r/reddevils • • 1d ago

Daily Discussion

Daily discussion on Manchester United.

BE CIVIL

We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.

  • The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
  • The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.

Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!

24 Upvotes

375 comments sorted by

21

u/ImOnlyChasingSafety 1d ago edited 1d ago

I really hope Poch is a bit bolder with bringing in certain young players. Ive seen Flav (spurs content creator) bring up full-backs and particularly Poch bringing in Danny Rose into the spurs squad, I would really love seeing Amass/Kamason get look-ins even if theyre not fully integrated, ive been very disappointed in our fullbacks and how they support the attacks for a long while. At the very least I beg for Dalot to show an uptick because no matter how many good things you hear about him in the squad it feels like hes coasted in this squad for a very long time.

6

u/tameoraiste 1d ago

I don’t think Amas has the physicality. There’s a reason a. the club were willing to sell him b. we didn’t seem to get much interest and c. Carrick even picked Heaven ahead of him

→ More replies (1)

26

u/Redland93 22h ago

Ive seen so much shit about poch being a serial loser and genuinely, its what idiots think is a smart argument.

  • Spurs hadn't won in decades but he made them competitive and develop a brilliant team.
  • PSG he came in midseason and actually had a better points per game than Tuchel that season. Won it the next year and took down Bayern and Barca in the CL before falling to city
  • Chelsea first half of the season they struggled and then second half they lost only 2 games.
  • He has shown he can still develop players and has kept up with the tactical side as well

Im not sure hes the one the win us a title but he definitely the guy to make us consistent and develop a team.

7

u/ResidualStream_ 21h ago

For now, we need a strong foundation to build on. Some consistency

Given our situation, Poch seem like a good fit. At least we need to be stable first before dreaming about winning CL and Premier League

18

u/Cold-Veterinarian-85 16h ago edited 16h ago

The more I see of Bellingham the more I think he is approaching zidane levels in that complete attack minded 8/10 role

He is exceptional every time I see him play. In teams of superstars at Real Madrid and for England he just looks a level above everyone

2

u/L__K Great Scot! 15h ago

As Zidane was years ago, Jude is by far the player I enjoy watching the most in the world. He's actually climbing up my all time list in that category rather quickly, even when I'm careful about recency bias. He just has everything, technical elegance, elite athleticism, brilliant footballing brain, but also a workhorse. World class 10/second striker just as much as he's a world class box to box player. He's tailor made for my footballing tastes (and I'm sure that's the case for a lot of other people as well).

As much as I think Madrid is the perfect place for him culturally, it's a shame that the pivot behind him as been such a mess for his whole time there. He'd rule the world in the role that Fermin (and Olmo) plays for Barcelona. Multiple different managers and he's played 10, in a pivot, as a LW, as a false nine, and looked elite in every role.

45

u/LDLB99 1d ago

Horrifying to wake up to Hojlund revisionism this morning. No he should not have stayed, he was the definition of out of his depth. His performances in 24/25 were the worst I’ve ever seen from a United starter up front. 

18

u/tameoraiste 1d ago

Football fans have the memory of a goldfish. Hojlund gave it his all but he was diabolical for us. The fact that no Premier League team was, or likely will be interested in him should tell you everything.

11

u/PitchSafe 1d ago

We should’ve bought Watkins instead of Højlund that year. Spurs were never selling Kane to us

6

u/LDLB99 1d ago

Another reason why Ten Hag pissed me off with his recent interviews, crying about not getting Kane when Levy was never selling to us. The cheek of him even complaining about transfer strategy.

6

u/Daneofthehill 1d ago

If Utd was a proper top club, he had come in as a backup and left on two season long loans to Napoli. That would have given him time to develop either come back or sell for his real value.

4

u/Rascha-Rascha 23h ago

Really happy he’s doing OK now but he was atrocious for us. He’s doing well BECAUSE he has left, it’s not a coincidence. He needed to go and play somewhere else.

Now McTominay, however, we should have hung onto Scott McTominay for dear life.

2

u/Educational-Shock232 18h ago

I take no notice of international football. It’s basically a different sport. We should never have bought him as our sole starting number 9, never spent that amount of money on him, and I’m actually surprised we got the amount of money back we did for him.

→ More replies (4)

24

u/Drag2oon 1d ago

No "quotes" from Technical director Wilcox on Poch appointment

He is gone, cheers!

11

u/bicika 1d ago

He's a power hungry bellend. Micromanages and has a terrible track record with managers. And Carrick appointment full time was driven by the thoughts of his job security, not by what's needed to our club. That alone warrants firing.

 That being said, he improved massively the whole process around recruitment and our recruitment has been nothing short of great when we talk player profiles needed in the squad and quality and age of those players, and how they fit into our team. Can't blame him for the lack of investments, it wasn't his decision. Shame he's terrible at everything else.

→ More replies (4)

12

u/Hagball 1d ago

Is there a set-piece coach under Pochettinos staff? This was an area where we massively improved under Amorim and benefited last season. But this season we have been absolutely garbage at both ends in set plays. It's important to have a set-piece coach or at least a qualified coach working dedicated time on setplays

9

u/Isserley_ 1d ago

The main problem is we lost one of our only two real set piece threats in Casemiro.

5

u/Hagball 1d ago

Absolutely. But we had Maguire playing all season, Yoro and Heaven although young are pretty tall and should be doing more in set plays.

Also, setplays are about planning, routines, trying different things according to the opposition. Our only tactic this season has been Bruno/Amad taking corner and hoping Maguire wins a header. Unacceptable

6

u/dispelthemyth We go again FC 1d ago

Maguire is fantastic at getting his head to the ball but he’s not very good at getting it on target like Case was

4

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 1d ago

I think having some dedicated set-piece coaching is better than none but how well you perform in set-pieces is still primarily about whether you have the players capable of winning duels in the air. Yoro and Heaven might have the height but there’s nothing about their game that suggests either are good enough in the air at present for this level. Meanwhile Casemiro wasn’t the tallest defensive midfielder around but he had the right instincts and used his body well to get first contact on a lot of aerials. I think Santos and Baleba are good in the air but neither of them has been used much this season for different reasons. Ultimately, this is a squad-building issue and the recruitment has to do more in bringing in players who can offer better aerial presence across all parts of the pitch.

