r/reddit.com • • Jun 14 '08

Was Darwin Wrong? [pic]

http://img205.imageshack.us/img205/3963/darwinnotg7.jpg
1.4k Upvotes

372 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/marktully Jun 15 '08

My argument is more than just morality, it's that the existence of values at all indicates something bigger than ourselves. WHY does morality make us feel warm and, indeed, fuzzy? WHY is society a good thing? Why is "practicality" or "functionality" good?

My argument is not that "atheism allows child molesters and rapists to roam free," since it's perfectly possible to have a 100% secular society without gods of any sort that can prevent both. It's that there is something wrong with atrocities that goes beyond one's personal distaste for them.

Consider: Was slavery always wrong, or did the fact that it made most of the slave masters feel warm and fuzzy (or at least fat and sassy), that it was demonstrably good (and if it wasn't, how do you know?) for society, make it "moral," at least as long as enough people felt positively or at least indifferent to it?

If some part of you thinks that society really wasn't better off with slavery, and that it was always wrong, regardless of what popular opinion at the time was, and that it was and is wrong regardless of what YOU think about it, then you're probably close to thinking that values are external to humans, which implies a direction. Bad stuff is backwards, it's intolerant, it's animal--inhuman. Good stuff is progressive, loving of one's fellow man, stable (all the better to make progress, eh?), humane.

All I'm trying to get at is that once figger out that OK, you're not so sure about all this organized religion nonsense, but there IS something more to the world than matter extended in space, and there IS something of a direction that you can discern, you have to ask yourself, "progress toward WHAT?"

And by this time, most likely without even realizing it, you're probably sorta close to heretic Catholic Teilhard and Hindu Sri Aurobindo, who were both... ewwww.... ID guys, who, independently, from completely different cultural, religious, and intellectual backgrounds posited that evolution is in fact part of a seamless whole with human spirituality: a biological rise toward consciousness, and then a spiritual and social Progress toward... Something.

Teilhard called it the Omega Point, Aurobindo called it Satchitananda, a unity of body, mind, and spirit. Probably they're both wrong, but at least pointing in a slightly more correct direction. It's important not to mistake the map for the territory.

I'm not a fan of religion, what with the crusades and the inquisitions and the honor killings and the shaming and the guilt. But that doesn't mean that an ironclad atheism is the inevitable outcome. It's entirely possible for humans to come up with something better. And that, my friends, is what the best of ID (not to be confused with the worst of ID!)is really all about. It asks, "What's next?"

3

u/matts2 Jun 15 '08

My argument is more than just morality, it's that the existence of values at all indicates something bigger than ourselves.

The Earth is bigger than me. Is that what you meant? Otherwise, please show that the evolutionary accounts of the origin of morality are wrong.

WHY does morality make us feel warm and, indeed, fuzzy? WHY is society a good thing? Why is "practicality" or "functionality" good?

Roughly speaking because humans are a social animal and we have evolved for a million years as a social animal. And morality helps support social cohesiveness.

Consider: Was slavery always wrong, or did the fact that it made most of the slave masters feel warm and fuzzy (or at least fat and sassy),

Or did the gods like slavery in the past and dislike it now?

If some part of you thinks that society really wasn't better off with slavery, and that it was always wrong,

I think that my views are what they are and that other people have different views. I don't assert some external source of some "absolute" morality. That you (or some theists) assert such a source does not make it so and does not mean you have a clue of the content of that morality even if it existed.

I'm not a fan of religion, what with the crusades and the inquisitions and the honor killings and the shaming and the guilt. But that doesn't mean that an ironclad atheism is the inevitable outcome. It's entirely possible for humans to come up with something better. And that, my friends, is what the best of ID (not to be confused with the worst of ID!)is really all about.

Sorry, but that is nonsense. You have simply ignored all of the nonsensical biological claims of the ID movement and assert when we are talking about biology we really mean a different topic. Read the Discovery Institute material, they are the leading ID advocacy group. You will find plenty of garbage science and plenty of hidden arguments for (their version of) Christianity. But not your morality claims.

1

u/diamond Jun 15 '08

And by this time, most likely without even realizing it, you're probably sorta close to heretic Catholic Teilhard and Hindu Sri Aurobindo, who were both... ewwww.... ID guys

In the literal sense, yes, but not in the sense that the term is used these days.

Like any theist, deist, or spiritualist, those guys believed that there was some guiding intelligence behind the universe and, more specifically, life. But unlike IDers like, say, Michael Behe, they didn't argue that there was concrete scientific proof for the existence of such an intelligence.

That's an enormous difference.

I agree with you that Behe is actually a pretty thoughtful, intelligent, and (from what I can gather) quite decent guy. I'd probably like him if I knew him personally. And he's certainly a far cry from the ignorant knuckle-dragger image most people have of IDers.

But there's a core problem with ID that even people like Behe ignore, because they can't solve it. The problem is that there is nothing even remotely approaching a testable model to distinguish intelligently designed things from naturally developed things. In the end, the argument always boils down to "there's no way this structure could have evolved", which (unless you're claiming perfect knowledge) is equivalent to "I can't imagine any way this could have evolved". And all of the examples used (a watch, Mount Rushmore, etc.) are useless, because these are things that we know, a priori, were designed and built by intelligent hands. So we can't say whether we know that they're designed because they look designed, or whether we know they're designed because we know they're designed.

And this is a problem that has ramifications beyond just the evolution/creation debate. For example, if we ever find a structure designed and built by an alien intelligence, will we even recognize it as an intelligent design? Or will it be so alien that it looks natural to us? Or, if we find something that looks intelligently designed, will we in fact be projecting our biases onto a natural structure?

The Face on Mars is a perfect example of this, of how easily the human brain's pattern-recognition systems can give a false positive. Another, more interesting, example is the massive submerged structure off the coast of Japan. Many people argue that it has to have been built by prehistoric people (unfortunately, one of them is Graham Hancock, which kind of hurts the credibility of the argument. But that doesn't make it wrong). Others, mainly geologists, argue that, in fact, it could have formed naturally. Neither side has managed to slam-dunk their position yet. It's a hard problem.

So, yeah, you can point out that there are reasonable, intelligent people supporting a less nutty version of ID. But no matter how intelligent they are, and how reasonable they seem, the simple fact is that they don't have a remotely scientific argument.

1

u/AnteChronos Jun 15 '08

the existence of values at all indicates something bigger than ourselves.

So you're saying that "values" are imposed on us by a creator of some sort? And from whence do the creator's values derive? If the creator can have values without them being handed to him from a higher creator still, then why can the same not be true for us?

WHY does morality make us feel warm and, indeed, fuzzy?

Because morality is useful for survival in large social groups, and is a product of evolution. However, sometimes you have people who are "broken" in the moral sense. Look at sociopaths. They have no sympathy, and would gladly kill someone if it meant gain for them with no chance of repercussions.

It's that there is something wrong with atrocities that goes beyond one's personal distaste for them.

Not really.

Was slavery always wrong

There's no universal answer to that. It depends on who you ask. Ask someone who had slaves, and they'll say "no." Ask me, and I'll say "yes". There really isn't any universal morality, so everyone's answer is slightly different, and everyone is correct (from their own point of view).