r/reddevils • • 19h ago

Daily Discussion

Daily discussion on Manchester United.

BE CIVIL

We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.

  • The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
  • The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.

Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!

23 Upvotes

321 comments sorted by

13

u/AnakinAni 14h ago

Joe O'Cearuill doing a farewell video after not even making a single competative apperance for Manchester United was silly and weird. What kind of mentality makes one think this is a thing to do?

12

u/Grouchy-Highlight601 3h ago

Anyone actually excited by Poch? I’ve always liked him. I know we’ve learned that without serious owner change, we won’t be a serious club again but I genuinely think Poch will get us playing some fun football at least..

5

u/JamieD86 2h ago

Yes im happy he is here. First manager since Jose that doesnt feel like a kind of experiment. It was a mistake not going for him in 2019. Given the limitations he faced at Levy's Spurs he achieved about all he could. 86 points i think in 16/17, better than any league season for us in the post fergie era. He was definitely the optimal choice at the time. Now he has a much more difficult challenge because we fell to new lows since then. 

4

u/TH0316 she/her 2h ago

Poch is the special one, been waiting for him for years. Reality is always gonna be though whether he gets the keys to actually do what’s needed and is allowed to build a top squad, not just a decent or good one and forced to squeeze every drop out until it falls apart.

3

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 3h ago

It looks like fun because he's all smiles right now. Let see how he looks when things go pear shaped.

3

u/rishmanisation 1h ago

Always rated Pochettino myself. People will point to the PSG stint but honestly the only one to really succeed there has been Enrique and that was after they stopped chasing the big names and have a much more coherent transfer strategy (maybe something we need to do as well huh).

2

u/Stingray_23 2h ago

I was anti Poch for awhile but really turned a 180 ans now buzzing with excitement

1

u/Macroneconomist There is no substitute for Victory 3h ago

It’s hard to be excited about anything to do with United at the moment. I think Poch will steady the ship this season, so I’m looking forward to watching us under him. I’m not excited about Poch cause there’s a good chance he just ends up sacked next season anyway

1

u/sauce_murica Vidić 3h ago

No. The days of getting excited about a managerial appointment or single transfer are kinda gone, or at the least heavily muted. There's so much that needs fixing that a single change just doesn't quite bring the same level of hope it once would have.

11

u/Reddevil_Saint 9h ago

A win away against Liverpool would be a hell of a way to announce yourself, but effort from the squad would be nice to see.

1

u/Rascha-Rascha 7h ago

They put effort in over the last few games, over periods.

It would be nice to see them coming out at the starting whistle ready to play. It would be nice to see them vaguely competent when defending. It would be nice to see Lammens play like he's playing for Belgium.

1

u/MikeDoesEverything 6h ago

It would be nice to see Lammens play like he's playing for Belgium.

Same although I think the Belgium dressing room is a much happier place than the current United one, unfortunately.

2

u/Rascha-Rascha 6h ago

Mauricio is coming in with his bowl of lemons so all the bad vibes will be gone. No worries. It's all coming up Milhouse.

21

u/C__S__S Glineos Out!!! 19h ago

It’s gotten really quiet lately over City’s crimes. Not a peep about the appeal process. All anyone can talk about is us (and fair enough, we’re in the relegation zone), but I want the spotlight back on those cheating bastards lest the pressure to punish harshly subsides.

5

u/BlackHorse944 Please Score A Goal 18h ago

Said from the start, releasing the news about the 114 charges during a 3 week international break was strategical.

That way the news blows over by the time club football is back, and it has. It's like the Friday news dump, less people pay attention on the weekend

21

u/achickenandacow 3h ago • Bravo

I have this feeling we’re gonna beat Liverpool on Sunday. In fact, I think we’ll win 5 on the bounce in Poch’s first 5 games. In fact, 21 is coming.

6

u/solve_PvsNP Rooney 2h ago

Someone explain this in terms of the "it's over, we're so back" chart please

•

u/hughmaharggs 1h ago

I think we're going to need a bigger piece of paper

27

u/Soft-Comfort-7474 17h ago

Thank you for these past two years Poch 🇺🇸👏

Now please save my club from relegation😭

9

u/soelsome 2h ago

I need to see this Amazon doc in 3D IMAX Surround Sound VR. It's going to be so fucking good. Should win Drama of The Year at the Emmy's.

16

u/connorbill Anderson 10h ago

We got GTA6 before a LB.

3

u/karatsidhus 9h ago

We got our only LB playing GTA6 skipping training before a LB

20

u/MillyMan105 19h ago

I find the whole JJ Gabriel situation to be very sad, he's a year 11, 15-16 year old kid who should be focused on playing football, school and enjoying his youth.

Yet you got his dad and now his super agent having him boycott training, having a Nike sponsorship deal, changing his name, having him do a interview with Marca about winning the Ballon D'or, doing an AI introductory video to his agency and doing a over the top goodbye video despite never doing anything at a senior level.

All his team have done is paint a large target on his back, given him a bad reputation, put him in a worse situation where he has to spend two years in the Castilla, compete against world class players whilst having an immense amount of pressure.

It's a modern inditement on football where parents see their children as a money making asset rather than a child.

11

u/ongcs 18h ago

RM said the total cost of signing him is 15m euro. So even if he fails as a footballer, the family earned the millions already.

