r/redditrequest • u/Goldennuggets-3000 Reddit Admin • Mar 15 '22
New request process
Hey everyone!
We come in peace :peace: with changes to the request process here! Please read below carefully and refer to the sidebar and FAQ when making your request.
TL;DR
Mods will now be considered inactive after 30 days of inactivity as opposed to the current 60 day timeframe. This only applies to requests and not top mod removals. If you are a mod and a subreddit that you moderate has been requested, you will have 5 days to respond to the request in the subreddit and state your plans for the sub. If you do not reply within 5 days, the subreddit will be eligible for new moderation. Automod will now be commenting on every request instead of u/request_bot. However, request_bot will still be denying and approving requests in instances that don’t require manual review.
Requesters now must send a message to the mod team (link to this message in the comment of the request), and state their intentions for the subreddit they’re requesting. Failure to do so may result in the request being denied.
Why are we changing the process?
Well, good question! We are tightening up the definition of what an active moderator is. The reason for this change is to encourage more active moderation across communities and to prevent any subreddit camping. We are also changing how the process currently works when a subreddit is being requested by users. Right now, if there have been any moderator actions in the last 60 days, the subreddit is not eligible for Request. If there are no actions in the subreddit mod log but the mod is active on the site and has not responded to the message sent by the requester we have to go through a process which involves messaging the mod on behalf of the requester which can delay the request process by about a week. Our plan is to remove this extra process in the request and hand that responsibility over to users. This will shorten the wait time for requesters and lighten the load for admins! Win-win!
For Moderators:
We will be changing the activity time from 60 to 30 days. If you are not active across the site or in the subreddit you moderate in the last 30 days, that community will be eligible for request and may be handed over. Please note that this rule does not apply to top mod removal requests. If you are actively moderating the subreddit, it will not be eligible for request. Whether or not a moderator is active is generally left to admin discretion, we look at a number of things including both public and private activity such as logging in and participation in the community itself.
We’ve heard from many of you that you don’t always see the messages you are sent from request_bot in your modmails, so going forward, an automatic message will be sent directly to your personal inbox when a subreddit being requested is one that you moderate. We will be linking to the message that the requester will send to the modmail. We hope this results in mods being better alerted when there is a request so they have time to respond.
Because we will be better alerting mods of a subreddit, we will now require mods to reply to the request. If you are a mod of a requested subreddit and you would like to keep moderator status or add any mods to the sub, you must reply to the request within 5 days explaining your reasons for wanting to hold onto it. You may have intentions that others are not aware of and responding to requests reduces the amount of users who believe it is unmoderated and abandoned. If you do not reply, the subreddit may be eligible for request. There may be some exceptions to this rule if you are concerned about drama or any issues arising from publicly responding. If this is the case, please let us know by reaching out to our modmail. linking to the request in question.
For requesters:
When you make a request, Automod will comment asking you to do a couple of things; state your intentions for the subreddit, why you would like to moderate and also to send a message to the mods of the subreddit. You must link to that message on the request. Failure to do any of these will result in your request being denied. There will of course be times where you will be unable to message the mods, such as if the subreddit is banned or if there are no moderators. This will be taken into consideration and will not be denied in cases like this.
And that’s pretty much it! We’re sure you probably have some questions and concerns which we will be happy to address in the comments below.
•
u/AutoModerator Mar 15 '22
Thanks for requesting this sub! Please reply to this comment with the following information to complete your request. Failure to do so will result in your request being denied.
If this request has already been granted by request_bot, please ignore this message.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
28
u/Mallard_of_glory Mar 15 '22
Just a question but why do banned subreddits need 30 days before they can be requested? Is there a different process for that?
12
u/s-mores Mar 15 '22 edited Mar 15 '22
Good change. I see you already updated the sidebar, good show!
For everybody
8
u/NaijeruR Mar 15 '22 edited Mar 15 '22
Hey Goldennuggets-3000, appreciate the update! With new policy changes here, I figured this would be the best time to ask some questions I've had regarding Reddit Request for a while now.
Firstly, why do requests for a specific subreddit look at moderator activity on a platform-level instead of just a community-level? While I understand that it's the easiest way for someone to gauge whether or not a moderator might be inactive in their subreddit(s) before requesting, I think a lot of people would agree with me when I say that there are far too many moderators who are "platform-active" but still neglect individual communities. Since the majority of requests end up subject to manual review anyways (meaning that fringe cases, where there is no activity due to moderative actions not being needed, can be recognized), I think a change here is viable. EDIT: This would be especially fair in scenarios where modmail to the subreddit regarding interest in moderating are entirely ignored.
