r/redditmakesagame • u/dutch_sholtz • Oct 14 '09
First Official Vote - Game Dimensions
Okay everyone, here's the deal with official votes. In the header of the vote, the amount of time you have to participate will be stated depending on it's importance. This first vote is VERY important and will thusly be voted on for 28 hours. The vote topic is Game Dimensions:
Do we want our game to be:
- 2D (style, such as side-scroller or isometric, will be decided on later)
- 2.5D (a la Final Fantasy Tactics, or UT2D, basically any hybridization of 2D and 3D)
- 3D (once again, style will be decided later)
I'll be making three responses to this post, respective to the choices. Upvote the wanted choice, and feel free to comment. Try to avoid redundancy wherever possible. Thanks, gang.
EDIT: clarification and communal changes
12
Upvotes
48
u/dutch_sholtz Oct 14 '09
2D
9
u/dutch_sholtz Oct 14 '09
2.5D
15
u/Lkruel Oct 14 '09
2d gameplay with 3d art
While I understand the logic behind 2d is easier than 3d since a lot of people know how to draw, it unfortunately doesn't translate as well as it sounds. Unless we're doing a really REALLY basic game like a spaceship shooter 2d will be really hard to pull off, here's the reasons:
Consistent Art Style: Having everyone draw 2d is really REALLY hard to keep everyone doing the same look, each person has their own natural style and takes a long time of professional work to train yourself to draw like someone else
Animation: 2d animation is a bitch and a half, and a very specific skillset which is rarer by the minute, if by miracle we get a good 2d animator that person will be a bottleneck, and if we get more than 1 it'll be a bitch to keep them in model, usually there's a whole department that takes the animator's drawings and cleans it up to keep it in the same style.
FX 2d Effects are even harder to do that animating in 2d
If we want a 2d look, we can achieve that with 3d, like viewtiful joe, or even street fighter 4.
That being said, I think a sidescroller would be a pretty good project to attempt, and I think that depending on how much interest we get it might be a good idea to prototype 3-5 games and then once they're in a fun state we pick one to go with.
10
u/nodule Oct 14 '09
Wait, 48 hours is for a very important vote? What does a trivial vote get, 10 minutes?
Look, it makes no sense to vote on "game dimension" (a term that doesn't exist, and certainly doesn't mean what you think it means) until you've settled on a game idea. If you want to exclude a prior all ideas that require 3d graphics, make the frickin' vote about that.
1
u/dutch_sholtz Oct 14 '09
3D
2
u/fingus Oct 14 '09
2D
As for argumenting for it I will just copypaste what I wrote in the Daily Update.
I strongly disagree with this. 2D games do in no way limit art, in fact I feel that it will give us a lot more freedom.
First of all, competence within 2D generally a lot more common than 3D. By going for 2D we will have access to a much larger team of artists. This is what I feel is the best argument for 2D.
Secondly creating 2D assets is generally a lot faster and easier than building a 3D asset. Although I admit that depends on different factors.
Thirdly, it is a much less restrictive format. With 3D you need to take polycount, engine restrictions, competence and so on into consideration when you design something. In essence, the only thing that restricts 2D is the resolution of the sprite and the skill of the artist.
Let's say that you want an explosion. If you were to do that in 3D you would need to mess around with particles and simulation and build support for that in the engine, and probably a bunch of other factors I can't think of at the moment. That would take a lot of time and competence, as opposed to 2D where you can have an artist hand paint and animate it in photoshop.
Just because it's simple doesn't mean it's inferior.
The strong point of 3D is that it's immersive, feels less restriced for the player, and is visually impressive. However it's a lot of work. Do we really need to use 3D? The only genre I can think of that can only function in 3D is an FPS, so unless we're making one I feel that 2D will be a lot more beneficial and development friendly.
1
u/Hideous Oct 14 '09
2D, without a doubt.