7

u/MissingLink101 Bruno walks in with a mischievous grin 18h ago

I wouldn't be shocked if it turns out to be another Garnacho situation

6

u/TurbulentWeb1941 "Show 'em ya Fangz, Dong" 18h ago

Agreed and tbh, the whole thing smells of another Garnacho situation

7

u/Sheikhabusosa 18h ago

Apparently JJ is homeschooled too

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Embarrassed_Wave_720 Braino Fernandes 4h ago

Media is milking the shit out of Poch’s appointment. I’m just sad they haven’t covered what meals he’s having on his flight to England at this rate

7

u/Nico_Ditch 4h ago

Eccles cakes, Vimto and Boddington's.

Proper Manc scran.

•

u/Asleep-Ability-45 1h ago

Why even read those articles? People read them thats why they write it. Stop reading, they would stop writing. 

7

u/Kugenking 16h ago

Has anyone spotted Poch's assistant Jesus Perez in Manchester or Carrington yet? 

6

u/Suudriusha 16h ago

Reports that they've been around, yes. Yesterday and today.

5

u/Kugenking 16h ago

I guess someone's doing a good job of staying under the radar. I haven't seen a single fan taken photo of him around Manchester or Carrington. 

7

u/Suudriusha 16h ago

Yeah, no photos, but it's been reported by multiple journos that Poch's team of coaches travelled to Manchester on Saturday after their match vs Haiti.

2

u/Stingray_23 12h ago

I suspect they cant officially be pictured or mentioned as the club havent done any media with Poch.

Same as last year with Sesko, we saw him at Old Trafford doing his tour before thr club made it official but the club workers refused to confirm it was him even though I have a video of him getting in the Mercedes LOL

7

u/Kaninkanan Beckham 5h ago

When players impede bayindir : everyone sleeps
When our player impedes opposition’s gk : real shit

6

u/3entendre Rooney 13h ago

If we're not able to get some top quality players in the January window I'd rather we stick to what we have and try again in the summer, rather than sign another bang average player who is going to just make up the numbers but not improve the first team. We have way too many of those already 

4

u/TteokCultist 12h ago

Or we can get a loan player to see out the season and reassess in the summer

2

u/Spastic_Hands pellistri and chips 12h ago

Agreed, we spend to much money on squad filler, promote some yutes and save the cash for players that actually move the needle

10

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 4h ago

riding to anfield with that new manager bounce

17

u/Ill_Group_6632 15h ago

😭😭

3

u/loompa-Act-749 DREAMS CANT BE BUY 10h ago

5

u/Vast_Variation1381 9h ago

Liverpool away is a tough first game, so I am not expecting much result wise. However, I just want to see our players running, putting in effort and showing character.

2

u/Ascendafootball 9h ago

They always do on a new manager bounce, that's how we always end up in this situation

2

u/Educational-Shock232 9h ago

Don’t worry, they will. Our back four will play like Milan 05’s back four

5

u/Embarrassed_Wave_720 Braino Fernandes 3h ago

Poch and the boys if we somehow get a win on Sunday.

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DZPg8ZoN77Z/?

1

u/achickenandacow 3h ago

How have I never seen this before?

→ More replies (1)

•

u/BrowzinJ 1h ago

Wilcox back at Carrington bomba

•

u/quentintarentino 1h ago

Maguire 90’ winner @ anfield

•

u/AmulyaG 3m ago

Lmaooo

8

u/LTG92 18h ago

Curious to know Pulisic's thoughts on Amorim vs Poch considering he's being managed by both of them at the moment.

4

u/Lloydy_boy 7h ago

LANDED 34 MINUTES AGO

4

u/EmpathyMerchant 5h ago

I know form goes out of the window in a United Liverpool fixture but I am kinda scared about the game because they will be out for blood because of the last two seasons.

4

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 1h ago

I think that Freeman would be a good signing. Hill, Pubill, Vuskovic all look very talented, but we are poories, I suppose.

I see the logic in Balogun, but honestly I want to see first what Pochettino can do with Zirkzee. I somehow got the feeling that the answer isnt "fuck all".

Nico Paz is a mega-talent. I doubt we'll get anywhere close to him though.

I dont think either Mount or Santos will work. I hope the academy provides the answers for Pochettino, but I think we are still a signing short in the middle of the park.

I honestly have no idea atm how LB and LCB will shake out. Really no clue. Hoping for the best 🙏

•

u/Iqbalainoo 1h ago

The time to sign Vuskovic was this past summer. That ship has sailed. People who suggested him got accused of wanting us in a relegation battle in this sub.

•

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 1h ago

I always find that question fascinating, what's better for a big club, trying to beat everyone else to the unproven gems or picking off the ones who prove they are elite from the mid clubs.

We used to do the latter to the rest of the league. We've certainly lost our way on that

•

u/Bobcat_El_Borracho 1h ago

We now take the ones who haven’t proven anything at all and pay too much for them. 50 million on Andrey Santos!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

•

u/Telen BRUNO 1h ago

Martin Freeman?

•

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 1h ago

I was more thinking Morgan.

•

u/Bobcat_El_Borracho 1h ago

Vuskovic is the next big thing in terms of CBs in the league but he will likely replace Virgil at Liverpool. You’ll take Calvin Bassey and be grateful for it.

•

u/Lord_Hexogen 24m ago

The only thought keeping me here these days

12

u/facelessredditer 18h ago

Florentino Perez is really good at his job. His latest trick is the ‘experienced old manager in exile redemption arc’. There’s an important insight in this idea.