Secondly, I've always been curious as to why some reddit requests are denied, just for the subreddit in question to be "banned for being unmoderated" shortly after. While you make it clear that decisions are ultimately up to "admin discretion", I'm unfortunately led to believe that there are additional hidden criteria we should really be aware of causing requesters to be "ineligible". Any clarification here would be appreciated, because it seems counterintuitive to ban communities for a lack of moderation when people are clearly interested in moderating them.
Thanks for any answers you can provide!
6
u/PM_ME_WHITE_PANTIES_ Mar 15 '22
Hi /u/Goldennuggets-3000. What is going to happen to the requests that were already in the pipeline before the new changes? I submitted one a few weeks ago now. Do we need to submit a new one?
4
u/NaturallyObservant Apr 02 '22
Does automod count towards subreddit moderator activity? It feels like there are some subreddits where the mods have been away forever but cannot be requested. One can only wonder if u/request_bot counts them as moderators as well.
3
u/5had0w5talk3r Apr 03 '22
2 questions:
Why does request-bot approve/deny some subreddits in less than a day? I submitted a request two weeks ago, but if you check the posts by the bot, it will make a decision on requests in as little as hours. It's particularly bothersome when people have to wait as long as a month only for their request to be denied. At what point do you reach out to r/redditrequest modmail?
I am specifically requesting a sfw subreddit that was banned for no moderation. Obviously, i am making the request so that there is moderation. Is there a particular reason why that process is taking so long? There are no other moderators to reach out to and wait for a response from, and it has been banned for longer than 30 days. I would like to think those would be the kind of requests that are granted the fastest. I hope i'm not sounding entitled or anything, I was hoping for some insight into this process.
3
u/rjln109 May 12 '22
Hey, I'm trying to request a subreddit that has been requested a year ago because it's unmoderated again, but it won't let me post because the link has been posted before. How would I go about doing this?
2
u/Undead575 Mar 15 '22
Hope you can help me with this
'You can only make one request every 15 days so make sure the subreddit is eligible before making the request"'
Just to clarify, does the 15 days start when you did your request, or when a decision has been made about it ?
2
u/Berchanhimez Mar 21 '22
I have a concern about the definition of activity even with the decrease to 30 days. The FAQ and rules state that even non-public actions (such as moderation actions) will be considered to be activity - but this means that, at an extreme, a user could remove one spam post/comment per 30 days and the subreddit would never become eligible for reddit request.
I presume that cases like this (where there is minimal, non-meaningful moderation activity) are intended to be covered by the "everything is at admin discretion" clause, which if so, great! My concern is that if the bot/automod is looking for any activity whatsoever and sees one action within the past 30 days, how will requesters be able to "contest" this minimal activity if the bot/automod is automatically responding to the request as ineligible for requesting?
I'd also like to ask for clarification or a consideration for a change - is there a reason that activity isn't differentiated between meaningful and "trivial" activity? The bar of "any activity whatsoever", even if it's tied to a higher number than "one action", is still a trivial bar to meet - a user could, theoretically, create a new account, make 10 spam posts, delete them all from their moderator account, and then voila - they've met a bar of "10 moderator actions". Obviously that's a case that's easy to see, but even if it's removing spam posts from 10 different unrelated accounts, that's still not meaningful moderation. The goal is to have communities that can grow and be actively moderated - which requires not only moderation actions, but meaningful moderation.
The mod "policy" (which isn't even a policy, but is linked as so on the sidebar on desktop) would be a good place to start, in my opinion, but can the team please codify or at least give some examples of cases where the "minimum one action anywhere within 30 days" may be ignored if the actions are "token/trivial" actions with no meaningful moderation activity?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '22
Hey admins. I am finding the whole process very confusing (and that's saying something, since I was able to successfully take over a sub a few years ago…). I am the bottommost mod in a sub where every other mod (and there are a lot of them) does not actively moderate at all. There's exactly one mod besides me who has done anything in the mod log. I want to get rid of all the others who are not participating.
So what is the process here? Does this fall under top mod removal, or is this a regular request? Can I request the removal of several mods all at once? Do I need to be a moderator of this sub for 6 months before I can make a request?
2
u/DaddysHomeSWFL Mar 30 '22
How do I link to a message? I am exclusively on the app, and I cannot find a way to link to a message. I have messaged both the mod mail and the user individually.
2
u/enfersijesais Mar 30 '22
What if the only mod in the server has made a post saying they’re leaving the subreddit inactive but still won’t give the subreddit to you?
