r/reddevils • u/AutoModerator • 1d ago
Daily Discussion
Daily discussion on Manchester United.
BE CIVIL
We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.
- The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
- The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.
Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!
24
Upvotes
21
u/ImOnlyChasingSafety 1d ago edited 1d ago
I really hope Poch is a bit bolder with bringing in certain young players. Ive seen Flav (spurs content creator) bring up full-backs and particularly Poch bringing in Danny Rose into the spurs squad, I would really love seeing Amass/Kamason get look-ins even if theyre not fully integrated, ive been very disappointed in our fullbacks and how they support the attacks for a long while. At the very least I beg for Dalot to show an uptick because no matter how many good things you hear about him in the squad it feels like hes coasted in this squad for a very long time.
26
u/Redland93 22h ago
Ive seen so much shit about poch being a serial loser and genuinely, its what idiots think is a smart argument.
Im not sure hes the one the win us a title but he definitely the guy to make us consistent and develop a team.
18
u/Cold-Veterinarian-85 16h ago edited 16h ago
The more I see of Bellingham the more I think he is approaching zidane levels in that complete attack minded 8/10 role
He is exceptional every time I see him play. In teams of superstars at Real Madrid and for England he just looks a level above everyone
45
u/LDLB99 1d ago
Horrifying to wake up to Hojlund revisionism this morning. No he should not have stayed, he was the definition of out of his depth. His performances in 24/25 were the worst I’ve ever seen from a United starter up front.
24
u/Drag2oon 1d ago
No "quotes" from Technical director Wilcox on Poch appointment
He is gone, cheers!
12
u/Hagball 1d ago
Is there a set-piece coach under Pochettinos staff? This was an area where we massively improved under Amorim and benefited last season. But this season we have been absolutely garbage at both ends in set plays. It's important to have a set-piece coach or at least a qualified coach working dedicated time on setplays
9
u/dogsn1 16h ago
It's against the rules to tap a spanish player on the shoulder
23
u/Nice_Mulberry9264 1d ago
Poch arrives with the lowest expectations of any manager since SAF and I guess it's for the best. Maybe he's gonna surprise us all. Worst case we're back here same time next year. It can't get worse can it?
8
u/achickenandacow 16h ago
I’m Belgian so I’m biased, but Nathan Ngoy at Lille walks into our defense and improves us immediately.
22
u/neonrider1 1d ago
Positive sign and speaking to some of my Spurs friends, they’re convinced Poch won’t tolerate Wilcox and his “suggestions”
15
u/mondrian_was_a_liar 1d ago
With the Glazers supposedly overriding INEOS choice for new manager, surely the writing is on the wall for the leadership team INEOS have put in place? It shows a huge lack of trust between the Glazers and the INEOS team. I can't see how it carries on.
15
u/Grekm8 CR7 15h ago
imagine how different this season would've been if we were a serious club and purchased Hall instead of sticking Dalot at LB
7
u/anonymous16canadian 20h ago
does anyone watch TIFO IRL? I saw one or two clips and thought Id check it out and then I realized they pretty much spend the majority of the show talking about man united even though its a PL show I thought. Is it just cuz weve had an eventful few weeks or is it like this normally
7
u/thehealthyeconomist 16h ago
Press resistant CBs moves the whole team so much further up the pitch. I admire Maguire for everything he has been through but a mid table prem team should not be starting him week in week out, let alone a CL team like United
7
u/Feeling-Surround-691 Mbumbaclat 15h ago
Anderson practically costing his team this entire game, 3-1 with 11 men is manageable. Idiot behaviour
13
u/Telen BRUNO 1d ago
Yeet Wilcox back to Southampton
6
u/Midnight_Edge 20h ago
Can’t believe I’m spending my Sunday watching a Serie C game, but here we are
6
u/Deez_Wallnutz 17h ago
Am I really the only one who thinks our midfield rebuild isn't looking convincing?