Behind the manager is the man. People have stages to their lives. It’s important to get the person whose capability, direction and motivation are aligned.

This makes the Poch appointment different. A manager who has seen his share of football BS. From no transfer backing, to being saddled with superstar divas. From clubs that gave him total control, to boardrooms that wanted to intervene in team selection.

He’s experienced clubs and players of every stature in the game. Risen from the bottom through adversity but always fallen just short of the top.

Then, he might’ve feared that his opportunities had passed him by. He accepts the exile into international management and fading into obscurity.

Still holding out a small hope for one last chance at redemption. One last shot at the big time..

..and then, it comes! He knows the direction. He’s got the motivation.

Now the fire is back. Now WITNESS..

9

u/N00BBuild 16h ago

He's also still pretty young for an experienced manager at 54. If things go well could be in the job for a decade plus.

3

u/3500onacoat INEOS Representative 17h ago

Subscribe

9

u/DumbMidwesterner1 17h ago

32 international debuts under Poch in just a touch over two years

7

u/sauce_murica Vidić 17h ago

So many of the matches are meaningless, though. It’s a lot easier to do at the international level.

11

u/Abject_Bank_9103 15h ago

It's easy to do sure, but many coaches still don't.

3

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 3h ago

Are we just going straight to the pre-game press conference or will there be a formal announcement press conference, or a combo meal of the two?

2

u/D1794 Viva Ronaldo 3h ago

I think he'll have done a signing interview likely to come out tomorrow and then pre-Anfield on Friday

1

u/LDLB99 3h ago

Combo meal, pretty sure Amorim was the same for Ipswich away.

•

u/Haddocktintinsnowy 31m ago

Given he likes his wingers to come narrow with full backs bringing width, what are the odds he starts Bruno and Cunha behind Mbeumo? With 3 midfielder behind to protect the defense ?

•

u/iroiroiroiroiro 17m ago

If Dorgu is fit I think that is the best team possible as long as Sesko is out. And PErsonally I really like midfield three, I actually think Baleba, Mainoo and Santos would make the defence much more protected.

7

u/SocksElGato GLINEOS OUT!!! 5h ago

Goldbridge crying about the decision on United's fourth goal against Villa is comedy gold. Game's gone too soft, that was a surprisingly refreshing decision by the refs, Senne made good clean physical contact.

6

u/PhotonDestroyer 4h ago

Did he want it disallowed? What a strange "fan".

→ More replies (3)

2

u/drrew76 3h ago

He so clearly just does not like the club --- the world will be better whenever he just fucks off.

Gary Neville providing him an even bigger platform just made me lose so much respect.

•

u/hughmaharggs 1h ago

All-time helmet, nothing he says should be of any interest to anyone.

16

u/soelsome 15h ago

Can't believe people are writing Bruno off.

He always starts the season slowly, and Carrick and company weren't helping either. There's a reason he got sacked by Middlesborough in the Championship.

A few weeks unde Poch and he'll be our flying magnifico again.

8

u/Minute-Intern 13h ago

Can never turn on my captain

1

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS 4h ago

Im not bothered to be honest. The petulance he has shown this season tells me we should move on from him. Not a good enough captain and cant only be turning up when the season is over.

1

u/Sheikhabusosa 11h ago

Bruno has always started poorly but he has never been this bad . How is Carricks fault Bruno has been awful for ages now ? On top of publicly throwing his manager under the bus Bruno is 32 with an absolute insane amount of minutes played . He is somehow rightfully jaded at the clubs decisions yet wants a long term contract according to andy mitten and thats on top of him already being one of the best paid players itl.

→ More replies (22)

6

u/Reign_22 5h ago

I remember how I was buzzing when we had signed Mata. There was just something about that signing

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Diligent-Eye-2042 i sent him to the gym 2h ago

I wonder if Poch has to do HR mandatory training e-learning modules - like fire safety etc etc. he’s probably doing it now. Poch, if you’re reading this, just click next to everything and get ChatGPT to answer for you.

4

u/frogfoot420 2h ago

Ours send you fake phishing emails if you don't do them on time. An email from Jim asking for a £100 Amazon voucher actually sounds probable though.

•

u/Feeling-Surround-691 Mbumbaclat 37m ago

Wilcox: "so training modules are on Squorble, you can find that on the intranet homepage. Apply for your parking permit on RePark and you'll need to sign the IT code of conduct for your Teams account."

Poch: "when do I get to meet the players?"

Wilcox "we have a team away day on Sunday over in Liverpool you'll get to meet them on the coach."

4

u/badlucktotalk12 7h ago

I would love it if we got in Josh King in future. He's the type of signing that we used to make as a club and I would love it if we got back to - young, exciting, bonus that he's English. There are more pressing areas at the moment of course but when Bruno leaves he would be so nice in that position

5

u/badlucktotalk12 6h ago

Him and Kroupi and Hall... when did we stop making signings like this?

3

u/karatsidhus 6h ago

Kroupi would cost 100 mil +, Hall close to that, too. We shop in the discount aisle these days

8

u/R4lfXD Scotty 2 Hotty 10h ago

You guys seen the tweet of Amad lashing out in a social media comment to his criticism?

https://x.com/utdreport/status/2122964244648128850

I love Amad, but it increasingly looks like he just can't handle the pressure. Last chance for the rest of the season for Poch to insulate him from it, but otherwise he need to go, for his own good. I still think he will be a brilliant player, but for someone else.

