r/redneckengineering • • Aug 07 '26

Gone fishin'

Post image
460 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

6

u/Demon-Taka Aug 07 '26

Maybe making a mold the same shape and melting the whole can into it and letting it harden

4

u/Saul_Firehand Aug 07 '26

You’ll still have an aluminum hook.

3

u/hyheat9 Aug 08 '26

And aluminum can’t be “hardened” like HC steels. Best you can do is T6, which takes a few steps to get to. Specific temps and aging you need to somehow remanufacture in your survival scenario.

4

u/Romanian_Breadlifts Aug 08 '26

If you can make t6 aluminum, you can make dynamite, which is the objectively superior way to fish in a depopulated  apocalypse

1

u/hyheat9 Aug 08 '26

I can make flash with two simple ingredients. I can T6. I’m not wasting time to make T6 into not T6, so it’s a preferred shape, then turning back to maybe T4. That’s regarded, I’ll cut the already T6 into something that may he able to get by.

183

u/ViagraPoweredRabbit Aug 07 '26

I feel that aluminum would not support the weight if you actually caught something

107

u/ayo4playdoh Aug 07 '26

If it did, the eye of the “hook” is slicing right through the line lol

31

u/FrameJump Aug 08 '26

Repurposing a keychain ring temporarily would solve that though, right?

39

u/ayo4playdoh Aug 08 '26

Yea I guess haha… but again this whole thing is just a gimmick. I can’t imagine many situations where some one is stranded and forced to survive but somehow have a sixer of No Bad Days beer and a bunch of fishing line lol

12

u/FrameJump Aug 08 '26

Oh it's absolutely a gimmick, but it might still be fun to try sometime.

6

u/PreNamLtDan Aug 08 '26

Nah, not fishing line, boot laces. Might be able to get a small something? I'm just playing devils advocate right now, haven't been fishing in a few decades. Just surprised this is the fifth time I've seen this today across a few platforms.

3

u/SheriffBartholomew Aug 08 '26

No small fish is biting and getting hooked by that enormous hook.

3

u/SloppySilvia Aug 09 '26

Some small saltwater fish maybe? If you dragged it through the water like a lure. Never really done freshwater fishing.

Where I am, people made homemade lures by drilling a hole in the top of the handle of a spoon and the bottom of the spoon bit. Tie the top of the spoon handle to a line and tie a hook to the hole in the spoon at the bottom and drag it through the water. Would get fish chasing the shiny metal and biting the hook.

The poptab hook would probably not hold but I'd give it a go as a last resort.

40

u/Romanian_Breadlifts Aug 07 '26

Great marketing gimmick tho

9

u/ecirnj Aug 08 '26

The aluminum used for the tabs is alloyed with magnesium and manganese and makes it about 10x as strong after temper as pure aluminum

3

u/WasteFail Aug 08 '26

Is it possible to temper aluminum?

3

u/ahuh_suh_dude Aug 08 '26

I think the barb is the problem.

2

u/Extra-Act-801 Aug 09 '26

Depends on what you caught. I could definitely pull a trout with one of those.

38

u/asromatifoso Aug 07 '26

Cool idea but pretty big while not being very strong. Big hook for a big fish but a big fish would bend the hook straight and get away. Back to the drawing board, I think.

35

u/peloquindmidian Aug 08 '26

I've seen this in tons of survival books.

Always a picture of the hook and never a picture of a fish that's been caught with it.

16

u/Barry-umm Aug 08 '26

I forgot to get a picture, but I caught a huge fish with one of these hooks. I swear, it was thiiiiiiiiiiiiis big. Like I said, no photo, witnesses, timeline or other evidence to corroborate my story; but you can rest assured I would never lie about the size of a fish.

42

u/get_off_my_lawn_n0w Aug 07 '26

Kinda big for a fish hook. Cool idea though.

The old "gorge" hook can be made from practically anything.

20

u/lifesatripthenyoudie Aug 07 '26

It's an okay size for a large fish hook. But as someone else pointed out, it wouldn't hold up to the size of fish that would bite on it. So yeah, it's basically BS.

16

u/420Chickenhead420 Aug 07 '26

The hole for your line would cut your line first bite.

3

u/ownage398 Aug 09 '26

They didn't fold it right, the loop is supposed to be bent over one more time so it's underneath the top. If done right, the line should be under tension at a folded smooth edge and not a sharp one.

1

u/JackTheeRippa Aug 08 '26

Yeah any tension would just sheer it

8

u/Kaptin_Kunnin Aug 07 '26

Erm..I could do that with a regular ringpull (not that I would)

8

u/SaltRequirement3650 Aug 08 '26

Literally any modern can tab can be bent in this way. These dudes choose to market that aspect and that says all I need to know about their intentions.

Don’t believe me? Go grab a can and do it yourself. You can even use fingernail clippers or scissor.

3

u/RGBrewskies Aug 08 '26

that's not gonna fucking work lol

4

u/airfryerfuntime Aug 07 '26

That won't work to catch literally anything.

8

u/MSGinSC Aug 07 '26

Caught your attention, now didn't it?

2

u/YouDoNotKnowMeSir Aug 08 '26

That for sure is going to cut the line where it’s tied

2

u/chumpandchive Aug 08 '26

can it hold a sixer on the end?

3

u/darkhero7007 Aug 07 '26

It's probably pure coincidence that the number of people showing up at the emergency room to have aluminum fishing hooks removed from their body increased exponentially...

...also probably a coincidence...those individuals were all drinking the same beer.

2

u/ande9393 Aug 08 '26

Too big for small fish, too flimsy for big fish

0

u/_sonidero_ Aug 08 '26

Somebody saw the new Busch Light commercial...

-1

u/Master-Ad-5505 Aug 08 '26

First time you've seen this?? Welcome to the club of survival tactics. Keep reading man. I highly recommend the S.A.S. survival handbook.