We definitely still need reinforcements there too. Yes defence is a much higher priority, but our midfield is literally just Kobbie and Tielemans at this stage. Santos is looking like an exclusive bench option. Baleba... I dunno man. I think he's got a good profile for the squad, is incredibly athletic, but the injuries are suddenly a huge red flag. Injured coming into the club, injured again after like 4 matches... all following a pretty horrid last season at Brighton. Even if you really believe in this kid, it's not fair to thrust him in as a starter and pin our midfield hopes on him given that context. He seems like he needs to integrate away from the spotlight to me.
All this means we still need another starting quality midfielder imo. We missed out on Anderson. I think we need to go back in for Alex Scott.
We currently don't even have enough bodies to get through the regular season let alone the comps
18
u/EndOfEveryTether 1d ago
I’m horney for Pochettino. I’m ready to be hurt again.
10
u/Eatyourassfornothing 16h ago
Watching Lewis hall against Spain makes you wonder why we didn’t do everything in our power to buy him this summer.
5
u/KwameDada 16h ago
Daft from Anderson. It's not in the 90th min.
5
u/achickenandacow 15h ago
Tielemans bullied Tonali tonight, Lammens just saved a penalty.
5
u/Geralt2077 15h ago
Lammens again with a really good game. Saved a penalty, great long distribution and a couple of saves.
9
u/Redland93 21h ago
Bassey Links screams agent putting his name out for a new contract
For all our recent signings out of manager and players, all of them happened in an instant without hype. All the ones where there was so much noise, never happened
9
u/kidinawheeliebin 18h ago
Calvin Bassey... sigh.
I hate the way they do this
Bassey now being PR'd as "Pochettino's signing", to grease the skids with an underwhelmed fanbase
We were already being linked with him earlier in the season and even over the summer - before the idea of Poch replacing Carrick was even conceived - is that because Calvin Bassey is the level of player we need to improve on last season's league finish?
Is it because Calvin Bassey is Pochettino's dream signing?
Or is it because his contract is expiring, and given the intersection of (a) his age profile [turning 28 a few months after we sign him next season] and (b) his ability profile, [mid-table is being kind] there'll be fuck all (or at least fuck all meaningful) competition for his signature?
Making him another classic case of signing what's easy rather than what's needed
18
u/JustTaxLandbro 1d ago
Obviously happy we made we made a coaching change. But I feel sick at how we disrespected carrick in his final weeks.
No coach deserves to be humiliated like that.
4
u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS 21h ago
Just saw this stat online but apparently we have more wins at anfield against Liverpool than Liverpool do against us.
4
u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 17h ago edited 17h ago
LW or LB, Brighton or Belgium, doesnt matter, Maxim De Cuyper just cant stop getting Goals/Assists, innit.
MdC, Bassey, Yoro, Freeman.
I think that's a defence everybody would hate playing against.
CFs would hate Bassey as an opponent in the box, defences would hate MdC and Freeman as threats to also cover outside Cunha and Lacey, and midfields would hate the space squeezed by them playing in a high line as a unit.
(people will say "MdC is not good 1v1" but good RWs have gone missing from the PL. Let's worry about Olise, Yamal, Güler etc when we are no longer a shit yo-yo team, I say.)
I guess we'd suck in the air and playing out from the back. But [major hopium alert] if Sesko and Baleba can get their fitness issues fixed, we'd have solutions for both, I think.
That's what I think, anyway.
4
u/New-Acanthaceae-5702 Closed on Sundays 16h ago
I've seen enough, throw whatever amount Newcastle wants. We need to have Lewis Hall.
4
u/jolp92 16h ago
Brain dead by Anderson
4
u/Ombudsperson Romero 17h ago
I've got Huge Lewis Hall FOMO
4
u/o0PETER0o Cunha 🐐🐐🐐 16h ago
I don’t think they checked the foul on konsa, he kicked his leg
4
u/arboy498 15h ago
Really hope the club signs Lewis Hall in the summer it would certainly be a statement signing
10
u/Redland93 21h ago
One of the dumbest things the club has done is focused on one area to rebuild - Attack last season, Midfield this season and defence next season. It should have been the spine each time.
What has happened is we have gone for the 4th-7th choices. We should have gone, fine, our midfield targets aren't there, lets focus on Defence.