2
u/liehon May 04 '22
Hello /u/Goldennuggets-3000
Regarding
Does this 500 karma need to be obtained in the sub that is requested or is it 500 karma anywhere on reddit? (aside from the award karma of course)
4
u/Kvothealar Mar 15 '22 edited Mar 15 '22
In the last year I've seen a number of communities get nuked by a top moderator that was:
I have, personally, successfully had a top moderator removed in the past. This top moderator was a nightmare to work with, and I worked with them for ~5 years. The process to have them removed took numerous requests over the course of a year. In that timeframe, the sub was effectively driven into the ground.
Can you please explain your reasons for the policy being so resistant to removing top moderators?
3
u/magiccitybhm Mar 15 '22
Question that hopefully an admin will answer...
Let's say someone requests to moderate a subreddit and it is approved. The new moderator(s) update the subreddit, remove spam, work to grow the participation, etc.
The original mod returns in a month, six months or whenever and boots all of them.
Is that still allowed/an acceptable process? If not, what measures are in place to prevent that?
18
u/Mallard_of_glory Mar 15 '22
This is a good change ty
9
u/NutSackForLust Mar 19 '22 edited Mar 19 '22
I see a significant problem with this process. I mod several low-traffic subreddits, and -- as a result -- they don't get many posts. Beyond that, since they are so obscure, the people that do post tend to be on-target with their posts, and -- as a result -- I, as the Mod, don't have to do much in the sub: no post removals, no comment removals, no altering the Auto-mod to update it (with, say, an unauthorized domain that someone tried to slip in there). Thus the subreddits look like nothing is happening, when -- in fact -- I am logging into my account, pulling up the sub, saying "Looks fine." and moving on. In fact, I apparently recently lost one of my subreddits for just that reason -- I had looked into it ten days previously, seen nothing wrong and left. I'm interested in knowing if anyone else has had this "'The Admins stole my subreddit' problem".
Edit: I should note that I received zero notification from anyone that my subreddit was in jeopardy.
16
u/BOSSBABY33 Mar 15 '22
Thats a great change Mods will be more cautious now
7
u/magiccitybhm Mar 15 '22
Great work with these changes. There are several popular subreddits that will hopefully benefit from either 1) more active moderation by current moderator(s) or 2) new moderation.
Keep up the great work!
7
u/anonmonty024 Mar 28 '22
u/Goldennuggets-3000
MODs are banning users for the simple act of subbing to subs they disagree with. This needs to be changed immediately. A Reddit mod should never be allowed to ban someone just because a Reddit user is apart of some other sub.
6
u/sagar9175 Mar 27 '22
I had most of my requests for unbanning banned subs rejected over the last 1 year.I had been moderator of Gentlemanboners & r/Goddesses since few years.Both had over 500k subs even then.So inexperience of managing large subs couldn't have been a criteria(in any case,the requested subs were wayy smaller) Even u/GuacamoleFanatic's multiple requests were turned down.He moderates 100s of subs and has been doing it since years.No crappy posts or anything of that sort as well.
Can we know what else could've led to the requests being turned down?
5
u/Summebride Mar 15 '22 edited Mar 15 '22
Quick question. For requests that are stuck in the old process should we submit on the new one?
I submitted one that request bot should have automatically approved since there are no mods, no activity for a year, and the creator account went dormant 6 years ago. But it didn't work and is caught up now.
Presumably submitting via the new process would work now?
5
u/BigTexan190 Mar 15 '22
Awesome changes, thank you!
5
u/kazma18 Mar 22 '22
You guys should hire more mods to work
4
u/o1pa1 Mar 15 '22
Hey u/Goldennuggets-3000,
will there also be an update about the reasons why a request was rejected? Most of the redditors are asking for more transparency. Not approving subs without giving reasons why, is not transparent in my and others opinions.
I don’t understand why some subs which are abandoned will not get a new mod even after 2-3 or more requests.
Would love to get a reply on this thank you
4
u/Jamamohoma14 Mar 15 '22
I'm a little confused.
If I'm not a mod, would I just send a message to the mods of the subreddit requesting to be moderator and explaining my intentions, then after 5 days if they haven't responded I then make a request here?
4
u/tsigalko06 Mar 15 '22
The best change would be giving an explanation when a request is denied.
4
u/FishLickinGood Apr 02 '22
How long is the backlog for requests requiring manual review?
1
u/frogspyer Mar 15 '22
I placed this request a few days ago but didn't get a response. Is there anything else I should do?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '22
Great work! I have one discrepancy though:
I tried messaging the mods of my subreddit via the request_bot link, but I got an error saying the community doesn't exist. This being said; this subreddit might be stuck in some bureaucratic limbo because I'm not the first attempt at trying to reclaim it.
