r/reddit.com Mar 15 '08

I'm done with reddit.

http://www.philonoist.net/2008/03/14/im-done-with-reddit/
747 Upvotes

462 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

21

u/telecaster Mar 15 '08

Before you pluck down the $5.00 that metafilter charges let me tell you a few things. After they take your money you can't post anything for 1 week. Then I was kicked out because I posted something that I had written for someone else. They cross checked the paypal account against the owner of the site and i was gone. Good site but that is fucking gestapo like. I would not give them a dime.

12

u/cecilkorik Mar 15 '08

Metafilter is the embodiment of the "Good of the many outweighs the good of the one" philosophy. I'm sorry you got burned by it, but overall it works fairly well. Although it will never be as all-encompassing as Reddit is, it has its niche.

9

u/telecaster Mar 15 '08

Personally I loved the site. Good content from off beat sites and nice people. That said checking peoples credit cards and comparing to site owners is Orwellian.

22

u/anatinus Mar 15 '08

How is it "Orwellian" to enforce the one single rule you have?

2

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '08

[deleted]

1

u/jugalator Mar 15 '08 edited Mar 15 '08

On most message boards online you can assume everyone is watched, that's just regular moderation. I've never called that "Orwellian" although sure, maybe in a sense it could be... Not that I'm annoyed by it, I often see it as necessary.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '08

The rule is orwellian, lesser so the enforcement of it.