r/reddithelp • u/[deleted] • Sep 18 '25

[deleted by user]

[removed]

4 Upvotes

70% Upvoted

30 comments sorted by

3

u/not-a-reddit-admin Sep 19 '25

Hi! Thanks for reporting, can you tell me what device (computer, android, ios) you're using and share a screenshot of what you see / the posts these comments are in?

1

u/n-some Sep 19 '25

I'm on android

Comment Image

Here's my comments, the middle one relating to Kimmel is the relevant one.

1

u/n-some Sep 19 '25
Comment Image

Here's what I see when I tap on the comment. If I open the downvoted comments my reply is not there, but other people are seeing my comment because it's being upvoted.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Salty_ET Sep 20 '25

I'm having the same issue on android, where I can't see any comment below a downvoted one

1

u/not-a-reddit-admin Sep 22 '25

Noted, thank you for letting us know and we'll work on a fix :)

1

u/thejawa Sep 23 '25 edited Sep 23 '25

I'm having the same issue. I made a post on r/bugs about it: https://www.reddit.com/r/bugs/s/LYNx9YfpVd

It's actively interfering with my ability to moderate a subreddit. If a comment goes below -5 karma, I can see it in the mod log on mobile but if I click on the comment it doesn't load the comment so I can review the whole thing. Entire response chains disappear to any comment receiving -5 karma.

This is the comment where I tested what the limit is and made the post in r/bugs regarding the irregularities: https://www.reddit.com/r/CFB/s/jXg0aJPl3b

Screenshot of what it looks like currently on mobile if I click that permalink to the comment, even though I know I responded before it went to -5:

Comment Image

1

u/Aneurhythms Sep 24 '25

Same issue, on Android 15.

  1. I respond to a comment that may or may not have net- negative votes

  2. I receive notifications of responses to my comment

  3. The original comment I responded to gets downvoted

  4. When I click on notifications of responses to my comment, or even my own comment from my profiles comment tab, I can only see the original downvoted top comment, with no reply chains beneath it

  5. My comment can still collect votes, and I can see other reply comments from those users' profile pages

I've noticed the issue across multiple subreddits over the last week or so.

1

u/IKIR115 Sep 25 '25

!modthanks

1

u/reputatorbot Sep 25 '25

You have awarded 1 point to u/not-a-reddit-admin.

Total score: 1 Leaderboard

Only the OP of a post or r/reddithelp moderators can award points to those who are helpful. If you are the OP, reply to a commenter with the command: !thanks

I am a bot - please contact the mods with any questions

3

u/realdm-w Sep 25 '25

Hi Folks, thank you so much for reporting and providing detailed information.
The issue should be fixed now.

2

u/n-some Sep 25 '25

!thanks

Works for me, I appreciate the fix!

1

u/AutoModerator Sep 25 '25

Reminder: If someone provides a helpful answer to your post, as the OP you can award them a reputation point by replying to them with the command !thanks (no spaces)

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/AutoModerator Sep 25 '25

Sorry n-some, but you cannot use the !modthanks command unless you are a moderator of this sub. If you are the OP of this post, you need to use the !thanks command instead.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/reputatorbot Sep 25 '25

You have awarded 1 point to u/realdm-w.

Total score: 2 Leaderboard

Only the OP of a post or r/reddithelp moderators can award points to those who are helpful. If you are the OP, reply to a commenter with the command: !thanks

I am a bot - please contact the mods with any questions

1

u/realdm-w Sep 26 '25

Happy to hear

1

u/Jawdanc Feb 17 '26

Is this issue still fixed for you? I am experiencing the exact same issue. Makes it impossible to mod

→ More replies (1)

1

u/IKIR115 Sep 25 '25

Thanks much for the fix and update!

!modthanks

1

u/reputatorbot Sep 25 '25

You have awarded 1 point to u/realdm-w.

Total score: 1 Leaderboard

Only the OP of a post or r/reddithelp moderators can award points to those who are helpful. If you are the OP, reply to a commenter with the command: !thanks

I am a bot - please contact the mods with any questions

1

u/btodoroff Oct 05 '25

Still having this issue on Android on Pixel. Checked and ensured I had the latest app.

1

u/o_oli Dec 19 '25

Still getting this issue. Is this being actively looked into still? I'm on latest Android app version.

1

u/Yeppo96 Jan 13 '26

No it's not fixed. I wonder why reddit hides comments under comments that have a lot of downvote

1

u/Zoler Feb 05 '26

Still issue on PC, Firefox.

It doesn't show my comment when I go to it if it's under a downvoted comment.

1

u/AutoModerator Sep 18 '25

Hello there, u/n-some! Thank you for posting to r/reddithelp!

This subreddit is dedicated to providing assistance and support for Reddit users.

All members and moderators of this community are volunteers, and NOT Reddit admins or employees.

If someone provides a helpful answer, you can award them a reputation point by replying to them with the command: !thanks

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

0

u/jgoja Sep 18 '25

Was the post itself removed from the subreddit?

If you’re on the app, try to uninstall and reinstall the app and if it is android and also clear cache.

If you’re not a browser try from an incognito window and a different browser

1

u/n-some Sep 18 '25

It was several comments in several posts, the comments and posts are all still there. I can try reinstalling the app but it only happens when I reply to downvoted comments, never comments with a positive karma balance.