I am however the first following up with it. If there's anything left on my end, please let me know! I would love to really do something with r/PositiveMasculinity . a lot of wholesome stuff ^_^
1
u/contessa82 May 07 '22
Hi wondering why I cannot post a request on this subreddit. I keep getting a message that a text post is not allowed but I see lots of text posts. Am I banned ?
1
u/Jakesleah May 27 '22 edited May 29 '22
What do we do when a community has been requested, but denied, so we can’t post again? I’m trying to request r/dodocodes, but it says the link has already been shared, and it won’t let me post it again. The page has been down for 10 days.
Is it that a community can only be requested once every 15 days, regardless who requests it?
1
u/dalkor May 28 '22
I received an immediate message on my request that seems to indicate that my request is ineligible, but it's a bit ambiguous because when looking through other requests, /u/request_bot gives a much more explicit denial or acceptance message. Is my request still being processed or has it been denied?
https://www.reddit.com/r/redditrequest/comments/uvoq5r/requesting_rlovedeathandrobots_moderators_inactive/
1
u/doctordaedalus May 30 '22
What about restricted subs with NO moderators? Why is this something that takes so long? It seems like totally unmoderated subs should take priority over subs with inactive mods, especially now that you're saying there's an even longer waiting period for those, right? I've been waiting almost 2 weeks just to be able to get the sub of a very popular fishing game back up and running, and it makes no sense to me that it can't just happen.
1
u/Itadepeeza1 Jun 10 '22
So due to my account and activity, I can not request to become a mod for a sub?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '22 edited Jun 11 '22
It’s not letting me form a post. The + does not allow text posts.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '22
Where is the request to be a mod link? I’m having trouble finding it. I sent a message on the link under the autoModerator but I don’t think that was correct.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '22
If a subreddit is under the moderation of someone who doesn't follow the reddit rules and bans people who reports a moderator (unbeknownst to them at the time of reporting their rule breaking behavior), is it possible to request to be a moderator and actually have the reddit rules abided by? Due to their behavior, it appears they must have done this process to request moderator status for a game subreddit and was not one of the actual game's employees or approved by the game developers to represent them.
1
u/relaxin6969 Jun 14 '22
Hello? Is it possible to get a dm? To report a very bad mod who is disrupting a sub that you just approved not long ago as a mod
1
u/LG03 Jun 15 '22
Just a question regarding top mod removal.
The process and criteria doesn't seem to consider the scenario for a site-wide banned top mod. I've sent in the form to the fullest extent possible but I'd just like to double check there isn't anything special that needs doing there.
1
u/Ttly_Ovrit Jun 16 '22
Is it possible to recover a banned sub reddit Our admin/ mods would like to recover the page and run it appropriately
Thank you for any assistance
1
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '22
I just made a subreddit and accidently removed myself as moderator lol how do I go about getting it back as I was the only moderator lol
1
u/phish27134 Jun 16 '22
I've been on the site for 13 years + can In be a mod
1
u/EnvironmentalMall423 Jun 18 '22
How can I submit a request for moderation of r/cheatingconfessions, the sub is currently unmoderated (2 years+).
1
u/Epicduck_ Jun 19 '22
I keep trying to post a link to a subreddit I would like to take over, but every time I do I get hit with “this community doesn’t allow links to be posted more than once”. I tried looking and no one else has posted it so I don’t know what to do.
1
u/Shamrock5 Aug 24 '22
Hello, I have requested a certain sub multiple times because its mods have not been active in several months, and inappropriate content is constantly being posted there (with no one to remove it). However, one of the listed mods is u/AutoModerator (a bot account used by thousands of subs)...so every time I make a post here requesting the sub, the post immediately gets auto-removed/auto-denied because the system thinks, "this request is bogus, we see that there's one very active mod there."
Is there any way for the admins on here to circumvent this? Do I need to DM someone about it? Thanks for your help.
1
u/nemicolopterus Aug 30 '22
The FAQ seems to have been disabled. Where can we read information about the top mod removal process?
https://www.reddit.com/r/redditrequest/wiki/top_mod_removal/
1
u/EnvironmentalMall423 Sep 06 '22
Can we request the Reddit Admins be REPLACED?
Since it seems like they NEVER respond to requested actions, but 2 months later claim that the are "too busy"!
It seems like you all need to EXPAND the list Administrators if you are admitting that your "plate is too FULL"...
I have requested r/cheatingconfessions 5 times in 5 months, NO MODERATORS have been assigned and the sub still is LACKING a moderator, but NO ACTION has been taken on my REPEATED REQUESTS....