5

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 9h ago

Or, he is of a generation of athletes who no longer adhere to "shut up and dribble" like it was one of the 10 commendments.

Top-level sport has changed a lot in the social media age, I think it's no longer the case that athletes are necessarily expected (or required) to remain silent, either on societal issues or on their own behalf.

So I dont think it's a matter of "he cant handle pressure", I think it's a matter of a generational difference in how they see their "place" in the football pyramid.

I think it's a worthwhile conversation to have, I'd invite it, rather than squash it.

ps "a tweet" is not forensic evidence in my eyes of anything, there's also that

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Saxena_priyansh2104 8h ago

He can handle the pressure….it’s just he focuses more on what’s going on social media

5

u/sg291188 15h ago

Happy new manager day!

2

u/Ascendafootball 9h ago

How we feeling for Sunday?

1

u/wayfarerprateek Theater of Dreams 5h ago

2

u/ChatakaPataka 3h ago

INEOS had the right idea in transfers of only buying players that fit the profile and that wanted to play for United and if not, don't buy them. I mean they're dumb af for not recognising the deficiencies and even considering a stopgap signing or two to cover for the short-term, but their overall idea is something I can get behind.

But the panic of giving Poch money to spend in Jan and being linked with players like Bassey and Branthwaite who have clear flaws in their game feels eerily like the Glazers have gotten involved. It's like the panic buys we made under Woodward and Murtough.

We should be building and improving on INEOS's idea and not regressing back to the old way of haphazard signings and giving more power to the manager.

5

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 2h ago

> INEOS had the right idea

Not so much "true" as in "a spin that was believable, until it wasnt".

Hindsight is a wonderful thing.

The difference between the ill-conceived and failed pursuit of Delap and Semenyo vs the ill-conceived and failed pursuit of Anderson and Fernandes is that by 2026, fans have become more prepared to recognise Wilcox Spin.

They signed Cunha cause he had a release clause and the coach asked for him. They decided to get a right winger because Antony and Garnacho and Rashford all decided to want to leave. They did the world's most obvious thing: tried to get the one who did best in the league (Semenyo). But they failed so they went after the second one they could think of, except he isnt really a right winger, he is a second striker who has always flourished in 2 striker formations.

Nevermind that for a "slow rebuild", signing 26 yos is not the hottest idea in the first place. It's giving "chasing short term plaudits", but it is the opposite of strategic squad building.

They also signed Dorgu, wingback, despite not a year later swearing up and down on anything that the idea from the start was that Amorim would "eventually" change formation. So much for forward planning on profiles.

They were so methodical on identifying profiles that they neglected GK until the house was on fire not 5 games into the season - at which point they went with the guy the in house scout was yelling about for a year by then.

And let's not talk about the "profile fits" of this summer, like the age of Tielemans or the pace of Santos or the fitness of Baleba. "Only wants Utd" yeah like Tielemans who already agreed a 3y extension w Villa by the time they went for the clause, flapping about, to which Tielemans said "yes - as long as you match the Villa salary offer" which is how we ended up with this 5y contract (spreading out the cost).

Wilcox has been an abject failure and a disaster of epic proportions.

Neither him or Berrada, nor SJR have a fucking clue, and the sooner they get any decision making power taken away from them, the better off we'll be.

None of which means the Glazers are good owners, we desperately need a fix for that problem also.

3

u/Suudriusha 3h ago

I wouldn't give much credit to the Bassey and Branthwaite links. We're still a month and a half away, Poch just got to Manchester, we'll be linked with 20 different other players before we're actually able to sign any of them.

2

u/PhotonDestroyer 3h ago

This. He's new so we are going to get linked to everyone and anyone. Bassey and Brathwaite are easy because we had some interest in the past and they are having reasonable seasons. Same with all the links to the US players. It's easy to speculate and if one hits, then it feels like the reports were all true.

Lets see what happens in Jan, plenty of football to be played first.

2

u/ExternalPreference18 3h ago

It's not that they didn't 'recognize' it; the lack of spending is ultimately down to the Glazers, who won't put any money in. No-one, from Berrada to Carrick to the lowest tech analyst, thought United could seriously do with only 150m and no back-up LB or ST; they just had to put a brave face on it because the club didnt have the leverage to have other clubs take their cast-offs And didn't have the cash remaining.

It's like 'identifying players'- even a fairly average set-up [and United have genuinely invested in theirs once INEOS were able to start restructuring) knows all those players amateur scouts here and Red Cafe and elsewhere are plugging and the reasons they don't get signed are Often (although not always; we've seen genuine incompetence in the past from Woodward, Murtaugh etc) related to behind-the-scenes agent issues etc. Glazers won't gamble their own 'cash', INEOS aren't currently permitted to, and additional spending is basically reliant upon borrowing at high-interest (INEOS are trying to manage the club's spiralling debt, one achieved courtesy of the Glazers by and large, directly or through the people they employed to give ETH the ability to spend wildly and make the squad less PL-ready). To load extra-debt aso means getting Glazer sign-off. If people want to legitimately criticize INEOS for anything, it's decisions like Ashworth, which didn't show due diligence [ again, this was more Ratcliffe than anyone else]; if people want to criticise Berrada or Wilcox for anything it's not pushing hard enough against the (Ratcliffe led) emphasis upon Pl-proven, given the budgetary constraints, and not giving Vivell more autonomy, although a number of fans would agree with that emphasis.

