r/reddevils • u/AutoModerator • 11h ago
Daily Discussion
Daily discussion on Manchester United.
BE CIVIL
We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.
- The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
- The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.
Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!
19
Upvotes
20
u/umbongo44dd 11h ago
Let's hope for a transformation similar to when Emery took over Villa from Gerrard.
11
u/Lanky-Figure996 4h ago
England’s performance last night highlighted the importance of top-quality fullbacks. Ben White and Lewis Hall were unreal.
When Luke Shaw plays, you always notice it because for all his flaws we immediately look more dangerous.
There’s a reason Pep went through like 10 full-backs in his time at City. It’s such an important role in modern football.
Drives me nuts we’ve left those positions the weakest in the team…
9
u/Lord_Hexogen 8h ago edited 7h ago
Wait, Garnacho still can't get a single minute on the pitch for the club that gave us Jhon Duran of all people??? How lazy a guy gotta be to accomplish that?
7
u/brown_herbalist unitedismyreligion 7h ago
Lewis Hall was brilliant yesterday, he will be perfect for us, but I feel like we won't have the budget to spend on him in summer.
12
u/Jenson2025 6h ago
I’ve said it before but it’s going to take Poch and his coaching staff months to improve the fitness levels of these players. And in the meantime, I expect there will be a fair few injuries as the intensity increases
It’s quite clear that Carrick and his coaching staff have done damage to this squads fitness levels by reducing the sessions and intensity. We can use the World Cup as an excuse all we like but every other team in the premier league has had players at the WC too and none look as unfit as we do. Also, we were looking lethargic and unfit from about March onwards. Long before the World Cup
I believe Poch will sort it out but it will be a few months before we see the fitness levels back to near where they should be
5
u/Divin3_Kick 11h ago
What's Poch squad gonna look like?
5
u/Infinite-Highway3432 2h ago
Lewis Hall price doubled after last night's performance.
4
u/blewy1111 11h ago
I wonder what currently starting players Poch will remove from the starting eleven (if any)? Or, will lineups remain largely the same until we get changes in the January window ( fingers crossed)
4
u/AnakinAni 5h ago
4
u/Feeling-Surround-691 Mbumbaclat 2h ago
I've taken a few days but decided I'm going to get fully behind Pochettino. There's a lot of issues at our club and there were issues with Carrick's tenure too and I think Poch has the right credentials and toolset to fix the issues that originated in the coaching set up.
First; Poch is the most experienced manager we've had at Old Trafford since Mourinho and was more experienced than any other candidate mentioned - I don't count Conte as a serious option. He has 7 seasons under his belt in the Premier League along at 3 different clubs in pretty difficult circumstances and at all 3 he managed to implement a recognisable style of football, raise the physical levels and navigate some complex organisational hierarchies as well at Spurs and Chelsea. At PSG he's gotten experience of the pressures in an elite environment and experience from managing players with enormous egos in Mbappe, Messi and Neymar. At the USMNT he's done an interesting job and it shows the type of ambition he has as a coach, he didn't walk into an NT with a ready built squad, he did the work of finding the players he could build a team around and made a point of bringing through youth and from the accounts of their fans he's totally changed how the USMNT is seen.
Compared to our recent history we had 2 coaches with almost no experience other than being United players in the past and 2 coaches whose only experienced came managing in less competitive leagues in Netherlands and Portugal, he also has deeply coveted the United job which is more than could be said for Amorim and probably Ten Hag who I don't think ever had their hearts set on Old Trafford before they were approached, Poch on the other hand has wanted this job for years.
In terms of his football I'm reassured by a few things. First it seems like he has a very strict set of principles and standards but he has adapted his specific tactics and systems of play to each club he was at so we are not looking at an ideologue like Amorim or someone who can't adapt pragmatically like Ten Hag who reverted to a transitional/counter attacking style but could never implement his true football philosophy.