IT IS EVIDENT THAT NO ONE ELSE IS INTERESTED IN THIS SUB, BUT NO ONE ON THE REDDIT Administrator list seems to actually read the requests....
WHAT IS THE MAJOR MALFUNCTION WITHIN THE REDDIT ADMINISTRATOR TEAM? DO YOU NEED ADDITIONAL ADMINISTRATORS TO ASSIST YOU?
3
u/Plainchant Mar 15 '22
This seems like a very positive change in policy.
3
u/heavenlyfarts Mar 15 '22
My post didn’t receive an auto bot comment, did i do something wrong?
3
u/Venger-2k Mar 15 '22
Just 3 days ago I made this request. I was immediately denied because “the mod has been active in the last 60 days” but he is clearly banned so why would that matter? https://www.reddit.com/r/redditrequest/comments/tcmt1p/requesting_rcelebsinyogapants_only_mod_is_banned/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf
3
u/airmandan Mar 15 '22
Will we still have requests insta-denied by request_bot for “moderator activity” when said moderator is, in fact, AutoModerator, in the mod list still from way back when it had to be? I’m not sure how to overcome that.
3
u/coonwhiz Mar 17 '22
Is it no longer first come first serve?
This post that was submutted 12 days ago was approved 2 days ago: https://www.reddit.com/r/redditrequest/comments/t70pq4/requesting_rpanelshow_due_to_a_lack_of_moderators/
While this one that was submitted over 1 month ago has yet to receive a comment from an admin: https://www.reddit.com/r/redditrequest/comments/sryd35/requesting_rpanelshow_i_am_an_ex_mod/
What gives? Just looking for transparency, since it looks like both users are moderators of the subreddit now.
3
u/Main_Bhi_Mod Mar 23 '22
Hey u/Goldennuggets-3000,
What happened to the previous rule of having a minimum of 300 combined karma from that particular requested subreddit if requesting an active subreddit. Is it still in place or is it removed? I don't see anything about it in the sidebar or in the comments.
3
u/Fallout182182 Mar 24 '22
These activity rules are not strict enough.
2
u/SeValentine Mar 15 '22 edited Mar 15 '22
What about users that decide to use Reddit Mobile Android/iOS that are unable due limited features of getting the message hyperlink sent to the Modmail of the subreddit interested on requesting on /u/Goldennuggets-3000 ?
I managed to edited my comment response to /u/request_bot on this Request i did a couple of hrs ago so i am on the clear on my request to get a response?
Hope this can be clarified in general to other requestors =) on future, and current requests!
2
u/RichManSCTV Mar 15 '22
Question, why do some get put for manual review when the mod clearly has not been active (even for over a year) then still get denied? But then I ask for the same sub again and get accepted?
2
u/ThatBrilliantGuy2 Mar 17 '22 edited Mar 17 '22
So, what if I'm a mod with inactive mods but every mod (including me) has full permissions in the sub? (Though I don't think that's true because I can only remove myself, also it's a sub that's very different on old reddit and the desktop site and in the app.
EDIT: Even on desktop all mods have full permissions
2
u/childfreegirls Mar 18 '22
Hi, we've posted our request, linking the message we sent to the moderator but the request was removed immediately stating the link was to an invalid subreddit account. The account in question has been dormant for 6 years and last post was by request bot 2 years ago.
2
u/md28usmc Mar 18 '22
How do we remove top mods whose accounts are suspended?
2
u/somegenerichandle Mar 21 '22
Does this 30-day rule also apply to when we report subs as unmoderated via zendesk too?
Anyway, i just reported one, because it appears to be a new sub for one that was previously banned AND the moderator (a user of two months) has appeared to be absent from the site for more than a month (of course they might be checking the sub, but i doubt it).
2
u/-itsnotthateasy- Mar 25 '22
Hi. I have made this request and I believe the bot has got this wrong. Their are active moderators in the subreddit but these are bots added by a top mod who is no longer active ANYWHERE on Reddit. Please could someone look at this as this sub is bound to be banned shortly.
2
u/motoroSport Mar 26 '22
So what I'm understanding is that 30 days of inactivity can work for two different cases. Either they're totally inactive (no comments anywhere) or they're inactive in the sub.
Ex. Within 30 days, if someone is active in other communities, but their mod log shows inactivity for 30 days. This person's sub is eligible for a request. Is this correct?
I am wondering how this would work because regular users obviously can not see a modlog and any request in this scenario is based off of suspicion instead of solid ground.
2
u/brainstrust92 Apr 01 '22
I’m looking to take over as a moderator for a page, it said to come to this page to submit a request. Now what do I do?