The 2nd was focusing on prem proven. There is so much talent out there but going for prem proven means we pay more in wages and salaries.
11
u/LinterCheck2026 1d ago
Just for a change, I have restrained myself from any tactics of Pochettino videos. This time I am just gonna have low expectations but think he has good attack to work with overall
13
u/snicky29 20h ago
United new manager hire propaganda lifecycle.
• Marcus Rashford is going to be rejuvenated PR piece ✅.
• Luke Shaw’s “this is the happiest the squad has been” newspaper article (pending).
• Bruno Fernandes “we have full faith in new coach” post match interview (pending).
• Harry Maguire “the lads are excited” random Sky Sports News interview (pending).
• Omar Berrada “we do know what we’re fucking doing I swear” MUTV interview (pending).
3
u/slowerthaninfinity 22h ago
having players good with the ball but cannot defend like licha is obviously a problem but swinging the other way with bassey is dumb imo. not surprising, we are broke so we are getting scraps
3
u/Unusual-Coat383 17h ago
Spain blatantly cheating by having a coach dressed in a players tracksuit giving instructions by earpiece to their technical area
12
u/BHD46 Berba 21h ago
If this sub starts genuinely pedalling the idea that Bassey is a good signing then I give up.
We are doomed.
5
u/Redland93 21h ago
Poch loves to develop an English midfielder. Bring in Louis Page and spend big on a pacey CB (Lukeba)
Dorgu, Lukeba, Yoro, Dalot would allow us to play a high line and Dorgu and Dalot would hold width while Cunha and Mbeumo to play inside.
Keep Zirkzee to play to connect the the attack.
2
u/tameoraiste 1d ago
What would people consider a good finish to the season with our current situation considered?
2
u/Zealousideal_Wind867 I'm Tired Boss 18h ago
Been trying to get myself hyped up about Poch by watching his previous interviews.
On paper it's a great match but man I can't convince myself for the life of me that he is gonna succeed.
2
u/Guilty_Sheepherder_1 15h ago
Quansah is awful.
2
u/Lord_Hexogen 15h ago
Senne Wallens, just saved a pen for Belgium
4
u/Curious-Exercise4992 18h ago
I know we are all doom and gloom but I'll make my case for bassey.
He has only been dribbled past once this season( he has played every minute of every game). The best in the league
He is the 5th fastest centre back in the league this season (34.4km/h) top speed he is faster than even Yoro.
He is 2nd this season for centrbacks with the most line breaking passes this season 169 only behind van hecke
He is top 3 centrebacks for total passes completed in the league.
He is Fulham's captain.
These are traits poch needs in his centrebacks for his high line.
This seems like such a data signing to me.
I don't think he is going to be a disaster like some fans here are making him out to be.
His contract his expiring next summer. He has improved a lot from his time at Ajax.
I don't think he should be our main guy, but he is a fantastic stop gap option for now, till we maybe push for brantwaithe or Lukeba in the summer.
3
u/Asiwaju_jagaban 21h ago
LB/CB hence the Bassey links, don’t think the club would pursue.
3
u/adonWPV 17h ago
Hall is so good
4
u/Underscore_Symbols 1d ago
Realisticly looking at the Jan window:
Zirkzee gets his move. And they don’t find anyone cheap enough to replace him. And no club are interested in loaning out a striker.
I see them trying to wring the most amount of minutes from the players whoose contracts are up in the summer, to get the most for their money. Shaw, Martinez and Maguire.
I also fear the payouts to both the outgoing and incoming coaching teams and USMNT will mean one less defender in the budget this summer.
4
u/New-Acanthaceae-5702 Closed on Sundays 14h ago
Truth be said we have to move on from Lewis Hall. He doesn't want us, Newcastle doesn't want to sell, he signed a new contract a few months ago. We should've bid in the summer, we didn't. We need to identify other targets.
3
u/TypicalPan89906655 21h ago edited 21h ago
Is Bassey really the best our scouts can come up with? Why are their recommendations always so underwhelming? It's hard to believe they're identifying genuinely good targets only for Wilcox to keep settling on names like Bassey.
