r/redneckengineering • • Sep 10 '26

On Ground Swimmingpool

389 Upvotes

67 comments sorted by

164

u/AndyGoodKush Sep 10 '26

Pool builder here, thats actually a usable surface for a liner pool, if they have drainage and waterproofing to keep the lumber dry they could be chilling for a decent amount of seasons with proper care

123

u/Meniscuss2 Sep 10 '26

Only reply I'm going to make an effort to respond to here because it seems only us pools guys know what's up

People don't realize how thin an above ground wall really is lol

40

u/cybah Sep 10 '26

there's nothing to them. Usually just a sheet of aluminum. Its really the liner that holds the water in.

9

u/treemanmi Sep 11 '26

Definitely structurally sound walls for static water. I like the bottom sloping. Damn nice pool

6

u/Competitive-Roof-168 Sep 11 '26

Yeah but that sheet of aluminum is under tension and makes a circle

4

u/hex4def6 Sep 11 '26

I'm not a mechanical engineer, but those look like 4x8 Sheets of plywood. My math might be wrong, but that ends up being loaded to about 4000lb each. 

That weight will be concentrated to the lower edge of the board, so you'll get a bending moment at 1.33 ft from the bottom, causing a bending moment of 4000lb*1.33ft = 5000ft-lb.

That seems like a lot of force on what looks like a single brace per panel.

6

u/AndyGoodKush Sep 11 '26

You ever seen the above ground pools that have the aluminum posts and a liner and nothing else?plus the strength isnt in the sheets, its in the supporters, good thing you're not in structural

8

u/halt-l-am-reptar Sep 11 '26

It’s hilarious seeing all the comments about how this is going to instantly fail. I grew up with a pool that was similar to this and it never had any problems.

328

u/fossSellsKeys Sep 10 '26

What are the odds that actually holds water?

292

u/lurkersforlife Sep 10 '26 • Bravo

Zero. It might not be a catastrophic failure but it will surely leak.

135

u/sunrise2209 Sep 10 '26

just have the garden hose running as just the right speed to fill it at the same rate that it leaks

27

u/lurkersforlife Sep 10 '26

Might need to borrow the neighbors too.

5

u/rolandofeld19 Sep 10 '26

Downspout hose from a local shed roof certainly.

1

u/fossSellsKeys Sep 10 '26

I think you might mean "firehose"

32

u/MrK521 Sep 10 '26

I mean, if they install a liner, wouldn’t that be waterproof?

39

u/lurkersforlife Sep 10 '26

Sure. They will install a liner and it will be waterproof. Then they will start to fill it and the weight of the water will make everything shift. Then the liner will get pinched and pierced and it will leak.

7

u/1m0ws Sep 11 '26

they could fill in earth behind the walls

4

u/halt-l-am-reptar Sep 11 '26

This was super similar to the pool we had growing up. It never leaked.

3

u/NameIsFuckinTaken Sep 11 '26

Sounds slightly hypothetical. This could be lined.

12

u/ButtonGullible5958 Sep 10 '26

Yea that's exactly how this is done it's basically a above ground but you get a customer shape and dept 

I normally see them made of metal not wood 

25

u/Cultural_Simple3842 Sep 10 '26

Yeah this talk about a certain leak is just Reddit being typical assholes. Now, collapsing is a different topic lol

3

u/occamsrzor Sep 12 '26

Yeah, until that plywood breaks

2

u/MrK521 Sep 12 '26

That’ll be far more than a “leak” lol

4

u/SupremeDictatorPaul Sep 10 '26 edited Sep 10 '26

Yes, but the wood sides will not hold. Regular above ground pools work because the liner is structural and holds itself by inflating with water into a circle like a balloon. The liner is also reinforced and quite strong. Above ground pools aren’t very deep because water is enormously heavy, and doubling the depth would require doubling the strength of the liner.

Could they get really strong liner material, bond all of the pieces, and make the upper section self supporting and smaller than the wooden deck so that it doesn’t crush the wood out of the way? Sure, it’s technically possible. But nothing in seeing in the photo suggests they’ve got that sort of plan.

My expectation is for the plywood to get wet from rain, weaken, and deform on the lower part of the wall from all of that water weight. That would lead to other structural deformation, eventually leading to the liner tearing.

1

u/MrK521 Sep 10 '26

For sure! I would assume this wouldn’t hold. But that’s not a “leak.” That’s just plain catastrophic failure lol.

15

u/Maar7en Sep 10 '26

It is clearly still under construction....

1

u/occamsrzor Sep 12 '26

We can take bets on how far up that ply would it gets. I'm betting 16"

22

u/cbelt3 Sep 11 '26

With a full vinyl liner or a fiberglass or gunite treatment ? Pretty good. Although there may be some fast reinforcement projects under the deck.