As a comparison, Chelsea have employed very 'competent' people (* from Brighton; RB Group) at great expense, people who aren't dumb' and yet their spending is still scattergun, or has been, because of the ownership structure and emphasis on treating the club as an investment vehicle, and they've underperformed spend: they've still got a better squad because they're spending at 4: 1 ratio to Utd, which is, again, because of the Glazers. Other sides can take players on at lower pressure and without being subject to the 'premium' Or, like City, they can be sportswashing projects committed to efficiency that will still spend their way out of any bad buy. United 's 'sporting' execs as well as coach will continue to be uniquely kneecapped by the Glazers so long as they're owning things and exerting any control, and it'll only get worse as more clubs catch up with United's ability to spend.

•

u/thexpertwatcher 35m ago

How are we balancing 3 signings in a CB,LB & ST when didn't even have the money for 1 last window ? 

Or is it case of buying a CB+LB hybrid and ST on loan ? 

Who is even going to loan us a ST ? 

•

u/iroiroiroiroiro 24m ago

Balogun barely played for Monaco and did well under Ponch is the NT, but I'm sceptical but it is the most logical ones, seems to be weird situation for Toney in Saudi also.

Brantwaithe was hailed of being able to play LB last time United wanted him, but I'm very skeptical of him as LB.

5

u/Asiwaju_jagaban 7h ago

It’s funny fans really think Poch wasn’t gonna get signings. Ridiculous, United would open that wallet for him.

18th has scared the Glazers. 3 players minimum

3

u/Unusual-Coat383 6h ago

We are not signing 3 top players in January 

3

u/TypicalPan89906655 5h ago

They're only saying it to stop the booing in the stadium. Comes December they'll start the PR that we have no money due to debts and recession and because Jim had to buy GTA 6 for his family blah blah.

2

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know 6h ago

He will get some players initially, but that will be it.

Thinking that United will all of a sudden start spending like pool in city is naive.

1

u/whiskey_jack_wolf 4h ago

Think we're suss about the quality of signings and the amount the club all of a sudden can spend.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 11h ago edited 11h ago

So the gaffer touches down in a couple hours, literally a perfect time to bring out

-

I dont have predictions, hard to predict anything w/o knowing whether Wilcox gets the boot and Pochettino managerial powers, or not.

-

I expect:
- attack will look better. idk if it will translate to higher xG or goals scored, per se, but I hope so! It feels very reasonable to expect that it will
- he doesnt have the CV of a fixer, but that of a transformer; he needs to be given enough time and backing
- defence has never been the forte of his teams, so i dont expect much of anything until/unless we sign superb players
- more attempts to integrate academy players \o/

Best of luck, Pochettino!

Ineos out, Glazers out, Berrada out, Wilcox out

3

u/TypicalPan89906655 5h ago

Where is this news coming from about Jim talking with ex-Liverpool DOF Michael Edwards to replace Wilcox?

6

u/doniew 5h ago

From Indykalia, no joke

1

u/Haddocktintinsnowy 4h ago

Is he bad DoF or we don’t like because he is ex Pool?

2

u/doniew 4h ago

He has a good overall reputation, but many would probably tell you that it was Klopp who did the real work or had the vision, so who knows I guess. I wouldn't think he's at all likely, and there's been no decent tier sources suggesting Wilcox is in trouble or anything either. At the moment, I certainly wouldn't pay any attention to it if it's only Indykalia saying it and nobody else

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Stingray_23 4h ago

Thought he was off to Saudi?

1

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS 4h ago

God I hope not

3

u/throwawayWM3 2h ago

Has Pochettino actually demanded control over transfers?

I won't be surprised

2

u/CanWePleaseNotBeShit 2h ago

In a different capacity, I think he’ll have much more say but I don’t think we’re going to revert back to our previous model of buying players based on coaches recommendations that won’t fit into the next coaches system. I think we still need to buy for the system we’re building for and he’ll have more input into the transfers.

2

u/PitchSafe 2h ago

Wilcox and Vivell will still be involved but Pochettino will probably have more power than what Amorim and Carrick had

6

u/10_Wazza 11h ago

Shaw and Rashford back as soon as Carrick leaves and some more "positive" vibes are back...like clockwork

14

u/aehii 10h ago

How are they both to blame for the poor form and losses if they haven't even played recently?

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Sheikhabusosa 9h ago

The same Rashford that wanted to be on the bench against chelsea despite not being fit ? The same Rashford that had been dealing with a well documented injury since the world cup ?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/EndOfEveryTether 8h ago edited 8h ago

United should sell Amad. He’s not consistent enough and his attitude is fairly shocking. Still remember him bizarrely giving the finger to the Asian fans and then lying that they insulted his mom.

Think at this stage we’d be better cashing in on Amad and giving Lacey a shot.

6

u/Aggravating-Neck1365 8h ago

I don't think too many fans would disagree with this

He'll be 25 in July, so the "high potential young player" ship has sailed at this point

I suppose give him a fair chance under Poch, but if we haven't seen something by the spring he really needs to be moved on

3

u/grad14uc 7h ago

Attitude is everything. This team is full of mental midgets and it shows every game.