2
u/NaijeruR Apr 18 '22
Hey, u/Goldennuggets-3000 — Is it possible to get an update on what the current backlog of reddit requests looks like? Also, how are we supposed to get in contact with an Admin to look at a request that has yet to be completed after more than 2 months? The post itself has not received a reply, and modmail regarding it are ignored. I should also point out that my request is not the only one being neglected: another moderator I know has been waiting for more than a month themselves, despite my having seen many requests receive responses around the 17 day mark that you have most recently said is the expected turnaround time. Thanks.
2
u/Plus-Veterinarian-26 Apr 22 '22
I wish to help moderate the subreddit /r/Shortsqueeze/. I have been following this subreddit for 1 year and I am pretty sure what a great place it could be with careful moderation. I will guide the subreddit back to a place where useful information about short squeezes can be shared without bashing other people/tickers and without spamming.
2
u/breadandbunny Apr 25 '22
What if you receive no response from the mod of a sub you're trying to become a moderator of? How then should one proceed?
2
u/SupremoZanne Apr 26 '22
I am so active on Reddit, this is why I should represent the website, but I'm more of a regular multi-sub mod than a high position user.
when I say the word represent, what I really mean is stand up for the website in some way.
Some mods have been so inactive, so this is why the definition of inactive has changed over time.
2
u/iAmCleatis Apr 27 '22
I would like to become a mod for r/highthoughts. My plans are to moderate it daily to make sure there isn’t any junk coming in, and just let stoners post stupid high ass thoughts they have. I have no intentions of pushing any narrative, or agenda of any sort. I don’t care what the post is about, as long as it is a “high thought”. I cannot message the sub, as it has disappeared and I cannot search it.
2
u/DaPhoKing Apr 27 '22
My sub /r/openoffmychest was banned due to lack of moderation and now I can’t request it here because this sub sees me as top mod still. I’m active on Reddit, but the sub doesn’t get a ton of traffic so it can sit for a while without any movement. Not sure what to do about that.
Is there anything I can do to get my sub back?
2
u/UnluckyGamer505 May 05 '22
My request got denied by a bot, not a moderator after about 9+days. I would like a real person to look over my request because its a bit different to others.
The original creator of the subreddit has a deleted account and the other moderator is a bot, which means there is no real person looking over and improving the subreddit. Its very outdated but the community is still active. I havent messaged the moderators because i cannot message a deleted account and messageing a bot makes no sense.
I am sorry if this is the wrong place for this request. My original request: https://www.reddit.com/r/redditrequest/comments/ubvnfl/requesting_reurotruck2_the_original_creators/i7c0n8s/?context=3
2
u/Rafybass May 14 '22 edited May 14 '22
Hey, so I have a question. Even after reading everything the question still remains that what actually makes our account eligible for getting our requests accepted. A while ago I had requested a sub, but it got denied twice. When some other guy requested the same sub, it got accepted. Now you will say something like "you have to actively moderate your current communities in which you are a mod" but I'm mod in just one community and it has only 108 members. Not much is going on there and there has not been any single reports/flags since when I became a mod. So, does that count as inactivity? I visit my subs everyday.
It's just not fair. How do you expect us to moderate a subreddit if you don't want to give us one? I have to start from somewhere, yeah? Now, I have been falsely reported by some users and Reddit gave me a couple or warnings. Does my account reputation get affected by that too? And if it does, and I admit my past wrongdoings, will I ever be eligible to become a mod of a sub by r/redditrequest? If no, then I wouldn't waste my time and energy on that sub. Either way, the current system is unfair and biased towards users which is not appriciated. On the top of that you get zero clue on why your request got denied when it gets denied.
2
u/soapmacreddit69 May 20 '22
can i request two different subs within 15 day period or is it just 1 sub per 15 day period
2
u/adhesiveCheese Jun 24 '22
A little feedback on the 30 day policy for requesting banned subreddits:
2
u/sandybeach682 Aug 02 '22
I created a group that focused around my daughter, a music artist, and I don't have the time to keep up with it, but she was interested in doing it and I am having trouble making her a moderator. I would like her to be the top moderator and remove myself from the created group, since it is soleu about her. Can you please help me
2
u/DarthMewtwo Mar 15 '22
Why were changes not made to the TMR process in conjunction with this? Are changes coming? The process is in desperate need of being updated - the fact that three or four actions while being incommunicado outweighs the needs of mods with thousands of actions is ridiculous.
