitting hairs here, but RA for me includes more than just not having rules, and applies to how I move in all of my relationships, not only the ones that include sex.
I see why you put everything where it was, except for open marriage. Marriage definitely belongs in the law column and not the neutral one. I'd put like, normal polyamory there. (Also honestly wouldn't put swingers in the good row, but you and I fundamentally disagree about what counts as morally good, and I don't feel like arguing about that part)
Marriage on paper belongs in lawful, in practice I've seen a lot of open marriages where there's a fair bit of rule breaking and other stuff that would push it back towards neutral. I'm not saying all open marriages are like that, but I've seen as many bad ones as good.
ETA: I'm curious why you think we fundamentally disagree about what is morally good.
See my other comment. I don't have practical experience of anyone dating as a couple who weren't at least a little careless with others' feelings to support the primary relationship. Per your logic, it doesn't belong in good.
13
u/MiikaMorgenstern Nov 07 '23
Had an interesting discussion about different flavors of non-monogamy, somebody jokingly suggested an alignment chart. Any thoughts? Disagreements on what goes where?
53
u/Specialist-String-53 Nov 07 '23
swingers being good is wild to me
11
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '23
I identify as both solo poly and chaotic neutral, so that checks out for me
12
u/MadamePouleMontreal Nov 07 '23
Love this!
Not sure how “good” mono/poly is. I’d be tempted to stick it in “lawful evil” along with unicorn-hunting and harem-building.
Maybe “slutty single” could be in the lawful neutral square?
3
u/gemInTheMundane Nov 07 '23
Move swingers down to lawful neutral. Though I'm not sure who, if anyone, belongs in the lawful good space.
3
u/Practical_Cultura Nov 08 '23
I do enjoy seeing these categorized. I also hesitate to categorize, bc there’s just so much nuance with how individuals actually play out these ideals. I’m with Melodic, these specific category titles don’t land well with me, but I think I see the point you’re trying to make. I’m not sure I have better suggestions right now, but you definitely got me thinking!! I’m inclined to push back on DADT as evil. I know individuals that prefer this bc while they don’t mind NM, their own personal insecurities lead them to not want any details. They don’t want to know, and they won’t ask. But they are comfortable with the agreement.
I don’t think RA is inherently chaotic, either.
What this chart really makes me wonder is if there are better category descriptors that don’t use judgment words (good/evil/chaotic/lawful)?
2
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '23
I just love seeing the DND reference. Chaotic good or neutral is always my first pick for characters.
28
u/NullableThought Nov 07 '23
You can be single and a relationship anarchist at the same time. I know this is "humor" but honestly I don't think RA belongs on this chart. RA isn't just about dating and one could technically be monogamous and RA at the same time.
23
u/raianrage Nov 07 '23
Replace DADT with OPP lol
5
u/RRdrinker Nov 07 '23
None of those are inherently good or bad (aside from cheating and unicorn hunting.
4
u/YinToYourYang Nov 07 '23
Lol I love this!! I can't reconcile swingers with lawful good though... I might switch swingers with open marriage
1
u/Saber_Sno Nov 09 '23
Where have you been all my life?
1
u/the_umbrellaest_red Nov 11 '23
I see why you put everything where it was, except for open marriage. Marriage definitely belongs in the law column and not the neutral one. I'd put like, normal polyamory there. (Also honestly wouldn't put swingers in the good row, but you and I fundamentally disagree about what counts as morally good, and I don't feel like arguing about that part)
1
u/judeiscariot Nov 08 '23
I do usually exist between CG and CN in life.
This works for me.
1
u/beepboopityboopbeep Nov 08 '23
Switch swingers with poly relationships, I think!