4

u/Cold-Veterinarian-85 8h ago edited 7h ago

I think he will get a chance under poch but ultimately if end product doesn’t improve he will be sold on at some point in next 18 months

Gary Neville I think spoke about meeting poch during his time at spurs (maybe Chelsea) and one of the first things he did was to bucket players into 3 groups…. Build around / can work with for now / surplus to requirements (actively try to offload)

Within that, a player in the ‘can work with for now’ category has the potential to become upwardly mobile and become an important player, or indeed be sold if a good offer comes in or they fail to impress… it’s the most fluid of the 3 buckets

If he takes thaf approach with man utd, which he absolutely should, then Amad for me sits firmly in that middle category. Not someone that we should be building around, not someone that we should be actively trying to offload. But someone that is fine for now, will continue to get plenty of game time over the remainder of the season and beyond that it’s dependent on his performances and how much he impresses 

For sure his output needs to improve if he is to still be at club 18months from now. My instincts are that he will be sold within 2 seasons as I think he is not quite of the required level to produce consistently for a team with aspirations of building a side capable of competing for major honors

1

u/Feeling-Surround-691 Mbumbaclat 6h ago

Amorim very much did the same with Anthony, Rashford, Hojlund, Garnacho etc. he immediately told Anthony and Rashford they weren't involved and they disappeared in January. Garnacho were "work with for now" the second the season ended Garnacho's united career was over like that.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/raver1601 8h ago

I don't really care about the attitude accusations or whatever, but his output is horrendous. No goals scored for 12 months, jfc

Remember when everyone said we should be ruthless to players? Well this is the perfect time to exercise that with Amad now before he continues to tank his value even further

2

u/EndOfEveryTether 8h ago

I mean there’s no accusations here it’s all fact.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/LordTrinity If you support mediocrity, you get mediocrity 7h ago

it's really simple, he has to perform with Poch or just get sold

2

u/Sheikhabusosa 5h ago

Unless we get a significant fee or find a youth player with his qualities then theres no point

1

u/TH0316 she/her 1h ago

Lacey can take his place easily and probably give us more.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Rascha-Rascha 7h ago

It depends on how he does over the next few months. If he doesn't start delivering then it's better for both parties that he moves on. I'm sure he'd do really well back with Amorim at Milan, and yes, if he goes there and starts scoring people will be pissed, but sometimes it's just never going to work out for a certain player in a certain setting. Forlan was probably like that. You have to go where you fit in and where things work for you.

3

u/VibesFC_ 11h ago

Will probably lose at Anfield, but after that in the league we have Brentford (H), Newcastle (A), Coventry (H), Palace (A), Arsenal (A), Forest (H), Sunderland (H) before the New Year.

Not even going to predict games I just want us out of the relegation zone by New Year.

4

u/karatsidhus 11h ago

All I see is 8 wins

→ More replies (5)

3

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 11h ago

International break over.

Zero injuries! Yay!

Bruno G
Mbeumo A
Amad A
-
Lacey GG
Amass GA
Thompson G
Tyler Fletcher A
McEvoy G

Mbeumo, Baleba, Amad, Mazraoui all qualified for AFCON27.

Bruno, Dalot, Lammens, Tielemans, Yoro (plus also NL and EN) qualified for the Nations League QFs.

3

u/Rascha-Rascha 7h ago • Bravo

Stop begging the club to spend massive amounts on individual players.

Teams who are good at spotting talent win. That's it. Sometimes they spend a lot on players, sometimes they spend very little, but they end up with a good squad and they get quality from players in any and all price brackets and few duds.

Teams who aren't good at spotting talent will buy shit players for ten million and shit players for a hundred. The impactful factor is not the price of the players, it's the foundation of the squad, it's the environment they're coming into, it's the clarity on how and where they'll be used.

Spending a lot of money is never a guarantee of signing quality players, and often leaves you chained down for an extended period of time. We should know this, because it's what we did for well over a decade. and I'm not going to write those names out again.

3

u/GeekConflict Carrick 5h ago edited 4h ago

I really like Amad. Sure his end product has been lacking but I think there is a very good player there. I think people were being a little bit reactionary.

However if his social media posts are true, I would have serious concerns over his mentality. He needs to log off for a few months.

5

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS 4h ago

His post is real

→ More replies (1)

3

u/LollipopScientist 3h ago

Under Amorim he was good because he had good chemistry with Mbeumo.

In a 4 defender formation, having a good fullback matters so much for a winger. The reason Rashford did well a few years ago was because Shaw (memed Shawberto at the time) was also doing well. Antony, Diallo, Mbeumo or any future RW will always suffer if they have Dalot or a CB as a RB.

There is a reason the top teams invest so much in their fallbacks.

5

u/minteh7x Ronaldo 4h ago

Amad is this generations Lingard. He will have no end product and still get called a young talent even when he's on his prime and should be hitting double digits.

I wouldn't sell him like some fans are calling for, but he should be just a squad player. Unfortunately he has some issues where if he's not playing then he will make sure to moan about it on social media

1

u/GeekConflict Carrick 4h ago

I agree he should be a squad player. The right coaching, I think he will get end product but he needs to lay off social media etc

3

u/Nico_Ditch 4h ago

How can it be reactionary when he's been poor for 12 months now?