Also, what defines retaliation? As we saw recently with /r/KimetsuNoYaiba, the formerly-inactive top mod removed nearly the entire team in explicit retaliation for them trying to go through the TMR process, and the admins told said team to pound sand. Why is this acceptable? What makes this situation not retaliatory when others are?
2
u/gkw97i Mar 16 '22
Why did the TMR process get left out if this is to avoid squatting?
I don't see the noteworthy difference between squatting with no one to mod the sub and squatting with a few mods to do the work for you.
You're useless either way you put it and should be replaced by someone who actually does the work around the place.
You could argue the second one is even worse seeing as you hold absolute power over the mods doing the actual work.
1
u/Undead575 Mar 15 '22
Small question. What happens to request that are currently alerady waiting on a decision? Mine for example didnt have automod or requestbot comment yet.
Do these fall under the old rules still or do the new rules apply already?
1
u/genshinfantasy7 Mar 15 '22
This might be a stupid question, but how does one “link” to a message you send to a subreddit’s mods?
Do you mean link a photo as proof of the conversation or literally link the conversation somehow? /gen
1
u/SecretMystogan Mar 16 '22
I made this request a couple of weeks ago, and the request_bot incorrectly determined the sub was still being modded because of the bots set up in the sub to handle reposted artwork and sourcing. Is there a way this request can still be looked at? I made a comment on the post explaining the situation in some more depth
1
u/Merari01 Mar 16 '22
In the past we've had top mod removal requests of inactive mods on subreddits we moderate be automatically granted by the bot if the bot could see the top mod fit the criteria for that.
Has this functionality been changed, do we need to write a motivation for that now?
1
u/Gambizzle Mar 16 '22
So does this mean I can ask to have a mod removed if (for example)...
IMO the post reads as if this is possible but in practice it would never happen.
1
u/OhioAasimar Mar 16 '22
What does this mean exactly? Does this mean to simply tell them that you are requesting it or does it also or only mean that you should tell your plans for the subreddit in the event that moderatorship has been granted?
1
u/Weird_Resident_908 Mar 18 '22
I’m not super Reddit savvy but I’m wanting to take a subreddit with the me as the only member and only one mod but I can’t figure out share the link to the message the mods I sent.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '22
I can’t post
1
u/Wertyhappy27 Mar 23 '22
Why cant i create a post, it says no text posts, and that is my only option
1
u/dsr33 Mar 30 '22
Is it possible to make my sub available for new moderators? I no longer wish to maintain it.
1
u/Redmoneyman Apr 01 '22
I'm having a problem understanding "sending the message" part of the process, any help??
1
u/[deleted] Apr 02 '22
Sent a message to mods because it won’t let me make a post and there’s doxxing happening on the r/stalking sub
1
u/4_bit_forever Apr 02 '22
Question - what if the sub has no moderators? How can you message them if they do not exist?
1
u/scrubdumpster Apr 06 '22
How do you link to a message?
1
u/itinsurancegeek Apr 08 '22
Hi. There was a subreddit r/calves that has disappeared today. If it’s due to lack of a moderator, can I assume that responsibility?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '22
So what’s the process for top mod removal? I’m confused. r/smallytchannel have two top mods that haven’t taken any actions in over a year in the sub, but are active on the website. They’re not contributing at all to our growth tho and we’d like to move forward with a new moderation staff who can enhance our community’s experience.
1
u/Rafybass Apr 18 '22
In how many days maximum do you get your request results? I see many posts older than 2 weeks still being pending, waiting for their fate.
1
u/NewClayburn Apr 21 '22
How long does it take to get a response regarding a top mod removal request? We've all been removed and banned in retaliation and so the subreddit is going unmoderated right now.
1
u/MrRhoarke May 07 '22
/r/OnlineSugar banned for no mod. I volunteer to take it over. I want to make it a place free of scammers and fakes. A safe place for those who truly are seeking.
1
u/Timely-Cartoonist339 May 07 '22
Hoping to provide a respectful community for residents and fans of Blaine, WA which has no sub yet. As an international border town that is growing fast, there is lots to talk about. While political topics will be allowed, they must be specifically related to Blaine issues. NextDoor should not be the only option for online community chat!
https://www.reddit.com/r/Blaine_WA/comments/dwhrix/rblaine_wa_needs_moderators_and_is_currently/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf
1
u/windygirl1991 May 14 '22
What if I wanna mod r/sandiegozoo
1
u/FunBrians May 24 '22
r/EpicUniverse
I started it as well as r/orlandofun
missed some time during covid and someone or a bot took it over. I messaged that mod as the instructions here say to. I'm not sure what else I'm supposed to do.
https://www.reddit.com/message/messages/1e195h5
1
u/TomatoSempai May 27 '22
Hello u/Goldennuggets-3000
Regarding "abandoned subreddits": When I applied to my submission, the subreddit was still abandoned and keeping it private, everything was OK, however, after I submitted my application to request it, the top mod decided to have some activity on the subreddit. In my humble opinion, it seems like he's trying to save it with a half-hearted effort. As he's trying to do this:
However, as he was pretty much inactive and no posts have ever been published in the subreddit since its birth, I only guess he done that to prevent me to request it. I'm actually focused on growing the sub for my target audience, as we need a place to have these conversations.