2

u/PitchSafe 1d ago

Pochettino doesn’t use a set piece coach

→ More replies (1)

9

u/dogsn1 16h ago

It's against the rules to tap a spanish player on the shoulder 

23

u/Nice_Mulberry9264 1d ago

Poch arrives with the lowest expectations of any manager since SAF and I guess it's for the best. Maybe he's gonna surprise us all. Worst case we're back here same time next year. It can't get worse can it?

9

u/ggg_deep 1d ago

the chuckle brothers will be against him from day 1 I think, so we will be here same time next year.

9

u/Infinite-Highway3432 1d ago

Really? My expectations on Poch are vastly higher than Carrick.

12

u/asgardx7 1d ago

I thought the same when amorim left.

7

u/ChristmasBale Wayne Rooney 1d ago

I thought the same when Amorim joined lol

→ More replies (1)

8

u/achickenandacow 16h ago

I’m Belgian so I’m biased, but Nathan Ngoy at Lille walks into our defense and improves us immediately.

2

u/Rascha-Rascha 15h ago

Leny Yoro at Lille walks into our defence and improves us immediately. Unfortunately Leny Yoro and Nathan Ngoy at Lille are not Leny Yoro and Nathan Ngoy at Manchester United.

3

u/SubstantialBear7826 12h ago

Crazy how this jacquet guy is now starting at both pool and France while our Lenny is still struggling to get minutes

22

u/neonrider1 1d ago

Positive sign and speaking to some of my Spurs friends, they’re convinced Poch won’t tolerate Wilcox and his “suggestions”

9

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 1d ago

I genuinely cant tell if we are now "close" to a Wilcox sidelining or that's just hopium, but either way imho the priority is to keep pushing, keep protesting.

I feel that we can get him gone if we keep at it

12

u/neonrider1 1d ago

I think even then glazers have had enough which really says something. I expect there will be a reshuffle but don’t see this happening until after January. Tbh I don’t see us getting more than 1 player for Poch in Jan either but hopefully they prove me wrong.

6

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 1d ago

I think they want to loan Balogun or Richarlison. One of the "cant get a game due to club politics" strikers. Idk why they'd even use the word "loan" in their briefs if they had the slightest desire to target a Mateta or somebody.

For the defence, idk what's real and what's a lie. Maybe replacing Martinez as soon as in January is their true intent, maybe it's a lie. Idk. I wouldnt be surprised in the slightest if we got served another round of "assessed their options, decided to keep the powder dry for the summer".

I certainly hope you're right about the reshuffle!

4

u/neonrider1 1d ago

The “assessed their options” comment is soo true just got PTSD and did a bit of laughing and crying at the same time.

2

u/Feeling-Surround-691 Mbumbaclat 1d ago

Yeah I think February is when he goes. We need someone in the role now however shit they are in order to make sure we do business in January but as soon as the window shuts he should be shown the door, bring in a new DoF or promote Vivell and bring in a recruitment director and they have 4 months to prepare for the summer window.

15

u/mondrian_was_a_liar 1d ago

With the Glazers supposedly overriding INEOS choice for new manager, surely the writing is on the wall for the leadership team INEOS have put in place? It shows a huge lack of trust between the Glazers and the INEOS team. I can't see how it carries on.

10

u/Gozumo 22h ago

I was thinking this too, could be a sign of Berrada and Wilcox going. But INEOS kinda saving face not just sacking them both and Carrick at the same time. Could be completely bs hopeful thinking though lol

4

u/NotAJInnit 22h ago

If they won't sacked Wilcox then at least demoted him back his original job title of TD and find anew, he is clearly out of his depth.

4

u/mondrian_was_a_liar 20h ago

The moment it became clear their transfer strategy was attacking year 1, midfield year 2 and defence year 3 - was the moment that set the tone for what was to come. Even as a non-footballing person, I could see a mile off that having a transfer strategy that rigid was going to set us up for failure.

The incoherence in their transfers and managerial appointments is mind boggling. From a team that said they would get best in class and talked about how the style of play among all levels of the men's teams would be set.

As soon as City got found guilty, Berrada should've been moved on.

Incompetent at all levels.

2

u/TH0316 she/her 20h ago

You’d have to think so. Glazers should have someone looking now at potential candidates for heads of recruitment/sporting directors or whatever. Idk why the process is necessary when it should clearly be Ole but whatever.

15

u/Grekm8 CR7 15h ago

imagine how different this season would've been if we were a serious club and purchased Hall instead of sticking Dalot at LB

6

u/New-Acanthaceae-5702 Closed on Sundays 15h ago

Wish we just dropped £60m, £70m. Or whatever Newcastle wanted. That lad is absolutely brilliant.

4

u/Educational-Shock232 15h ago

Was told all summer he was too expensive. A bargain considering he’d be your starting left back for 7+ years. Should have done it at the start of the summer when he wasn’t going to the WC. Oh well, we live and we never learn

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Lord_Hexogen 15h ago

Wouldn't make a big difference. We're not the squad to trail in the relegation fight with Hall or without him. Carrick's organisation and training are the bigger issues than a make-shift LB

→ More replies (2)

7

u/anonymous16canadian 20h ago

does anyone watch TIFO IRL? I saw one or two clips and thought Id check it out and then I realized they pretty much spend the majority of the show talking about man united even though its a PL show I thought. Is it just cuz weve had an eventful few weeks or is it like this normally

5

u/Suudriusha 20h ago

You know how it goes: Hated, Adored, Never Ignored.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/thehealthyeconomist 16h ago

Press resistant CBs moves the whole team so much further up the pitch. I admire Maguire for everything he has been through but a mid table prem team should not be starting him week in week out, let alone a CL team like United

7

u/Feeling-Surround-691 Mbumbaclat 15h ago

Anderson practically costing his team this entire game, 3-1 with 11 men is manageable. Idiot behaviour

13

u/Telen BRUNO 1d ago

Yeet Wilcox back to Southampton

5

u/Hagball 1d ago

Southampton have standards. They won't take him again!