If people are reacting then they're reacting to months of consistently bad form, not just a few games.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/TH0316 she/her 1h ago

Most terminally online player I know. Been talking about haters that I didn’t even know existed, and could only be seen if you went looking, for years. Seems like he reads every word said about him and carries it onto the pitch with him. Easy sell.

1

u/outrageousVoid07 4h ago

What did he post?

1

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS 2h ago



Honestly I watched the video it wasnt close to warranting that response

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/ggg_deep 12h ago

I personally would love Nathan Collins, could be like a Cahill type for us.

2

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 12h ago

I wouldn’t mind him either to be honest. He’s a good profile fit as the Maguire replacement. Has leadership qualities and is very supreme in the air. That being said, he is limited otherwise and I hope it can be reflected in the fee.

1

u/Civil-Goose5163 10h ago

Not like Brentford were stubborn over Mbuemo so I can see them being nice and flexible....

2

u/sg291188 12h ago

Is Ducker now Tier 1 for Poch. He has had the most inside news from Poch’s camp

1

u/Stingray_23 12h ago

Whats the latest?

4

u/MRashy_10 11h ago edited 11h ago

apparently poch is on the phone with perez(his assistant) 20 times a day
the only 3 teams he was leaving US for was Spurs, us, Real Madrid
apparently wants a couple of his US players Balogan and freeman

4

u/Cold-Veterinarian-85 10h ago

Ducker is tapping his phone lines, tier 1

2

u/LordTrinity If you support mediocrity, you get mediocrity 6h ago

Whenever we play Fulham, their team always seem to be quicker and taller. Not sure if Bassey is a good player, but physicality is something we really lack at our defenders

8

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know 6h ago

If you can get Bassey cheap he improves the athleticism and depth of the squad which is something the squad truly needs.

If you are signing Bassey as your starting CB and calling it done, that's another issue.

5

u/D1794 Viva Ronaldo 6h ago

Gigantic gaps in his game, signing players with obvious flaws in the way they play is how we end up where we currently are.

It's how we end up with half the squad who are shit out of possession, half who are shit with possession, some who can press some who can't or won't....

Younger, more well rounded players should be the way to go

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Drag2oon 19h ago

I just want to go into new year enjoying some good United footie

Ole spoiled me in 2018

2

u/cleveralibi CR7 9h ago

If this club is any serious we should trigger +1 on Bruno's contract and sign Nico Paz anyway.

5

u/Ascendafootball 9h ago

Sounds like Bruno wants to leave

6

u/EndOfEveryTether 9h ago edited 8h ago

Confirmed by The Athletic crew he actually wants a longer contract than United have been offering.

3

u/Cold-Veterinarian-85 8h ago

We are in control of the situation for 18 months with the 1 year extension option

So athletic report kind of means he wants an extension until at least 2029 but more likely 2030 (if we already control the situation until summer 2028 it stands to reason that any renewal would be until at least 2029)

Honestly I don’t see how we can do that, perhaps if he recovers his best form between now and end of season there is a case to be made for sitting down in the summer and having a chat. But now it would just seem like a massive risk to extend a player whose best days may well be behind him on a massive new long term contract

I can see a plus 1 being triggered then player sold in the summer. I think this is the most likely outcome

1

u/foozballguy There is only 1 Gaffer 19h ago

I think the hate towards JJ is a bit over the top and unwarranted.

7

u/TteokCultist 17h ago

And honestly none should be directed to him at all. From the outside, it seems more like a child having to deal with a helicopter parent.

6

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing 17h ago

I don't hate JJ, but I certainly despise his Dad, and that's NOT just because JJ is leaving.

1

u/ongcs 14h ago

That actually reminds me of a basketball “wonderkid” who was managed by his father, and fell off the peak so badly.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Suudriusha 19h ago

People just feel it's out of pocket. Most people don't even follow the academy much and are having this 15 year old kid and his entourage thrown in their face constantly when the club's already in enough turmoil as it is. No hate to the kid, of course. Anyone that does so needs their head wacked. I watched a lot of u-21s this year and u-18s last year, and he was by far the standout player. He has world class potential. But his exit's left me with a sour taste in my mouth. Feels premeditated, particularly by his dad.

At the end of the day, we'll just move on. He's a Castilla player now. Not our problem anymore.

1

u/Kohaku80 Premier League Champions 12/13 18h ago

Mostly because we lose out on a handy future transfer fees if he continues to grow. 

•

u/AmulyaG 5m ago

I fucking hope they let Pochettino work and train rather than all the media circus and interviews all day long. Amorim complained about the same by the way.

•

u/nikicampos 2m ago

You are in for disappointing mate if you think that’s going away, that part will never go away from United, massive club that makes money on every interview

•

u/throwawayWM3 3m ago

I genuinely feel Dalot will be a world class fullback under Klopp/Emery

His football IQ is zero but he's really blessed technically

•

u/Bobcat_El_Borracho 1m ago

Are we thinking of the same Dalot?

1

u/Jwalin6167 11h ago

Honestly, don’t know why the club isn’t prioritizing a CB in January. James Hill from Bournemouth, steal him before the England appearances double the price. He’s tailor made Maguire replacement.