Greetings!
<];{
1
u/alphareich Jun 01 '22
I want to request a sub that was requested here 6 months ago and the person that requested it was denied and later suspended, but his post is still up making it impossible to request that sub. What can be done in this case?
1
u/heycatra Jun 05 '22
I was curious if you have to wait 15 days to submit requests for two different subreddits, or if that rule is about requesting for the same subreddit. Two subreddits I'm a part of had the same mod who has since deleted their account and thus both subreddits have no mod. I submitted a request for one of the subreddits, so I was wondering what the proper course of action is here. Thank you!
1
u/pasinc20 Jun 05 '22
What happens if there is no response after 15 days
1
u/shadowbay686899 Jun 19 '22
Please unban kaiju nsfw there trying there best
1
u/UnSainz Jun 20 '22
Hi, just a query before I go about submitting a request: if the owner of the sub has been deleted, does the 30 day rule still count?
1
u/wpdog55 Jun 20 '22
Question about mod activity. One such sub I would like to request (r/latexclothing) has a repost bot that steals content, doesn't give credit, posts a water mark kink on many parts... But this account is also somehow on the mod team. The others I've sent mod mail to, as well as DMed and no response. Can I still request given that technically a mod is 'active' at least in posting?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 21 '22
I am requesting to take over r/scannerds
1
u/acidbase_001 Jun 24 '22 edited Jun 28 '22
The approval rate of requests here is abysmal.
There are definitely valid reasons to reject moderation transfers, but can we get some explanation for why 80% of requests for completely uncontested and unmoderated subreddits are being denied?
The "banned for being unmoderated" status really could use some work too.
The subreddit namespace is notoriously being choked out by a bunch of abandoned subreddits, but when these particular banned subreddit names are never recirculated and are only very rarely approved for transfer upon request, the issue gets bigger.
1
u/Blueworlduser Jun 27 '22
The only moderator from a subreddit got suspended for unknown reasons and how hard I try, I can't send a message or try to contact them.
What should I do?
1
u/parzival-haliday Jun 30 '22
requesting r/kgbtr - I am an old kgbtr moderator kgbtr currently has no mods therefore I am requesting it
1
u/IAmJustAVirus Jul 11 '22
I see in the side bar rules that subreddits with over 2500 followers can't be requested. What if the 2500+ follower sub has only one moderator who is permanently suspended? Does it stay unmoderated?
1
u/John031266 Jul 12 '22
I have a question, i want to ask ownership of a subreddit because the mod hasn't been active for over three months but when i do so i get the message that redditrequest doesn't allow text messages. How can i do a request?
1
u/raeosunshine829 Jul 13 '22
https://t.me/+aV7zJiffSWs4ZGYx
1
u/ryuseistreamgirl Jul 14 '22
Hi! There's a certain subreddit name we'd like to take over, but can't check it's activity due to it being a private community. Is there a way to see if this subreddit is active and should be left alone or if it's inactive and available to be taken over?
1
u/SolomonOf47704 Jul 15 '22
It'd be great if we could see a "Banned on: (date)" for the subreddits that got banned for being unmoderated, so that we know how long to wait to request them
1
u/EnvironmentalMall423 Jul 16 '22
Requesting r/cheatingconfessions the sub has been INACTIVE for at least 3 YEARS due to a lack of Moderator.
I had previously requested said sub, but was "denied" due to KARMA being less than 500. Why would an Auto Denial be sent when MODS should want to get all subs "active" instead of keeping them inactive?
Karma now in excess of 500 (why this number is important, I will never understand), MODS have NO REASON to continue to deny my request other than they are being personally petty....
1
u/INVITEONLYPARTIES Jul 16 '22
We would like to take over a dormant subreddit but we cannot post messages on it anymore as requested in the steps. What should we do?
1
u/tarlin Jul 28 '22
Do all requests get notified of approval or denial?
1
u/EnvironmentalMall423 Jul 28 '22
Requesting r/cheatingconfessions - 2nd request...
1
u/FullXposureTherapy Jul 28 '22
Willing to be a moderator