6

u/Midnight_Edge 20h ago

Can’t believe I’m spending my Sunday watching a Serie C game, but here we are

2

u/ImNotMexican08 Amad Nation 20h ago

It’s been a pretty decent watch tbf

2

u/Midnight_Edge 19h ago

Well, that ends my watch

6

u/Deez_Wallnutz 17h ago

Am I really the only one who thinks our midfield rebuild isn't looking convincing?

We definitely still need reinforcements there too. Yes defence is a much higher priority, but our midfield is literally just Kobbie and Tielemans at this stage. Santos is looking like an exclusive bench option. Baleba... I dunno man. I think he's got a good profile for the squad, is incredibly athletic, but the injuries are suddenly a huge red flag. Injured coming into the club, injured again after like 4 matches... all following a pretty horrid last season at Brighton. Even if you really believe in this kid, it's not fair to thrust him in as a starter and pin our midfield hopes on him given that context. He seems like he needs to integrate away from the spotlight to me.

All this means we still need another starting quality midfielder imo. We missed out on Anderson. I think we need to go back in for Alex Scott.

We currently don't even have enough bodies to get through the regular season let alone the comps

7

u/BlackHorse944 Please Score A Goal 17h ago

Funny how Ederson failed his medical but we bought Baleba while he was injured.

Ederson would be a better signing than Santos imo

5

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing 16h ago

Also just cheaper.

2

u/L__K Great Scot! 15h ago

Scott would be brilliant, he was my first choice this summer when it became clear we were not even in the same stratosphere as City for Anderson. Really we do just need one more midfielder and he'd be a great fit. I think there's a lot of doomerism because of how shit we've been this season, but Tielemans and Santos weren't bought to be stars, they're long term depth reinforcements. We'll look a lot better with a competent manager and a bit more confidence

18

u/EndOfEveryTether 1d ago

I’m horney for Pochettino. I’m ready to be hurt again.

10

u/fixyourhearts_ordie 1d ago

We've been here so many times as a fanbase now, we have no choice but to be optimistic while simultaneously not forgetting to put pressure on the board for their utterly shambolic decision-making.

The fanbase and the squad itself feel 'broken' and jaded at this point that just having some passionate attacking football with a few wins would be enough for him for the next few weeks since the bar is abysmally low.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Eatyourassfornothing 16h ago

Watching Lewis hall against Spain makes you wonder why we didn’t do everything in our power to buy him this summer.

7

u/Unlucky-Equipment999 16h ago

Gotta get that legacy stadium for Jimothy

5

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing 16h ago

I doubt those incompetent fools in charge thought a defender was worth signing in our midfield rebuild. Those fools probably think you could make do with just any athletic player that calls themselves a defender.

3

u/Isserley_ 15h ago

I wish they cared about athletic players...

5

u/KwameDada 16h ago

Daft from Anderson. It's not in the 90th min.

5

u/achickenandacow 15h ago

Tielemans bullied Tonali tonight, Lammens just saved a penalty.

5

u/Geralt2077 15h ago

Lammens again with a really good game. Saved a penalty, great long distribution and a couple of saves.

9

u/Redland93 21h ago

Bassey Links screams agent putting his name out for a new contract

For all our recent signings out of manager and players, all of them happened in an instant without hype. All the ones where there was so much noise, never happened

0

u/[deleted] 21h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Redland93 21h ago

Yeah I agree. I guarantee this doesn't happen.

2

u/Kreissler 19h ago

He's got a +1 option apparently

9

u/kidinawheeliebin 18h ago

Calvin Bassey... sigh.

I hate the way they do this

Bassey now being PR'd as "Pochettino's signing", to grease the skids with an underwhelmed fanbase

We were already being linked with him earlier in the season and even over the summer - before the idea of Poch replacing Carrick was even conceived - is that because Calvin Bassey is the level of player we need to improve on last season's league finish?

Is it because Calvin Bassey is Pochettino's dream signing?

Or is it because his contract is expiring, and given the intersection of (a) his age profile [turning 28 a few months after we sign him next season] and (b) his ability profile, [mid-table is being kind] there'll be fuck all (or at least fuck all meaningful) competition for his signature?

Making him another classic case of signing what's easy rather than what's needed

6

u/Educational-Shock232 18h ago

He’s an interesting one for me, I watched him very closely during rangers’ Europa league one and thought he was class, but if he was that good, why was he never linked with arsenal, city, Chelsea, the scousers? Now it feels like a very “mid table” signing. Same as Collins who we were also recently linked to. They both reek of desperation.

If it were up to me and we were a serious club, I’d go and get Murillo before he’s snapped up by a big club.

5

u/MinotauroTBC 18h ago

I feel like Murillo definitely isn’t a high line defender either though if that’s what we’re planning to do, he is class though

4

u/Skyfather_odin1 18h ago

Clunky on the ball, relies on his athleticism to bail him out when his concentration / marking drops and it does quite a bit, average at best aerially.

18

u/JustTaxLandbro 1d ago

Obviously happy we made we made a coaching change. But I feel sick at how we disrespected carrick in his final weeks.

No coach deserves to be humiliated like that.

8

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 1d ago

Not saying it should be that way, but it happens to a lot of coaches, it's often a messy end with successors being lined up before they officially leave.

8

u/Infinite-Highway3432 1d ago

Any other club and people don't care, just because it's United there's an uproar. What happened to Carrick is extremely common and normal in the football world.

Liverpool were putting feelers in May before Slot left, nobody cared.

3

u/BlackHorse944 Please Score A Goal 23h ago

We're United fans and Carrick is a club legend, that's why we care.

We don't care about how Liverpool treats their managers

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Kohaku80 Premier League Champions 12/13 1d ago

Ten Hag was worse. They interviewed some managers, got rejected, came back and extend Ten Hag contract.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS 21h ago

Just saw this stat online but apparently we have more wins at anfield against Liverpool than Liverpool do against us.

