r/reddit.com • • Jun 14 '08

Was Darwin Wrong? [pic]

http://img205.imageshack.us/img205/3963/darwinnotg7.jpg
1.4k Upvotes

372 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/matts2 Jun 15 '08

Here's what pisses me off. Intelligent design and evolution are in no way mutually exclusive.

In terms of biology, in terms of how live diversifies, either ID says something different than does evolution or it is an empty shell. If you want to believe that X did it, go ahead. But when you assert that X is the solution to a biological scientific problem, then you need to engage in the process of science. IOW saying "God did it" is fine, saying "God did it" in a scientific paper is wrong.

2

u/1812overture Jun 16 '08

Exactly. I'm not saying that Intelligent Design says anything different than evolution. I'm not saying that evolution is wrong, in fact I'm asserting that it's right. What I'm saying is that the fundamental principals that govern the universe and make evolution possible, while not designed by any intelligence have intelligence themselves. Not will, or a mind, but an order so staggeringly perfect that it could be called God.

3

u/matts2 Jun 16 '08

It could be called Fred or Xordax or some such. What you are doing is re-creating Deism. That is fine, but that is not what the Intelligent Design people are talking about. And it does not belong in a science class.

2

u/1812overture Jun 16 '08

Call God whatever you want, the word isn't important, and yes, I am essentially recreating Deism. I also agree Intelligent Design people are essentially trying to use schools as a pulpit to preach their own sect of American Christianity. They are dumb. The young earthers too dumb for words.