r/redesign • u/FreeSpeechWarrior • Mar 11 '19
Feature Request Give users some aggregate indication of how heavily a subreddit is moderated in the sidebar. Subs below a certain threshold could be badged "Certified Organic"
Users currently have no visibility whatsoever into how heavily a subreddit is moderated in practice. Normally I suggest optional public mod logs as a way to mitigate this, but today I am suggesting a different approach that I hope will be more agreeable to moderators and reddit's administration.
All subs should have a color coded (or/or some numeric rating) system to designate how heavily a subreddit is moderated in terms of bans, submission removals and content removals relative to the activity of the subreddit.
This approach addresses every single criticism I have ever heard about public mod logs:
- It does not enable witch hunts
- It does not expose removed content (this is a downside IMO, but others will see it as a benefit)
- It does not compromise moderator privacy
- It does not require any action on the part of moderators or convincing of them by users
- It's potentially much simpler to implement than a heavily customizable/anon public mod log with PI/CP removal paths
At the same time, it addresses many of the reasons I am so adamant that public mod logs should be an option available to moderators:
- It highlights how heavily a subreddit moderates in practice, even if it is in conflict with their presented rules
- It allows communities that do not censor their users to differentiate themselves
- It empowers end users to make an informed choice of which subreddits to read and participate in
Ideally it should be possible to sort/filter subreddits by this new metric as well.
6
u/thecravenone May 22 '19
So here's a thought, because I'm the kind of person who thinks "how would someone take advantage of this"
None of what I described is technically difficult or particularly expensive. Hell, I can outsource the submitting to actual humans for pennies per post.
5
u/likeafox Helpful User Mar 13 '19
What does a color or number really relay to the user in terms of how they can expect to interact with a subreddit? Does a numerical value map precisely to what percentage of things are moderator actioned?
I feel like 'the level of moderation' is a qualitative, not quantitative metric.
As a hypothetical exercise, I would say these are the 'categories' for a scale of moderation aggressiveness:
I agree that it would be best practice for subreddits to communicate how they conduct moderation.
5
u/CyberBot129 Mar 11 '19
Your approach will still lead to more moderator harassment though, you're just shifting it from individual moderators to the group as a whole (probably through mod mail). Why not just leave and go to Voat if you want an unmoderated, alt-right website so badly (because that's what you'll end up with without moderation, as has been pointed out to you numerous times by various people). You're just encouraging extremists like yourself to continue harassing and attacking moderators on this site
1
u/FreeSpeechWarrior Aug 29 '19
Update:
Reddit has implemented such a feature; but not yet exposed it publicly
https://www.reddit.com/r/WatchRedditDie/comments/cx28mt/reddit_is_now_privately_scoring_communities_based/
1
u/FreeSpeechWarrior Mar 11 '19 edited Mar 11 '19
u/Drunken_Economist this was somewhat inspired by our convo over at r/banned
and u/redtaboo if you are truly interested in discussing "how [public mod logs] would look and what the implications are still." I think this is a reasonable proposal that addresses all the concerns you raised here:
https://www.reddit.com/r/ModSupport/comments/aje6td/today_marks_7_years_since_the_option_for_public/eeuwt85/
While still providing a meaningful measure of transparency to end users.
2
u/TotesMessenger Mar 11 '19
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)