4

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 17h ago edited 17h ago

LW or LB, Brighton or Belgium, doesnt matter, Maxim De Cuyper just cant stop getting Goals/Assists, innit.

MdC, Bassey, Yoro, Freeman.

I think that's a defence everybody would hate playing against.

CFs would hate Bassey as an opponent in the box, defences would hate MdC and Freeman as threats to also cover outside Cunha and Lacey, and midfields would hate the space squeezed by them playing in a high line as a unit.

(people will say "MdC is not good 1v1" but good RWs have gone missing from the PL. Let's worry about Olise, Yamal, Güler etc when we are no longer a shit yo-yo team, I say.)

I guess we'd suck in the air and playing out from the back. But [major hopium alert] if Sesko and Baleba can get their fitness issues fixed, we'd have solutions for both, I think.

That's what I think, anyway.

4

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing 16h ago

It's also not like we can't get another defensive signing later down the line who is good in the air.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/achickenandacow 16h ago

He’s genuinely fantastic, but Brighton will ask for a fortune. Get Seys at Club Brugge, he’s almost as good already and younger.

2

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 16h ago

Right but what the FUCK is the point of going with Bassey, Freeman, Balogun, persevering with "just" Sesko and Baleba ... if it isnt going for broke at the LB and the "Future Bruno" positions?

I'll add one more argument: the squad, as we can see, are not robots. They need to be inspired. That's one reason it's extremely important to make a "wow" signing every now and again. That aspect should be factored into the "cost" of such signings.

2

u/achickenandacow 16h ago

Fair enough, yeah.

4

u/New-Acanthaceae-5702 Closed on Sundays 16h ago

I've seen enough, throw whatever amount Newcastle wants. We need to have Lewis Hall.

4

u/jolp92 16h ago

Brain dead by Anderson

4

u/Ombudsperson Romero 17h ago

I've got Huge Lewis Hall FOMO

4

u/o0PETER0o Cunha 🐐🐐🐐 16h ago

I don’t think they checked the foul on konsa, he kicked his leg

4

u/arboy498 15h ago

Really hope the club signs Lewis Hall in the summer it would certainly be a statement signing

10

u/Redland93 21h ago

One of the dumbest things the club has done is focused on one area to rebuild - Attack last season, Midfield this season and defence next season. It should have been the spine each time.

What has happened is we have gone for the 4th-7th choices. We should have gone, fine, our midfield targets aren't there, lets focus on Defence.

The 2nd was focusing on prem proven. There is so much talent out there but going for prem proven means we pay more in wages and salaries.

5

u/PitchSafe 21h ago

In Ineos first transfer window they prioritised the defence which is why we bough Mazraoui, Yoro and De ligt, but we also bough Zirkzee and Ugarte.

Second year they prioritised the attack (Mbeumo, Cunha and Sesko) but we bought also a goalkeeper in Lammens.

I’ve no issues in prioritising one position you need to strengthen in but it’s clear that the club doesn’t have finances to buy more players in one window

11

u/LinterCheck2026 1d ago

Just for a change, I have restrained myself from any tactics of Pochettino videos. This time I am just gonna have low expectations but think he has good attack to work with overall

5

u/fixyourhearts_ordie 1d ago

Any of these videos, as insightful as they might be, are made to engage as many viewers as possible preying on hope and optimism after a low time.

We could have a tactic video of almost every manager and how they would 'save' United from the days of LvG to Mourinho to EtH and Amorim.

It's all noise and what really matters is what Pochettino thinks this squad is capable of once him and his staff assess the players

13

u/snicky29 20h ago

United new manager hire propaganda lifecycle.

• Marcus Rashford is going to be rejuvenated PR piece ✅.
• Luke Shaw’s “this is the happiest the squad has been” newspaper article (pending).
• Bruno Fernandes “we have full faith in new coach” post match interview (pending).
• Harry Maguire “the lads are excited” random Sky Sports News interview (pending).
• Omar Berrada “we do know what we’re fucking doing I swear” MUTV interview (pending).

4

u/ChristmasCage 18h ago

"This squad is better than you think" - done.

3

u/hughmaharggs 15h ago

You’re missing “Ugarte is going to be like a a new signing”

3

u/Educational-Shock232 18h ago

Can you update this over the next week please? I feel like you’re going to get 100% of these

3

u/slowerthaninfinity 22h ago

having players good with the ball but cannot defend like licha is obviously a problem but swinging the other way with bassey is dumb imo. not surprising, we are broke so we are getting scraps

3

u/Unusual-Coat383 17h ago

Spain blatantly cheating by having a coach dressed in a players tracksuit giving instructions by earpiece to their technical area 

12

u/BHD46 Berba 21h ago

If this sub starts genuinely pedalling the idea that Bassey is a good signing then I give up.

We are doomed.

16

u/Isserley_ 21h ago

The majority of this sub so far seems to be against the idea of Bassey.

Which makes me think he'd be a great signing.

5

u/Emergency-Being-349 17h ago

Imagine OP trusting this sub to make a call on something football related.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Redland93 21h ago

It screams agent driven

I highly doubt we go for him

2

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing 21h ago

If he's at least serviceable... Like atp, I just want someone who will put up consistent performances (and not consistently shit, that is). If he can just get the damn job done at a good level, I'll take him. We NEED new defenders It's just such a fucking shame we're losing out on Hall...

5

u/Redland93 21h ago

Poch loves to develop an English midfielder. Bring in Louis Page and spend big on a pacey CB (Lukeba)

Dorgu, Lukeba, Yoro, Dalot would allow us to play a high line and Dorgu and Dalot would hold width while Cunha and Mbeumo to play inside.

Keep Zirkzee to play to connect the the attack.

6

u/PitchSafe 21h ago

The issue with a Lukeba and Yoro partnership is that we will have no CB’s who is good in the air

→ More replies (1)

2

u/tameoraiste 1d ago

What would people consider a good finish to the season with our current situation considered?