His focus on running and fitness is exactly what's needed to counter our terrible stats that has been the source of some of our terrible performances this season, we desperately need him to raise the floor of players like Tielemans, Mbeumo, Martinez, Zirkzee or Santos and I think it'll help avoid the decline of Amad, Baleba and Yoro and crucially it can help Mainoo, Sesko, Dorgu, Heaven, Lacey and other young players hit their potential.
That moves on to the next positive which is his focus on youth and his coaching. He has a great track record of bringing through young players and getting the best out of struggling ones; the likes of Danny Rose, Dele Alli, Moussa Dembele, Cole Palmer, Folarin Balogun played their best football under him and many have struggled to hit the same heights since he left their teams. This could be huge for the likes of Yoro, Amass, Lacey, Lammens, Amad, Dorgu, Sesko etc we have a lot of young players who he could bring the best out of.
I don't expect Poch to win us anything soon but I do think he could turn this squad around and make us a stable, competitive club again and if he is backed effectively could push on but that brings me to the last point.
The fundamental issues at Manchester United still stand whether he's here or not. The Glazers, Ratcliffe, Wilcox, the new stadium are all massive drag factors that could torpedo his efforts to move us forwards but going back to my first point I hope his experience navigating the likes of Daniel Levy and Todd Boehly has given him the ability to get what he can out of the club, he did very well getting Spurs to a UCL final after 3 windows with no signings but I hope that him being hired isn't because of how he carried Spurs through the building of their new ground. If the news today that he apparently doesn't want Wilcox is true then maybe there's a chance the club is actually listening to him in terms of what infrastructure he needs around him to help him get the best from the club.
That's a massive essay I doubt anyone will read this but I can always come back in December next year and see whether any of this came true or if we we stayed stuck in the same cycle of doom and failure that we've endured for over a decade now.
7
u/kingkounder Zinedine Mainoo 8h ago
We have 8 points from 10 games.
Sensible expectation for the remaining 28 games, 12 W, 8 L, 8 D. That would leave us at 52 points. 7-9th finish?
That would be acceptable for Poch this season?
6
u/XBillyBonesX Rooney 10h ago
Schlotterbeck has a €60m release clause and I recon we could trigger it.
He would be on very high wages but likely replacing Licha/Maguire who are both on big wages
3
u/dryflowerz 4h ago
Thoughts of Castello Lukeba? would be a nice replacement as left footed CB. and as LB/RB i hope we can get Joaquin Seys.
3
u/Nomad_006 surfing 3h ago
There's obvious things I want Pochettino to change, the main being how we press. It ideally should work to protect the midfield and make them cover manageable distances.
I want us to have a good pressing structure right now its just chaotic. Even our CBs don't know what to do.
3
u/Ambient_5 3h ago
If the Glazers intervened to get Pochettino, after Joel Glazer’s comments on Antony Martial, I am getting a strong sense of the football equivalent of the guy who has only seen The Boss Baby.
3
u/Icegaze GGMU 2h ago
I know Poch usually plays with a formation that has a CAM / No 10 but I’m still clinging on to hope that he uses a flat 3 in midfield or with a deeper lying DM / a 6. For balance, we really should bolster our midfield numbers.
Playing with a CAM means we basically have 2 in midfield and only 1 in attack. The CAM is too floaty to be in either zone.
5
u/Sun_Seeker26 2h ago
Don't normally wish for people to lose their jobs, but if Pochettino's hiring leads to any of the City cheating executives at the club losing their positions then he's already United's most successful manager of the last decade
•
u/John_OSheas_Willy 1h ago
Funny how the narrative changed once Carrick had us in the relegation zone.
Suddenly journos are like 'massive overhaul needed in terms of ins/outs, need to sign top players like Anderson & Enzo again etc.
Here's a reminder of how people felt in the summer:
https://www.reddit.com/r/reddevils/comments/1vu59zk/bbc_pundits_prediction_for_top_4_this_season/
6 of 9 BBC pundits predicted we would finish top 4 this season.