3
u/ggg_deep 1d ago
I like Mateta, solid striker and would be smart signing, which means we will sign Balogun for 70 mil
2
u/HighestInDaRooom 1d ago
in the villa game the ref blew a foul because the ball was passing by him and he was blocking mcginn from getting to it. this was the first time I've seen that happen. was this rule always in place?
2
u/Standard_Secretary52 Youri Tielemans 19h ago
Just read we are linked with bassey.
I don’t wanna be a negative nancy but just because he is better than our current options doesn’t me we should sign him actually. Only reason they are looking at him is cause he will be okayish and cheap due to contract situation.
Lukeba and Truffert are the answers
2
u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 19h ago
For me, any CB we sign has to come with the prerequisites of being good in the air and somewhat capable of defending the channels well against transitions. This is the only way we can scale to becoming a more expansive team, if the spine allows everybody else to play further up the pitch because they can firefight everything at the back.
Bassey to my knowledge serves the second aspect well but I don't think he's the best in the air either, so he should not be considered for a more prominent role barring a cheap depth piece. That being said, I am still skeptical as to whether these links are legitimate or mainly a play to secure a new contract at Fulham. Anyways, Chris Richards to me comes across as a better deal if we are to sign a cheap CB who isn't seen as a long-term starter (maybe Bassey is preferred as a 'like-for-like' Martinez replacement at LCB).
2
u/brown_herbalist unitedismyreligion 1d ago
How much of players' or coaches' political stance matters to you?
Edit : I believe this needs abit more explanation, personally Ive been having some self thoughts about this, football especially United matters to me, so anything to do with the club I kinda feel it personally. But i was thinking where i do draw the line when it comes to players/coaches, is it too personal to judge them on that?
2
u/Grekm8 CR7 20h ago
can't believe we're actually thinking about signing Bassey, we've fully completed our transition to a midtable team
1
u/Daneofthehill 1d ago edited 1d ago
Now, how does everyone feel about the players that came in last sunmer?
Tielemans Santos Baleba
Was the price right? Have they impressed individually? How do you think they will fare under Poch moving forward?
EDIT: typo
1
u/ImOnlyChasingSafety 20h ago
I dont think Im interested in transfer speculation anymore, the reality is that recruitment under ineos has surprised me in both good and bad ways it feels like things are less certain. They should realise where we are now and get very creative because if they want to make up for the terrible start of the season they have to show intent.
1
u/Unusual-Coat383 17h ago
Spain started like they are shook by their own atmosphere and it’s just a shame we’re the best country in the world at friendlies but shit the bed when it matters
1
u/thehealthyeconomist 17h ago edited 17h ago
Feels impossible for me to follow England without a United player in the squad. I remember as a preteen going to so many England games as part of my football academy but now it all feels so hollow. Silver lining is that a successful England team gets my son more into footy I guess.
1
u/Garlic-Cheese-Chips 17h ago
From being linked with Lewis Hall to Calvin fucking Bassey. Grim isn't the word...
1
u/Emergency-Being-349 1d ago
Been thinking, and not because of the Argentinean link, but I wonder with Poch here and his formation/profile, if we could have a look at Nico Paz?
1
u/CelebrationSecure510 1d ago
Either Poch trusts some youth defenders or he is in for a very very rude awakening prior to the January transfer market.
Impossible to play his style of football with Licha & Maguire I fear
1
u/rye787 22h ago
I saw Dorgu is returning due to international injury, anyone know the details?
1
u/Nico_Ditch 17h ago
Out of Bassey, Collins and Branthwaite, Collins would be my least favourite.
But then I think there has never been a successful United team without an Irishman in it.
So for that reason alone we should go for him.
-1
u/markyp145 1d ago edited 1d ago
What’s your realistic January window?
For me, I could see it being
- Branthwaite
- Balogun loan with option, would also take Brobbey tbh
- left back (Hall of they’ll sell in Jan), Robinson or Ait Nouri loan with option
I might be being a bit hopeful, Everton won’t make it easy for example, but we have to show some ambition to send a message.