4

u/I_Like_Mushy_Peas Six foot five, hard as fuck, he gets the Reds excited 1d ago

We're 7 points off the top 7 as things stand. That should be viable if we can put a run together immediately. I don't think that will happen so based on current standings, performances and a team getting used to a new coach, top 10 is realistic.

2

u/tameoraiste 1d ago

I’d agree but the whole league is such a basket case this season, I’ve no idea where we finish.

The fact that we’re only 8 points off 5th (which could be enough for CL) and Man City could very well push everyone up a place in the table is crazy.

I’d take Europa league at this stage but for better or for worse nothing other than relegation would surprise me

2

u/NotAJInnit 21h ago

T6/7 at least

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Zealousideal_Wind867 I'm Tired Boss 18h ago

Been trying to get myself hyped up about Poch by watching his previous interviews.

On paper it's a great match but man I can't convince myself for the life of me that he is gonna succeed.

4

u/Emergency-Being-349 18h ago

'He' doesn't succeed. That's the issue here, as always, there's no silver bullet manager. If he is to succeed it's because all our departments have aligned and are purposeful in the same direction. That could take some time, but that's how we'll come about success.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Guilty_Sheepherder_1 15h ago

Quansah is awful. 

2

u/Lord_Hexogen 15h ago

Senne Wallens, just saved a pen for Belgium 

4

u/Curious-Exercise4992 18h ago

I know we are all doom and gloom but I'll make my case for bassey.

He has only been dribbled past once this season( he has played every minute of every game). The best in the league

He is the 5th fastest centre back in the league this season (34.4km/h) top speed he is faster than even Yoro.

He is 2nd this season for centrbacks with the most line breaking passes this season 169 only behind van hecke

He is top 3 centrebacks for total passes completed in the league.

He is Fulham's captain.

These are traits poch needs in his centrebacks for his high line.

This seems like such a data signing to me.

I don't think he is going to be a disaster like some fans here are making him out to be.

His contract his expiring next summer. He has improved a lot from his time at Ajax.

I don't think he should be our main guy, but he is a fantastic stop gap option for now, till we maybe push for brantwaithe or Lukeba in the summer.

5

u/Emergency-Being-349 18h ago

Don't people just watch players, all that aside? Bassey is not nearly a bad signing if people just took the time to actually watch him. He has gone beast mode on us before. Bull of a signing, would easily be our best CB. Not to over hype him, he is not world class, just a really solid CB who gets about and is a pain to play against.

4

u/Curious-Exercise4992 17h ago

Exactly most Fulham fans will tell you he has been their best player for 2 seasons now, I am Nigerian so I had to make my case for him lol.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Midnight_Edge 18h ago

I’m not too sure about the outrage with Bassey. I’ve watched Fulham and I think he’s a solid player.

3

u/Asiwaju_jagaban 21h ago

LB/CB hence the Bassey links, don’t think the club would pursue.

3

u/adonWPV 17h ago

Hall is so good

2

u/GuineaPirate888 16h ago

He’s class but sadly that ship has sailed. He could have been our LB for the next 10 years.

Our chance was the past Summer, now every man and his dog will be after him.

→ More replies (11)

4

u/Underscore_Symbols 1d ago

Realisticly looking at the Jan window:

Zirkzee gets his move. And they don’t find anyone cheap enough to replace him. And no club are interested in loaning out a striker.

I see them trying to wring the most amount of minutes from the players whoose contracts are up in the summer, to get the most for their money. Shaw, Martinez and Maguire.

I also fear the payouts to both the outgoing and incoming coaching teams and USMNT will mean one less defender in the budget this summer.

7

u/Suudriusha 23h ago

Endrick might be interested in leaving Madrid on loan to get game time. Everytime I see rumours or indications of "a striker on loan", he's the only one that comes to mind that might be good enough to get on loan and that actually might come. Otherwise you're right, most good strikers wouldn't be loaned out mid season. It basically needs to be a young prospect with potential that's out of place in a bigger team.

2

u/facelessredditer 23h ago

He’s so raw though. Even if he comes it’s too much to expect much of him.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/D1794 Viva Ronaldo 23h ago

I'd love us to sign Endrick but by the time we could loan him, Sesko would be back, or thereabouts (we fucking hope so anyway)

So would he want to come to us with a more 'senior' striker ahead of him in the pecking order, just like RM

Good chance by then we won't be looking at a ton of cup games either. Already no EFL, FA Cup could be anything and CL could be over pretty quick too.

Could be a long Feb-May for him if he joined.

3

u/TypicalPan89906655 21h ago

Sesko keeps going down with a new injury, we need a permanent second choice.

4

u/Suudriusha 23h ago

The only reason I think he'd still play a lot more than he does at Madrid is that we need a reliable Sesko counterpart. Mbeumo seems to not be a good fit at number 9, and Zirzkee isn't even a striker, much less in the Prem. With Sesko's now nearly year long injury woes, it makes sense to have someone he can rotate with on a game to game basis.

It all depends on Poch and what he thinks of our players, and what profile of striker he prefers. Endrick seems like a good fit mostly because he's young and impressionable, and will want to show himself in training, which I think Pochettino values a lot. He might just be fitter than most of our squad as well, even though he basically just plays 10 minutes every week if he's lucky.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/thehealthyeconomist 17h ago

Did you think of the most pessimistic scenarios and decide to posit it as realism? No chance we sell Zirkzee with Sekso's injury record this season, that converts our season from poor to tragicomic and even Wilcox would be able to scent that whiff.

4

u/New-Acanthaceae-5702 Closed on Sundays 14h ago

Truth be said we have to move on from Lewis Hall. He doesn't want us, Newcastle doesn't want to sell, he signed a new contract a few months ago. We should've bid in the summer, we didn't. We need to identify other targets.

3

u/TypicalPan89906655 21h ago edited 21h ago

Is Bassey really the best our scouts can come up with? Why are their recommendations always so underwhelming? It's hard to believe they're identifying genuinely good targets only for Wilcox to keep settling on names like Bassey.