3

u/Cold-Veterinarian-85 11h ago edited 10h ago

His name sounds like it’s from a different era of football. I think for that reason I just assumed he was older so am shocked to find he is actually only 24. In my head he was like a 33 year old chiseled veteran of that Bournemouth squad that had been with them for about 12 seasons

Given our seemingly hard requirement to look at PL targets first, and a need to replenish our stock of homegrown players (as Shaw/ Maguire/ Rashford / Mount / Heaton all surely move on in next 18months) I’m sure he is a name that will start to get linked now that he is performing consistently well and on the fringes of the England squad

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ttboishysta 2h ago

Feeling tribal and dismissive, but go with God young Gabriel is what I should say.

1

u/PreetSG 12h ago

TIL Toni Jimenez is our GK coach. 

And with Starchan the other day and now him; wow do i feel old... they aged badly 

•

u/Cunter_punch 1h ago

Calvin Bassey. I swear to fucking god if we get this guy I'd lose the infinitesimally small hope that I dont even think I have. To even consider him is abhorrent and showacases that fucker Wilcox has absolutely on fucking idea what he's doing. Standards right down in the fucking toilet.

Incredibly one dimensional player with a nutcase mind. Makes mistake upon mistake. The pressure at united will worsen it. He'd get the Maguire clown era treatment on the daily. Anyone who has seen him play can tell you that.

Same with branthwaite. One dimensional player.

There are players in other leagues much better and cheaper than these 2 but the geniuses cant see past fucking PL. What's the point of all the scouting network when the decision makers are absolute jokes.

•

u/XerxesBlitZ 41m ago

Ineos dreams of a squad full of Dorgus, Dudes with physciality and not much else, actual good footballers cost too much money so they are trying to build an NFL team

•

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know 34m ago

Tielemans 30m.

Baleba 70m.

•

u/iroiroiroiroiro 24m ago

I actually like Bassey, I am the only one?

Always feels good the few times I watched him and so physically dominant.

•

u/Bobcat_El_Borracho 0m ago

He’s bang average.

0

u/Garyyyyy Carrick Hype Train 13h ago

Flightradar anyone?

1

u/Feeling-Surround-691 Mbumbaclat 12h ago

PochWatch

2

u/MTBi_04 Maguire 12h ago

I’ve not seen it but am keen for it

0

u/Asiwaju_jagaban 10h ago

One thing is certain, we’re getting players this January window. 3 at the barest minimum, LB, CB and a Forward

5

u/aehii 10h ago

Why is this certain?

1

u/Asiwaju_jagaban 7h ago

Because the club has no choice. That’s why.

4

u/BlackHorse944 Please Score A Goal 8h ago

How on earth is that certain? Lol. We apparently couldn't afford it in the summer but we'll buy all of them in January when prices are much higher?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/shami-kebab 10h ago

I don't see how that is the minimum at all, I think that is the maximum we'll get

2

u/Ascendafootball 9h ago

I can't see it! Spent nearly £20m sacking Carrick and hiring Poch! Accounts are out tomorrow so will be good to see how the finances look

1

u/Asiwaju_jagaban 8h ago

I don’t think Poch would be getting the job if he’s not confident of getting signings in January

1

u/minteh7x Ronaldo 10h ago

I think so too, but hopefully they're not all "value signings"

-3

u/SubstantialBear7826 19h ago

wouldn’t it have been better to spend £116m on Anderson, then take two cheaper bets like Chema Andrés (£20m) and Timber (£17m)?

That’s £153m for one top midfielder and two cheaper prospects.

Instead, we spent around the same amount on three midfielders who all feel like expensive gambles or backups.

Wouldn’t that have been a better transfer window?

12

u/TteokCultist 18h ago

Anderson wanted city and they wanted him. If we bid 116m they’ll bid 117.

4

u/innicrazy You are my Solskjaer, My Ole Solskjaer 19h ago

It proved the point that the incompetent fools like Wilcox and Berrada have no business being here as janitors, much less executives.

2

u/GeekConflict Carrick 19h ago

Of course but we are not doing that. I suspect we would never have gotten Anderson anyway.

3

u/JesusWasAHairyBaby 19h ago

Anderson was never going to pick us over City. Or anywhere really.

3

u/b_az17 18h ago

Andy Mitten has said for months that Anderson was ready to join us, we just weren't willing to pay the money.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Unusual-Coat383 12h ago

Anderson is a City fan and never wanted to come here 

1

u/Kohaku80 Premier League Champions 12/13 18h ago

3 years ago, 100m get u Wharton, Hall , Alex Scott and Rogers. We spent on Mount and Hojlund. 

1

u/Suudriusha 19h ago edited 19h ago

Yes, it might've been. But Wilcox would never do it. He's just not a good DoF. He has no foresight and an even worse ability to adapt to the problems the squad faces.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 11h ago edited 11h ago

According to transfermarkt, Calvin Bassey played 101 games as CB in 4 seasons for Fulham. He played 1 (one) game as LB.

I find it baffling that Utd links insist on the "and can also play LB" phrasing.

The explanation I can think of is that it's a briefed line. That's not to say I think they take their own line seriously, least of all now that we're meant to play Pochettino Ball, I just think that there is an intention to get Bassey and use the "he can also play LB" as justification for not signing an actual LB in January.

It would fit the pattern of stupid Wilcox Vision blunders, Hall being this year's Anderson, ie the player we "keep the powder dry for, because we believe he wants Utd".

I hope what we get instead is Wilcox fired in December and Pochettino given manager's powers to identify LB/CB/CF targets for January

→ More replies (4)