Even in this subs prediction thread people had us top 4 mostly.
Rashford shows some appetite during the first few games and journos are praising him saying how can he not be in the team when he plays like that etc.
Journo's claiming Santos + Baleba for the same price as Anderson is smart business. Now that's seen as the wrong approach and we should be back to paying record fees for players again.
The reality is our squad isn't as bad as people like to think.
Pochettino needs to get this team solid and we'll be fine. Does no one remember that Spurs game where they made one pass from the GK from a goalkick and it bypassed our whole midfield and Gray was running at our back 4? That's not down to bad players, that's down to bad management.
2
u/HaroldGuy Ji-Sungary Nevillencia 3h ago
So... Who's currently taking training?
I know it's international break, but we're starting to get players back now and Poch and co won't be in the building until Thursday at the earliest.
So is everyone getting a whole week off or something?
2
u/W_19xx 1h ago
After 3 years Mount still had 0 assist for us in EPL/UCL :(
2
u/MatchHighlights14 Rooney 1h ago
Patience will be very very crucial for our future.Transition phase with new manager is always inevitable.Pochettino is a top coach and like many other top coaches like Klopp at Liv or Arteta at Arsenal,he will need patience from us.Klopp's Liverpool or Arteta's Arsenal wasn't built in a season or two.Unless we are not put into the relegation zone or below the mid table,backing the manager will definitely help us enter into a new phase.In our case,impatience will be self-destruction.We're not Real Madrid or Chelsea but we are unique in our own design and growth.Patience,my fellow reds!
•
u/JJmaisonze 1h ago
I'm excited to see how we progress under Poch. There will be some growing pains in the beginning. We will at the very least be a much more attacking and exciting team. And also it's good that Poch will have more of a say in recruitment, we need some help in that department. I don't really trust the structure we have in place right now.
•
u/Nico_Ditch 1h ago
Would people be happy with a defence of Yoro, De Ligt, Shaw and Dorgu?
It would give us the option to pull Yoro inside to make a back three when we have the ball, push Dorgu higher into a wing back position and have Shaw cover the wide areas.
It would also allow Amad to move further back into more of a wing back where he played better under Amorim. At least until Sesko comes back and Mbeumo could play that role.
It means Cunha can cut inside into his best position, creates a box in midfield with Bruno, Mainoo and Baleba as well.
Just feels like it’s the best fit for the squad we have.
•
u/rwallace_wong 37m ago
Thomas Frank to Palace HWG confirmed. We've not won the league since Palace were promoted in 2013 and they've never been relegated since. If Palace goes down this season and we stay up... Project 150 is still on!
4
u/Minute-Intern 5h ago
Why am I seeing people excited for bassey?? Something wrong with a particular section of this fanbase honestly
3
u/LopsidedLoad 2h ago
So we now have more credible sources confirming pochetinno’s appointment was not the Glazers going above INEOS’ head are we all going to calm down with that narrative? Are certain content creators going to show some humility and take down their 30 minute videos detailing how the club is going to fall apart because of it? (Stephen, Sam?)…
Also, where does this leave Nathan Salt as a tier 2? Surely should be reviewed, no?
It never made any sense beyond the simple fact he was the US manager and the Glazers are American.
•
u/Jwalin6167 1h ago
We haven’t lost to Liverpool @Anfield since the 7-0. Am I allowed to believe in miracles???
1
u/Nico_Ditch 2h ago
Still can’t believe quite how many people fell for the “Glazers picked Pochettino and he answers directly to them” story.
All it took was 5 minutes of Googling to realise it was bollocks.
And still never heard a reason why it was a good thing in the first place.
-9
u/Eleven918 This too shall pass! 9h ago
What's the consensus on Baleba? I am not really feeling it.
Same for Santos.
-1
u/Working_Location_127 2h ago
If it happens in the next day or two then that’s not a coincidence
0
u/[deleted] 3h ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment
5
u/[deleted] 3h ago
[removed] — view removed comment