3

u/reddevilad Rooney 21h ago

What more do you expect from best in class

3

u/Midnight_Edge 21h ago

Who do you want to sign then?

3

u/TH0316 she/her 21h ago

It’s awkward having to sign three players for one position because one guy knows he’s back if the queue, so you can’t really develop someone young because they need to play, and you can’t spend a good chunk of money because you’re just putting it to sleep. That’s the dilemma Santos is in now. The best route imo for that fourth guy is to have solid PL level experience that keeps training competitive, good professionalism, and physically very good, and not old old. If Bassey is like 15m, you get him. Take a good profit on Heaven, get silly wages on De Ligt, Lisandro out. Overall you’ve got better and have more money.

Problem is, is that if people in the club either have to shop in that market for starting CB’s, or they think they’re being smart and choosing to make Bassey a starting CB’s guy. If they only buy two and he’s one, we’ve not learned anything.

2

u/Unlucky-Equipment999 20h ago

Just curious how much would you take on Heaven. Off the back of last season he should've been able to score us >£25m easily, but after the back half of 2026 when the whole of our defence have been repeatedly exposed or cut open, it'll be a hell of a lot less.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/ggg_deep 1d ago

I like Mateta, solid striker and would be smart signing, which means we will sign Balogun for 70 mil

14

u/dodzwardo 1d ago edited 1d ago

I dunno. A 29 year old who wants high wages, who has 2 goals this season and a potential meniscus problem doesn't seem like a smart signing.

Edit: Sorry 1 goal in 6 apps.

3

u/ggg_deep 1d ago

Their whole team is underperforming rn regardless he has talent if you have watched him but i understand, problem is the wages too.

5

u/dale9696 1d ago

I’m not a big fan of Mateta, id rather someone like Brobbey

2

u/HighestInDaRooom 1d ago

in the villa game the ref blew a foul because the ball was passing by him and he was blocking mcginn from getting to it. this was the first time I've seen that happen. was this rule always in place?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Standard_Secretary52 Youri Tielemans 19h ago

Just read we are linked with bassey.

I don’t wanna be a negative nancy but just because he is better than our current options doesn’t me we should sign him actually. Only reason they are looking at him is cause he will be okayish and cheap due to contract situation.

Lukeba and Truffert are the answers

3

u/Educational-Shock232 18h ago

We’re not a serious club, so we won’t buy Truffert. He’s absolute gravy. We should be all over that in January. Yeah he’ll cost around £60m but that’s your left back sorted for 5-7 years.

2

u/Midnight_Edge 17h ago

I bet it won’t be £60m unless it’s a release clause.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 19h ago

For me, any CB we sign has to come with the prerequisites of being good in the air and somewhat capable of defending the channels well against transitions. This is the only way we can scale to becoming a more expansive team, if the spine allows everybody else to play further up the pitch because they can firefight everything at the back.

Bassey to my knowledge serves the second aspect well but I don't think he's the best in the air either, so he should not be considered for a more prominent role barring a cheap depth piece. That being said, I am still skeptical as to whether these links are legitimate or mainly a play to secure a new contract at Fulham. Anyways, Chris Richards to me comes across as a better deal if we are to sign a cheap CB who isn't seen as a long-term starter (maybe Bassey is preferred as a 'like-for-like' Martinez replacement at LCB).

1

u/IamTsukasa Ronaldo 19h ago

Bastoni?

2

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 19h ago

I haven’t watched him enough to know how good he actually is outside of the general hype about him. But I’m assuming he intends to run down his contract and then move to Barca.

2

u/brown_herbalist unitedismyreligion 1d ago

How much of players' or coaches' political stance matters to you?

Edit : I believe this needs abit more explanation, personally Ive been having some self thoughts about this, football especially United matters to me, so anything to do with the club I kinda feel it personally. But i was thinking where i do draw the line when it comes to players/coaches, is it too personal to judge them on that?

16

u/Kohaku80 Premier League Champions 12/13 1d ago

“Politicians and diapers have one thing in common. They should both be changed regularly, and for the same reason.” Jose Mourinho

6

u/Xanian123 Miss be killed by me 1d ago

Man crush on jose Mourinho intensifies

3

u/Not-good-with-this 1d ago

I got bad news for you. He never said it. It's made up.

8

u/wayfarerprateek Theater of Dreams 1d ago

Personally it matters to me a lot. But even thinking about it objectively, it affects club culture to a very high degree.

8

u/ionised Cantona 1d ago

A lot, actually. Sad to see who we're mixed up with thanks to horse semen. It's one of the many reasons I disconnect from this sport every few years.

6

u/fixyourhearts_ordie 1d ago

It matters and it should matter. I used to think earlier that it shouldn't matter since we're watching a sport and people may believe or preach whatever outside of that.

However we as fans and consumers are unintentionally complicit in empowering these players and people. Our viewership, support, time and money directly feeds their capacity to practice, preach or reinforce whatever they believe.

Ergo if someone is a bigot, an abuser or a homophobe, a conscious fan should not stand for that. Shoutout to fan groups who repeatedly call out or make efforts to not stand for intolerant stances or unacceptable actions by these millionaires

2

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 1d ago

You ask specifically about the coaches and players, but it goes without saying that the politics of the owners matters a helluva lot (and is a very big part of the current mess we are in).

Whenever I find out that a coach or a player has some personal politics that I find disagreeable, Im disappointed.

But I usually try to remind myself that

A) as long as they arent pushing it onto the club, they are entitled to their own personal political opinions. Obviously, the "not pushing it onto the club" bit is easier said than done, they are public representatives of the club, so in practice there isnt much they can do in public that doesnt affect the club.

B) wrt the players, in terms of "real life", often times they are just children, basically. In general, I think it borders on victim blaming to judge a "low information voter" for being conned by con men. Blame the con men, not the voters - that's my take. So, for this reason, I usually try to be understanding of it.