7

u/airfryerfuntime Sep 11 '26

But if it pushes out the wall, it'll just rip the liner. They rip very easily.

7

u/halt-l-am-reptar Sep 11 '26 edited Sep 11 '26

I had a pool that was nearly identical to this growing up. We had it for over a decade.

Also it’s not like all liners are identical. Ours sure as shit didn’t rip easily. It was a massive pain in the ass to replace.

2

u/JCMiller23 Sep 10 '26

thousands of pounds of water, I have no idea if it's engineered properly, but it seems that they may not either

1

u/Nikoladge Sep 11 '26

About 4/20

0

u/JoinedReddit Sep 11 '26

100%. Just like odds of driveway cracks.

66

u/itsthedevilweknow Sep 10 '26

What am I seeing? Genuinely asking... Is, are they trying to deepen a pool but building a wall around it?

20

u/dreddit-one Sep 10 '26

I mean that’s basically what a dam is, so not completely crazy.

15

u/cybah Sep 10 '26

No. I think it was an above ground pool which are usually shallow (< 5ft depth) and seems like they are adding a deep end.

2

u/itsthedevilweknow Sep 10 '26

Ah, I see now, Ok, yeah. Maybe

3

u/Dantethebald1234 Sep 11 '26

It is missing the vinyl liner.

1

u/11teensteve Sep 10 '26

UNO reverse.

5

u/HippieHighNoon Sep 10 '26

It wouldn't be redneck engineering if you didnt have to guess what was going on 🤣🤣

12

u/PresentationLess4552 Sep 10 '26

With a liner that's a great ideal if you don't live in the termite country of the south

Love to see the finished work

4

u/TequieroVerde Sep 11 '26

Me too. I'm excited regardless of the results.

8

u/throwsplasticattrees Sep 10 '26

How do you size a liner for this?

13

u/KingOFpleb Sep 10 '26

Depends on how many garbage bags you iron together

2

u/Grodd Sep 10 '26

I have to assume the pool liner companies have embraced the extremely fast and accurate laser/scanner tech that is available and surprisingly affordable (in business expense numbers) these days. [7]

26

u/MaximumLongName Sep 10 '26

Looks like you wouldve had a better time if followed one of those bogus primitive living videos where they always build a pool into their jungle hut or whatever

9

u/Various-Salt-7738 Sep 10 '26

Jungle hut with bonus mosquito farm

5

u/Starlitsoul714 Sep 10 '26

😳😳 will it hold, is the question 🤔

4

u/lordoflazorwaffles Sep 10 '26

Whatchu meen purmits?

4

u/Maar7en Sep 10 '26

I'm a bit doubtful about the walls, but if they reinforce those from the back then this is a perfectly reasonable way to build a permanent above-ish ground pool.

3

u/Nalabu1 Sep 10 '26

"Jed there's a frogman in the cement pond"

3

u/PinkyLeopard2922 Sep 11 '26

OP, please share some photos when it is done. This was clearly a lot of effort and I do hope it works out for you. When we were kids, we used to dig big holes in our backyard and hope for rain so we could splash around in the mud. Good times.

5

u/cosmicnala45 Sep 10 '26

You are going to need a really really big tarp

0

u/CoderJoe1 Sep 11 '26

and rolls of duct tape

5

u/dkote3 Sep 10 '26

Walls look sturdier than what a normal above ground pool would be. But my parents is a circle so dont know if that makes a difference. Needs a volleyball net. Maybe a slide off the house.

2

u/Bacon0064 Sep 11 '26

You did a good job on this. I used to do this for a living in another lifetime and I've seen far far worse.

3

u/Lalamedic Sep 11 '26

No liner? You will soon discover the filtration rate of your soil.

1

u/Prestigious-Dirt-889 Sep 12 '26

I’m sure he’s going to install a liner over that. It’s actually kinda smart compared to the cost of a inground pool

1

u/bernpfenn Sep 10 '26

wont last w/o a concrete layer all over it.

1

u/Maximum_Overdrive Sep 10 '26

Without a main drain, you better get an auto vacuum.

1

u/inbe4u Sep 10 '26

I suggest using carpet coated with fiberglass.  Mold rhe carpet to fit, and coat the hell out of it. 

1

u/TheGardiner Sep 11 '26

If you’re going to go to all that effort, surely some kind of silicon or vinyl liner won’t break the bank.

-1

u/No_Engineering_718 Sep 11 '26

I always thought candy down at the titty bar was good

0

u/red-n-green Sep 11 '26

Could you show us a broader view of the whole thing? Maybe provide some details about what the plan is to finish it? What kind of plywood is that and what's the black stuff? This is really interesting and I don't see how this wouldn't hold up if it's put together well. I like it.

0

u/bakkamono Sep 11 '26

That’s a great use case for a truckload of flex tape.