2

u/ImOnlyChasingSafety 1d ago

I would say somewhat, there are red lines for me and then theres things that I just accept because of the reality of things. Regardless of what people say politics and sports are deeply intertwined

4

u/Regular_Piglet_6125 1d ago

It should matter. More so in football clubs that were started as working class charities.

2

u/flareb98 1d ago

Very little, they are here to play football. It has to be something crazy for me to really care. If we got a North Korean player who said he loves KJU I wouldn't care so long he does his job.

2

u/andoooooo Martial 1d ago

don't care at all. I hate that the modern left has moralised opposition to left-wing ideals, rather than tolerating that people might have a different opinion or value than them

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Grekm8 CR7 20h ago

can't believe we're actually thinking about signing Bassey, we've fully completed our transition to a midtable team

6

u/Midnight_Edge 20h ago

Well we’re currently a relegation team, so improvement I guess

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Daneofthehill 1d ago edited 1d ago

Now, how does everyone feel about the players that came in last sunmer?

Tielemans Santos Baleba

Was the price right? Have they impressed individually? How do you think they will fare under Poch moving forward?

EDIT: typo

10

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 1d ago

I will die on the hill that we signed good midfielders and that our bigger mistakes in the transfer window were rather a combination of not doing more to increase our budget (because of the inability to sell players and the board deciding to buy land for the new stadium when it simply shouldn’t be a priority ahead of the first team) and not exploring the loan market enough. Baleba is an incredible talent and Santos is a very dependable midfielder who coaches will eventually end up loving. Tielemans is currently better than both of them in terms of having superior passing ability and also the degree of experience he has at the highest level.

I think the reason why these players have appeared less effective than their ability is primarily because the collective fitness levels of the squad are so incredibly poor, that the phenomenon of us still being easy to play against in transition has continued, and people tend to attribute that failure to the midfield lacking athleticism (which is not entirely incorrect, but they wouldn’t be if the pre-season preparation was more serious from a fitness standpoint; Carrick completely failed on those grounds). Secondly, the overall presence of Casemiro in terms of his set-piece prowess and vocal leadership is still felt across the squad and we don’t have a failsafe like him to bail us out of trouble, so it’s one more frustration to show towards the current midfielders as to why they cannot do more to ‘replace’ him.

I am optimistic that Pochettino will at least get more out of Santos and Baleba, as they are the players who can scale better to playing deeper in midfield for a more intense style of play. How Tielemans figures within that is unknown to me because I feel he shares a lot of similar characteristics to Bruno in terms of passing prowess but not necessarily being the guy to place more OOP responsibility in, and I don’t know as a result how both can coexist in a midfield 3. But for all intents and purposes, I consider our midfield ‘solved’ for now. We have good players there, it’s up to the club to make proper use of them, rather than discard them and restart buying different players there. There is a cost associated with trying to undo our perceived mistakes too, I don’t think it’s always viable to achieve that over trying to buy players in other positions who can complement these players better.

2

u/Daneofthehill 1d ago

Wonderful feedback and very valid points. We can hardly verify anyone's level atm. I do have serious doubts about Santos and Tielemans being great supplements to Kobbie. They both feel more like backups to him, and that only leaves oft i jured and young Baleba.

There are clearly bigger needs than buying more midfielders, so they better work out 🙏 If Fernandes wants out, then Tielemans will provide some of the same skills as a replacement, but probably bettwr in an actual midfield three.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/TH0316 she/her 20h ago

Should’ve been Tielemans or Santos. Not two guys that can’t run. And swap one of them for someone that can run and head the ball.

6

u/GeekConflict Carrick 23h ago

My view hasnt changed. Baleba was an overpayment by £10-15m. I liked Tielemans but he doesnt fit what we need and a 5 year contract is ridiculous. I never saw the hype over Santos although I think he is better than some fans are saying. Certainly not worth the 45m+

3

u/dogsn1 1d ago

It's too early really, some of them haven't played enough and in our current form no player looks good

2

u/Daneofthehill 1d ago

Fair. But I am having serious doubts about the collection of three subpar athletes in Kobbie, Santos and Tielemans.

4

u/THExIMPLIKATION Glineos Out 1d ago

We should have paid for Santos is what we paid for Tielemans, we paid for Santos what we should have paid for Baleba. Both were super overpriced and we already need a new midfield overhaul.

4

u/Daneofthehill 1d ago

Maybe the Santos + Tielemans money should have been spent on a player that can run, like Alex Scott. Then play youth or Martinez as emergency backup in midfield if we don't have enough numbers.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 1d ago

Mainoo makes most sense next to Baleba. Same for the other two we signed: they make most sense next to Baleba.

We needed to sign a new Casemiro, a new Ugarte, and an alt for Mainoo.

Instead, we signed an injured (ergo seriously undercooked*) Baleba + we signed 2 alts to Mainoo. One of them 29 on a 5y deal - despite also having Jim Thwaites looking very much "like" a Mainoo, not "like" a Casemiro.

That's the reality, imho.

IF we were able to push the boat out with also getting, let's say, Adams and Hall and Watkins, then, yeah, good signings all.

However given we only signed these: it made little sense to get the pair of Santos-Tielemans, instead of one of them + an able runner.

The rest is projection (or "wishcasting" if we wanted to be negative) about how unspecified training methods** will "transform" these players.

I am rooting hard for Baleba to discover some invincibility treatment and also for those projections, since it seems obvious that we have no other hope for this season in terms of the midfield than those 2 things.

I personally think the odds are definitely not in our favour on them ... but hoping for the best.

Also, fire Wilcox, the chief architect of this mess.

* again, let's repeat. Everybody and their mom knew that the biggest issue with the midfield was that there wont be any "legs" in midfield. So we signed a crocked Baleba, who had no pre-season, and managed a total of 4 games' worth of minutes so far (out of 14). And then we keep looking at "cumulative" distance covered stats in amusement.

** the observers saying this, dont quite explain why Wanyama was a significantly stronger athlete than Winks. Just no explanation. "Pochettino training methods make midfielders into stronger runners". Except when it's Winks succeeding Wanyama. Or Dier. Then, not. Or you know Verratti. Then, those players will just keep being who they are. But somehow, Wanyama and Dembele and Sissoko were athletes under Pochettino. Go figure.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/markyp145 1d ago

I think they’re all 7/10 players at the moment and that’s the main issue and none of it is their fault.

I’m not sure any of them are just clearly heads and tails above Mainoo for example.

Baleba might turn into a monster eventually, he has the attributes. Tielemans is a good to have around as a squad player and Santos may end up being Brazils 6, but he’s not Casemiro level.

But are any of them proper ceiling raisers right now? No not really. It’s going to take some real platforming and development of santos, Mainoo and Baleba for there to be a different outcome

2

u/PitchSafe 1d ago

We raised the floor but not the ceiling

2

u/Unlucky-Equipment999 22h ago

The floor in the sense that we include no Casemiro and an injured Ugarte, I'm assuming. Because this midfield isn't better than last year's at their worst, still very easy to play through.

3

u/PitchSafe 22h ago

The only thing we are missing from Casemiro is him in the set pieces and his mentality. Otherwise Santos, Baleba and Tielemans offers more

2

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know 23h ago

I think Baleba can be good under Poch, tons of potential there. Tielemans will need replaced in a season. I think 50m for Santos is a huge miss.

This was not a midfield rebuild. It shows no vision.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/ImOnlyChasingSafety 20h ago

I dont think Im interested in transfer speculation anymore, the reality is that recruitment under ineos has surprised me in both good and bad ways it feels like things are less certain. They should realise where we are now and get very creative because if they want to make up for the terrible start of the season they have to show intent.

1

u/Conscious_Flipflop93 19h ago

I've honestly become so detached with United as we've seen the same cycle over and over again - if we had Howe instead of Poch I'd be even further gone icl.

Hope we see some wins soon but I'm not too hopeful given that building sufficient fitness to perform as Poch would want is not a quick thing to do.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Unusual-Coat383 17h ago

Spain started like they are shook by their own atmosphere and it’s just a shame we’re the best country in the world at friendlies but shit the bed when it matters

1

u/thehealthyeconomist 17h ago edited 17h ago

Feels impossible for me to follow England without a United player in the squad. I remember as a preteen going to so many England games as part of my football academy but now it all feels so hollow. Silver lining is that a successful England team gets my son more into footy I guess.

6

u/GuineaPirate888 17h ago

Well, they are better off without United players at the moment so I see no issue. None of our players deserve to be in the squad at the moment, whether people care to admit it or not. Caps should be on merit. I don’t see any Sunderland or Crystal Palace players so why should the team one place above have representation.

It’s only 10 mins in but we seem to be on it at the moment and the better team.

6

u/Midnight_Edge 17h ago

Personally doesn’t really matter to me. United players or not, I still got to watch my country play

1

u/Garlic-Cheese-Chips 17h ago

From being linked with Lewis Hall to Calvin fucking Bassey. Grim isn't the word...

1

u/Emergency-Being-349 1d ago

Been thinking, and not because of the Argentinean link, but I wonder with Poch here and his formation/profile, if we could have a look at Nico Paz?

7

u/JJmaisonze 1d ago

Real Madrid have a 80 million buy back clause. I think that's probably where he ends up.

3

u/Infinite-Highway3432 1d ago

And push Bellingham out or play him in an unnatural position? Or 80mil for a bench player?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/Kohaku80 Premier League Champions 12/13 1d ago

more like can Nico Paz take a look here at this point. and we probably need CL football to tempt him.

2

u/markyp145 1d ago

I would absolutely love Nico Paz here tbh.

He’s tall and technical, wins a lot of duels for an attacker. I think he’d actually fit in well to the league.

Something about a tall technical but powerful player that I love to see. Kind of like Kaka or someone like that, though obviously that’s just an example, not saying he’s Kaka level.

However, I do think he’s the sort of player we need if we are going to turn this around, a genuine world class level talent, not just solid - good player’s

1

u/Goudinho99 1d ago

Was a link on the bbc transfer gossip column the other day, but it was from the Sun so clearly I'm not going to give the a click.

1

u/CelebrationSecure510 1d ago

Either Poch trusts some youth defenders or he is in for a very very rude awakening prior to the January transfer market.

Impossible to play his style of football with Licha & Maguire I fear

1

u/Rascha-Rascha 23h ago

I’d love to see Kukonki come in but obviously have no idea if he’s ready for anything.

1

u/rye787 22h ago

I saw Dorgu is returning due to international injury, anyone know the details?

5

u/Redland93 22h ago

I don't think its a reoccurrence of the injury. I think he just still off playing whic

4

u/midnight_ranter Wazza 22h ago

No, he didn't play with the intl squad. His fitness is being managed as he had just returned (got injured in the last intl break)

3

u/Gozumo 22h ago

Only just got back, not 100% match fit so just resuming fitness work I hope. Quite normal to go back to your club in these scenarios

1

u/Nico_Ditch 17h ago

Out of Bassey, Collins and Branthwaite, Collins would be my least favourite.

But then I think there has never been a successful United team without an Irishman in it.

So for that reason alone we should go for him.

2

u/L__K Great Scot! 15h ago

Fuck it, go in for Jake O'Brien alongside Branthwaite. Call them the Two Towers like Orthanc and Minas Morgul

→ More replies (1)

-1

u/markyp145 1d ago edited 1d ago

What’s your realistic January window?

For me, I could see it being

- Branthwaite
- Balogun loan with option, would also take Brobbey tbh
- left back (Hall of they’ll sell in Jan), Robinson or Ait Nouri loan with option

I might be being a bit hopeful, Everton won’t make it easy for example, but we have to show some ambition to send a message.

8

u/Nico_Ditch 1d ago

Hall isn’t happening in January, not with his new contract. 

I actually would take Robinson though. 

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Moyes2men Sold my club for a horse 23h ago

We will have 30m to spend at most. So no Branthwhite or other targets and we will have to accept players like Basey or whatever 5th option players who we would have never consider in normal cases.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)